10 Krey Boulevard Rensselaer, NY 12144
THIS FILING LETTER DOES NOT CONTAIN ANY PRIVILEGED OR
CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION. THE BODY OF REPORT ALONG WITH THE REDACTED VERSIONS OF TABLES 2, 3 AND 4 (MARKED PUBLIC) DO NOT CONTAIN ANY PRIVILEGED OR CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION.
ATTACHMENT 1 TO THE REPORT INCLUDES THE UNREDACTED TABLES WHICH CONTAIN PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION, AND ARE SUBMITTED SEPARATELY.
June 1, 2012
VIA ELECTRONIC FILING
Kimberly D. Bose
Secretary
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission 888 First Street, N.E.
Washington, D.C. 20426
Subject: Semi-Annual Reports on Demand Response Programs and New Generation
Projects; Docket Nos. ER01-3001-000 and ER03-647-000.
Dear Ms. Bose:
Enclosed for filing in the above-referenced dockets are the New York Independent System Operator’s (“NYISO’s”) Semi-Annual Reports to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (“Commission”) on the NYISO’s Demand Side Management programs and new generation projects in the New York Control Area. This filing is made for
informational purposes only in accordance with the Commission’s delegated orders issued February 19, 2010 and February 23, 2010 in these dockets.
I.List of Attachments Submitted
1.NYISO Semi-Annual Compliance Report on New Generation Projects,
June 1, 2012 (Attachment I);
2.Attachment A to the NYISO Semi-Annual Compliance Report on New
Generation Projects, (Attachment II);
Honorable Kimberly D. Bose June 1, 2012
Page 2
3.Attachment B to the NYISO Semi-Annual Compliance Report on New
Generation Projects, (Attachment III);
4. NYISO Semi-Annual Compliance Report on Demand Response Programs,
June 1, 2012 - public, redacted (Attachment IV); and
5. Attachment A to the NYISO Semi-Annual Compliance Report on Demand
Response Programs, June 1, 2012 - CONFIDENTIAL (Attachment V).
II.Request for Confidential Treatment of Demand Response Report
Attachment A
The attached Semi-Annual Compliance Report on Demand Response Programs (“Demand Response Report”) summarizes the current status of demand response
participation in the NYISO’s markets as of June 1, 2012. The Demand Response Report includes redactions of confidential, commercially sensitive information in Tables 2 and 4. The redactions are submitted separately as Attachment A of the Demand Response Report, which contains the unredacted versions of Tables 2 and 4.
In accordance with Sections 388.107 and 388.112 of the Commission’s
Regulations,1 Article 6 of the NYISO’s Market Administration and Control Area Services Tariff, Sections 1.0(4) and 4.0 of the NYISO’s Code of Conduct, the NYISO requests Privileged and Confidential treatment of the contents of Attachment A. The NYISO also requests that the Confidential Attachment be exempted from public disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act (“FOIA”), 5 U.S.C. §522.2
The confidential Attachment contains privileged, commercially sensitive, trade
secret information that is not made public by the NYISO. Disclosure of such information
could cause competitive harm to the affected Market Participants,3 and could adversely
affect competition in the markets administered by the NYISO. This information includes
the number of demand response resources in a load zone that, when aggregated, are not
greater than five (5). With such a small number of resources in the load zone, the
NYISO’s aggregation of the data reported for that load zone may not sufficiently mask
confidential and commercially sensitive Market Participant information. Further, because
this confidential, commercially sensitive information is exempt from disclosure under 5
U.S.C. §522(b)(4), the NYISO requests that the contents of Attachment A receive
Privileged and Confidential treatment and be exempt from FOIA disclosure. Attachment
1 18 C.F.R. §§ 388.107 and 388.112 (2011).
2 The information provided by the NYISO for which the NYISO claims an exemption from FOIA disclosure is labeled “Contains Privileged Information - Do Not Release.”
3 Terms with initial capitalization not defined herein have the meaning set forth in the NYISO’s Market Administration and Control Area Services Tariff.
Honorable Kimberly D. Bose June 1, 2012
Page 3
A is identified and marked in accordance with the Commission’s regulations and rules published by the Secretary’s Office for submitting privileged information.4
III.Correspondence
Copies of correspondence concerning this filing should be addressed to Robert E. Fernandez, General Counsel
Raymond Stalter, Director of Regulatory Affairs Gloria Kavanah, Senior Attorney
*David Allen, Senior Attorney
10 Krey Boulevard
Rensselaer, NY 12144
Tel: (518) 356-6000
Fax: (518) 356-4702
rfernandez@nyiso.com
rstalter@nyiso.com
gkavanah@nyiso.com
dallen@nyiso.com
*person designated to receive service
Respectfully Submitted
/s/ David Allen
David Allen
Counsel,
New York Independent System Operator, Inc.
4 Federal Energy Regulatory Commission Submission Guidelines, July 1, 2010, page 2.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that I have this day served the foregoing document upon each person
designated on the official service list compiled by the Secretary in this proceeding in accordance with the requirements of Rule 2010 of the Rules of Practice and Procedure, 18 C.F.R. §385.2010.
Dated at Rensselaer, NY this 1st day of June, 2012.
/s/ Joy A. Zimberlin
Joy A. Zimberlin
New York Independent System Operator, Inc
10 Krey Blvd.
Rensselaer, NY 12144 (518) 356-6207
NYISO Report on New Generation Projects
June 1, 2012
In its October 23, 2006 order, the Commission ordered the NYISO to submit “a list of
investments in new generation projects in New York (including a description and current status of each such project), regardless of the stage of project development at the time of the filing.”1 The NYISO keeps a list of Interconnection Requests and Transmission Projects for the New
York Control Area (“NYCA”) that includes information about all generation projects in the State that have requested interconnection.
The NYISO interconnection process is described in two attachments of the NYISO
OATT: Attachment X entitled, “Standard Large Facility Interconnection Procedures,” and
Attachment Z entitled, “Small Generator Interconnection Procedures.” Attachment X applies to Generating Facilities that exceed 20 MW in size and to Merchant Transmission Facilities,
collectively referred to as “Large Facilities.” Attachment Z applies to Generating Facilities no larger than 20 MW.
Under Attachment X, Developers of Large Facilities must submit an Interconnection
Request to the NYISO. The NYISO assigns a Queue Position to all valid Interconnection
Requests. Under Attachment X, proposed generation and transmission projects undergo up to three studies: the Feasibility Study, the System Reliability Impact Study, and the Facilities Study. The Facilities Study is performed on a Class Year basis for a group of eligible projects pursuant to the requirements of Attachment S of the NYISO OATT. Under Attachment Z, proposed small generators undergo a process that is similar, but with different paths and options that are
dependent on the specific circumstances of the project.
Proposed generation and transmission projects currently in the NYISO Interconnection
Process are listed on the list of Interconnection Requests and Transmission Projects for the
NYCA (“NYISO Interconnection Queue”). The generation projects on that list are shown in
Attachment A, which is dated April 30, 2012. The NYISO updates the NYISO Interconnection
Queue on at least a monthly basis and posts the most recent list on the NYISO’s public web site
at http://www.nyiso.com/public/markets_operations/services/planning/documents/index.jsp.
Explanations for the various columns of the list are provided in the notations on the last page of the list. The status of each project on the NYISO Interconnection Queue is shown in the column labeled “S.” An explanation of this column is provided in Attachment B. Also, note that the proposed in-service date for each project is the date provided to the NYISO by the respective Owner/Developer, is updated only on a periodic basis, and is subject to change.
1 New York Indep. Sys. Operator, Inc., 117 FERC ¶ 61,086, at P 14 (2006).
INTERCONNECTION REQUESTS AND TRANSMISSION PROJECTS / NEW YORK CONTROL AREA
Page 1 of 2
QueueDateSPWPType/LocationInterconnectionLastAvailabilityProposed In-Service
Pos.Owner/DeveloperProject Nameof IR(MW)(MW)FuelCounty/StateZPointUtilitySUpdateof StudiesOriginalCurrent
115Central Hudson Gas & ElectricEast Fishkill Transformer4/24/02N/AACDutchess, NYGEast Fishkill 345kV/115kVCONED/CHG&E48/19/08None2007/062012
119ECOGEN, LLCPrattsburgh Wind Farm5/20/0278.2WYates, NYCEelpot Rd-Flat St. 115kVNYSEG103/31/12SRIS, FS2005/022013/12
127AAirtricity Munnsville Wind Farm, LLCMunnsville10/9/026WMadison, NYE46kV lineNYSEG114/30/11SRIS, FS2005/122013/12
147NY Windpower, LLCWest Hill Windfarm4/16/0431.5WMadison, NYCOneida-Fenner 115kVNM-NG109/30/10SRIS, FS2006/Q42012/09
154KeySpan Energy for LIPAHoltsville-Brentwood-Pilgrim8/19/04N/AACSuffolk, NYKHoltsville & Pilgrim 138kVLIPA53/31/11None2007/062017
161Marble River, LLCMarble River Wind Farm12/7/048383WClinton, NYDWillis-Plattsburgh WP-1 230kVNYPA113/31/12SRIS, FS20062012/10
166Cape Vincent Wind Power, LLCSt. Lawrence Wind Farm2/8/0579.579.5WJefferson, NYELyme Substation 115kVNM-NG103/1/12SRIS, FS2006/122013/09
169Alabama Ledge Wind Farm, LLCAlabama Ledge Wind Farm2/8/0579.879.8WGenesee, NYBOakfield-Lockport 115kVNM-NG93/1/12FES, SRIS2007/12-2009/122013/10
171Marble River, LLCMarble River II Wind Farm2/8/05132.2132.2WClinton, NYDWillis-Plattsburgh WP-2 230kVNYPA113/31/12SRIS, FS2007/122012/10
180AGreen PowerCody Rd3/17/051010WMadison, NYCFenner - Cortland 115kVNM-NG1112/31/11NoneNone2013/Q4
189Atlantic Wind, LLCHorse Creek Wind4/8/05126126WJefferson, NYECoffeen St-Thousand Island 115kV NM-NG84/30/12FES, SRIS2006/122013/10
197PPM Roaring Brook, LLC / PPMRoaring Brook Wind7/1/057878WLewis, NYEBoonville-Lowville 115kVNM-NG113/31/11FES, SRIS, FS2009/122012/12
198New Grange Wind Farm, LLCArkwright Summit Wind Farm7/21/0579.879.8WChautauqua, NYADunkirk-Falconer 115kVNM-NG912/31/11FES, SRIS2008/122013/09
201NRG EnergyBerrians GT8/17/05200200CC-NG Queens, NYJAstoria West Substation 138kVCONED96/30/11FES, SRIS2008/022014/06
204ADuer's Patent Project, LLCBeekmantown Windfarm10/31/0519.519.5WClinton, NYDKents Falls - Sciota 115kVNYSEG104/30/11None2008/062013/06
205National GridLuther Forest11/2/054040LSaratoga, NYFRound Lake 115kVNM-NG65/31/11SIS2007/082012/Q2
206Hudson Transmission PartnersHudson Transmission12/14/05660660DC/ACNY, NY - Bergen, NJJWest 49th Street 345kVCONED1211/30/11FES, SRIS, FS2009/Q22013/05
207Cape Vincent Wind Power, LLCCape Vincent1/12/06210210WJefferson, NYERockledge Substation 115kVNM-NG106/30/11FES, SRIS, FS2009/Q42013/09
213Noble Environmental Power, LLCEllenburg II Windfield4/3/062121WClinton, NYDWillis-Plattsburgh WP-2 230kVNYPA1010/31/11SRIS, FS2007/10N/A
216Nine Mile Point Nuclear, LLCNine Mile Point Uprate5/5/06168168NUOswego, NYCScriba Station 345kVNM-NG113/1/12SRIS, FS2010/Q32012/06
222Ball Hill Windpark, LLCBall Hill Windpark7/21/069090WChautauqua, NYADunkirk-Gardenville 230kVNM-NG104/30/12FES, SRIS, FS2008/102014/Q1
224NRG Energy, Inc.Berrians GT II8/23/065090CC-NG Queens , NYJAstoria West Substation 138kVCONED96/30/11FES, SRIS2010/062014/06
227ALaidlaw Energy Group Inc.Laidlaw Energy & Env.10/30/0677WoCattaraugus, NYA13.2kVNM-NG710/28/09NoneN/A
232Bayonne Energy Center, LLCBayonne Energy Center11/27/06500500CT-DBayonne, NJJGowanus Substation 345kVConEd134/30/12FES, SRIS, FS2008/112012/05
237Allegany Wind, LLCAllegany Wind1/9/0772.572.5WCattaraugus, NYAHomer Hill - Dugan Rd. 115kVNM-NG104/30/12FES, SRIS, FS2009/102013/08
239AInnovative Energy System, Inc.Modern Innovative Plant1/31/076.46.4MNiagara, NYAYoungstown - Sanborn 34.5kVNM-NG85/31/11None2007/122012/07
241Noble Chateaugay Windpark II, LLCChateaugay II Windpark3/15/0719.519.5WFranklin, NYDChateaugay Substation 34.5kVNYSEG610/31/11None2008/07N/A
250Seneca Energy II, LLCOntario7/2/075.65.6MOntario, NYCHaley Rd. - Hall 34.5kVNYSEG1112/31/11None2009/102012/11
251CPV Valley, LLCCPV Valley Energy Center7/5/07677.6690.6CC-NG Orange, NYGCoopers - Rock Tavern 345kVNYPA94/3012FES, SRIS2012/052016/05
253Marble River, LLCMarble River SPS8/13/07TBDTBD ACClinton, NYDMoses-Willis-Plattsburgh 230kVNYPA57/31/11None2007/122012/10
263Stony Creek Wind Farm, LLCStony Creek Wind Farm10/12/0794.494.4WWyoming, NYCStolle Rd - Meyer 230kVNYSEG104/30/12FES, SRIS, FS2010/012012/12
264RG&ESeth Green10/23/072.82.8HMonroe, NYB11kVRG&E93/31/12None2008/042013Q1
266NRG Energy, Inc.Berrians GT III11/28/07250290CC-NG Queens, NYJAstoria 345kVNYPA83/1/12FES, SRIS2010/062016/06
267Winergy Power, LLCWinergy NYC Wind Farm11/30/07600600WNew York, NYJGowanus Substation 345kVConEd53/1/12FES2015/012019/01-2020/01
270Wind Development Contract Co LLCHounsfield Wind12/13/07244.8244.8WJefferson, NYEFitzpatrick - Edic 345kVNYPA61/31/12FES/SRIS2010/092015/12
276Air Energie TCI, Inc.Crown City Wind Farm1/30/089090WCortland, NYCCortland - Fenner 115kVNM-NG65/31/11FES, SRIS2011/122014/12
284Broome Energy Resources, LLCNanticoke Landfill3/6/081.61.6MBroome, NYCNanticoke Landfill Plant 34.5kVNYSEG103/31/12None2008/072012/12
285Machias Wind Farm, LLCMachias I3/27/0879.279.2WCattaraugus, NYAGardenville - Homer Hill 115kVNM-NG56/30/10FES2010/122012/12
290AGreen Island Power AuthorityGreen Island Power4/7/082020LAlbany, NYFMaplewood - Johnson Rd 115kVNM-NG611/30/11SIS2009/122012/Q4
291Long Island Cable, LLCLI Cable - Phase 14/14/08440440WSuffolk, NYKRuland Road 138kVLIPA53/1/12FES2013/012019/01-2020/01
292Long Island Cable, LLCLI Cable - Phase 2a4/14/08220220WSuffolk, NYKRuland Road 138kVLIPA53/1/12FES2013/062019/01-2020/01
294Orange & RocklandRamapo-Sugarloaf4/29/08N/AN/A ACOrange/Rockland, NYGRamapo - Sugarloaf 138kVO&R63/1/12SIS2009/06N/A
295CCH Holdings Group, LLCCross Hudson II5/6/08800800ACNew York, NY-NJJWest 49th St. Substation 345kVConEd512/31/10FES2011/062013/06
305Transmission Developers Inc.Transmission Developers NYC7/18/0810001000DCQuebec - NY, NYJAstoria Substation 345kVNYPA73/31/12FES, SRIS2014/Q12016/Q2
307New York Wire, LLCNew York Wire-Phase 17/29/08550550DCNJ - Kings, NYJGowanus Substation 345kVConEd511/3/10FES2013/072014/10
310Cricket Valley Energy Center, LLCCricket Valley Energy Center9/22/081019.91136CC-NG Dutchess, NYGPleasant Valley - Long Mt. 345kVConEd93/1/12FES, SRIS2014/122015/09
311New York State Electric & GasConcord Casino9/24/0848.048.0LSullivan, NYECoopers Corner - Rock HillNYSEG510/28/09None2009/09N/A
319AES Energy Storage, LLCCayuga Energy Storage12/3/082020ESOnondaga, NYCMilliken 115kVNYSEG512/31/10None2010/07N/A
320AES Energy Storage, LLCSomerset Energy Storage12/3/082020ESNiagara, NYASomerset 69kVNYSEG512/31/10None2010/07N/A
2012_06_01_NewGen_Rprt_Att-A_NYISO_IQ.xlsUpdated: 4/30/2012
INTERCONNECTION REQUESTS AND TRANSMISSION PROJECTS / NEW YORK CONTROL AREA
Page 2 of 2
QueueDateSPWPType/LocationInterconnectionLastAvailabilityProposed In-Service
Pos.Owner/DeveloperProject Nameof IR(MW)(MW)FuelCounty/StateZPointUtilitySUpdateof StudiesOriginalCurrent
322Rolling Upland Wind Farm, LLCRolling Upland Wind1/13/0959.459.4W
326NYSEG/RG&ERochester SVC/PST Trans.3/9/09N/AN/AAC
331National GridNortheast NY Reinforcement4/22/09N/AN/AAC
333National GridWestern NY Reinforcement5/5/09N/AN/AAC
335NextEra Energy Resources, LLCCold Creek Spring Wind6/9/09150.7150.7W
336Enfield Energy, LLCBlack Oak Wind6/29/095050W
337Long Island Power AuthorityNorthport Norwalk Harbor7/14/09N/AN/AAC
338RG&EBrown's Race II8/11/098.38.3H
339RG&ETransmission Reinforcement8/17/09N/AN/AAC
342Albany Energy, LLCAlbany Landfill9/3/096.46.4M
343Champlain Wind Link, LLCChamplain Wind Link I9/29/09600600AC
346Beacon PowerScotia Industrial Park11/24/092020F
347Franklin Wind Farm, LLCFranklin Wind12/2/0950.450.4W
349Taylor Biomass Energy, LLCTaylor Biomass12/30/091922.5SW
351Linden VFT, LLCLinden VFT Uprate3/2/101515AC
354Atlantic Wind, LLCNorth Ridge Wind5/13/10100100W
355Brookfield Renewable PowerStewarts Bridge Hydro8/3/1033H
357West Point Partners, LLCNY Power Pathway9/10/1010001000DC
358West Point Partners, LLCWest Point Transmission9/13/1010001000DC
360NextEra Energy Resources, LLCWatkins Glen Wind12/22/10300.8300.8W
361US PowerGen Co.Luyster Creek Energy2/15/11401444CC
362Monticello Hills Wind, LLCMonticello Hills Wind3/7/111818W
363Poseidon Transmission, LLCPoseidon Transmisssion4/27/11500500DC
364Bruce Hill Wind, LLCBruce Hill Wind5/4/111818W
365Transmission Developers Inc.Champlain Hudson SPS7/15/11TBDTBDAC
366NextEra Energy Resources, LLCWatkins Glen East8/2/11150.6150.6W
367Orange & RocklandNorth Rockland Transformer9/14/11TBDTBDAC
368Consolidated Edison Co. of NYFeeder 76 Ramapo to Rock Tavern 10/13/11TBDTBDAC
369Clover Leaf Power, LLCClover Leaf Hollers Ave10/24/11173.9192.8CT
370Smokey Avenue Wind, LLCSmokey Avenue Wind10/28/111818W
371South Mountain Wind, LLCSouth Mountain Wind10/31/111818W
372Dry Lots Wind, LLCDry Lots Wind10/31/113333W
373New York Power AuthorityCoopers Corners Shunt Reactor12/21/11N/AN/AAC
374CPV Valley, LLCCPV Valley II2/21/12820820CC
375Eagle Creek Hydro, LLCEagle Creek Hydro3/6/121111H
377Monroe CountyMonroe County Mill Seat3/16/123.23.2M
378Invenergy Wind NY, LLCMarsh Hill Wind3/29/1216.216.2W
379Seneca Energy II, LLCSeneca II Expansion4/24/126.46.4M
Madison, NYE County Line - Brothertown 115kVNYSEG
Monroe, NYB Station 124 115kVNYSEG
Saratoga, NYF NGrid 230kVNM-NG
Cattaraugus, NYA NGrid 115kVNM-NG
Cattaraugus, NYA Salamanca - Falconer 115kVNM-NG
Thompkins, NYC Black Oak Rd 115kVNYSEG
Suffolk, NYK Northport 138kVLIPA
Monroe, NYB Station 3 / Station 137 34.5kVRG&E
Monroe, NYB Niagara - Kintigh 345kVRG&E
Albany, NYF34.5kVNM-NG
Clinton, NY - VTD Plattsburgh - New Haven, VT 230kVNYPA
Schenectady, NYF Spier - RotterdamNM-NG
Delaware, NYE Sidney - Delhi 115kVNYSEG
Montgomery, NYG Maybrook - Rock TavernCHGE
Richmond, NY-NJJ Goethals 345kVCONED
St. Lawrence, NYE Nicholville - Parishville 115kVNM-NG
Saratoga, NYF Spier Falls - EJ WestNM-NG
Albany, Orange or Westchester, F, G orNM-NG/CenHud or
NYH New Scotland - Roseton or Buchanan 345kVConed
Greene, Westchester, NY F, H Leeds - Buchanan North 345kVNM-NG/ConEd
Schuyler, NYC Hillside - Meyer 230 kVNYSEG
Queens, NYJ Astoria SubstationCONED
Otsego, NYE W. Winfield - Richfield Spring 46kV NYSEG
Suffolk, NYK Ruland Rd. SubstationLIPA
Delaware, NYE Axtell Road Substation 34.5 kVNYSEG
Queens, NYJ Astoria and Farragut Subsations ConEd/NYPA
Schuyler, NYC Montour Falls SubstationNYSEG
Rockland, NYG Line Y94 345kVConEd
Orange, Rockland, NY G Ramapo to Rock Tavern 345 kV ConEd/CenHud
Bronx, NYJ Parkchester City Sub. 138 kVConEd
Otsego, NYF Worcester - Schenevus 23kVNM-NG
Delaware, NYE River Rd Substation 46kVNYSEG
Herkimer, NYE Schuyler to WhitesboroNM-NG
Sullivan, NYE Coopers Corners 345 kVNYSEG
Wawayanda, NYG Rock Tavern to Coopers CornersNYPA
Sullivan, NYE Rio 69kV SwitchyardO&R
Monroe, NYB Sanford Rd. 34.5kVNM-NG
Steuben, NYC Jasper - South Canisteo 34.5kVNYSEG
Seneca, NY C Seneca - Waterloo 34.5kV NYSEG
73/31/12FES, SRIS2012/122014/12
63/31/11SIS2011/122012-2013
1210/31/11SIS2010-20192010-2019
57/31/09None2014/Q22014/Q2
59/30/11FES2012/122012/12
510/31/11FES2010/102013/10
61/31/11SIS20162016
93/31/12None2011/082013/Q1
63/1/12SIS2015/092016/W
101/31/12None2010/122012/Q1 - 2015/12
58/31/10None2014/062014/06
63/31/11None2011/082012/08
35/31/11None2012/122012/12
93/31/12SRIS2012/042012/Q4
96/30/11SRIS2010/11N/A
56/30/11FES2014/122014/12
74/30/12SRIS2012/102012/12
31/31/12None2016/072016/07
31/31/12None2015/05-2016/05 2015/05-2016/05
36/30/11None2013/092013/06
39/30/11None2014/062014/06
94/30/12None2012/112014/12
310/31/11None2016/052016/05
311/30/11None2013/122013/12
47/31/11None2016/Q12016/Q1
31/31/12None2013/Q32014/Q2
512/31/11None2016/062016/06
411/30/11None2016/082016/08
33/31/12None2016/122016/12
33/31/12None2013/122013/12
33/31/12None2013/112013/11
31/31/12None2014/112014/11
53/31/12NoneTBDTBD
43/31/12None2017/052017/05
44/30/12None2013/102013/10
24/30/12None2013/Q42013/Q4
24/30/12None2015/122015/12
7 4/30/12 None 2012/12 2012/12
NOTES: ● The column labeled 'SP' refers to the maximum summer megawatt electrical output. The column labeled 'WP' refers to the maximum winter megawatt electrical output.
● Type / Fuel. Key: ST=Steam Turbine, CT=Combustion Turbine, CC=Combined Cycle, CS= Steam Turbine & Combustion Turbine, H=Hydro, PS=Pumped Storage, W=Wind, NU=Nuclear, NG=Natural Gas, M=Methane, SW=Solid Waste, S=Solar, Wo=Wood, F=Flywheel ES=Energy Storage, O=Oil, C=Coal, D=Dual Fuel, AC=AC Transmission, DC=DC Transmission, L=Load
● The column labeled 'Z' refers to the zone
● The column labeled 'S' refers to the status of the project in the NYISO's LFIP. Key: 1=Scoping Meeting Pending, 2=FES Pending, 3=FES in Progress, 4=SRIS/SIS Pending, 5=SRIS/SIS in Progress, 6=SRIS/SIS Approved, 7=FS Pending, 8=Rejected Cost Allocation/Next FS Pending, 9=FS in Progress, 10=Accepted Cost Allocation/IA in Progress, 11=IA Completed, 12=Under Construction, 13=In Service for Test, 14=In Service Commercial, 0=Withdrawn
● Availability of Studies Key: None=Not Available, FES=Feasibility Study Available, SRIS=System Reliability Impact Study Available, FS=Facilities Study and/or ATRA Available ● Proposed in-service dates are shown in format Year/Qualifier, where Qualifier may indicate the month, season, or quarter.
2012_06_01_NewGen_Rprt_Att-A_NYISO_IQ.xlsUpdated: 4/30/2012
1=Scoping Meeting Pending
2=FESA Pending
3=FES in Progress
4=SRIS Pending
5=SRIS in Progress
6=SRIS Approved
7=FS Pending
8=Rejected Cost Allocation/
Next FS Pending--
9=FS in Progress
10=Accepted Cost Allocation/ IA
in Progress
11=IA Completed
12=Under Construction
Interconnection Request has
been received, but scoping
meeting has not yet occurred
Awaiting execution of
Feasibility Study Agreement
Feasibility Study is in Progress
Awaiting execution of SRIS Agreement and/or OC
approval of SRIS scope
SRIS Approved by NYISO Operating Committee
Awaiting execution of
Facilities Study Agreement
Project was in prior class year, but rejected cost allocation—Awaiting
execution of Facilities Study Agreement for next Class
Year or the start of the next Class Year
Project in current Class Year Facilities Study
Interconnection Agreement is being negotiated
Interconnection Agreement is executed and/or filed with
FERC
Project is under construction
New York Independent System Operator, Inc.
Docket No. ER01-3001-____
Semi-Annual Compliance Report on Demand Response Programs
June 1, 2012
This report summarizes the current status of demand response participation in the New York Independent System Operator’s (NYISO’s) markets as of June 1, 2012. As in previous years, this report focuses on enrolled demand response participation in preparation for the Summer Capability Period.1 A discussion of the current status of several demand response initiatives that the NYISO has underway is also provided below.
Activations of the NYISO’s two reliability-based programs (the Emergency Demand Response Program (EDRP) and the Installed Capacity Special Case Resources (ICAP/SCR)) during the Summer 2011Capability Period were reported in the NYISO’s 2011 Demand
Response Annual Report.2
The NYISO has two economic programs, the Day-Ahead Demand Response Program
(DADRP) and the Demand-Side Ancillary Services Program (DSASP). DADRP offer activity is
sporadic and a limited number of resources participate. With the December 2011 release of
technical specifications for Direct Communication for DSASP, interest and activity in DSASP
has increased and there are a limited number of resources working toward implementation of
their communication infrastructure and completion of the market pre-qualification process.
Demand Response Enrollment
This report presents statistical data on demand response enrollment. Demand response
resources include individual retail electricity consumers that enroll to perform their own load
1 Capitalized terms not defined herein shall bear the meanings assigned by the NYISO’s Market Administration and Control Area Services Tariff.
2 Docket No. ER01-3001-000, NYISO 2011 Demand Response Annual Report (filed January 17, 2012),
and Supplement and Errata to Annual Report (filed January 25, 2012) (collectively, the January 2012
Report).
- 1 -
reductions and curtailment service providers, which is a general term used to identify the NYISO Customers that represent end-use customers in the NYISO’s demand response programs.3
Table 1 identifies the number of curtailment service providers by the following organizational categories:
• Aggregators, entities which enroll retail electricity consumers as individual resources that
may be aggregated for treatment as a single resource;
• Direct Customers, entities which register as a Market Participant with the NYISO to
participate on their own behalf in any of the NYISO’s markets, including the NYISO’s demand response programs;
• LSEs, entities which provide commodity service to retail customers; and
• Transmission Owners (TO), the investor- and public authority-owned transmission and
distribution companies that are NYISO Customers located in New York State.
Table 1. Demand Response Service Providers by Provider Type
Count as of Change from June
Provider TypeMay 2012 2011 Report
Aggregator25‐8
Direct Customer10‐4
LSE71
Transmission Owner5‐2
Total47‐13
Since the June 2011 Report4, the NYISO’s demand response programs have experienced
a net decrease of 13 curtailment service providers. The decrease in curtailment service providers
3 The term “curtailment service providers” as used in this report refers to Responsible Interface Parties (RIPs) as that term is used in the Installed Capacity Manual, Demand Response Providers (DRPs) as defined in the DADRP Manual, and the four classes of market participants identified in the EDRP
Manual. A retail customer participating in a NYISO demand response program with its own load acts as its own curtailment service provider.
4 Docket No. ER01-3001-000, NYISO 2011 Demand Response Semi-Annual Report (filed June 3, 2011), “the June 2011 Report”).
- 2 -
since last May may be the result of mergers and acquisitions, direct customers that choose to
enroll through an aggregator or LSE, or withdrawal from the NYISO market due to new financial requirements for NYISO market participants that went into effect in October 2011.
Figure 1 below provides a geographic distribution of resources currently enrolled in the NYISO’s EDRP and ICAP/SCR programs.
Figure 1. Zonal Distribution of Combined Reliability Program Enrollment
EDRP + SCR MW
by NYISO Zone
May 2012
B81.0
AMW
C
392.5101.8
MWMW
Total Enrolled:
1805.5 MW
E
40.8
MW
409.9J
MW
D
F
126.2
MW
G
50.9 MW
459.9 MW
H6.1 MW
I35.0 MW
K101.5 MW
Tables 2 through 4 present zonal enrollment statistics for EDRP, ICAP/SCR, and
DADRP, respectively, as of mid-May 2012. For each Load Zone (Zone), information on the total number of resources, total MW registered, and the amount of load reduction being supplied
through the use of Local Generators is provided. In addition, changes in number of resources and enrolled MW since the June 2011 Report are shown by Zone.
- 3 -
Table 2. EDRP Enrollment: May 2012
Change in
Number ofEDRP MW ofEDRP MW of Count from Change in MW
EDRPLoadEnrolled LocalTotal EDRP May 2011 from May 2011
ZoneResourcesReductionGeneratorsMWReportReport
A178.61.09.64‐0.9
B150.13.43.5142.5
C362.20.02.29‐12.9
D80.00.00.00‐3.7
E3712.90.313.211‐11.9
F3224.24.228.42223.1
G150.00.50.52‐16.6
H*0.00.00.0‐1‐1.8
I*0.10.00.1‐12‐3.6
J90.50.00.5‐13‐4.6
K170.63.23.8173.8
Totals18649.212.661.950‐26.5
* Number of end‐use locations by category is fewer than 5 and has been masked for this public version of
the table. The unredacted values are presented in the confidential appendix submitted as Attachment A.
Enrollment in EDRP shows a reduction of 30% in enrolled MW since May 2011. The
largest reductions occurred in Zones G (Hudson), C (Central), and E (Mohawk Valley). Zone F, Capital, shows an increase of 23.1 MW, nearly one third of the MW enrolled for May 2012.
Nominal changes occurred in all other Zones. The changes in enrollment do not necessarily
indicate that there will be a reduction in enrollment of EDRP resources for the Summer 2012
Capability Period because EDRP resources can enroll in the month prior to when the resources expect to participate. For example, in 2011, the enrolled MW increased by 70% between May (88.4 MW) and July 2011 (148.1 MW).
- 4 -
Table 3. ICAP/SCR Enrollment: May 2012
ICAP MW ofICAP MW of Change in Count Change in ICAP
Number ofLoadEnrolled LocalTotal ICAPfrom May 2011 MW from May
ZoneSCRsReductionGeneratorsMWReport2011 Report
A434373.39.6382.9‐76‐7.2
B21370.57.077.5‐37‐37.6
C31997.32.399.6‐3‐27.7
D15459.90.0459.9‐7145.5
E14627.50.127.5‐10‐17.1
F19788.29.697.8‐2‐36.5
G14945.45.050.31‐14.1
H235.20.96.12‐2.7
I13430.34.735.05‐6.7
J2399307.2102.3409.4‐146‐34.0
K80889.78.097.7‐176‐47.1
Totals48371594.3149.41743.7‐449‐85.2
The ICAP/SCR data in Table 3 is based on the enrollments prior to the May ICAP Spot Market Auction. Approximately 8.6% of enrolled MW in ICAP/SCR are attributed to Local Generator resources.
The data in Table 3 shows a MW enrollment decrease of 5% compared with the same
period reported in the June 2011 Report and an 8% reduction in the number of end-use locations. Historic data shows that enrollment in the ICAP/SCR program changes monthly throughout the Summer Capability Period. Between May 2011 and June 2011, for example, there was an
increase of 6% in enrolled end-use locations and an 11% increase in enrolled MW.
- 5 -
Zone
Number of End
Use Locations
DADRP Load DADRP Local Reduction MW Generator MW
Total DADRPCount from Change in MW
MWMay 2011 from May 2011
ReportReport
A00.00.00.0‐4‐58.0
B00.00.00.0‐1‐2.8
C00.00.00.0‐2‐38.0
D00.00.00.0‐1‐100.0
E00.00.00.0‐1‐10.0
F*28.00.028.0‐5‐64.0
G*9.00.09.000.0
H00.00.00.000.0
I00.00.00.000.0
J00.00.00.0‐2‐6.6
K00.00.00.0‐30‐15.0
Total437.00.037.0‐46‐294.4
* Number of end‐use locations by category is fewer than 5 and has been masked for this public version of
the table. The unredacted values are presented in the confidential appendix submitted as Attachment A.
Enrollment in DADRP has been static for several years and many of the enrolled
resources have shown no activity in the energy market for more than three years. The changes in enrollment reported for DADRP are of two types: resources that formally withdrew from the DADRP program in 2011 (7 resources, 26.4 MW) and resources that have been removed from reporting due to inactivity since 2008 to provide a more accurate representation of the enrolled MW in the DADRP (20 resources, 268 MW). The DADRP resources that have been removed from reporting are still eligible to make offers in the day-ahead energy market and will be
counted in future enrollment reports if their activity in DADRP changes.
Demand Side Ancillary Services Program
In December 2011, the NYISO released the technical specifications for NYISO Direct
Communications for DSASP Providers, which are the market participants that represent the
demand side resources in the NYISO’s ancillary services market. As a result, DSASP Providers
have shown an increased interest in the program with more beginning to register. As DSASP
Providers complete the NYISO registration process and install the infrastructure for Direct
- 6 -
Communications for DSASP, the NYISO expects enrollment of individual resources for DSASP. Additional information regarding current activities associated with aggregations for DSASP is
discussed below.
Demand Response Initiatives for 2012
The NYISO is working with its stakeholders on a number of initiatives intended to
improve the administration of its demand response programs, and to address regulatory
directives to facilitate market participation. This section provides a brief synopsis of the efforts to date on these initiatives:
Continued Development of the Demand Response Information System (DRIS)
The NYISO has one planned deployment in June 2012 for DRIS to integrate demand
response event creation and notification into DRIS. This deployment will be used by NYISO
Operators to deploy demand response resources and provide a way for market participants to
respond with an estimate of their anticipated capability directly into DRIS. To familiarize DRIS users with the new capabilities for event notification, the NYISO has scheduled multiple DRIS training sessions and will conduct a communication test shortly after deployment to allow DRIS users to exercise the new features.
Market Rules for Aggregations of Small Demand Resources in the Ancillary Services Market
The NYISO has proposed market rules and procedures for integrating aggregations of
small demand resources into its ancillary service markets through the Demand Side Ancillary
Services Program (DSASP). Presentations to stakeholders on these issues were made in
February, April, and May 2012.5 The NYISO anticipates filing proposed tariff changes in the
late summer 2012.
5 Presentations on Aggregations for DSASP made to the Market Issues Working Group:
February: http://www.nyiso.com/public/webdocs/committees/bic_miwg/meeting_materials/2012-02-
17/Concepts_for_DSASP_Aggregation-MIWG-02-17-12.pdf,
April: http://www.nyiso.com/public/webdocs/committees/bic_miwg/meeting_materials/2012-04-
26/DSASP_Aggregations.pdf,
- 7 -
Order 745 Compliance Filing on the Feasibility of a Dynamic Net Benefit Tests
As directed in Order 745, the NYISO will make a compliance filing in September 2012 to report on the results of a study to determine the feasibility of integrating a dynamic version of the Net Benefits Test on a real-time basis.
Demand Response in the Real-Time Energy Market
The NYISO will begin work with its stakeholders during the second half of 2012 with the objective to complete a market design for demand response in the real-time energy market by the end of 2012.
Implementation of NYISO’s Order 745 Compliance Filing for a Monthly Net Benefits Test
The NYISO submitted its filing in compliance with Order 745 on August 19, 2011. The
NYISO has identified the changes to its systems and procedures that will be necessary to
implement the compliance filing. Once the NYISO receives an order from the Commission on
its compliance filing, it will assess the implementation plan requirements and schedule.
May: http://www.nyiso.com/public/webdocs/committees/bic_miwg/meeting_materials/2012-05-
15/DSASP_Aggregations-MIWG-05-15-12.pdf
- 8 -