NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
36Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Transco LLC Transmission
Facilities and Formula Rates
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
36.1Overview
36.1.1Cost Allocation
The purpose of Section 36.2 is to provide for the allocation of costs to be recovered
through the Transco Facilities Charge (“TFC”) described in Section 6.13 of Schedule 13 of the
ISO OATT for the following New York Transco, LLC (“NY Transco”) projects, each of which
has been approved by the New York Public Service Commission on November 4, 2013, in Case
No. 12-E-0503 (the “Transmission Owner Transmission Solutions” or “TOTS” projects): (1) the
Second Ramapo-to-Rock Tavern 345-kV Line Project; (2) the Marcy South Series Compensation
and Fraser-to-Coopers Corners Reconductoring Project; and (3) the Staten Island Unbottling
Project.1
36.1.2Formula Rates
Section 36.3 provides NY Transco’s formula rate and implementation rules for the formula rate to recover costs related to its projects through the TFC.
1 Any costs incurred on the forced cooling portion of the Staten Island Unbottling Project after the date of the Commission’s order approving the offer of partial settlement in Docket No. ER15-572-000, issued on March 17, 2016, shall not be recovered through the TFC without further order of the Commission.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
36.2Attachment 1 to Attachment DD
36.2.1Allocation Tables
36.2.1.1 TOTS Projects
COST ALLOCATION TABLE
Transmission DistrictAllocation of Project Costs (%)
Consolidated Edison Co. of NY, Inc.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Orange and Rockland Utilities, Inc. Long Island Power Authority
Niagara Mohawk Power Corp.
New York Gas & Electric Corp.
Rochester Gas and Electric Corp.
Central Hudson Gas & Electric Corp.
New York Power Authority
63.18
8.55
12.16
10.12
5.99
Load is treated the same as all other load serving entities
(“LSE”) and NYPA as an LSE will pay the same rate as the LSEs in each transmission
district.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
36.3Attachment 2 to Attachment DD
36.3.1Formula Rates
36.3.1.1 Rate Formula Template
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Index
Rate Formula Template
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Utilizing FERC Form 1 Data
New York Transco LLC
Appendix AMain body of the Formula Rate
Attachment 1 Detail of the Revenue Credits
Projected Annual Transmission Revenue Requirement
For the 12 months ended 12/31/
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 2Monthly Plant and Accumulated Depreciation balances
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 3Cost Support Detail
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 4Calculations showing the revenue requirement by Investment, including any Incentives,
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 5Cost of Debt should Construction Financing be Obtained
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 6a and 6bDetail of the Accumulated Deferred Income Tax Balances
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 7 and 7aTrue-Up calculations
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 8True-Up for the Construction Financing calculations in Attachment 5
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 9Depreciation Rates
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 10W orkpapers
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Appendix A
Page 1 of 5
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Formula Rate - Non-Levelized
Line
No.
Rate Formula Template
Utilizing FERC Form 1 Data
New York Transco LLC
(1)(2)
Projected Annual Transmission Revenue Requirement
For the 12 months ended 12/31/
(3)
Allocated
Amount
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
1GROSS REVENUE REQUIREMENT
REVENUE CREDITS
2Total Revenue Credits
3Net Revenue Requirement
4True-up Adjustment
5 NET ADJUSTED REVENUE REQUIREMENT
(line 74)
Total
Attachment 1, line 6-
(line 1 minus line 2)
Attachment 7-
(line 3 plus line 4)
12 months$-
Allocator
TP1.0000-
-
DA1.00000-
$-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Appendix A
Page 2 of 5
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Line
No.
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Formula Rate - Non-Levelized
(1)(2)
Form No. 1
Page, Line, Col. RATE BASE:
GROSS PLANT IN SERVICE (Note M)
Production(Attach 2, line 75)
Transmission(Attach 2, line 15)
Distribution(Attach 2, line 30)
General & Intangible(Attach 2, lines 45 & 60)
TOTAL GROSS PLANT (sum lines 6-9)(GP=1 if plant =0)
ACCUMULATED DEPRECIATION & AMORTIZATION (Note M)
Production (Attach 2, line 151)
Transmission(Attach 2, line 91)
Distribution(Attach 2, line 106)
General & Intangible(Attach 2, lines 121 & 136 TOTAL ACCUM. DEPRECIATION (sum lines 12-15)
NET PLANT IN SERVICE
Production (line 6- line 12)
Rate Formula Template
Utilizing FERC Form 1 Data
New York Transco LLC
(3)
Company Total
-NA
-TP
-NA
-W /S
-GP=
-NA
-TP
-NA
-W /S
-
-
For the 12 months ended 12/31/
(4)(5)
Transmission
Allocator(Col 3 times Col 4)
--
1.0000-
--
--
--
--
1.0000-
--
--
-
-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
Transmission
Distribution
General & Intangible
TOTAL NET PLANT (sum lines 18-21)
ADJUSTMENTS TO RATE BASE(Note A)
ADIT
Account No. 255 (enter negative) (Note F)
CW IP
Unfunded Reserv es (enter negative) Unamortized Regulatory Assets
Unamortized Abandoned Plant
(line 7- line 13)-
(line 8- line 14)-
(line 9- line 15)-
(NP=1 if plant =0)-
(Attach 6a, line 9)-
(Attach 3, line 153)-
(Attach 10)-
(Attach 3, line 170a)-
(Attach 10) (Note L)-
(Attach 10) (Note K) -
-
-
-
NP=--
TP1.0000-
NP--
DA-
DA1.0000-
DA1.0000-
DA 1.0000 -
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
30TOTAL ADJUSTMENTS (sum lines 24-29)--
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
31LAND HELD FOR FUTURE USEAttachment 10-TP1.0000-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
32
33
34
35
W ORKING CAPITAL (Note C)
CW Ccalculated (1/8 * Line 45)
Materials & Supplies (Note B)(Attach 3, line 189)
Prepayments (Account 165 - Note C) (Attach 3, line 170)
--
-TP1.0000-
-GP--
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
36TOTAL WORKING CAPITAL (sum lines 33-35)--
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
37RATE BASE (sum lines 22, 30, 31, & 36)--
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Appendix A
Page 3 of 5
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Formula Rate - Non-Levelized
(1)
38O&M
39 Transmission
Rate Formula Template
Utilizing FERC Form 1 Data
New York Transco LLC
(2)(3)
Form No. 1
Page, Line, Col.Company Total
321.112.b-
For the 12 months ended 12/31/
(4)(5)
Transmission
Allocator(Col 3 times Col 4)
TP=1.0000-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
40
41
42
43
44
44a
44b
44c
45
46
47
48
49
Less Accounts 565, 561 and 561.1 to 561.8
A&G
Less EPRI & Reg. Comm. Exp. & Other Ad. Plus Transmission Related Reg. Comm. Exp. PBOP expense adjustment
Less Account 566
Amortization of Regulatory Assets
Account 566 excluding amort. of Reg Assets
TOTAL O&M (sum lines 39, 41, 43, 44, 44b, 44c
DEPRECIATION EXPENSE
Transmission
General and Intangible
Amortization of Abandoned Plant
321.96.b & 84.b to 92.b-
323.197.b-
(Note D & Attach 3, line 171)-
(Note D & Attach 3, line 172)-
(Attach 3, line 243)-
321.97.b-
(Attach 10, line 2)-
(line 44a less line 44b)-
less lines 40 & 42, 44a) (Note D)-
336.7.f (Note M)-
336.1.f + 336.10.f (Note M)-
(Attach 3, line 155) (Note K) -
TP=1.0000-
W /S--
DA--
TP=1.0000-
TP=1.0000-
DA--
DA--
DA--
-
TP1.0000-
W /S--
DA 1.0000 -
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
TOTAL DEPRECIATION (Sum lines 47-49)
TAXES OTHER THAN INCOME TAXES (Note E)
LABOR RELATED
Payroll
Highway and vehicle PLANT RELATED
Property
Gross Receipts
Other
-
263._.i (enter FN1 line #)-
263._.i (enter FN1 line #)-
263._.i (enter FN1 line #)-
263._.i (enter FN1 line #)-
263._.i (enter FN1 line #) -
-
W /S--
W /S--
GP--
NA--
GP --
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
TOTAL OTHER TAXES (sum lines 53-58)-
INCOME TAXES(Note F)
T=1 - {[(1 - SIT) * (1 - FIT)] / (1 - SIT * FIT * p))}*(1-n) =-
CIT=(T/1-T) * (1-(W CLTD/R)) =-
where W CLTD=(line 91) and R= (line 94)
and FIT, SIT, p, & n are as given in footnote F.
1 / (1 - T) = (T from line 61)-
Amortized Investment Tax Credit (Atttachment 4, line 14)-
Income Tax Calculation = line 62 * line 71 * (1-n)-
ITC adjustment (line 65 * line 66 * (1- n))-
Total Income Taxes(line 67 plus line 68)-
RETURN
[ Rate Base (line 37) * Rate of Return (line 94)]-
Rev Requirement before Incentive Projects (sum lines 45, 50, 59, 69, 71)-
Incentive Return and Income Tax on Authorized Projects (Attach 4, line 67, col h & j)-
Total Revenue Requirement (sum lines 72 & 73) -
-
-
NP--
-
NA-
-
DA100%-
-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Appendix A
Page 4 of 5
Formula Rate - Non-LevelizedRate Formula Template
Utilizing FERC Form 1 Data
For the 12 months ended 12/31/
New York Transco LLC SUPPORTING
CALCULATIONS AND NOTES
75TRANSMISSION PLANT INCLUDED IN RTO RATES
76Total transmission plant(line 7, column 3)-
77Less transmission plant excluded from RTO rates(Note H)(Attachment 3, line 175)-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
Less transmission plant included in OATT Ancillary Services (Note H)(Attachment 3, line 175) Transmission plant included in RTO rates (line 76 less lines 77 & 78)
Percentage of transmission plant included in RTO Rates (line 79 divided by line 76) [If line 76 equal zero, enter 1)
W AGES & SALARY ALLOCATOR (W &S) (Note I)
Form 1 Reference $
Production354.20.b-
Transmission354.21.b-
Distribution354.23.b-
Other354.24,25,26.b-
Total (sum lines 83-86) [TP equals 1 if there are no wages & salaries]-
RETURN (R)(Note J)
Long Term Debt(Attach 3, lines 249 & 270 or Attach 5) (Note G)
Preferred Stock (Attachment 3, lines 251 & 273)
-
-
TP=1.0000
TPAllocation
0.00-
1.00-
0.00-W &S Allocator
0.00-($ / Allocation)
-=-=WS
$%CostW eighted
----=W CLTD
----
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
Common Stock(Attachment 3, line 257)-
Total (sum lines 91-93)-
Development of Base Carrying charge and Summary of Incentive and Non-Incentive Investments
Source of Total Column
Net Transmission Plant in Service(Attachment 4, lines 66, 66a…, column b)
CW IP in Rate Base(Line 26)
Unamortized Abandoned Plant(Line 29)
Regulatory Assets(Line 28)
Development of Base Carrying charge and Summary of Incentive and Non-Incentive Investments (Sum of lines 95 to 98)
Return and Taxes (Sum lines 69 & 71)
Total Revenue Credits(Line 2)
Base Carrying Charge (used in Attach 4, Line 65) (Line 100 - Line 101)/ Line 99
-9.50%-
-=R
(a)(b)(c)
Non-incentiveIncentive
Investments fromInvestments fromRow
Attachment 4RowAttachment 4Numb
(Note N)Numbers(Note N)ersTotal
-----
---
--
--
--
-
-
-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Appendix A
Page 5 of 5
SUPPORTING CALCULATIONS AND NOTES
Formula Rate - Non-LevelizedRate Formula Template
Utilizing FERC Form 1 Data
For the 12 months ended 12/31/
New York Transco LLC
General Note: References to pages in this formulary rate are indicated as:(page#, line#, col.#)
References to data from FERC Form 1 are indicated as:#.y.x(page, line, column)
Note
Letter
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
AThe balances in Accounts 190, 281, 282 and 283, as adjusted by any amounts in contra accounts identified as regulatory assets or liabilities related
to FASB 106 or 109. The formula uses the stated average of the beginning and end of year balances to prorate ADIT to comply with IRS normalization rules.
Balance of Account 255 is reduced by prior flow throughs and excluded if the utility chose to utilize amortization of tax credits against taxable income as discussed
in Note F. Account 281 is not allocated.
BIdentified in Form 1 as being only transmission related.
CCash Working Capital assigned to transmission is one-eighth of O&M allocated to transmission
Prepayments are the electric related prepayments booked to Account No. 165 and reported on Pages 110-111
line 57 in the Form 1. DLine 42 removes EPRI Annual Membership Dues listed in Form 1 at 353._.f (enter FN1 line
#),
any EPRI Lobbying expenses included in line 42 of the template and all Regulatory Commission Expenses itemized at 351.h
Line 42 removes all advertising included in Account 930.1, except safety, education or out-reach related advertising
Line 42 removes all EEI and EPRI research, development and demonstration expenses and NY Transco will not participate in EEI or EPRI.
Line 43 reflects all Regulatory Commission Expenses directly related to transmission service, RTO filings, or transmission siting itemized at 351.h
Line 38 or Line 41 and thus Line 45 shall include any NYISO charges other than penalties, including but not limited to
administrative costs. E Includes only FICA, unemployment, highway, property, gross receipts, and other assessments
charged in the current year.
Taxes related to income are excluded. Gross receipts taxes are not included in transmission revenue requirement in the Rate Formula Template, since they are recovered elsewhere.
F The currently effective income tax rate, where FIT is the Federal income tax rate; SIT is the State income tax rate, and p =
"the percentage of federal income tax deductible for state income taxes". If the utility is taxed in more than one state it must attach a work paper showing the name of each state and how the blended or composite SIT was developed. Furthermore, a utility that elected to utilize amortization of tax credits against taxable income, rather than book tax credits to Account No. 255 and reduce
rate base.
multiplied by (1/1-T) .
Inputs Required:FIT =-
SIT=-(State Income Tax Rate or Composite SIT from Attach 3)
p =-(percent of federal income tax deductible for state purposes)
n=-(not for profit entity ownership percentage)
For each Rate Year (including both Annual Projections and True-Up Adjustments) the statutory income tax rates utilized in the Formula Rate shall reflect the weighted average rates
actually in effect during the Rate Year. For example, if the statutory tax rate is 10% from January 1 through June 30, and 5% from July 1 through December 31, such rates would be weighted 181/365 and 184/365, respectively, for a non-leap year.
G The cost of debt is determined using the internal rate of return methodology shown on Attachment 5 once project financing is obtained. Prior to obtaining project financing,
an interest rate of 3.85% from Table 4 of Attachment 5 will be used and will not be trued up. Attachment 5 contains an estimate of the internal rate of return
methodology; the methodology will be applied to actual amounts for use in Appendix A.
After the completion of construction, the cost of debt will be calculated pursuant to Attachment 3
HRemoves dollar amount of transmission plant included in the development of OATT ancillary services
rates and generation step-up facilities, which are deemed to included in OATT ancillary services.
For these purposes, generation step-up facilities are those facilities at a generator substation on
which there is no through-flow when the generator is shut down.
IEnter dollar amounts
JROE will be supported in the original filing and no change in ROE may be made absent a filing with FERC under FPA Section 205 or 206.
The capital structure will be the actual capital structure up to 53% equity. Lines 93 will be capped at 53% equity. If the actual equity ratio exceeds 53% , the common stock ratio will be reset to 53% and the debt ratio will be equal to 1 minus sum of the preferred stock ratio and common stock ratio.
K Unamortized Abandoned Plant and Amortization of Abandoned Plant will be zero until the Commission accepts or approves recovery of the cost of abandoned plant. Company must submit a Section 205 filing to recover the cost of
abandoned plant. Any such filing to recover the cost of an abandoned plant item shall be made no later than 180 days after the date that Company formally declares such plant item abandoned.
LUnamortized Regulatory Assets, consisting of all expenses incurred but not included in CWIP prior to the date the rate is charged to customers, is included at line 28
Carrying costs equal to the weighted cost of capital on the balance of the regulatory asset will accrue until the rate is charged to customers
M Balances exclude Asset Retirement Costs
NNon-incentive investments are investments without ROE incentives and incentive investments are investments with ROE incentives
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 1 - Revenue Credit Workpaper*
New York Transco LLC
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Account 454 - Rent from Electric Property (300.19.b)
1 Rent from FERC Form No. 1
Account 456 (including 456.1) (300.21.b and 300.22.b)
2 Other Electric Revenues (Note 2)
3 Professional Services
4 Revenues from Directly Assigned Transmission Facility Charges (Note 2)
5 Rent or Attachment Fees associated with Transmission Facilities
6 Total Revenue Credits
Notes 1 & 3
-
Notes 1 & 3
-
-
-
-
Sum lines 2-5 + line 1-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Note 1 All revenues booked to Account 454 that are derived from cost items classified as transmission-related will be included as a revenue credit. All revenues booked to Account 456
(includes 456.1) that are derived from cost items classified as transmission-related, and are not derived from rates under this transmission formula rate will be included as a
revenue credit. Work papers will be included to properly classify revenues booked to these accounts to the transmission function. A breakdown of all Account 454 revenues by subaccount will be provided below, and will be used to derive the proper calculation of revenue credits. A breakdown of all Account 456 revenues by subaccount and customer will be provided and tabulated below, and will be used to develop the proper calculation of revenue credits.
Note 2
If the facilities associated with the revenues are not included in the formula, the revenue is shown below, but not included in the total above and explained in the Attachment 3.
Note 3All Account 454 and 456 Revenues must be itemized below
Line No.
1Account 456TOTALNY-ISOOther 1Other 2
1aTransmission Service----
…----
1x
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
9a
9b
9c
9d
9e
9f
9g
…
9x
10
Trans. Fac. Charge----
Trans Studies----
Total----
Less:
Revenue for Demands in Divisor----
Sub Total Revenue Credit----
Prior Period Adjustments----
Total----
Account 454$
Joint pole attachments - telephone-
Joint pole attachments - cable-
Underground rentals-
Transmission tower wireless rentals-
Misc non-transmission rentals-
-
-
-
Total
-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 2 - Cost Support
New York Transco LLC
Plant in Service Worksheet
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
Calculation of Transmission Plant In Service
December
January
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September October
November
December
Transmission Plant In Service
Calculation of Distribution Plant In Service
December
January
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September October
November
December
Distribution Plant In Service
Calculation of Intangible Plant In Service
Source (Less ARO, see Note M) p206.58.b
company records
company records
company records
company records
company records
company records
company records
company records
company records
company records
company records
p207.58.g
(sum lines 2-14) /13
Source (Less ARO, see Note M) p206.75.b
company records
company records
company records
company records
company records
company records
company records
company records
company records
company records
company records
p207.75.g
(sum lines 17-29) /13
Source (Less ARO, see Note M)
YearBalance
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2015-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
2016-
-
Enter
Amount ofDocket Nos. for
Transmission CIACs Transmission CIACs
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
32Decemberp204.5.b2016--
33Januarycompany records2016--
34Februarycompany records2016--
35Marchcompany records2016--
36Aprilcompany records2016--
37Maycompany records2016--
38Junecompany records2016--
39Julycompany records2016--
40Augustcompany records2016--
41Septembercompany records2016--
42Octobercompany records2016--
43Novembercompany records2016--
44Decemberp205.5.g2016--
45Intangible Plant In Service(sum lines 32-44) /13--
46Calculation of General Plant In ServiceSource (Less ARO, see Note M)
47Decemberp206.99.b2016-
48Januarycompany records2016-
49Februarycompany records2016-
50Marchcompany records2016-
51Aprilcompany records2016-
52Maycompany records2016-
53Junecompany records2016-
54Julycompany records2016-
55Augustcompany records2016-
56Septembercompany records2016-
57Octobercompany records2016-
58Novembercompany records2016-
59Decemberp207.99.g2016-
60General Plant In Service(sum lines 47-59) /13-
61Calculation of Production Plant In ServiceSource (Less ARO, see Note M)
62Decemberp204.46b2016-
63Januarycompany records2016-
64Februarycompany records2016-
65Marchcompany records2016-
66Aprilcompany records2016-
67Maycompany records2016-
68Junecompany records2016-
69Julycompany records2016-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
70Augustcompany records2016-
71Septembercompany records2016-
72Octobercompany records2016-
73Novembercompany records2016-
74Decemberp205.46.g2016-
75Production Plant In Service(sum lines 62-74) /13-
76Total Plant In Service(sum lines 15, 30, 45, 60, & 75)-
Accumulated Depreciation Worksheet
77Calculation of Transmission Accumulated DepreciationSource (Less ARO, see Note M)YearBalance
78DecemberPrior year p219.25.b2016-
79Januarycompany records2016-
80Februarycompany records2016-
81Marchcompany records2016-
82Aprilcompany records2016-
83Maycompany records2016-
84Junecompany records2016-
85Julycompany records2016-
86Augustcompany records2016-
87Septembercompany records2016-
88Octobercompany records2016-
89Novembercompany records2016-
90Decemberp219.25.b2016-
91Transmission Accumulated Depreciation(sum lines 78-90) /13-
92Calculation of Distribution Accumulated DepreciationSource (Less ARO, see Note M)
93DecemberPrior year p219.26.b2016-
94Januarycompany records2016-
95Februarycompany records2016-
96Marchcompany records2016-
97Aprilcompany records2016-
98Maycompany records2016-
99Junecompany records2016-
100Julycompany records2016-
101Augustcompany records2016-
102Septembercompany records2016-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
103Octobercompany records2016-
104Novembercompany records2016-
105Decemberp219.26.b2016-
106Distribution Accumulated Depreciation(sum lines 93-105) /13-
Amount of
107Calculation of Intangible Accumulated AmortizationSource (Less ARO, see Note M)Transmission CIACs
108DecemberPrior year p200.21.c2016--
109Januarycompany records2016--
110Februarycompany records2016--
111Marchcompany records2016--
112Aprilcompany records2016--
113Maycompany records2016--
114Junecompany records2016--
115Julycompany records2016--
116Augustcompany records2016--
117Septembercompany records2016--
118Octobercompany records2016--
119Novembercompany records2016--
120Decemberp200.21.c2016--
121Accumulated Intangible Amortization(sum lines 108-120) /13--
122Calculation of General Accumulated DepreciationSource (Less ARO, see Note M)
123DecemberPrior year p219.28.b2016-
124Januarycompany records2016-
125Februarycompany records2016-
126Marchcompany records2016-
127Aprilcompany records2016-
128Maycompany records2016-
129Junecompany records2016-
130Julycompany records2016-
131Augustcompany records2016-
132Septembercompany records2016-
133Octobercompany records2016-
134Novembercompany records2016-
135Decemberp219.28.b2016-
136Accumulated General Depreciation(sum lines 123-135) /13-
137Calculation of Production Accumulated DepreciationSource (Less ARO, see Note M)
138Decemberp219.20:24.b (prior year)2016-
139Januarycompany records2016-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
140Februarycompany records2016-
141Marchcompany records2016-
142Aprilcompany records2016-
143Maycompany records2016-
144Junecompany records2016-
145Julycompany records2016-
146Augustcompany records2016-
147Septembercompany records2016-
148Octobercompany records2016-
149Novembercompany records2016-
150Decemberp219.20 thru 219.24.b2016-
151Production Accumulated Depreciation(sum lines 138-150) /13-
152Total Accumulated Depreciation and Amortization(sum lines 91, 106, 121, 136, & 151)-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 3 - Cost Support
New York Transco LLC
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Numbering continues from Attachment 2
153Account No. 255 (enter negative from FERC Form No. 1)266.8 and 267.8
154Unamortized Abandoned PlantAttachment 10, line 4, col. (y)
(recovery of abandoned plant requires a FERC order approving the amount and recovery period)
155 Amortization of Abandoned Plant Attachment 10, line 4, col. (h)
156Prepayments (Account 165)
(Prepayments exclude Prepaid Pension Assets)
157December111.57.d
158Januarycompany records
159Februarycompany records
160Marchcompany records
161Aprilcompany records
162Maycompany records
163Junecompany records
164Julycompany records
165Augustcompany records
166Septembercompany records
167Octobercompany records
168Novembercompany records
169 December 111.57.c
Beginning of YearEnd of Year
--
YearBalance
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
Details
Average Balance
-
-
Amortization Expense
-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
170Prepayments(sum lines 157-169) /13-
Reserves
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
170a(b)(c)
Amount
Reserve 1-
Reserve 2-
Reserve 3-
Reserve 4-
… -
… -
(d)(e)(f)
Enter 1 if NOT in a Enter 1 if the accrual account Enter the percentage paid
trust or reservedis included in the formulafor by customers, 1 less
account, enter zero (0)rate, enter (0) if O if thethe percent associated
if included in a trustaccrual account is NOTwith an offsetting liability
or reserved accountincluded in the formula rateon the balance sheet
---
---
---
---
---
---
(g)(h)
Amount Allocated,
Allocation (Plant orcol. c x col. d x col. e
x col. f x col. g Labor Allocator)
--
--
--
--
--
--
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Total-
All unfunded reserves will be listed above, specifically including (but not limited to) all subaccounts for FERC Account Nos. 228.1 through 228.4. "Unfunded reserve" is defined as an accrued balance (1) created and increased by debiting an expense which is included in this formula rate (column (e), using the same allocator in column (g) as used in the formula to allocate the amounts in the corresponding expense account) (2) in
advance of an anticipated expenditure related to that expense (3) that is not deposited in a restricted account (e.g., set aside in an escrow account, see column (d)) with the earnings thereon retained within that
account. Where a given reserve is only partially funded through accruals collected from customers, only the balance funded by customer collections shall serve as a rate base credit, see column (f). The source of
monthly balance data is company records.
EPRI Dues Cost Support
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Allocated General & Common Expenses
EPRI Dues
171EPRI and EEI Dues to be excluded from the formula ratep353._.f (enter FN1 line #)-
Regulatory Expense Related to Transmission Cost Support
Transmission
Form 1 AmountRelatedOtherDetails*
Directly Assigned A&G
172Regulatory Commission Exp Account 928p323.189.b---
* insert case specific detail and associated assignments here
Multi-state Workpaper
Income Tax Rates
Weighting
New York
1
State 2
State 3
State 4
State 5
Weighed Average
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
173
SIT=State Income Tax Rate or Composite0.0710
Multiple state rates are weighted based on the state apportionment factors on the state income tax returns and the number of days in the year that the rates are effective (see Note F)
0.07
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Safety Related and Education and Out Reach Cost Support
Safety Related,
Education, Siting &
Form 1 AmountOutreach RelatedOtherDetails
Directly Assigned A&G
174General Advertising Exp Account 930.1company records-
Safety advertising consists of any advertising whose primary purpose is to educate the recipient as to what is safe or is not safe.
Education advertising consists of any advertising whose primary purpose is to educate the recipient as about transmission related facts or issues Outreach advertising consists of advertising whose primary purpose is to attract the attention of the recipient about a transmission related issue Siting advertising consists of advertising whose primary purpose is to inform the recipient about locating transmission facilities
Lobbying expenses are not allowed to be included in account 930.1
Excluded Plant Cost Support
Transmission plant
included in OATT
ExcludedAncillary Services
Transmissionand not otherwise
FacilitiesexcludedDescription of the Facilities
Adjustment to Remove Revenue Requirements Associated with Excluded Transmission Facilities
175Excluded Transmission Facilities--General Description of the Facilities
A worksheet will be provided if there are ever any excluded transmission plant or transmission plant in OATT Ancillary Services
Add more lines if necessary
Materials & Supplies
Stores ExpenseTransmission Materials & Construction Materials
Note: for the projection, the prior year's actual balances will be usedUndistributedSupplies& SuppliesTotal
Form No.1 pagep227.16p227.8p227.5
176DecemberColumn b----
177JanuaryCompany Records----
178FebruaryCompany Records----
179MarchCompany Records----
180AprilCompany Records----
181MayCompany Records----
182JuneCompany Records----
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
183JulyCompany Records----
184AugustCompany Records----
185SeptemberCompany Records----
186OctoberCompany Records----
187NovemberCompany Records----
188DecemberColumn c----
189Average-
PBOPs
Details
190ConEd
191Total PBOP expenses$(8,800,000)
192Labor dollars$1,444,841,000
193Cost per labor dollar$(0.0061)
194labor (labor not capitalized) current yearCompany Records-
195PBOP Expense for current year-
196PBOP Expense in Account 926 for current yearCompany Records-
197PBOP Adjustment for Appendix A, Line 44-
198Lines 191-193 cannot change absent approval or acceptance by FERC in a separate proceeding.
198NiMo
199Total PBOP expenses$70,883,643
200Labor dollars$313,713,746
201Cost per labor dollar$0.2260
202labor (labor not capitalized) current yearCompany Records-
203PBOP Expense for current year-
204PBOP Expense in Account 926 for current yearCompany Records-
205PBOP Adjustment for Appendix A, Line 44-
206Lines 199-201 cannot change absent approval or acceptance by FERC in a separate proceeding.
207NYSEG
208Total PBOP expenses$2,057,829
209Labor dollars$187,586,000
210Cost per labor dollar$0.0110
211labor (labor not capitalized) current yearCompany Records-
212PBOP Expense for current year-
213PBOP Expense in Account 926 for current yearCompany Records-
214PBOP Adjustment for Appendix A, Line 44-
215Lines 208-210 cannot change absent approval or acceptance by FERC in a separate proceeding.
216RGE
217Total PBOP expenses$3,561,081
218Labor dollars$79,625,000
219Cost per labor dollar$0.0447
220labor (labor not capitalized) current yearCompany Records-
221PBOP Expense for current year-
222PBOP Expense in Account 926 for current yearCompany Records-
223PBOP Adjustment for Appendix A, Line 44-
224Lines 217-219 cannot change absent approval or acceptance by FERC in a separate proceeding.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
225CHG&E
226Total PBOP expenses$(3,863,900)
227Labor dollars108,206,368
228Cost per labor dollar$(0.0357)
229labor (labor not capitalized) current yearCompany Records-
230PBOP Expense for current year-
231PBOP Expense in Account 926 for current yearCompany Records-
232PBOP Adjustment for Appendix A, Line 44-
233Lines 226-228 cannot change absent approval or acceptance by FERC in a separate proceeding.
234New York Transco LLC
235Total PBOP expenses$-
236Labor dollars$-
237Cost per labor dollar$0.000
238labor (labor not capitalized) current yearCompany Records-
239PBOP Expense for current year-
240PBOP Expense in Account 926 for current yearCompany Records-
241PBOP Adjustment for Appendix A, Line 44-
242Lines 235-237 cannot change absent approval or acceptance by FERC in a separate proceeding.
243PBOP expense adjustment(sum lines 197, 214, 205, 223, 232, & 241)-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 3 - Cost Support
COST OF CAPITALNew York Transco LLC
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Line No.
244
245
246
247
248
249
250251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258259
260261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268269
270
271272
273274
275
Form No.1
DescriptionReferenceDecemberJanuaryFebruaryMarch
Col. (a)Col. (b)Col. (c)Col. (d)
Long Term Debt:
Acct 221 Bonds112.18.c,d----
Acct 223 Advances from Assoc. Companies112.20.c,d----
Acct 224 Other Long Term Debt112.21.c,d----
Less Acct 222 Reacquired Debt112.19 c, d enter negative----
Total Long Term DebtSum Lines 244 - 248----
Preferred Stock (1)112.3.c,d----
Common Equity- Per Books112.16.c,d----
Less Acct 204 Preferred Stock112.3.c,d----
Less Acct 219 Accum Other Compre. Income112.15.c,d----
Less Acct 216.1 Unappropriated Undistributed
Subsidiary Earnings112.12.c,d
Adjusted Common EquityLn 253 - 254 - 255 - 256----
Total (Line 249 plus Line 251 plus Line 257)----
Cost of Debt
Acct 427 Interest on Long Term Debt117.62.c
Acct 428 Amortization of Debt Discount and Expense117.63.c
Acct 428.1 Amortization of Loss on Reacquired Debt117.64.c
Acct 430 Interest on Debt to Assoc. Companies (LTD
portion only) (2)117.67.c
Less: Acct 429 Amort of Premium on Debt117.65.c enter negative
Less: Acct 429.1 Amort of Gain on117.66.c enter negative
Total Interest ExpenseSum Lines 262 - 267
Average Cost of Debt (Line 268 / Line 249)
Cost of Preferred Stock
Preferred Stock Dividends118.29.c
Average Cost of Preferred Stock (Line 273 / Line 251)
Note 1. If and when the Company issues preferred stock, footnote will indicate the authorizing regulatory agency, the docket/case number, and the date of the Note 2. Interest on Debt to Associated Companies (FERC 430) will be populated with interest related to Long-Term Debt only.
AprilMayJuneJulyAugust
Col. (e)Col. (f)Col. (g)Col. (h)Col. (i)
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
SeptemberOctoberNovemberDecember13 Month Avg.
Col. (j)Col. (k)Col. (l)Col. (m)Col. (n)
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-----
-
-----
-----
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Project W orksheetRate Formula TemplateFor the 12 months ended 12/31/
Attachment 4Utilizing Appendix A Data
The calcuations below calcuate that additional revenue requirement for 100 basis points of ROE and 1 percent change in the equity component of the capital structure.
These amounts are then used to caluate the actual increase in revenue in the table below (starting on line 66) associated with the actual incentive authortized by the Commisison The use of the 100 basis point calulations do not presume any particular incentive (i.e., 100 basis points) being granted by the Commisison.
New York Transco LLC
Base ROE and Income Taxes Carrying Charge
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
1 Rate Base
2 BASE RETURN CALCULATION:
3 Long Term Debt(Appendix A, Line 91)
4 Preferred Stock(Appendix A, Line 92)
5 Common Stock(Appendix A, Line 93)
6 Total (sum lines 3-5)
7 Return multiplied by Rate Base (line 1 * line 6)
8 INCOME TAXES
9T=1 - {[(1 - SIT) * (1 - FIT)] / (1 - SIT * FIT * p)} = (Appendix A, line 61)
10CIT=(T/1-T) * (1-(W CLTD/R)) =
11where W CLTD=(line 3) and R= (line 6)
12and FIT, SIT & p are as given in footnote F on Appendix A.
131 / (1 - T) = (T from line 9)
14 Amortized Investment Tax Credit (266.8f) (enter negative)
15 Income Tax Calculation = line 10 * line 7 * (1-n)
16 ITC adjustment (line 13 * line 14) * (1-n)
17 Total Income Taxes(line 15 plus line 16)
18 Base Return and Income Taxes
19 Rate Base
20 Return and Income Taxes at Base ROE
100 Basis Point Incentive ROE and Income Taxes Carrying Charge
21 Rate Base
22100 Basis Point Incentive Return impact on
23 Long Term Debt(line 3)
24 Preferred Stock(line 4)
25 Common Stock(line 5 plus 100 basis points)
26 Total (sum lines 24-26)
27100 Basis Point Incentive Return multiplied by Rate Base (line 21 * line 26)
28 INCOME TAXES
29T=1 - {[(1 - SIT) * (1 - FIT)] / (1 - SIT * FIT * p)} = (Appendix A, line 61)
30CIT=(T/1-T) * (1-(W CLTD/R)) =
31where W CLTD=(line 23) and R= (line 26)
32and FIT, SIT & p are as given in footnote F on Appendix A.
331 / (1 - T) = (T from line 29)
34 Amortized Investment Tax Credit (line 14)
35 Income Tax Calculation = line 30 * line 27 * (1-n)
36 ITC adjustment (line 33 * line 34) * (1-n)
37 Total Income Taxes(line 35 plus line 36)
38 Return and Income Taxes with 100 basis point increase in ROE
39 Rate Base
40 Return and Income Taxes with 100 basis point increase in ROE
41 Difference in Return and Income Taxes between Base ROE and 100 Basis Point Incentive
Effect of 1% Increase in the Equity Ratio
42 Rate Base
43100 Basis Point Incentive Return
44 Long Term Debt(line 3 minus 1% in equity ratio)
45 Preferred Stock(line 4)
46 Common Stock(line 5 plus 1% in equity ratio))
47 Total (sum lines 44-46)
48 Line 47 x line 42
49 INCOME TAXES
50T=1 - {[(1 - SIT) * (1 - FIT)] / (1 - SIT * FIT * p)} = (Appendix A, line 61)
51 CIT=(T/1-T) * (1-(W CLTD/R)) =
AllocatorResult
-
$%CostWeighted
-0%0.00%0.00%
-0%0.00%0.00%
-0%9.50%0.00%
-0.00%
-
-
-
-
-
--
-NP--
--
Sum lines 7 and 17-
Line 1-
Line 18 / line 19-
Attachment 4
Result
-
$%CostWeighted
-0%0.00%-
-0%0.00%-
-0%10.50%-
--
-
-
-
-
-
--
-NP--
--
Sum lines 27 and 37-
Line 21-
Line 38 / line 39-
Line 40- Line 20-
Results
-
$%CostWeighted
--1%0.00%0.00%
-0%0.00%0.00%
-1%9.50%0.10%
-0.10%
-
-
-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
52where W CLTD=(line 44) and R= (line 47)
53and FIT, SIT & p are as given in footnote F on Appendix A.
541 / (1 - T) = (T from line 50)
55 Amortized Investment Tax Credit (line 14)
56 Income Tax Calculation = line 51 * line 48 * (1-n)
57 ITC adjustment (line 54 * line 55) * (1-n)
58 Total Income Taxes(line 56 plus line 57)
59 Return and Income Taxes with 1% Increase in the Equity Ratio
60 Rate Base
61 Return and Income Taxes with 1% Increase in the Equity Ratio
62 Difference between Base ROE and 1% Increase in the Equity Ratio
63 Revenue Requirement per project including incentives
-
-
-
-NP-
-
Sum lines 48 and 58
Line 42
Line 59 / line 60
Line 61 - Line 20
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Attachment 4
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
64 Expense Allocator[Appendix A, lines 45 and 59, less Appendix A, line 44b / Gross Transmission Plant In Service Column (l) including Transmission CIACs] times TP on Appendix A, line 80 (Note B)-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
65 Base Carrying Charge (used in Line 102 Appendix A)-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
The table below breaks out the total revenue requirement on Appendix A separately for each investment. The total of Column (p) must equal the amount shown on Appendix A, Line 3.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
(a)(b)(c)(d)(e)(f)(g)(h)(i)(j)(k)(l)(m)(n)(o)(p)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
LineDescription
66-
66a-
66b-
66c-
…
…
…
…
…
…
…
…
…
…
…
…
…
67 Total
Check Sum Appendix A Line 3
Difference (must be zero)
Note:
ROEROE Base
Authorized by(From
Net InvestmentFERC (Note Appendix A,
(Note A)C)line 93)
--9.50%
--9.50%
--9.50%
--9.50%
-9.50%
9.50%
9.50%
9.50%
9.50%
9.50%
9.50%
9.50%
9.50%
9.50%
9.50%
9.50%
9.50%
9.50%
$0.00
Incentive %
Authorized by
FERC (NoteCol (e) / .01 x Incentive $ (Col
D)Line 41Col (f)(b) x Col (g)
----
----
----
-
-
Equity % in Capital
Structure (% aboveImpact of Equity
base %, -% below base Component of Capital
%)(1 equals 1%) (Note Structure(Col (b) x (i) Base Return and Tax (Line 65 x
D)x Line 62Col (b)
---
---
---
-
--
O&M (exc Amort.
Of Reg. Assets),
Gross Plant InExpenseTaxes Other than Depreciation/Am Total Revenues
Service (NoteAllocatorIncomeortization(Col. (h) + (j) +
B)(line 64)(Col. (l) x Col. (m)Expense(k) +(n) +(o))
-----
-----
-----
---
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
$0---
-
-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
A Column (b), Net Investment includes the Net Plant In Service, unamortized regulatory assets, unamortized abandoned plant and CWIP
B Column (l), Gross Plant in Service excludes Regulatory Assets, CW IP, and Abandoned Plant.
C Column (e), for each project with an incentive in column (e), note the docket No. in which FERC granted the incentive
D No incentive or change in the equity percentage in Columns (e) and (i) can be made absent Commisison authorization
ProjectDocket No.Note
TOTs 1 - Ramapo to Rock TavernER15-572Up to $228 million for the 3 TOTS projects in aggregate
TOTs 2 - Staten Island Unbottling Feeder SplitER15-572Up to $228 million for the 3 TOTS projects in aggregate
TOTs 3 - NYSEG's Marcy South Series Comp Fraser to Coopers CornerER15-572Up to $228 million for the 3 TOTS projects in aggregate
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 5 - Financing Costs for Long Term Debt using the Internal Rate of Return Methodology (Note 13)
New York Transco LLC
HYPOTHETICAL EXAMPLE
Assumes financing will be a 5 year loan with Origination Fees of $2.1 million and a Commitments Fee of 0.3% on the undrawn principal.
Consistent with GAAP, the Origination Fees and Commitments Fees will be amortized using the standard Internal Rate of Return formula below.
Each year, the amounts withdrawn, the interest paid in the year, Origination Fees, Commitments Fees, and total loan amount will be updated on this attachment.
Table 1
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Total Loan Amount
Table 2
Internal Rate of Return1
Based on following Financial Formula2:
NPV = 0 =
Table 3
Origination Fees
Underwriting Discount
Arrangement Fee
Upfront Fee
Rating Agency Fee
Legal Fees
Total Issuance Expense
Table 4
20142015
$125,000,000
4.892%
-
250,000
437,500
-
1,000,000
1,687,500
20162017201820192020
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
14LIBOR Rate0.64%1.03%1.60%2.13%2.13%2.13%2.13%
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
15Spread2.25%2.25%2.25%2.25%2.25%2.25%2.25%
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
16Interest Rate2.89%3.28%3.85%4.38%4.38%4.38%4.38%
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Table 5
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
(A)(B)( C)(D)(E)(F)(G)(H)(I)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Principal
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
CapitalDrawn In
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
ExpendituresQuarterPrincipal Drawn Interest & PrincipalOrigination FeesCommitment & Utilization
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
17Year($000's)($000's)To Date ($000's)($000's)($000's)Fee ($000's)Net Cash Flows ($000's)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
1/4 * Interest Rate from
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Line 16 x Col. E prior(line 1/1000 less Col. E prior
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
quarter and Principalquarter)*line 13/4 +line
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Cumulative Col. DrepaymentInput in first Qtr of Loan12/4000+line 11/4000(D-F-G-H)
18
19
203/31/2014Q319,3509,6759,6752,1007,575
216/30/2014Q419,3509,67519,350701249,481
229/30/2014Q119,3509,67529,0251411179,418
2312/31/2014Q219,3509,67538,7002111099,354
243/31/2015Q324,77512,38851,08827510212,010
25266/30/2015Q424,77512,38863,4754189311,876
9/30/2015Q124,77512,38875,8635258411,778
272812/31/2015Q224,77512,38888,2506287411,685
3/31/2016Q323,95011,975100,2257236511,187
296/30/2016Q423,95011,975112,2009625610,957
309/30/2016Q123,95011,975124,1751,0894710,839
3112/31/2016Q223,95011,975136,1501,2053810,732
323/31/2017Q323,57511,788147,9381,2922910,466
336/30/2017Q423,57511,788159,7251,6152010,152
349/30/2017Q123,57511,788171,5131,7631110,013
3512/31/2017Q223,57511,788183,3001,89339,891
36373/31/2018Q3--183,300185,280(185,280)
38
39
40
41
42
Notes 1 The IRR is the input to Debt Cost shown on Appendix A, Page 4, Line 91 during the construction period, after obtaining project financing, in accordance with Note G of Appendix A.
2. The IRR is a discount rate that makes the net present value of a series of cash flows equal to zero. The IRR equation is shown on line 4.
N is the last quarter the loan would be outstanding
t is each quarter
Ct is the cash flow (Table 5, Col. I in each quarter)
Alternatively the equation can be written as 0 = C0 + C1/(1+IRR) + C2/(1+IRR)2 + C3/(1+IRR)3 + . . . +Cn/(1+IRR)n and solved for IRR
The Excel ™ formula on line 2 is : (round(XIRR(first quarter of loan Col A of Table 5:last quarter of loan Col A of Table 5, first quarter of loan Col I of Table 5: last quarter of loan Col I of Table 5, 8%),4)) The 8% in the above formula is a seed number to ensure the formula produces a positive number.
3. Line 1 reflects the loan amount, the maximum amount that can be drawn on
4. Lines 5 through 13 include the fees associated with the loan. They are estimated based on current bank condition and are updated with the actual fees once the actual fees are known.
5. The estimate of the average 3 month Libor forward rate for the year on line 14 is that published by Bloomberg Finance L.P. during August of the prior year and is trued-up to actual
average 3 month Libor rate for the year under the loan.
6. Table 5, Col. C reflect the capital expenditures in each quarter
7. Table 5, Col. D reflect the amount of the loan that is drawn down in the quarter
8. Table 5, Col. E is the amount of principle drawn down
9. Table 5, Col F calculates the interest on the principle drawn down to date based on the applicable interest on line 16
10. Table 5, Col. G is the total origination fees in line 10 and is input in the first quarter that a portion of the loan in drawn
11. Table 5, Col. H is calculated as follows:
(line 1/1000 less Col. E prior quarter)*line 13/4 +line 12/4000+line 11/4000
Where A = Loan amount in line 1 less the amount drawn down (Table 5, Col. (E)) in the prior quarter
12. The inputs shall be estimated based on the current market conditions and is subject to true up for all inputs , e.g., fees, interest rates, spread, and Table 3 once the
amounts are known
13. Prior to obtaining long term debt, the cost of debt, will be 3.28%. If NY Transco obtains project financing, the long term debt rate will be determined using the methodology in Attachment 5 and Attachment 5 contains a
hypothetical example of the internal rate of return methodology; the methodology will be applied to actual amounts for use in Attachment A. After the first project is placed into service, NY Transco will use the its actual cost of long term debt determined in Attachment 3. The capital structure will be the actual capital structure up to 53% equity.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
New York Transco LLC
Attachment 6a - Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes (ADIT) Worksheet (Beginning of Year)
Beginning of Year
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Item
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
ADIT-282
ADIT-283
ADIT-190
Subtotal
Wages & Salary Allocator
NP
Beginning of Year
End of year from Attachment 6b, line 7
Average of Beginning of Year and End of Year ((7 +8)/2)
TransmissionPlantLabor
RelatedRelatedRelated
---
---
---
---
-
-
---
---
---
Total
From Acct. 282 total, below
From Acct. 283 total, below
From Acct. 190 total, below
-
-
-Enter as negative Appendix A, line 24.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
In filling out this attachment, a full and complete description of each item and justification for the allocation to Columns B-F and each separate ADIT item will be listed,
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
dissimilar items with amounts exceeding $100,000 will be listed separately. For ADIT directly related to project depreciation or CWIP, the balance must shown in a separate row for each project.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
ABCDEFG
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
TotalGas, Prod
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
10 ADIT-190Or OtherTransmissionPlantLabor
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
RelatedRelatedRelatedRelatedJustification
11a
11b
11c
…
12Subtotal - p234-----
13Less FASB 109 Above if not separately removed
14Less FASB 106 Above if not separately removed
15Total-----
Instructions for Account 190:
161. ADIT items related only to Non-Electric Operations (e.g., Gas, Water, Sewer) or Production are directly assigned to Column C
172. ADIT items related only to Transmission are directly assigned to Column D
183. ADIT items related to Plant and not in Columns C & D are included in Column E
194. ADIT items related to labor and not in Columns C & D are included in Column F
205. If the item giving rise to the ADIT is not included in the formula, the associated ADIT amount shall be excluded
New York Transco LLC
Attachment 6a - Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes (ADIT) Worksheet (Beginning of Year)
Beginning of Year
ABCDEFG
TotalGas, Prod
21 ADIT- 282Or OtherTransmissionPlantLabor
RelatedRelatedRelatedRelatedJustification
22a
22b
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
22c
…
…
…
…
…
…
23Subtotal - p275-----
24Less FASB 109 Above if not separately removed
25Less FASB 106 Above if not separately removed
26Total-----
Instructions for Account 282:
271. ADIT items related only to Non-Electric Operations (e.g., Gas, Water, Sewer) or Production are directly assigned to Column C
282. ADIT items related only to Transmission are directly assigned to Column D
293. ADIT items related to Plant and not in Columns C & D are included in Column E
304. ADIT items related to labor and not in Columns C & D are included in Column F
315. If the item giving rise to the ADIT is not included in the formula, the associated ADIT amount shall be excluded
New York Transco LLC
Attachment 6a - Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes (ADIT) Worksheet (Beginning of Year)
Beginning of Year
ABCDEFG
TotalGas, Prod
32 ADIT- 283Or OtherTransmissionPlantLabor
RelatedRelatedRelatedRelated
33a
33b
33c
…
…
…
…
…
…
…
34Subtotal - p277-----
35Less FASB 109 Above if not separately removed
36Less FASB 106 Above if not separately removed
37Total-----
Instructions for Account 283:
381. ADIT items related only to Non-Electric Operations (e.g., Gas, Water, Sewer) or Production are directly assigned to Column C
392. ADIT items related only to Transmission are directly assigned to Column D
403. ADIT items related to Plant and not in Columns C & D are included in Column E
414. ADIT items related to labor and not in Columns C & D are included in Column F
425. If the item giving rise to the ADIT is not included in the formula, the associated ADIT amount shall be excluded
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
New York Transco LLC
Attachment 6b - Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes (ADIT) Worksheet (End of Year)
End of Year
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Line
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
TransmissionPlantLabor
RelatedRelatedRelated
ADIT-282---
ADIT-283---
ADIT-190---
Subtotal---
Wages & Salary Allocator-
NP-
End of Year ADIT---
In filling out this attachment, a full and complete description of each item and justification for the allocation to Columns B-F and each separate ADIT item will be listed,
dissimilar items with amounts exceeding $100,000 will be listed separately. For ADIT directly related to project depreciation or CWIP, the balance must be shown in a separate row for each project.
ABCDE
TotalGas, Prod
ADIT-190Or OtherTransmissionPlant
RelatedRelatedRelated
Total
From Acct. 282 total, below
From Acct. 283 total, below
From Acct. 190 total, below
-
FG
Labor
Related Justification
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
9a
9b
9c
…
…
…
…
…
…
…
10Subtotal - p234-----
11Less FASB 109 Above if not separately removed
12Less FASB 106 Above if not separately removed
13Total-----
Instructions for Account 190:
141. ADIT items related only to Non-Electric Operations(e.g., Gas, Water, Sewer) or Production are directly assigned to Column C
152. ADIT items related only to Transmission are directly assigned to Column D
163. ADIT items related to Plant and not in Columns C & D are included in Column E
174. ADIT items related to labor and not in Columns C & D are included in Column F
185. If the item giving rise to the ADIT is not included in the formula, the associated ADIT amount shall be excluded
New York Transco LLC
Attachment 6b - Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes (ADIT) Worksheet (End of Year)
End of Year
ABCDEFG
TotalGas, Prod
19ADIT- 282Or OtherTransmissionPlantLabor
RelatedRelatedRelatedRelatedJustification
20a-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
20b
20c
…
…
…
…
…
…
21Subtotal - p275-----
22Less FASB 109 Above if not separately removed
23Less FASB 106 Above if not separately removed
24Total-----
Instructions for Account 282:
251. ADIT items related only to Non-Electric Operations(e.g., Gas, Water, Sewer) or Production are directly assigned to Column C
262. ADIT items related only to Transmission are directly assigned to Column D
273. ADIT items related to Plant and not in Columns C & D are included in Column E
284. ADIT items related to labor and not in Columns C & D are included in Column F
295. If the item giving rise to the ADIT is not included in the formula, the associated ADIT amount shall be excluded
New York Transco LLC
Attachment 6b - Accumulated Deferred Income Taxes (ADIT) Worksheet (End of Year)
End of Year
ABCDEFG
TotalGas, Prod
30ADIT- 283Or OtherTransmissionPlantLabor
RelatedRelatedRelatedRelated
31a
31b
31c
…
…
…
…
…
…
…
32Subtotal - p277-----
33Less FASB 109 Above if not separately removed
34Less FASB 106 Above if not separately removed
35Total-----
Instructions for Account 283:
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
361. ADIT items related only to Non-Electric Operations(e.g., Gas, Water, Sewer) or Production are directly assigned to Column C
372. ADIT items related only to Transmission are directly assigned to Column D
383. ADIT items related to Plant and not in Columns C & D are included in Column E
394. ADIT items related to labor and not in Columns C & D are included in Column F
405. If the item giving rise to the ADIT is not included in the formula, the associated ADIT amount shall be excluded
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 7 - Example of True-Up Calculation (Note 3)
New York Transco LLC
20142014
Revenue Requirement BilledActual Revenue RequirementOver (Under)
(Note 1)(Note 2)Recovery
$0Less$0Equals$0
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Interest Rate on Amount of Refunds or Surcharges
Over (Under) Recovery PlusMonthly Interest Rate on
InterestAttachment 7a
0.2708%
Surcharge
Months Calculated Interest Amortization (Refund) Owed
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
An over or under collection will be recovered prorata over year collected, held for one year and returned prorata over next year. If the first year is a partial year, the true-up (over or under recovery per month and interest calculation) will reflect only the number of months for which the rate was charged.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Calculation of Interest
January
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
January through December
Year 2014-
Year 2014-
Year 2014-
Year 2014-
Year 2014-
Year 2014-
Year 2014-
Year 2014-
Year 2014-
Year 2014-
Year 2014-
Year 2014-
Year 2014-
Monthly
0.2708%12--
0.2708%11--
0.2708%10--
0.2708%9--
0.2708%8--
0.2708%7--
0.2708%6--
0.2708%5--
0.2708%4--
0.2708%3--
0.2708%2--
0.2708%1--
--
Annual
0.2708%12--
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Over (Under) Recovery Plus Interest Amortized and Recovered Over 12 Months
JanuaryYear 2016-
FebruaryYear 2016-
MarchYear 2016-
AprilYear 2016-
MayYear 2016-
JuneYear 2016-
JulyYear 2016-
AugustYear 2016-
SeptemberYear 2016-
OctoberYear 2016-
November Year 2016 -
Monthly
0.2708%---
0.2708%---
0.2708%---
0.2708%---
0.2708%---
0.2708%---
0.2708%---
0.2708%---
0.2708%---
0.2708%---
0.2708%---
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
DecemberYear 2016-0.2708%---
-
Total Amount of True-Up Adjustment$-
Less Over (Under) Recovery$-
Total Interest$-
Note 1: Revenue requirements billed is input, source data are the invoices from NYISO. The amounts exclude any true ups or prior period adjustments. Note 2: The actual revenue requirement is input from Attachment 4, line 66, column p. The amounts exclude any true-ups or prior period adjustments. Note 3: This "Example" sheet will be populated with actuals and used in each year's annual true-up calculation.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 7a
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
True-Up Interest Calculation
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
FERC Quarterly Interest Rate
Qtr 3 (Previous Year)
Qtr 4 (Previous Year)
Qtr 1 (Current Year)
Qtr 2 (Current Year)
Average of the last 4 quarters
Interest Rate Used for True-up adjustment (Note B) Monthly Interest Rate for Attachment 7
Page 1
Pursuant to
18 C.F.R. Section
18 35.19 (a)
3.25%
3.25%
3.25%
3.25%
(Lines 1-4 / 4)3.25%
0.0325
(Line 6 / 12)0.0027
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 8 - Hypothetical Example of Final True-Up of Interest Rates and Interest Calculations for the Construction Loan (Note 1)
New York Transco LLC
SUMMARY
Revenue Requirement
Total Amount of
Monthly FERCConstruction Loan
Based on cost of debtBased on ActualRefund Interest RateRelated True-Up to be
Estimated Effective cost of debtFinal Effective cost of debt for theused in prior year true-Final Cost of DebtOver (Under)applicable over theincluded in rates
YEARused in true upconstruction loan:ups (Note 2)(Note 3)RecoveryATRR period(Refund)/Owed
20147.18%6.50%$2,500,000.00$2,400,000.00$100,000.000.550%$(148,288.33)
20156.8%6.50%$5,000,000.00$5,150,000.00$(150,000.00)0.560%$209,670.43
20167.2%6.50%$8,300,000.00$8,200,000.00$100,000.000.540%$(131,109.09)
20177.3%6.50%$12,300,000.00$12,000,000.00$300,000.000.580%$(368,656.73)
2018*7.1%6.50%$18,000,000.00$17,900,000.00$100,000.000.570%$(114,946.28)
2018**6.50%6.50%$25,000,000.00$25,000,000.00$-
$(553,329.99)
The Hypothetical Example:
* Assumes that the construction loan is retired on December 31, 2018
** Assumes that the construction loan IRR on Attachment 5 has an effective rate of 6.5%
Calculation of Applicable Interest Expense for each ATRR period
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Interest Rate on Amount of Refunds or Surcharges from 35.19a
Calculation of Interest for 2014 True-Up Period
Hypothetical Monthly
Over (Under) Recovery Plus Interest Interest Rate
Surcharge (Refund)
Months Calculated Interest Amortization Owed
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
An over or under collection will be recovered prorata over 2014, held for 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, and 2019 and returned prorate over 2020
JanuaryYear 2014-0.5500%
Monthly
12.00--
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
January through December
January through December
January through December
January through December
January through December
Year 2014-0.5500%11.00
Year 201410,0000.5500%10.00
Year 201410,0000.5500%9.00
Year 201410,0000.5500%8.00
Year 201410,0000.5500%7.00
Year 201410,0000.5500%6.00
Year 201410,0000.5500%5.00
Year 201410,0000.5500%4.00
Year 201410,0000.5500%3.00
Year 201410,0000.5500%2.00
Year 201410,0000.5500%1.00
Year 2015(103,025)0.5600%12.00
Year 2016(109,948)0.5400%12.00
Year 2017(117,073)0.5800%12.00
Year 2018(125,221)0.5700%12.00
Year 2019 (133,786) 0.5700% 12.00
-
(550)
(495)
(440)
(385)
(330)
(275)
(220)
(165)
(110)
(55)
(3,025)
Annual
(6,923)
(7,125)
(8,148)
(8,565)
(9,151)
-
(10,550)
(10,495)
(10,440)
(10,385)
(10,330)
(10,275)
(10,220)
(10,165)
(10,110)
(10,055)
(103,025)
(109,948)
(117,073)
(125,221)
(133,786)
(142,937)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Over (Under) Recovery Plus Interest Amortized and Recovered Over 12 Months
JanuaryYear 2020
Monthly
142,937
0.5700%
(815)(12,357)(131,395)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
Year 2020131,3950.5700%
Year 2020119,7860.5700%
Year 2020108,1120.5700%
Year 202096,3710.5700%
Year 202084,5630.5700%
Year 202072,6870.5700%
Year 202060,7440.5700%
Year 202048,7330.5700%
Year 202036,6530.5700%
Year 202024,5050.5700%
Year 2020 12,287 0.5700%
(749)
(683)
(616)
(549)
(482)
(414)
(346)
(278)
(209)
(140)
(70)
(5,351)
(12,357)(119,786)
(12,357)(108,112)
(12,357)(96,371)
(12,357)(84,563)
(12,357)(72,687)
(12,357)(60,744)
(12,357)(48,733)
(12,357)(36,653)
(12,357)(24,505)
(12,357)(12,287)
(12,357) 0
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Total Amount of True-Up Adjustment for 2014 ATRR Less Over (Under) Recovery
Total Interest
$(148,288)
$100,000
$ (48,288)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 8 - Hypothetical Example of Final True-Up of Interest Rates and Interest Calculations for the Construction Loan
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
New York Transco LLC
Calculation of Interest for 2015 True-Up Period
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
An over or under collection will be recovered prorata over 2015, held for 2016, 2017, 2018, and 2019 and returned prorate over 2020
JanuaryYear 2015(12,500)0.5600%
Monthly
12.0084013,340
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
February
March
April
May
June
Year 2015(12,500)
Year 2015(12,500)
Year 2015(12,500)
Year 2015(12,500)
Year 2015 (12,500)
0.5600%11.0077013,270
0.5600%10.0070013,200
0.5600%9.0063013,130
0.5600%8.0056013,060
0.5600%7.0049012,990
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
July
August
September
October
November
December
January through December
January through December
January through December
January through December
Year 2015(12,500)0.5600%6.00
Year 2015(12,500)0.5600%5.00
Year 2015(12,500)0.5600%4.00
Year 2015(12,500)0.5600%3.00
Year 2015(12,500)0.5600%2.00
Year 2015(12,500)0.5600%1.00
Year 2016155,4600.5400%12.00
Year 2017165,5340.5800%12.00
Year 2018177,0550.5700%12.00
Year 2019 189,166 0.5700% 12.00
420
350
280
210
140
70
5,460
Annual
10,074
11,521
12,111
12,939
12,920
12,850
12,780
12,710
12,640
12,570
155,460
165,534
177,055
189,166
202,104
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Over (Under) Recovery Plus Interest Amortized and Recovered Over 12 Months
JanuaryYear 2020
Monthly
(202,104)
0.5700%
1,15217,473185,784
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
Year 2020(185,784)0.5700%
Year 2020(169,370)0.5700%
Year 2020(152,863)0.5700%
Year 2020(136,262)0.5700%
Year 2020(119,566)0.5700%
Year 2020(102,775)0.5700%
Year 2020(85,888)0.5700%
Year 2020(68,905)0.5700%
Year 2020(51,826)0.5700%
Year 2020(34,649)0.5700%
Year 2020 (17,374) 0.5700%
1,059
965
871
777
682
586
490
393
295
197
99
7,566
17,473169,370
17,473152,863
17,473136,262
17,473119,566
17,473102,775
17,47385,888
17,47368,905
17,47351,826
17,47334,649
17,47317,374
17,473 (0)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Total Amount of True-Up Adjustment for 2015 ATRR Less Over (Under) Recovery
Total Interest
$209,670
$(150,000)
$ 59,670
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Calculation of Interest for 2016 True-Up Period
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
An over or under collection will be recovered prorata over 2016, held for 2017, 2018 and 2019 and returned prorate over 2020
JanuaryYear 20168,333
Monthly
0.5400%12.00
(540)(8,873)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
January through December
January through December
January through December
Year 20168,3330.5400%11.00
Year 20168,3330.5400%10.00
Year 20168,3330.5400%9.00
Year 20168,3330.5400%8.00
Year 20168,3330.5400%7.00
Year 20168,3330.5400%6.00
Year 20168,3330.5400%5.00
Year 20168,3330.5400%4.00
Year 20168,3330.5400%3.00
Year 20168,3330.5400%2.00
Year 20168,3330.5400%1.00
Year 2017(103,510)0.5800%12.00
Year 2018(110,714)0.5700%12.00
Year 2019 (118,287) 0.5700% 12.00
(495)
(450)
(405)
(360)
(315)
(270)
(225)
(180)
(135)
(90)
(45)
(3,510)
Annual
(7,204)
(7,573)
(8,091)
(8,828)
(8,783)
(8,738)
(8,693)
(8,648)
(8,603)
(8,558)
(8,513)
(8,468)
(8,423)
(8,378)
(103,510)
(110,714)
(118,287)
(126,378)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Over (Under) Recovery Plus Interest Amortized and Recovered Over 12 Months
JanuaryYear 2020
Monthly
126,378
0.5700%
(720)(10,926)(116,173)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
Year 2020116,1730.5700%
Year 2020105,9090.5700%
Year 202095,5870.5700%
Year 202085,2060.5700%
Year 202074,7660.5700%
Year 202064,2660.5700%
Year 202053,7070.5700%
Year 202043,0870.5700%
Year 202032,4070.5700%
Year 202021,6660.5700%
Year 2020 10,864 0.5700%
(662)
(604)
(545)
(486)
(426)
(366)
(306)
(246)
(185)
(123)
(62)
(4,731)
(10,926)(105,909)
(10,926)(95,587)
(10,926)(85,206)
(10,926)(74,766)
(10,926)(64,266)
(10,926)(53,707)
(10,926)(43,087)
(10,926)(32,407)
(10,926)(21,666)
(10,926)(10,864)
(10,926) 0
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Total Amount of True-Up Adjustment for 2016 ATRR Less Over (Under) Recovery
Total Interest
$(131,109)
$100,000
$ (31,109)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 8 - Hypothetical Example of Final True-Up of Interest Rates and Interest Calculations for the Construction Loan
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
New York Transco LLC
Calculation of Interest for 2017 True-Up Period
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
An over or under collection will be recovered prorata over 2017, held for 2018 and 2019, and returned prorate over 2020
JanuaryYear 201725,000
Monthly
0.5800%12.00(1,740)(26,740)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
Year 201725,000
Year 201725,000
Year 201725,000
Year 201725,000
Year 201725,000
Year 201725,000
Year 2017 25,000
0.5800%11.00(1,595)(26,595)
0.5800%10.00(1,450)(26,450)
0.5800%9.00(1,305)(26,305)
0.5800%8.00(1,160)(26,160)
0.5800%7.00(1,015)(26,015)
0.5800%6.00(870)(25,870)
0.5800%5.00(725)(25,725)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
September
October
November
December
January through December
January through December
Year 201725,0000.5800%4.00
Year 201725,0000.5800%3.00
Year 201725,0000.5800%2.00
Year 201725,0000.5800%1.00
Year 2018(311,310)0.5700%12.00
Year 2019 (332,604) 0.5700% 12.00
(580)
(435)
(290)
(145)
(11,310)
Annual
(21,294)
(22,750)
(25,580)
(25,435)
(25,290)
(25,145)
(311,310)
(332,604)
(355,354)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Over (Under) Recovery Plus Interest Amortized and Recovered Over 12 MonthsMonthly
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
JanuaryYear 2020355,3540.5700%
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
Year 2020326,6580.5700%
Year 2020297,7980.5700%
Year 2020268,7740.5700%
Year 2020239,5850.5700%
Year 2020210,2290.5700%
Year 2020180,7060.5700%
Year 2020151,0150.5700%
Year 2020121,1540.5700%
Year 202091,1230.5700%
Year 202060,9210.5700%
Year 2020 30,547 0.5700%
(2,026)
(1,862)
(1,697)
(1,532)
(1,366)
(1,198)
(1,030)
(861)
(691)
(519)
(347)
(174)
(13,303)
(30,721)(326,658)
(30,721)(297,798)
(30,721)(268,774)
(30,721)(239,585)
(30,721)(210,229)
(30,721)(180,706)
(30,721)(151,015)
(30,721)(121,154)
(30,721)(91,123)
(30,721)(60,921)
(30,721)(30,547)
(30,721) 0
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Total Amount of True-Up Adjustment for 2017 ATRR Less Over (Under) Recovery
Total Interest
$(368,657)
$300,000
$ (68,657)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Calculation of Interest for 2018 True-Up Period
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
An over or under collection will be recovered prorata over 2018, held for 2019 and returned prorate over 2020
JanuaryYear 20188,333
Monthly
0.5700%12.00
(570)(8,903)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
January through December
Year 20188,3330.5700%11.00
Year 20188,3330.5700%10.00
Year 20188,3330.5700%9.00
Year 20188,3330.5700%8.00
Year 20188,3330.5700%7.00
Year 20188,3330.5700%6.00
Year 20188,3330.5700%5.00
Year 20188,3330.5700%4.00
Year 20188,3330.5700%3.00
Year 20188,3330.5700%2.00
Year 20188,3330.5700%1.00
Year 2019(103,705)0.5700%12.00
(523)
(475)
(428)
(380)
(333)
(285)
(238)
(190)
(143)
(95)
(48)
(3,705)
Annual
(7,093)
(8,856)
(8,808)
(8,761)
(8,713)
(8,666)
(8,618)
(8,571)
(8,523)
(8,476)
(8,428)
(8,381)
(103,705)
(110,798)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Over (Under) Recovery Plus Interest Amortized and Recovered Over 12 Months
JanuaryYear 2020
Monthly
110,798
0.5700%
(632)(9,579)(101,851)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
February
March
April
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
December
Year 2020101,8510.5700%
Year 202092,8530.5700%
Year 202083,8030.5700%
Year 202074,7020.5700%
Year 202065,5490.5700%
Year 202056,3440.5700%
Year 202047,0860.5700%
Year 202037,7760.5700%
Year 202028,4120.5700%
Year 202018,9950.5700%
Year 2020 9,525 0.5700%
(581)
(529)
(478)
(426)
(374)
(321)
(268)
(215)
(162)
(108)
(54)
(4,148)
(9,579)(92,853)
(9,579)(83,803)
(9,579)(74,702)
(9,579)(65,549)
(9,579)(56,344)
(9,579)(47,086)
(9,579)(37,776)
(9,579)(28,412)
(9,579)(18,995)
(9,579)(9,525)
(9,579) 0
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Total Amount of True-Up Adjustment for 2018 ATRR$(114,946)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Less Over (Under) Recovery$100,000
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Total Interest$(14,946)
Note 1: This 'Hypothetical Example' sheet will be populated with actuals and used in each year's annual true-up calculation. Note 2: Enter the revenue requirement from the true-up for that year (Note 2)
Note 3: Enter the revenue requirement from re-running the prior year true-ups with the final cost of debt once all inputs to Attachment 5 are based on actual data.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 9 - Depreciation and Amortization
Rates
New York Transco LLC
Rate (Annual)
Account NumberFERC AccountPercent
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
TRANSMISSION PLANT
1 350.1Land Rights1.02
2 352Structures and Improvements2.05
3 353Station Equipment2.26
4 354Towers and Fixtures2.04
5 355Poles and Fixtures2.24
6 356Overhead Conductor and Devices2.22
7 357Underground Conduit2.05
8 358Underground Conductor and Devices2.39
9 359Roads & Trails1.17
10 PRODUCTION PLANTAll Accounts0.00
11 DISTRIBUTION PLANTAll Accounts0.00
GENERAL PLANT
12 390Structures & Improvements3.36
13 391Office Furniture & Equipment5.24
14 392Transportation Equipment9.78
15 393Stores Equipment3.91
16 394Tools, Shop & Garage Equipment4.68
17 395Laboratory Equipment3.75
18 396Power Operated Equipment7.62
19 397Communication Equipment3.82
20 398Miscellaneous Equipment4.55
INTANGIBLE PLANT
21 303Miscellaneous Intangible Plant
5 Yr20.00
7 Yr14.29
10 Year10.00
15 year6.67
Transmission facility Contributions in Aid of ConstructionNote 1
These depreciation and amortization rates will not change absent the appropriate filing at FERC.
Note 1: In the event a Contribution in Aid of Construction (CIAC) is made for a transmission facility, the transmission
depreciation rates above will be weighted based on the relative amount of underlying plant booked to the accounts
shown in lines 1-7 above and the weighted average depreciation rate will be used to amortize the CIAC.
Once determined for a particular CIAC, the rate will not change for that CIAC absent Commission approval.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Attachment 10 - Workpapers
New York Transco LLC
Regulatory Assets
(a)(b)(c)(d)(e)(f)(g)(h)(i)(j)(k)(l)(m)(n)(o)(p)(q)(r)(s)(t)(u)(v)(w)(x)(y)(z)(aa)
Dec. 31Jan. 31Feb. 28/29Mar. 31Apr. 30May 31Jun. 30Jul. 31Aug. 31Sept. 30Oct. 31Nov. 30Dec. 31
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
No.
RecoveryCurrent Amort % Allocated to
AmntRecovery Period Monthly Amort Amort Periods Expense (d) Formula Rate
Project Name Approved * Months * Exp (b) / (c) this year x (e) *
Amort Exp in
Formula
Rate**
(f) x (g)2015201620162016
20162016201620162016
Avg Unamortized
Balance% ApprovedAllocated toRate Base
Sum (i) through for Rate Base Formula Rate Balance (v)
2016 2016 2016 2016 (u) / 13 * (from (g)) x (w) x (x) Project Code Docket No
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
1a------
1b--
1c--
--
… --
--
… --
--
… --
2Total Regulatory Asset in Rate Base (sum lines 1a-1...):
--
------
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
------
-------
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
--
-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
* Non-zero values in these columns may only be established per FERC order
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
**All amortizations of the Regulatory Asset are to be booked to Account 566
Abandoned Plant
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
(a)(b)(c)(d)(e)(f)(g)(h)
(i)
Dec. 31
(j)(k)(l)(m)(n)
Jan. 31Feb. 28/29Mar. 31Apr. 30May 31
(o)(p)(q)(r)(s)
Jun. 30Jul. 31Aug. 31Sept. 30Oct. 31
(t)(u)(v)(w)(x)(y)(z)(aa)
Nov. 30 Dec. 31
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Avg Unamortized
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
No.
RecoveryCurrent Amort % Allocated to Amort Exp in
AmntRecovery Period Monthly Amort Amort Periods Expense (d) Formula Rate Formula Rate
Project Name Approved * Months * Exp (b) / (c) this year x (e) * (f) x (g)
20142015201520152015
20152015201520152015
Balance% ApprovedAllocated toRate Base
Sum (i) through for Rate Base Formula Rate Balance (v)
2015 2015 2015 (u) / 13 * (from (g)) x (w) x (x) Project Code Docket No
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
3a-
3b-
3c-
-
… -
-
-
-
… -
4Total Abandoned Plant in Rate Base (sum lines 3a-3...):
* Non-zero values in these columns may only be established per FERC order
Land Held for Future Use (LHFU)
(a)(b)(c)(d)
Land Held forDec. 31
Subaccount Future Use and
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
--
-
(e)(f)(g)(h)(i)
Jan. 31 Feb. 28/29 Mar. 31 Apr. 30 May 31
(j)(k)(l)(m)(n)
Jun. 30 Jul. 31 Aug. 31 Sept. 30 Oct. 31
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
---
-
(o)(p)(q)
Nov. 30Dec. 31Average of
Columns (d)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
No.No.Item NameEstimated Date2014201520152015201520152015201520152015201520152015Through (p)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
5a
5b
5c
…
…
…
…
…
6Total LHFU in rate base (sum lines 5a-5...):
CWIP in Rate Base
(a)(b)(c)(d)
Construction Start Estimated in-
(e)(f)(g)(h)(i)
Dec. 31Jan. 31Feb. 28/29Mar. 31
Approval Doc.
(j)(k)(l)(m)(n)
Apr. 30 May 31 Jun. 30 Jul. 31 Aug. 31
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
(o)(p)(q)(r)(s)(t)(u)
Sept. 30Oct. 31Nov. 30Dec. 31
Avg (f) through % approvedRate Base
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
No.Project Namejob IDDateservice dateNo.2015201620162016210620162016201620162016201620162016(r)for recoveryAmnt (s) x (t)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
7a219,600,0000
7b
7c
…
…
…
00000016,892,3080.0%-
-0.0%-
-0.0%-
-0.0%-
-0.0%-
-0.0%-
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
…--
…--
…--
…--
…--
8Total (sum lines 7a-7...)Total CWIP in Rate Base-
Change to recovery percent in Column (t) requires FERC order
Actual Additions by FERC Account
The total of these additions should total the additions reported in the FERC Form No.1 on page 206, lines 48 to 56
Project350352352353354355356357358359
Structures andOverheadUnderground
Structures andImprovements -StationTowers andPoles and Conductor and UndergroundConductor andRoads and
Land RightsImprovementsEquipmentEquipmentFixturesFixturesDevicesConduitDevicesTrailsTotal
9aProject 1-
9bProject 2-
9c-
…-
…-
…-
…-
…-
…-
…-
…-
…-
…-
10Total(sum lines 9a-9...)--
Intangible Plant Detail
The total
ItemDescriptionSourceService LifeAmount
11aCompany Records
11bCompany Records
11cCompany Records
…Company Records
…Company Records
…Company Records
…Company Records
…Company Records
…Company Records
…Company Records
…Company Records
…Company Records
…Company Records
…Company Records
12Total (sum lines 11a-11...) ties to 205.5.g-
Detail of Affiliate Charges Included in NY Transco's Books as Requested by Certain Parties to the Filing
Transactions between NY Transco and any entity that is associated (affiliated) with NY Transco must be reported on page 429 of the Form No. 1. The chart below is to include all charges to the NYTransco by an affiliate, by Affilate and by FERC account number
CentralConsolidatedRochester
FERC Account Hudson G&EEdisonNiagara Mohawk NY State E&GG&ETotal
13a101-
13b….-
13c….-
….….-
…….-
…350-
…….-
…….-
…….-
…….-
…….-
…….-
…920
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
-
…….-
…….-
…935-
14Total------(sum lines 13a-13...)
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
36.3.1.2 Formula Rate Implementation Protocols
The formula rate template (“Template”) and these Formula Rate Implementation
Protocols (“Protocols”) together comprise the filed rate (“Formula Rate”) of NY Transco for
transmission revenue requirement determinations under the ISO OATT. NY Transco shall
follow the instructions specified in the Formula Rate to calculate annually its Net Adjusted
Revenue Requirement, as set forth at page 1, line 5 of the Template (“Net Adjusted Revenue
Requirement”). The Net Adjusted Revenue Requirement shall be determined for January 1 to
December 31 of a given calendar year (the “Rate Year”). The Formula Rate shall become
effective for recovery of NY Transco’s Net Adjusted Revenue Requirement upon the effective
date for incorporation into the ISO OATT through an appropriate filing with the Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission (“FERC” or “Commission”) under Section 205 of the Federal Power
Act (“FPA”).
Section 1.Annual Projection
a.No later than September 30 preceding the first Rate Year, and each subsequent
Rate Year, NY Transco shall determine its projected Net Adjusted Revenue
Requirement for the upcoming Rate Year in accordance with NY Transco’s
Formula Rate (“Annual Projection”). The Annual Projection shall include the
True-up Adjustment described and defined in Section 2 below, if applicable. NY
Transco shall cause an electronic version of the Annual Projection to be posted in
both a Portable Document Format and fully-functioning Excel file fully populated
with formulas intact at a publicly accessible location on ISO’s internet website.
Such posting shall include (i) all inputs in sufficient detail to identify the
components of NY Transco’s projected Net Adjusted Revenue Requirement, and
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
(ii) explanations of the bases for the projections and input data to demonstrate that each input to the formula rate is consistent with the requirements of the formula rate. If the date for making such posting of the Annual Projection should fall on a weekend or a holiday recognized by FERC, then the posting shall be made no later than the next business day. NY Transco shall electronically serve each
Annual Projection upon the Service List.2
b. If NY Transco makes changes in the Annual Projection for a given Rate Year, NY
Transco shall cause such revised Annual Projection to be promptly posted at a
publicly accessible location on the ISO internet website and shall electronically
serve a link to the website upon the Service List. Changes posted prior to October
31 of the preceding Rate Year, or the next business day if October 31 is not a
business day (or such later date as can be accommodated under the ISO’s billing practices), shall be reflected in the Annual Projection for the Rate Year; changes posted after that date will be reflected, as appropriate, in the True-up Adjustment for the Rate Year.
c. The Annual Projection, including the True-Up Adjustment, for each Rate Year
shall be subject to review, challenge, true-up and refunds or surcharges with interest, to the extent and in the manner provided in these Protocols.
2 As used in these protocols, “Service List” shall include but not be limited to (i) the email list of ISO OATT Transmission Customers maintained by the ISO; (ii) any state regulatory agency with rate jurisdiction over a public utility located within the ISO footprint; and (iii) any consumer advocate agency authorized by state law to review and contest the rates for any such public utility, provided such consumer advocate agency requests to be placed on the Service List and provides an e-mail address to NY Transco.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Section 2.True-up Adjustment
NY Transco will calculate the amount of under- or over-collection of its actual Net
Revenue Requirement, as set forth at page 1, line 3 of the Template during the preceding Rate Year (“True-up Adjustment”) after the FERC Form No. 1 data for that Rate Year has been filed with the Commission. The True-up Adjustment shall be the sum of components a and b,
determined in the following manner:
a. NY Transco’s projected Net Revenue Requirement collected during the previous
Rate Year3 will be compared to NY Transco’s actual Net Revenue Requirement
for the previous Rate Year calculated in accordance with NY Transco’s Formula
Rate and based upon (i) NY Transco’s FERC Form No. 1 for that same Rate
Year, (ii) any FERC orders specifically applicable to NY Transco’s calculation of
its annual revenue requirement, (iii) the books and records of NY Transco (which
shall be maintained consistent with the FERC Uniform System of Accounts
(“USofA”)), (iv) FERC accounting policies and practices applicable to the
calculation of annual revenue requirements under formula rates, and (v) any
aspects of the ISO OATT and other governing documents that apply to the
calculation of annual revenue requirements under individual transmission owner
formula rates, to determine any over- or under-recovery (“True-up Adjustment
Over/Under Recovery”). NY Transco will include a variance analysis of, at
minimum, actual revenue requirement components of rate base, operating and
3 If the initial year of this rate schedule is a partial year, the initial projected Net Revenue Requirement will be divided by the number of months the Formula Rate is in effect to calculate the monthly projected cost of service to be collected each month of the first year. Similarly, the actual Net Revenue Requirement will be divided by the number of months the rate is in effect to calculate the actual cost of service to be collected each month of the first year. The first True-up Adjustment will compare the projected Net Revenue Requirement billed and the actual Net Revenue Requirement for that initial Rate Year.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
maintenance expenses, depreciation and amortization expense, taxes, return on rate base, and revenue credits as compared to the corresponding components in the projected revenue requirement that was calculated for the prior Rate Year with an explanation of all changes.
b.Interest on any True-up Adjustment Over/Under Recovery of the actual Net
Revenue Requirement shall be calculated in accordance with the Formula Rate
Attachment 7a.
Section 3.Annual Update
a.On or before June 30 following each Rate Year, NY Transco shall calculate its
actual Net Adjusted Revenue Requirement, including the True-up Adjustment as described in Section 2 (“Annual Update”) for such Rate Year, and shall cause
such Annual Update to be posted, in both a Portable Document Format and fullyfunctioning Excel format containing the populated template with formula intact for that year’s update, at a publicly accessible location on the ISO internet
website, and electronically serve a link to the website upon the Service List. In addition, the Annual Update shall be contemporaneously submitted as an
informational filing with the FERC.
b.If the date for making the Annual Update posting should fall on a weekend or a
holiday recognized by the FERC, then the posting shall be due on the next
business day.
c. The date on which the last of the events listed in Section 3.a or 3.b occurs shall be
that year’s “Publication Date.” Any delay past the date on which the last of the
events listed in Section 3.a or 3.b occurs shall result in an equivalent extension of
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
time for the submission of information requests and challenges, as described in Sections 4 and 5 below.
d. Together with the posting of the Annual Update, NY Transco shall cause to be
posted on the ISO website the time, date and location for a stakeholder meeting
including but not limited to (i) any Eligible Customer under the ISO OATT; (ii)
any regulatory agency with rate jurisdiction over a public utility located within the
ISO footprint; (iii) any consumer advocate authorized by state law to review and
contest the rates for any such public utility, or (iv) any party with standing under
FPA Section 205 or 206 (collectively, "Interested Persons") in order for NY
Transco to explain its Annual Update and to provide Interested Persons an
opportunity to seek information and clarifications regarding the Annual Update (“Stakeholder Meeting”). NY Transco shall accommodate interested parties that wish to participate in the Stakeholder Meeting via teleconference or webinar. The Stakeholder Meeting shall be held no less than twenty (20) business days and no more than thirty (30) business days after June 30.
e.The Annual Update for the Rate Year:
(i)Shall provide, via the Formula Rate worksheets, sufficiently detailed supporting
documentation for data (and all adjustments thereto or allocations thereof) used in the Formula Rate that are not stated in the FERC Form No. 1 to enable any
interested party to replicate the calculation of the Formula Rate.4
4 It is the intent of the Formula Rate, including the supporting explanations and allocations described therein, that
each input to the Formula Rate for purposes of determining the actual Net Adjusted Revenue Requirement for a
given Rate Year will be either taken directly from the FERC Form No. 1 or reconcilable to the FERC Form No. 1 by
the application of clearly identified and supported information. If the referenced from is superseded, the successor
form(s) shall be utilized and supplemented as necessary to provide equivalent information as that provided in the
superseded form. If the referenced form is discontinued, equivalent information as that provided in the discontinue
form shall be utilized.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
(ii)Shall provide supporting documentation and workpapers for the data used in the
Annual Update that are not otherwise available in the FERC Form No. 1,
including all adjustments made to the FERC Form No. 1 data in determining formula inputs.
(iii) Shall include a variance analysis of, at minimum, actual revenue requirement
components of rate base, operating and maintenance expenses, depreciation and
amortization expense, taxes, return on rate base, and revenue credits as compared
to the corresponding components in the projected revenue requirement that was
calculated for the prior Annual Update with an explanation of changes.
(iv) Shall provide notice and a narrative summary of all changes in NY Transco’s
accounting policies and practices from those in effect for the calendar year upon
which the immediately preceding Annual Update was based that affect the
Formula Rate or calculation of the Annual Update (“Accounting Change(s)”).
Accounting Changes may, among other things, include: (1) the initial
implementation of an accounting standard or policy, (2) the initial implementation
of accounting practices for unusual or unconventional items where FERC has not
provided specific accounting direction, (3) corrections of mistakes and prior
period adjustments,5 (4) the implementation of new estimation methods or
policies that change prior estimates, and (5) changes to income tax elections.
Such notice shall also include (1) those changes that could impact the Formula
Rate or the calculations under the Formula Rate within the next three years; and
5 For purposes of these Protocols, “mistakes” shall mean errors or omissions regarding the values inputted into the
Formula Rate template, such as, but not limited to, arithmetic and other inadvertent computational errors, erroneous
Form No. 1 references, or the like. Mistakes shall not include matters involving exercise of judgment or substantive
differences of opinion regarding the derivation of an input that is more properly the subject of the annual review
process.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
(2) any changes in the ISO OATT from the provisions of the ISO OATT in effect during the calendar year upon which the most recent Net Revenue Requirement was based and that could impact the Formula Rate or the calculations under the Formula Rate within the next three years.
(v)Shall be subject to review and challenge in accordance with the procedures set
forth in Sections 4, 5, and 6 of these Protocols.
(vi) Shall be subject to review and challenge in accordance with the procedures set
forth in these Protocols with respect to the prudence of any costs and expenditures included for recovery in the Annual Update; provided, however, that nothing in these Protocols is intended to modify the Commission’s applicable precedent with respect to the burden of going forward or burden of proof under formula rates in such prudence challenges; and
(vii) Shall not seek to modify the Formula Rate and shall not be subject to challenge by
any Interested Person seeking to modify the Formula Rate (i.e., any modifications to the Formula Rate will require, as applicable, an FPA Section 205 or Section 206 filing or initiation of a Section 206 investigation).
(viii) Shall provide support for any deferred income tax account balances, including any
Statement of Financial Accounting Standard Nos. 106 and 109 Adjustments.
(ix) Shall identify and provide support for any costs and expenses related to any
merger or acquisition of a jurisdictional facility (including, but not limited to,
acquisition premiums and goodwill) that have been included in the Annual
Update, including a citation to the FERC order approving the recovery of such
costs and expenses; otherwise, any such costs that have been reported in the
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
FERC Form No. 1 must be deducted from the costs to be recovered in the Annual
Update.
(x) Shall identify any asset retirement obligations (“ARO”) included in the Annual
Update, including a citation to the FERC order approving recovery of the ARO; otherwise, any such items reported in the FERC Form No. 1 must be deducted from the costs to be recovered in the Annual Update.
(xi) Shall identify the specific amounts included in the annual Update related to each
transmission incentive project, a citation to the proceeding in which FERC
granted the incentive, and provide a derivation of the value for each project. (xii) Shall include a worksheet listing all the errors and corrections agreed to by NY
Transco and any interested parties, or ordered by FERC, related to the previous
Rate Year that have been incorporated into the current Annual Update.
f. The following Formula Rate inputs shall be stated values to be used in the
Formula Rate until changed pursuant to an FPA Section 205 or 206 proceeding:
(i) rate of return on common equity (“ROE”); (ii) “Post-Employment Benefits
other than Pensions” pursuant to Statement of Financial Accounting Standards
No. 106, Employers’ Accounting for Postretirement Benefits Other Than
Pensions (“PBOP”) charges; and (iii) the depreciation and/or amortization rates as
set forth in Attachment 9 to the Formula Rate template. No changes may be made
to the ROE, capital structure, PBOP expenses, or depreciation and/or amortization
rates absent a filing under Sections 205 or 206 of the Federal Power Act.
g.Example - Timeline for 2015 Annual Update:
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
On or before September 30 of the first year, NY Transco will determine
the projected Net Adjusted Revenue Requirement for the second year, which is
expected to be the first year that costs are recovered from ISO customers under
the Formula Rate. NY Transco will post the Annual Projection for the second
Rate Year in accordance with Section 1 above. NY Transco will not determine a
True-up Adjustment or post an Annual Update on August 1 of the second year if
no costs have been recovered under the Formula Rate during the first year. On or
before September 30 of the second year, NY Transco will post the Annual
Projection for the third Rate Year. On or before August 1 of the third year, NY
Transco will post its first Annual Update, consisting of the True-up Adjustment
for the second Rate Year determined pursuant to Section 2 above. Such True-up
Adjustment will be reflected in the Annual Projection of the Net Adjusted
Revenue Requirement for the fourth Rate Year posted on or before September 30
of the third year. The Annual Update posted August 1 of the third year will be
subject to the customer review and challenge procedures described in Sections 4,
5, and 6 of these Protocols.
Section 4.Annual Review Procedures
Each Annual Update shall be subject to the following review procedures (“Annual Review Procedures”):
a. Interested Persons shall have up to the latest of one hundred fifty (150) calendar
days after the Publication Date, thirty (30) calendar days after the receipt of all
responses to timely submitted information requests (unless such period is
extended with the written consent of NY Transco), or thirty (30) calendar days
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
after resolution of a dispute that does not result in the production of additional
information (“Review Period”), to review the calculations and to notify NY
Transco in writing of any specific challenges, including but not limited to
challenges related to Accounting Changes and to the Annual Update
(“Preliminary Challenge”). Interested persons may challenge through a
Preliminary Challenge or a Formal Challenge: (1) whether NY Transco has
properly calculated the Annual Update under review (including any corrections
pursuant to Section 6); (ii) whether the costs included in the Annual Update are
properly recordable and recorded, prudent, reasonable, and incurred according to
appropriate procurement methods and cost control methodologies and otherwise
consistent with NY Transco’s accounting policies, practices and procedures
consistent with the USofA; (iii) whether the input data used in the Annual Update
are accurate and correctly used in the Formula Rate; (iv) the effect of Accounting
Changes; and (v) whether the Formula Rate has been applied according to its
terms, including the procedures in these Protocols. NY Transco shall promptly
cause to be posted all Preliminary Challenges at a publicly accessible location on
the ISO internet website and a link to the website will be electronically served
upon the Service List. Any Formal Challenges are to be filed in the NY Transco’s
informational filing dockets.
NY Transco shall respond in writing to a Preliminary Challenge within
twenty (20) business days of receipt, and its response shall notify the challenging
party of the extent to which NY Transco agrees or disagrees with the challenge.
If NY Transco disagrees with the Preliminary Challenge, its response shall
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
include supporting documentation. NY Transco shall promptly cause to be posted
responses to all Preliminary Challenges at a publicly accessible location on the
ISO internet website and a link to the website will be electronically served upon
the Service List.
b. Interested Persons shall have up to one hundred twenty (120) calendar days after
each annual Publication Date (unless such period is extended with the written
consent of NY Transco) to serve reasonable information requests on NY Transco.
Information requests shall be limited to what is necessary to determine if: (i) NY
Transco has properly calculated the Annual Update under review (including any
corrections pursuant to Section 6); (ii) the costs included in the Annual Update are
properly recordable and recorded, reasonable, prudent, and incurred according to
appropriate procurement methods and cost control methodologies and otherwise
consistent with NY Transco’s accounting policies, practices and procedures
consistent with the USofA; (iii) the input data used in the Annual Update are
accurate and correctly used in the Formula Rate; (iv) the effect of Accounting
Changes; (v) the Formula Rate has been applied according to its terms, including the procedures in these Protocols; and (vi) any other information that may
reasonably have substantive effect on the calculation of the revenue requirement pursuant to the Formula Rate. NY Transco shall cause any information requests received to be posted at a publicly accessible location on the ISO internet website and shall electronically serve a link to the website upon the Service List. The
information and document requests shall not otherwise be directed to ascertaining whether the formula rate is just and reasonable.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
c.NY Transco shall make a good faith effort to respond to information requests
pertaining to the Annual Update within ten (10) business days of receipt of such
requests. In the event an information request is not provided within 10 business
days, the parties will mutually agree on an extension of the Review Period.
To the extent NY Transco and any Interested Person(s) are unable to
resolve disputes related to information requests submitted in accordance with
these Annual Review Procedures, NY Transco or any Interested Person may
petition the FERC to appoint an Administrative Law Judge as a discovery master
to resolve the discovery dispute(s) in accordance with these Protocols and
consistent with the FERC’s discovery rules. NY Transco shall not clam that
responses to information and document requests provided pursuant to these
protocols are subject to any settlement privilege, in any subsequent FERC
proceeding addressing NY Transco’s Annual True-Up or Projected Net Revenue
Requirement.
d. Failure to pursue an issue through a Preliminary Challenges or to otherwise lodge
a Formal Challenge regarding any issue as to a given Annual Update only bars
pursuit of such issue with respect to that Annual Update, and in no event shall bar pursuit of such issue or the lodging of a Formal Challenge as to such issue as it relates to a subsequent Annual Update.
e. If a change made by NY Transco to its accounting policies, practices or
procedures, or their application to the Formula Rate, pursuant to Section 3(e)(iv)
of these Protocols is found by the FERC to be unjust, unreasonable, and/or unduly
discriminatory or preferential, then the calculation of the charges to be assessed
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
during the Rate Year then under review, and the charges to be assessed during any subsequent Rate Years, including any True-up Adjustments, shall not include such change, but shall include any lawful remedy that may be prescribed by
FERC to ensure that the Formula Rate continues to operate in a manner that is just, reasonable, and not unduly discriminatory or preferential.
Section 5. Resolution of Challenges
a. NY Transco shall appoint a senior representative to attempt to resolve any
Preliminary Challenge. If NY Transco and any Interested Person have not
resolved any Preliminary Challenge to the Annual Update within sixty (60)
calendar days after the end of the Review Period (unless such period is extended
with the written consent of NY Transco to continue efforts to resolve the
Preliminary Challenge), such Interested Person may, within thirty (30) calendar
days thereafter, file a challenge with the FERC (“Formal Challenge”), which shall
be served on NY Transco by electronic service on the date of such filing. Subject
to any applicable confidentiality and Critical Energy Infrastructure Information
restrictions, all information and correspondence produced by NY Transco
pursuant to these Protocols may be included in any Formal Challenge or other
FERC proceeding relating to the Formula Rate. Failure to raise an issue in a
Preliminary Challenge shall not bar an Interested Person from raising that issue in
a Formal Challenge.
b. Any response by NY Transco to a Formal Challenge must be submitted to the
FERC within thirty (30) calendar days of the date of the filing of the Formal
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Challenge, and NY Transco shall serve on the filing party(ies) and the Service List by electronic service on the date of such filing.
c. In any proceeding concerning a given year’s Annual Update (including
corrections) or Accounting Change(s), NY Transco shall bear the burden,
consistent with Section 205 of the Federal Power Act, of proving that it has
correctly applied the terms of the Formula Rate consistent with these Protocols. Nothing herein is intended to alter the burdens applied by FERC with respect to prudence challenges.
d. Except as specifically provided herein, nothing herein shall be deemed to limit in
any way the right of NY Transco to file unilaterally, pursuant to Section 205 of
the FPA and the regulations thereunder, an application seeking changes to the
Formula Rate or to any of the stated value inputs requiring a Section 205 filing
under these Protocols (including, but not limited to, ROE, depreciation and
amortization rates, and PBOPs), or the right of any other party or the Commission
to seek such changes pursuant to Section 206 of the FPA and the regulations
thereunder.
e. NY Transco may, at its discretion and at a time of its choosing, make a limited
filing pursuant to Section 205 to modify stated values in the Formula Rate for
amortization and depreciation rates, or PBOP rates. The sole issue in any such
limited Section 205 proceeding shall be whether such proposed change(s) is just
and reasonable, and it shall not address other aspects of the Formula Rate.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Section 6.Changes to Annual Updates
If NY Transco determines or concedes that corrections to the Annual Update are
required, whether under Sections 4 or 5 of these Protocols, including but not limited to those
requiring corrections to its FERC Form No. 1, or input data used for a Rate Year that would have
affected the Annual Update for that Rate Year, NY Transco shall promptly notify the Service
List, file a correction to the Annual Update with the FERC as an amended informational filing,
and cause such information to be posted at a publicly accessible location on the ISO internet
website. Such corrections shall be subject to review at the time they are made and shall be
reflected in the next Annual Update, with interest. A corrected posting shall reset the deadlines
under Section 4 and 5 of the Protocols for Interested Person review and the revised dates shall
run from the posting date(s) for each of the corrections. The scope of review shall be limited to
the aspects of the Formula Rate affected by the corrections. Interest on any over- or under-
recovery due to corrections for preceding True-up Adjustments shall be calculated monthly on
such over- or under-recovery from January 1 of the corrected Rate Year through December 31 of
the Rate Year in which such over- or under-recovery is reflected (“Correction Period”). The
applicable monthly interest rates for the Correction Period for an over-recovery shall be
determined in accordance with the Formula Rate true-up worksheet divided by twelve (12) for
each month from the beginning of the Correction Period through December 31 of the Rate Year
immediately preceding the Rate Year in which such over-recovery is reflected. The applicable
monthly interest rates for the Correction Period for an under-recovery shall be the annual interest
rate determined in accordance 18 C.F.R § 35.19a divided by twelve (12) for each month from the
beginning of the Correction Period through December 31 of the Rate Year immediately
preceding the Rate Year in which such under-recovery is reflected.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
Section 7.Construction Work in Progress
a.Accounting. For each transmission project for which NY Transco has been
authorized by a Commission order to include Construction Work in Progress
(“CWIP”) in transmission rate base (“CWIP Project”), NY Transco shall use the following accounting procedures to ensure that it does not recover an Allowance for Funds Used During Construction (“AFUDC”) for such project.
(i) NY Transco shall assign each CWIP Project a unique Funding Project Number
(“FPN”) for internal cost tracking purposes. For a CWIP Project for which the
NY Transco is recovering less than 100% of CWIP in rate base, two FPNs will be
assigned, one reflecting the CWIP balance in rate base and the other reflecting the
balancing accruing AFUDC. NY Transco will assign FPNs in such a way that an
Interested Person can identify that the balances are associated with the same
project.
(ii) NY Transco shall record actual construction costs to each FPN through work
orders that are coded to correspond to the FPN for each CWIP Project. Such
work orders shall be segregated from work orders for transmission projects for
which the Commission has not authorized NY Transco to include CWIP in rate
base.
(iii) For each CWIP Project for which NY Transco is allowed to include 100% of
CWIP in rate base, NY Transco shall ensure that no AFUDC will be accrued under the associated FPN.
(iv) For each CWIP Project, NY Transco shall prepare monthly work order summaries
of costs incurred under the associated FPN. These summaries shall show monthly
additions to CWIP and plant in service and shall correspond to amounts recorded
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1
NYISO Tariffs --> Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT) --> 36 OATT Attachment DD - Rules to Allocate the Cost of NY Tra
in NY Transco’s FERC Form No. 1. NY Transco shall use these summaries as data inputs into the Annual Update calculated pursuant to Section 3 and shall make such work order summaries available upon request pursuant to the review procedures of Section 4.
(v) When a CWIP Project is, or portion thereof, is placed into service, NY Transco
shall deduct from total CWIP the accumulated charges for work orders under the
FPN for that project, or portion thereof. The purpose of this control process is to
ensure that expenditures are not double counted as both CWIP and as additions to
plant.
(vi) For transmission projects for which the Commission has not authorized NY
Transco to include CWIP in rate base, NY Transco shall record AFUDC to be applied to CWIP and capitalized when the project is placed into service.
b.Annual Reporting. For each CWIP Project, NY Transco shall file a report with
the Commission at the time of NY Transco’s Annual Update that shall include the
following information concerning each such project:
(i)the actual amount of CWIP recorded for each project;
(ii)any amounts recorded in related FERC accounts or subaccounts, such as AFUDC
and regulatory liability;
(iii)the resulting effect of CWIP on the revenue requirement;
(iv)a statement of the current status of each project; and the estimated in-service date
for each project.
Effective Date: 4/3/2015 - Docket #: ER15-572-005 - Page 1