Howard H. Shafferman
Direct: 202.661.2205
Fax: 202.626.9036
hhs@ballardspahr.com
May 11, 2012
By Electronic Filing
Hon. Kimberly D. Bose, Secretary
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
888 First Street, N.E.
Washington, D.C. 20426
Subject:
Midwest Independent Transmission System Operator, Inc. and
International Transmission Company d/b/a ITCTransmission, Docket
No. ER11-1844-000, PUBLIC Version of Testimony of New York
Independent System Operator, Inc. Witness Robert Pike
Dear Ms. Bose:
The New York Independent System Operator, Inc. submits by electronic filing the
PUBLIC version of the attached Prepared Direct and Answering Testimony of Robert Pike
(Exhibit NYI-46 for identification), with verification.
The testimony has been served on all parties as required by Rule 2010 of the Commission’s
Rules of Practice and Procedure. In addition, two three-hole punched chambers copies are
being provided to Presiding Administrative Law Judge Steven Sterner, along
with a summary of the testimony.
Very truly yours,
/s/ Howard H. Shafferman
Howard H. Shafferman
Cc: Parties of Record
Vintricia Alexander. (Law Clerk to Judge Sterner)
HHS/
DMEAST #15031604 v1
Atlanta
|
Baltimore
|
Bethesda
|
Denver
|
Las Vegas
|
Los Angeles
|
New Jersey
|
Philadelphia
|
Phoenix
|
Salt Lake City
|
San Diego
Washington, DC
|
Wilmington
|
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-46
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BEFORE THE
FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION
Midwest Independent Transmission System
Operator, Inc. and
Docket No. ER11-1844-000
International Transmission Company d/b/a
ITCTransmission
SUMMARY OF TESTIMONY OF ROBERT PIKE (EXHIBIT NYI-46)
Mr. Pike is Director of Market Design for the New York Independent System Operator,
Inc. (“NYISO”).
By submitting testimony addressing the merits of the MISO/ITC filing, the NYISO is not
conceding that the Commission has legal authority under the Federal Power Act to accept the
MISO/ITC filing, that the Commission has made the findings necessary to permit the NYISO to
recover PAR-related charges it receives from MISO from the NYISO’s customers, or that the
collection of any or all the proposed charges - under any circumstance - is just and reasonable
and not unduly discriminatory or preferential.
In Section III of his testimony, Mr. Pike reviews the history and purposes of the phase
angle regulators (“PARs”) at the Michigan-Ontario interface (the “MI/ON Interface”) (page 3,
line 3 through page 11, line 22). Based on testimony from witnesses of the Midwest Independent
Transmission System Operator, Inc. (“MISO”) and the International Transmission Company
(“ITC”), and MISO and ITC responses to data requests, he explains that Detroit Edison placed a
PAR into service on the B3N circuit (one of the four transmission circuits constituting the
MI/ON Interface) in 2002 that failed in 2003 after being transferred to ITC ownership (the
DMEAST #15024249 v1
“Original PAR”), and that ITC installed two PARs on the B3N circuit as replacements for the
Original PAR (the “Replacement PARs”) (page 3, lines 5 through 18).
In 1998, Detroit Edison, Ontario Hydro (the pertinent part of which is now Hydro One
Networks Inc.) and Consumers Energy Company entered into an Interconnection Facilities
Expansion Agreement (the “1998 Facilities Agreement”) whereby Detroit Edison agreed to
install and operate the Original PAR, and Ontario Hydro agreed to install and operate a PAR on
the Ontario side of each of the other three MI/ON Interface circuits (the “Hydro One PARs”).
(page 3, line 20 through page 4, line 15). In 2007, ITC and Hydro One entered into a new
Interconnection Facilities Agreement (the “2007 Facilities Agreement”), under which ITC (due
to the failure of the Original PAR) agreed to install one or more PARs on the B3N circuit (i.e.,
the Replacement PARs).1 The proposed allocation of the costs of the Replacement PARs to
NYISO and PJM customers is at issue in this proceeding (page 4, line 17 through page 5, line 5).
In Section III, Mr. Pike identifies evidence demonstrating that the Replacement PARs
perform the same function as the Original PAR (page 5, line 7 through page 7, line 26). He also
presents documentation, including regulatory filings, confirming that the purpose of the MI/ON
PARs is to facilitate economic trades between Ontario and Michigan, in part through the
avoidance of curtailment of Ontario-Michigan transactions via Transmission Loading Relief
(“TLR”)2 (page 7, line 13 through page 9, line 28). Mr. Pike presents data confirming that TLRs
of transactions at the MI/ON Interface remain an obstacle to commerce between the regions of
MISO and the Independent Electricity System Operator (Ontario) (“IESO”) today. Reducing
the number of TLRs affecting External Transactions at the MI/ON Interface will provide benefits
1
The Replacement PARs and the Hydro One PARs are referred to collectively in NYISO testimony as the
“MI/ON PARs.”
2
TLR and its impacts are explained in Mr. Yeoman’s testimony.
DMEAST #15024249 v1
2
to MISO, IESO and their customers that are not provided to NYISO and its customers. (page 10,
line 2 through page 11, line 5). Mr. Pike presents information indicating that the MI/ON PARs
provide reliability benefits to ITC and its customers and maintains import capability for
transactions beneficial to ITC customers. Mr. Pike concludes that the Replacement PARs were
built for the benefit of ITC’s customers (page 11, lines 7 through 22).
In Section IV of his testimony, Mr. Pike rebuts assertions by MISO/ITC that the MI/ON
PARs provide “benefits” to NYISO based on statements made by the NYISO in its July 21, 2008
“exigent circumstances” filing in Docket No. ER08-1281, in which the NYISO proposed tariff
changes (subsequently accepted by the Commission and still in place) to prohibit “circuitous”
scheduling of external transactions in the control areas around Lake Erie (page 12, line 1 through
page 23, line 19). As Mr. Pike explains, the MI/ON PARs were not operated to mitigate that
circuitous scheduling problem and would not have been capable of fully “solving” the loop flow
problems experienced due to circuitous schedules (page 13, line 10 through page 14, line 14).
Instead, the problem was addressed by the NYISO’s Tariff revisions (page 13, lines 1 through 8).
In Section IV, Mr. Pike also reviews the market rules identified in the “Broader Regional
Markets” (“BRM”) initiatives which began in 2008, and in which NYISO, IESO, MISO, PJM,
ISO New England and Hydro-Québec are participating. The BRM initiative is an effort to
improve coordination between the markets, enhance utilization of existing resources and reduce
costs of power consumers. Mr. Pike explains how the new rules that the ISOs and RTOs are
developing will tend to reduce Lake Erie unscheduled power flow or permit the ISOs and RTOs
to mitigate the impacts on unscheduled Lake Erie power flows at a lower overall cost (page 15,
line 3 through page 18, line 22).
DMEAST #15024249 v1
3
In Section IV, Mr. Pike also explains that the allegation in the MISO/ITC filing letter,
premised on a study prepared by Potomac Economics, that “congestion relief savings could be
approximately $362 million annually from market mechanisms to control Lake Erie loop flow,
over half of which would accrued to the NYISO Region” is patently inaccurate (page 19, line 2
through page 21, line 16). Potomac Economics’ analysis was not a measure of congestion cost
impacts impact incurred from historic loop flow, nor was the analysis a measure of what savings
would accrue if loop flow were to be eliminated. Rather, Potomac Economics’ analysis was a
measure of production cost benefits associated with regional coordination of scheduling actions
(page 19, lines 13 through 18). The vast bulk (>85%) of the region-wide savings identified by
Potomac Economics are related to improving the economic efficiency of interchange scheduling
decisions to ensure that power is transported from the low-cost region to the high-cost region to
maximize the utilization of the transmission system, not to removing unscheduled power flows
from the interconnected transmission system. The MI/ON PARs do not impact the efficiency
measures that Potomac’s study was assessing (page 20, lines 2 through 19). Potomac
Economic’s analysis suggests that perfect control of Lake Erie loop flow could deliver a net $1
million in flowgate value relief to New York, but less than perfect control of Lake Erie
unscheduled power flow could actually result in a net detrimental impact to total NYISO
congestion costs (page 20, line 21 through page 21, line 16).
In Section IV, Mr. Pike also describes the limited circumstances in which effective,
coordinated operation of all of the MI/ON PARs may benefit New York, namely when (a) the
MI/ON PARs are operated to reduce clockwise loop flows, and (b) components of the New York
State Transmission System that are substantially affected by unscheduled Lake Erie power flows
are constrained (page 21, line 18 through page 22, line 13). New York may be “harmed,”
DMEAST #15024249 v1
4
however, if/when (x) the MI/ON PARs are operated to reduce counterclockwise loop flows, and
(y) components of the New York State Transmission System that are substantially affected by
unscheduled Lake Erie power flows are constrained (page 22, lines 13 through 16). If the
MI/ON PARs are not successfully operated to conform actual power flows to scheduled power
flows, but are still declared to be “regulating” for purposes of the NERC Interchange
Distribution Calculator (“IDC”), New York may be harmed because it may not be able to use
TLR to obtain relief from unscheduled Lake Erie power flows3 (page 23, lines 4 through 9).
New York may also be harmed if MISO and IESO do not accurately anticipate power flows and
move the MI/ON PARs in a direction that exacerbates unscheduled flows, or if the MI/ON PARs
are operated in a manner that regularly causes unscheduled power flows over the New York
State Transmission System (page 23, lines 11 through 19).
In Section V of his testimony, Mr. Pike explains the practical significance of the MISO’s
March 23, 2012 announcement relating to the initiation of service over the Replacement PARs
despite the outage - which continues to the present - of one of the Hydro One PARs (L4D) (page
24, line 1 through page 25, line 15). Specifically, MISO’s announcement that it did not intend to
change, on April 5, 2012 (the date on which it initiated Replacement PARs’ operation) the
methodology for pricing transactions scheduled across the MI/ON Interface amounts to an
admission that MISO does not expect the MI/ON PARs to be able to effectively conform actual
power flows to scheduled power flows at the MI/ON Interface without the L4D PAR in service
(page 24, line 8 through page 25, line 15).
3
See testimony of NYISO witness Yeomans for additional discussion of TLRs and the IDC.
DMEAST #15024249 v1
5
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 1 of 26
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
BEFORE THE
FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION
Midwest Independent Transmission System
Operator, Inc. and
Docket No. ER11-1844-000
International Transmission Company d/b/a
ITCTransmission
TESTIMONY OF ROBERT PIKE
1
I.
SUMMARY OF TESTIMONY
2
A summary precedes my testimony.
3
4
II.
WITNESS IDENTITY AND QUALIFICATIONS
5
Q.
Please state your name, title and business address.
6
A.
My name is Robert Pike. I am the Director of Market Design for the New York
7
Independent System Operator, Inc. (“NYISO”). My business address is 10 Krey
8
Boulevard, Rensselaer, New York 12144.
9
10
Q.
Please describe your educational background and work experience.
11
A.
I hold a Bachelor of Science in Electrical and Computer Engineering and Master of
12
Science in Electrical Engineering from Clarkson University and a Master of Business
13
Administration from Union College. I have worked for the NYISO and its
14
predecessor organization, the New York Power Pool, for nearly twenty years.
15
During that time I have held positions in Engineering, Operations, Information
16
Technology and Project and Product Management. For the last 15 years, I have been
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 2 of 26
1
involved in the design and implementation of electric markets at the NYISO. My
2
current responsibilities include the evaluation and evolution of the capacity, energy
3
and congestion rights markets to achieve improved efficiencies, incorporate desired
4
market features, and address regulatory obligations.
5
6
Q.
What topics do you address in your testimony?
7
A.
My direct testimony addresses:
8
(i) the history and purposes of the phase angle regulators (“PARs”) at the Michigan-
9
Ontario interface (“MI/ON Interface”) (see page 3);
10
(ii) the assertions by the Midwest Independent Transmission System Operator, Inc.
11
(“MISO”) and the International Transmission Company (“ITC”) of “benefits” to
12
NYISO from operation of the PARs whose cost allocation is at issue in this
13
proceeding (the “Replacement PARs”) (see page 12); and
14
(iii) the operation of the Replacement PARs despite the outage of one of the three
15
PARs on the Canadian side of the MI/ON Interface (see page 24).
16
17
Q.
In what context are you addressing these topics?
18
A.
By submitting testimony addressing the merits of the MISO/ITC filing, the NYISO is
19
not conceding that the Commission has legal authority under the Federal Power Act
20
to accept the MISO/ITC filing, that the Commission has made the findings necessary
21
to permit the NYISO to recover PAR-related charges it receives from MISO from the
22
NYISO’s customers, or that the collection of any or all the proposed charges - under
23
any circumstance - is just and reasonable and not unduly discriminatory or
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 3 of 26
1
preferential.
2
3
III.
HISTORY AND PURPOSES OF THE PARS AT THE MICHIGAN-ONTARIO
4
INTERFACE
5
Q.
Please provide an introduction to the history of the PARs at the MI/ON
6
Interface and, in particular, to the PAR on the B3N circuit at the MI/ON
7
Interface that was placed into service by Detroit Edison in 2002 and that failed
8
in 2003 while under ITC ownership (the “Original PAR”).
9
A.
Based on my review of the testimony of ITC and MISO witnesses, including the
10
testimony of Carlo P. Capra, Jeff Webb and Thomas Mallinger (all submitted on
11
October 20, 2010 in this proceeding) and of Digaunto Chatterjee (submitted on
12
January 31, 2012 in this proceeding), and my review of ITC’s responses to data
13
requests, the Original PAR was installed by Detroit Edison (through its then-
14
subsidiary, ITC) and made operational in 2002 pursuant to plans that were developed
15
in 1998 between Detroit Edison and Ontario Hydro to conform actual flows to
16
scheduled flows across the MI/ON Interface. See Capra testimony at 6. The
17
Original PAR was then transferred to ITC as a standalone entity. The Original PAR
18
failed in March 2003. See Exhibit NYI-47.
19
20
Q.
Did Detroit Edison enter into an agreement with Ontario Hydro to construct
21
the MI/ON PARs in 1998?
22
A.
Yes. In Section 3.2 of the Interconnection Facilities Expansion Agreement entered
23
into among Ontario Hydro, Detroit Edison and Consumers Energy Company on
24
December 21, 1998 (the “1998 Facilities Agreement”) (Exhibit NYI-48), Detroit
25
Edison agreed, at its own expense, to “purchase, install, activate and make
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 4 of 26
1
operational a 230 kV Phase-Shifting 645 MVA Transformer and associated bypass
2
switching facilities in the B3N interconnection terminal at its Bunce Creek Station”
3
(i.e., the Original PAR). In Section 3.1 of the 1998 Facilities Agreement (Exhibit
4
NYI-48), Ontario Hydro (now Hydro One) committed to install and operate three
5
PARs on the Ontario side of the MI/ON Interface. I refer to these three PARs in my
6
testimony as the “Hydro One PARs.” There are four transmission lines at the
7
MI/ON Interface that interconnect Michigan and Ontario. Each of the Hydro One
8
PARs is associated with a distinct transmission line, so three of the four transmission
9
lines at the MI/ON Interface are associated with Hydro One PARs.
10
11
Section 3.7 of the 1998 Facilities Agreement (Exhibit NYI-48) states, “Hydro and
12
Edison shall each be responsible for the performance of operation and maintenance,
13
extraordinary maintenance and repair, which can include replacement, of the New
14
Equipment and New Facilities [defined to include the Original PAR] which are
15
owned by them, including all costs associated therewith.”
16
17
Q.
Did ITC enter into an agreement with Hydro One Networks Inc. (“Hydro One”)
18
to construct two PARs on the B3N circuit as replacements for the Original PAR
19
(the “Replacement PARs”) in 2007?
20
A.
Yes. On September 20, 2007, ITC entered into the “Interconnection Facilities
21
Agreement Between Hydro One Networks Inc. and ITCTransmission Company” (the
22
“2007 Facilities Agreement”), which is included as Exhibit NYI-49 to my testimony.
23
Section 10.3 of the 2007 Facilities Agreement states, “[d]ue to the failure of the
24
Phase Angle Regulator referenced in Subsection 10.2(a) above [i.e., the Original
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 5 of 26
1
PAR], ITC agrees to install one or more Phase Angle Regulators with a combined
2
total capacity of at least 645 MVA in the B3N Interconnection terminal at its Bunce
3
Creek Station.” ITC decided to install two Replacement PARs at Bunce Creek to
4
replace the Original PAR. The proposed allocation of the costs of the Replacement
5
PARs to NYISO and PJM customers is at issue in this proceeding.
6
7
Q.
Do the Replacement PARs perform the same function as the Original PAR did?
8
A.
MISO and ITC have stated that the Replacement PARs are replacements for the
9
Original PAR and perform the same functions that the Original PAR was expected to
10
perform.
11
12
On page 25 of his testimony, MISO witness Chatterjee states that the Replacement
13
PARs (which he refers to as the “New PARs”) are “replacements” for the Original
14
PAR. Further, as an attachment to MISO’s response to NYISO/MISO 1-7, MISO
15
provided an excerpt from the “MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion
16
Plan” (“MTEP 06”) which describes Project ID No. 1308 as one that, among other
17
things, “replaces the failed Phase Angle Regulator with 2 new PAR’s in series.” (see
18
pages 11 and 19 of Exhibit NYI-50). The same description is used in Appendix A to
19
MTEP 06 (see page 7 of Exhibit NYI-51), provided as a separate attachment to
20
MISO’s response to NYISO/MISO 1-7. Also, in its response to data request to
21
NYISO/MISO 3-8 (Exhibit NYI-52), MISO also answered “In general, yes” to the
22
NYISO’s question about whether the Replacement PARs were designed and
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 6 of 26
1
constructed to perform the same function as the Original PAR was designed and
2
constructed to perform.
3
4
ITC witness Capra states in his testimony (at 9) that “[t]he design of the New PARs
5
will maintain the interface control capability and functionality of the original
6
design.”
REDACTED
7
REDACTED
ITC’s response to
8
NYISO/ITC 1-14 (Exhibit NYI-54 hereto) states, with reference to the Replacement
9
PAR project’s approval in MTEP 06, that: “The project was approved as a like for
10
like replacement and thus was not eligible for cost sharing within MISO under MISO
11
tariff Attachment FF.” This is consistent with the statements of ITC in its January 5,
12
2009 application to the United States Department of Energy (“DOE”) to amend its
13
Presidential Permit in DOE Docket No. PP230-4 (Exhibit NYI-55 at 1), in which
14
ITC requested “authorization to replace the [Original PAR] with two 700 MVA
15
phase shifting transformers connected in series.” In the application (at 5), ITC cited
16
the then-existing permit as stating that the Original PAR’s purpose was “to help
17
provide ‘enhanced control over the inadvertent power flow between Michigan and
18
Ontario and, by extension, around Lake Erie’…, so that ‘under normal operating
19
conditions … the electrical flow on the Michigan-Ontario interface will match the
20
Michigan-Ontario scheduled transactions across the interface.’” Further, the
21
application states (at 5-6) that:
22
“[i]n recognition of the failure of the original transformer … ITC chose a
23
differently designed unit and decided to replace the single failed unit with
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 7 of 26
1
two 700-MVA units connected in series…. Since the two new transformers
2
will nominally have 15 degrees more shifting capability than the failed
3
transformer, they should be capable of providing some increased amount of
4
control over unscheduled electrical flows when necessary. However, the
5
intended function of the new units will be the same as the original unit
6
was authorized to provide in 2001 -- to control unscheduled flows so that
7
actual flow matches scheduled flow, to the maximum extent possible. In
8
that sense, therefore, the new units should perhaps best be viewed as
9
replacement facilities providing an already authorized service, rather
10
than as new facilities providing a new service.”
11
The emphasis is mine.
12
13
Q.
Why did Detroit Edison and Ontario Hydro agree to construct the MI/ON
14
PARs?
15
A.
Schedule “A” to the 1998 Facilities Agreement, titled “Basic Principles of Ontario-
16
Michigan Phase Shifter Operation,” states (at page 1 of Exhibit NYI-48) that Ontario
17
Hydro and Detroit Edison “intend to improve reliability of bulk power supply by
18
adding and modifying facilities … to control circulating power flows that would
19
otherwise interfere with the ability to carry out scheduled transactions” and that the
20
PARs would be “operated primarily to control power flow circulating through the
21
electrical systems of the parties in order to protect the parties’ respective
22
transmission facilities and to facilitate transactions between and among the parties.”
23
24
Carlo Capra’s testimony (at 4-5) recognizes that removal of obstacles to Ontario-
25
Michigan trading was the fundamental reason that Ontario Hydro (“OH”) (the
26
predecessor to Hydro One) and Detroit Edison (formerly the parent of ITC) decided
27
to install the Hydro One PARs and the Original PAR on the B3N circuit. Mr.
28
Capra’s testimony states “the fundamental purpose of the joint Detroit Edison
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 8 of 26
1
Company and Ontario Hydro proposal to add additional PARs on the
2
interconnections between what was then the Detroit Edison Company and Ontario
3
Hydro was to improve the reliability of the bulk power system by controlling
4
circulating loop flows around Lake Erie that would otherwise interfere with the
5
ability to carry out scheduled transactions.”
6
7
Page 6 of Mr. Capra’s testimony quotes from Detroit Edison’s request to the
8
Department of Energy for permission to construct the Original PAR and other
9
facilities at the MI/ON Interface. The application explains that in 1998 over 8,500
10
MW of transactions scheduled between Ontario Hydro and utilities in Michigan were
11
curtailed via Transmission Loading Relief (“TLR”). TLR and its impacts are
12
explained in the testimony of NYISO witness Wesley Yeomans’ (Exhibit NYI-1).
13
14
Q.
Do other documents confirm that the purpose of the MI/ON PARs is to facilitate
15
economic trades between Ontario and Michigan?
16
A.
Yes. Documents produced by Detroit Edison in this proceeding similarly show that
17
the purpose of the MI/ON PARs is to facilitate trading between Detroit Edison and
18
Ontario across the MI/ON Interface. Exhibit NYI-56 is a November 12, 1998
19
internal Detroit Edison memorandum that describes the Original PAR (at 1) as part
20
of a project that is the “solution” to an increase in Lake Erie loop flow that “has
21
reduced our ability to import power from Ontario Hydro….This project provides
22
both a benefit in importing more power from OH through increased capacity and by
23
blocking the loop flow and the additional benefit of obtaining more import capability
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 9 of 26
1
on either the [MI/ON] or Southern Interface, therefore, providing operating
2
flexibility.”
3
4
Q.
Do ITC and Detroit Edison regulatory filings confirm that the purpose of the
5
MI/ON PARs is to facilitate economic trades between Ontario and Michigan?
6
Yes. The construction of the MI/ON PARs to enhance Michigan power supply
7
through increased transactions with Ontario is verified through ITC’s offering of the
8
Original PAR, in the portion submitted by ITC (at that time, a subsidiary of Detroit
9
Edison) of a December 2000 “Joint Report” to the Michigan Public Service
10
Commission (“MPSC”) in Case No. U-12781. The purpose of the Joint Report, filed
11
by several Michigan utilities, was to describe how the utilities would satisfy the
12
requirements of a 2000 Michigan law to increase import capability from Ontario by
13
2000 MW. The brief of Detroit Edison in Case Nos. U-12780 and U-12781 (at page
14
12 of Exhibit NYI-57) states that among the seven (7) projects identified by ITC in
15
the Joint Report was the addition of “a 675 MVA Phase Angle Regulator in the B3N
16
interconnection with Hydro One [i.e., the Original PAR].” In the Joint Report (at
17
page 8 of Exhibit NYI-58), ITC stated that it had installed the Original PAR, which,
18
operating in concert with similar phase angle regulators added by Hydro One
19
in the L4D and L51D interconnections, as well as the existing phase angle
20
regulator in the J5D interconnection, enables the control of 600-700 MW of
21
parallel path flow north of Lake Erie (Lake Erie circulation). As this
22
circulating power was using a significant portion of the International
23
Transmission Company-Ontario interface, the control of 600-700 MW of
24
circulating power translates into an increase in the firm commercial
25
capability of that interface. In total, the Hydro One to [Michigan] path
26
will realize an increase of 820 MW of firm commercial capability from
27
2000 to 2002.
28
The emphasis is mine.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 10 of 26
1
2
Q.
To what extent do TLRs of transactions at the MI/ON Interface remain an
3
obstacle to commerce between MISO and IESO today?
4
A.
The NYISO obtained from Open Access Technology International, Inc. (“OATI”) a
5
list of all transactions scheduled over the MI/ON Interface that were curtailed via
6
TLR between January 1, 2009 and December 31, 2011. Over that time period, 2213
7
transactions that were scheduled over the MI/ON Interface between Ontario and
8
MISO were curtailed or removed via TLR actions. Those transactions represented
9
more than 246,375 MW of scheduled interchange between Ontario and Michigan
10
that was prevented or interrupted via TLR. See Exhibit NYI-59. TLR actions
11
continue to disrupt transactions scheduled between MISO and the Independent
12
Electricity System Operator of Ontario (“IESO”).
13
14
Q.
Does the reduction of TLRs at the MI/ON Interface provide similar benefits to
15
New York?
16
A.
No. Based upon a review of transaction schedule data stored in the NYISO’s Market
17
Information System (“MIS”), for the calendar year 2011, approximately four-tenths
18
of one percent of the NYISO’s total real-time scheduled interchange had a source
19
from, or sink in, MISO. The NYISO implemented schedules for 169,4601
MWh of
20
MISO-based transactions, out of a total volume of 38,558,805 MWh of all
21
transactions scheduled at its borders. These are the only transactions that would be
22
likely to be scheduled across the MI/ON Interface. A portion of the NYISO/MISO
1 This information was derived from the NERC e-Tag data recorded for these transactions. The same
information should be available from data repositories to which other ISOs/RTOs have access.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 11 of 26
1
interchange is scheduled through PJM Interconnection, LLC’s (“PJM’s”) Balancing
2
Authority Area, not over the MI/ON Interface, so the component of NYISO
3
interchange that is scheduled over the MI/ON Interface is a small fraction of one
4
percent of the NYISO’s scheduled interchange with its neighbors. The potential
5
economic harm to NYISO from TLRs at the MI/ON Interface is negligible.
6
7
Q.
What other reliability benefits do the MI/ON PARs provide to ITC and its
8
customers?
9
A.
10
11
REDACTED
12
13
14
MTEP06 also notes (at page 19 of Exhibit NYI-50) that the Replacement PAR will
15
“increase both MVA capability and phase angle control.”
16
17
Q.
Given this information, what do you conclude about the motivations for the
18
Replacement PARs?
19
A.
ITC and its predecessor Detroit Edison entered into agreements with Hydro One to
20
construct the MI/ON PARs in order to maintain import capability for transactions
21
beneficial to ITC customers, and to improve the reliability of the ITC system. The
22
Replacement PARs were built for the benefit of ITC’s customers.
23
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 12 of 26
1
IV.
MISO/ITC’s ASSERTIONS OF “BENEFITS” TO NYISO AND ITS
2
CUSTOMERS
3
Q.
What does the MISO/ITC Filing utilize as the basis for asserting benefits from
4
the Replacement PARs to the NYISO and its customers?
5
A.
MISO and ITC’s October 20, 2010 filing letter in this docket asserts (at 3), in
6
connection with the NYISO’s July 21, 2008 exigent circumstances filing in Docket
7
No. ER08-1281, that the NYISO “urged the Commission to take an active interest
8
‘so that the [New] PARs are placed in operation and are operated to mitigate Lake
9
Erie circulation as soon as possible.’” The MISO/ITC filing letter (at 3-4) also
10
references statements in the NYISO’s exigent circumstances filing suggesting that
11
the operation of all of the MI/ON Interface to effectively conform actual power flows
12
to scheduled power flows would be an important component of the solution to Lake
13
Erie unscheduled power flows. See also NYISO’s July 21, 2008 exigent
14
circumstances filing at p 8 (and n26), 26-27 (Exhibit NYI-61 at 2, 3-4)
15
16
Q.
What unusual conditions were being experienced in the New York Control Area
17
(“NYCA”) in early- to mid-2008, prior to the NYISO’s submission of its exigent
18
circumstances filing in Commission docket ER08-1281?
19
A.
In 2008, the NYCA was experiencing large deviations between scheduled power
20
flows and actual power flows. The cause of the problem was a seam (gap) in market
21
rules between neighboring ISOs and RTOs, of which market participants were taking
22
advantage by scheduling External Transactions (imports, exports and wheels-
23
through) in the Control Areas around Lake Erie via “circuitous” (indirect) scheduling
24
paths.
25
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 13 of 26
1
Q.
What measures did the NYISO take to address these problems?
2
A.
On July 21, 2008, the NYISO made its exigent circumstances filing proposing
3
changes to its tariffs to prevent circuitous scheduling of External Transactions in the
4
Control Areas around Lake Erie. The Commission accepted the NYISO’s proposed
5
tariff changes for filing on an expedited basis and they took effect on July 22, 2008,
6
one day after the NYISO submitted its filing. The NYISO’s tariff changes were later
7
accepted for filing by the Commission on a more permanent basis in an order issued
8
on November 17, 2008 in Docket No. ER09-198.
9
10
Q.
Were the MI/ON PARs used to mitigate the unscheduled power flows that the
11
NYISO experienced in 2008?
12
A.
No. There was no attempt made to operate any of the MI/ON PARs to mitigate the
13
circuitous scheduling problem that occurred in early- to mid-2008. The tariff
14
solution that the NYISO developed was the only new solution implemented in 2008
15
to address the circuitous scheduling problem. The tariff solution that the NYISO
16
implemented in 2008 effectively limits circuitous scheduling and is still in place
17
today. Had the NYISO chosen to wait for the MI/ON PARs to solve the problem,
18
the NYISO would still be waiting for an effective solution to be implemented.
19
20
Q.
If the Replacement PARs and the Hydro One PARs had all been available,
21
would they have been capable of addressed the conditions experienced in 2008?
22
A.
No, they would not have been capable of fully “solving” the loop flow problems that
23
Control Areas around Lake Erie were experiencing due to the circuitous schedules.
24
MISO and ITC have indicated (at page 6 of the filing letter) that the PARs can
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 14 of 26
1
control up to 600 MW of loop flow. As shown in the data, available on the NYISO’s
2
website,
3
4
ment_II_MMAStudy2008.xls , during the circuitous scheduling period, unscheduled
5
power flows exceeded 1000 MWs, even 2000 MWs, at times in both the clockwise
6
and counter-clockwise directions around Lake Erie. Clockwise unscheduled power
7
flows were between 1000 MWs and 2000MWs in 684 hours from December 29,
8
2007 to May 31, 2008, and exceeded 2000 MWs in 48 hours during May 2008.
9
Counter-clockwise unscheduled power flows were between 1000 MWs and
10
2000MWs in 774 hours from October 1, 2007 to April 4, 2008, and exceeded 2000
11
MWs in 21 hours during December 2007. In addition, on 81 days between October
12
1, 2007 and May 31, 2008, unscheduled power flows changed by more than 1000
13
MWs and flowed in both the clockwise and counter-clockwise directions around
14
Lake Erie.
15
16
Q.
Have the conditions in which the NYISO made the statements cited by
17
MISO/ITC persisted?
18
A.
No. The circuitous scheduling prohibitions have proven sufficient - in conjunction
19
with the occasional use of TLR procedures - to prevent/remediate extreme Lake Erie
20
loop flow impacts on the NYCA. Since 2008, the NYISO, PJM, IESO and MISO
21
and others have been working together to develop more consistent market rules in
22
order to remove the incentive for market participants to engage in circuitous
23
scheduling, or similar practices that are designed to take advantage of seams between
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 15 of 26
1
the market rules implemented by the ISOs and RTOs around Lake Erie.
2
3
Q.
What are some of the new market rules identified in the Broader Regional
4
Market initiative that the ISOs and RTOs have developed since 2008? How will
5
the new rules tend to reduce Lake Erie unscheduled power flow or permit the
6
ISOs and RTOs to mitigate the impacts of unscheduled Lake Erie power flows
7
at a lower overall cost?
8
A.
The Broader Regional Markets (“BRM”) initiative is an effort to improve
9
coordination between the markets, enhance utilization of existing resources, and
10
reduce costs for power consumers. In addition to the NYISO, the regional initiative
11
involves IESO, MISO, PJM, ISO New England, and Hydro-Québec. The market
12
enhancements are provided by a number of different improvements.
13
14
Market-to-Market Coordination (“M2M”) increases the level of collaboration
15
between ISOs and RTOs to jointly address transmission constraints using the most
16
cost-effective generation in the participating ISOs/RTOs. Enhanced Interregional
17
Transaction Coordination (“EITC”) reduces the need to use more expensive local
18
power if less costly power is available from a neighboring grid operator, shortens the
19
time commitment for moving power between Balancing Authorities and enables
20
faster responses to changing conditions. Interface Pricing establishes efficient and
21
compatible interface proxy bus prices to better reflect the value of moving energy
22
between regions. I discuss each of these below. One of the originally identified
23
BRM solutions, Buy-Through of Congestion, which would have assigned the off-
24
contract path congestion charges to the entity that schedules a transaction that has
25
unscheduled, parallel path impacts, was deferred by the Commission.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 16 of 26
1
2
The BRM solutions recognize that generation dispatch and transaction schedules
3
have flow impacts beyond the native regions within which they are scheduled, and
4
incorporate the regional cost impacts into the scheduling process to improve the
5
efficiency of the scheduling outcomes throughout the region. BRM is not expected
6
to require fundamental changes to any of the underlying market rules of the
7
ISOs/RTOs, but rather to improve the set of rules for coordinating operation,
8
scheduling and pricing decisions between the interconnected markets. M2M
9
provides for coordinated re-dispatch of assets within neighboring control areas to
10
address transmission constraints, rather than having each ISO or RTO rely solely on
11
its own internal resources to address constraints on its transmission system. M2M
12
delivers a broader regional view of transmission system congestion, encourages
13
generation dispatch instructions to be consistent with the impact each resource has
14
on inter-regional transmission system loadings, and encourages the scheduling of
15
inter-regional transactions to be consistent with the region-to-region costs and the
16
impacts those power deliveries have on network constraints. The approach is
17
expected to more cost-effectively utilize the region’s collective assets to address
18
constraints across multiple systems, resulting in lower congestion costs to
19
consumers, and to provide a more consistent pricing profile across markets. It also
20
tends to discourage the use of resources, or the scheduling of transactions, that have
21
significant impacts on neighboring regions. In other words, M2M provides
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 17 of 26
1
economic incentives not to create unscheduled power flows that will harm other
2
M2M participants.
3
4
To facilitate more efficient use of transmission connections across the ISO/RTO
5
boundaries, the NYISO has moved to allow the scheduling of transactions with
6
neighboring electric systems on a more frequent basis. In July 2011, EITC was
7
implemented at the Chateauguay interface between New York and Québec,
8
decreasing the scheduling interval from one hour to 15 minutes. The NYISO and
9
PJM plan to implement this same capability at their common border in mid-2012. In
10
addition, the Commission’s recent approval of Coordinated Transaction Scheduling
11
(“CTS”) between the NYISO and ISO New England will allow more efficient use of
12
the transmission lines that connect the two ISOs. Enhancements include increasing
13
the frequency of scheduling energy transactions between regions, implementing
14
software changes to enable the two grid operators to coordinate supply costs into the
15
selection of the most economic transactions, and eliminating several fees that impede
16
efficient trade between regions. This initiative and related measures are intended to
17
reduce transmission congestion costs, provide better integration of renewable
18
resources, and lower total system operating costs. MISO and PJM have been
19
pursuing similar initiatives for the scheduling of interchange on their border.
20
Similarly, the NYISO and PJM expect to pursue a CTS option and to initiate
21
discussions with stakeholder in late 2012.
22
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 18 of 26
1
Finally, the NYISO has completed and implemented a preliminary set of Interface
2
Pricing revisions to its procedures for establishing interface (proxy bus) prices that
3
recognize the incremental distribution of power flows around Lake Erie when
4
evaluating and pricing the marginal impacts of transaction and generation schedules.
5
The NYISO’s compliance obligation to develop corresponding tariff revisions is
6
being addressed by the Commission in Docket No. ER08-1281. Interface Pricing is
7
expected to result in efficient and compatible interface proxy bus prices between the
8
markets that will improve the interconnected markets’ ability to efficiently transfer
9
power between the ISO/RTO regions. Better aligning prices at the interface between
10
markets will provide the correct signals to market participants, and better reflect the
11
value of moving energy between regions.
12
13
The BRM solutions described above are designed to ensure that scheduling decisions
14
are made with a more complete understanding of the full impacts of scheduling
15
decisions on other markets. In some cases (M2M, for example), the financial impact
16
of a scheduling decision on another participating ISO/RTO may be assessed against
17
the scheduling ISO or RTO. The additional information that is being made available,
18
along with the newly developed financial incentives are expected to change
19
scheduling decisions by improving recognition of cross-border impacts. The
20
ultimate result of these initiatives will be that ISOs and RTOs will take into account
21
the expected impacts of their resource and transaction scheduling decisions on
22
affected regions.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 19 of 26
1
2
Q.
Please respond to the allegation on page 6 of the filing letter that the potential
3
annual congestion relief savings from operation of the MI/ON PARs would be
4
approximately $362 million?
5
A.
The allegation that the potential congestion relief savings to NYISO customers
6
resulting from the operation of the MI/ON PARs to control Lake Erie unscheduled
7
power flows would be approximately $181 million (approximately half of the total
8
estimated savings of $362 million) is incorrect for a number of reasons.
9
10
The $362 million estimate was the “high gas price” estimate Potomac Economics
11
prepared, based on $6/MMBtu natural gas. The estimate Potomac Economics
12
prepared based on historical gas prices was $297 million. Given the low natural gas
13
prices we are experiencing today, I address the $297 million estimate. Potomac
14
Economics’ analysis was not a measure of congestion cost impacts incurred from
15
historic loop flow, nor was the analysis a measure of what savings would accrue if
16
loop flow were to be eliminated. Rather, Potomac Economics’ analysis was a
17
measure of production costs benefits associated with regional coordination of
18
scheduling actions. The analysis recognized the regional transmission system
19
impacts associated with both generation dispatch and transaction scheduling and
20
assumed that the interconnected ISOs and RTOs would implement regional
21
congestion management coordination actions to make the most economically
22
efficient resource scheduling decisions in recognition of those impacts. Effective
23
coordination will replace higher-cost resources with lower-cost resources, lowering
24
total resource production costs across the region.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 20 of 26
1
2
The vast bulk of the region-wide savings identified (greater than 85%) are related to
3
improving the economic efficiency of interchange scheduling decisions to ensure
4
that power is transported from the low-cost region to the high-cost region to
5
maximize the utilization of the transmission system. As noted above, NYISO is
6
pursuing these benefits by implementing EITC and CTS with its neighbors. NYISO
7
and HQ have already implemented, and NYISO and PJM will shortly implement,
8
more frequent inter-Control Area scheduling actions and shorter durations of
9
schedules (see FERC Docket No. ER11-2547). NYISO and ISO-NE (see FERC
10
Docket Nos. ER12-701 and ER12-1155) and NYISO and PJM are pursuing CTS
11
solutions that improves the scheduling process by coordinating the participating
12
ISOs/RTOs’ supply curves in order to identify the most economic inter-regional
13
transactions to schedule.
14
15
The MI/ON PARs do not impact these measures. Indeed, to the extent that 15-
16
minute or 5-minute scheduling in all of the Balancing Authorities around Lake Erie
17
would be necessary to achieve some of the savings that the Potomac Economics
18
study identifies, the MI/ON PARs could actually prove to be an impediment to
19
achieving the savings that Potomac Economics projects.
20
21
Of the remaining $42.7 million in production cost savings identified in Potomac
22
Economics’ analysis, only $14.0 million is associated with the NYISO. Coordinated
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 21 of 26
1
congestion management between PJM and NYISO accounts for $10.1 million of that
2
$14 million in expected savings. As noted above, NYISO and PJM have already
3
moved forward with M2M to capture those benefits. The NYISO and PJM have
4
asked the Commission for permission to implement M2M on January 15, 2013. The
5
remaining cross-border loop flow impacts from MISO and Ontario native
6
generation-to-load impacts, and transaction impacts on NYISO congestion, are
7
nearly equally divided between forward direction impacts (contribute to congestion)
8
and reverse direction impacts (relieve congestion), with corresponding calculated
9
flowgate values2
of $20 million and $19 million, respectively. This one-time
10
analysis suggests that perfect control of Lake Erie loop flow, and removal of the
11
impacts on NYISO congestion costs from these sources, could deliver a net $1
12
million in flowgate value relief to New York. Less than perfect control of Lake Erie
13
loop flow would result in different impacts that would depend on the correlation of
14
time period and magnitude of uncontrolled loop flow with NYISO transmission
15
constraints, and could result in a net detrimental impact to total NYISO congestion
16
costs if the MI/ON PARs are not operated efficiently.
17
18
Q.
Could there be benefits to New York if MISO, ITC, IESO and Hydro One are
19
able to get all five of the MI/ON PARs into service simultaneously?
20
Possibly. New York may benefit from the effective, coordinated operation of all of
21
the MI/ON PARs at all four interties between Michigan and Ontario. As NYISO
2 Potomac Economics’ analysis contemplated a potential production cost benefit of 10% of the value of
flowgate impact from loop flow, thereby $3.9 million of production cost savings is derived from $39 million in
flowgate value.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 22 of 26
1
witness Wesley Yeomans explains in his direct testimony (Exhibit NYI-1), New
2
York will not benefit from the operation of ITC’s Replacement PARs in isolation,
3
and does not see a potential for significant “benefits” when only three of the four
4
transmission lines at the MI/ON Interface are subject to effective PAR control.
5
6
Possible benefits to New York would depend on how the MI/ON PARs are operated
7
(i.e., what their mission is) and how effectively they are able to achieve their
8
intended function. If all of the MI/ON PARs are operated to, and are able to,
9
successfully conform actual power flows to scheduled power flows at the MI/ON
10
Interface, New York may “benefit” if/when (a) the MI/ON PARs are operated to
11
reduce clockwise loop flows, and (b) components of the New York State
12
Transmission System that are substantially affected by unscheduled Lake Erie power
13
flows are constrained. New York may be “harmed” if/when (x) the MI/ON PARs
14
are operated to reduce counterclockwise loop flows, and (y) components of the New
15
York State Transmission System that are substantially affected by unscheduled Lake
16
Erie power flows are constrained.
17
18
New York may benefit if the MI/ON PARs are successfully operated to better
19
conform actual power flows to scheduled power flows and the PARs operation
20
consistently reduces the observed magnitude and volatility of loop flows around
21
Lake Erie. In order to achieve benefits related to more consistent power flows, the
22
NYISO would need to be able to reserve less transmission system capacity to protect
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 23 of 26
1
against the uncertainty of encountering large (magnitude) or more volatile loop flows
2
without creating additional reliability risks.
3
4
If the MI/ON PARs are not successfully operated to conform actual power flows to
5
scheduled power flows, but are still declared to be “regulating” for purposes of the
6
NERC Interchange Distribution Calculator (“IDC”), then New York may be harmed
7
because it may not be able to use TLR to obtain relief from unscheduled Lake Erie
8
power flows. NYISO witness Wesley Yeomans explains TLR and the NERC IDC in
9
his direct testimony in this proceeding.
10
11
New York could also be harmed if the operators of the MI/ON PARs (MISO and
12
IESO) do not accurately anticipate power flows and move the PARs in a direction
13
that exacerbates, rather than reduces, unscheduled power flows. New York may also
14
be harmed if MISO and IESO operate the MI/ON PARs in a manner that regularly
15
causes unscheduled power flows over the New York State Transmission System (if
16
the MI/ON PARs are not operated in a “neutral” manner). If New York reserves less
17
transmission system capacity to protect against the uncertainty of encountering large
18
(magnitude) or more volatile loop flows, the impacts of unexpectedly large or
19
volatile power flows on New York will be more significant when they occur.
20
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 24 of 26
1
V.
OPERATION OF THE REPLACEMENT PARS WITHOUT THE L4D
2
HYDRO ONE PAR
3
Q.
Since the Replacement PARs were placed into service, have all of the other
4
PARs at the Michigan-Ontario Interface been operable?
5
A.
No. The PAR on the L4D circuit owned by Hydro One (the “L4D PAR”) has been
6
out of service since December of 2011.
7
8
Q.
Has MISO made statements about the impacts on the MISO market of
9
operating with less than the full complement of MI/ON PARs in service?
10
A.
Yes. On March 23, 2012, the MISO announced on its OASIS: “Testing on the L4D
11
PAR will continue through mid-May, and the L4D is not expected to be available for
12
use prior to the commissioning of the [Replacement PARs]…. As a result, MISO
13
does not intend to change the methodology for pricing transactions scheduled across
14
the Michigan-Ontario interface in conjunction with the start of coordinated
15
operations (April 5th) as originally planned. The existing pricing methodology will
16
remain in place until further notice.” See Exhibit NYI-21.
17
18
Q.
How did MISO explain its announcement?
19
A.
In MISO’s response to data request NYISO/MISO 7-1 (Exhibit NYI-62), MISO
20
explained that its intent in changing the method used to price transactions scheduled
21
across the MI/ON Interface was to “align the pricing of transactions scheduled across
22
the interface with actual power flows created by those transactions, to the extent
23
practical. As of April 5th [that is, the date on which the Replacement PARs went into
24
operation, with the L4D PAR out of service], actual power flow associated with
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 25 of 26
1
transactions scheduled across the Michigan-Ontario interface was not expected to
2
flow across the interface to a sufficient degree to warrant the pricing of such
3
transactions at the interface price.”
4
5
Q.
What is the practical implication of the MISO’s announcement?
6
MISO’s announcement explicitly recognizes that MISO does not expect the MI/ON
7
PARs to be able to effectively conform actual power flows to scheduled power flows
8
at the MI/ON Interface without the L4D PAR in service. MISO has developed two
9
methods for pricing External Transactions at the MI/ON Interface. MISO intends to
10
use a newly developed “interface price” at times when the MI/ON PARs are
11
expected to be able to conform actual power flows to scheduled power flows. When
12
the “interface price” method is not in effect, MISO will revert to the pricing method
13
it has employed for the past four-to-six years, which I will refer to as MISO’s
14
“traditional method.” MISO’s traditional method of pricing transactions assumes
15
unscheduled Lake Erie power flows will not be controlled by the MI/ON PARs.
16
17
VI.
CONCLUSION
18
Q.
Does this conclude your testimony?
19
A.
Yes.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit NYI-46
Page 26 of 26
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-47
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-47
Page 1 of 1
NYTO/ITC 1-44. How long were the Original PARs in service?
Response NYTO/ITC 1-44: ITC believes the Original PAR went into service under DTE’s
ownership in January 2002. It failed in March 2003, shortly after ITC came into existence as a
stand-alone company. As an ITC asset, therefore, the Original PAR was in service for less than
one month.
Response prepared by: Mike Moltane
45
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-48
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-48
Page 1 of 15
DECO_NYISO1-2_000001
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-48
Page 2 of 15
DECO_NYISO1-2_000002
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-48
Page 3 of 15
DECO_NYISO1-2_000003
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-48
Page 4 of 15
DECO_NYISO1-2_000004
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-48
Page 5 of 15
DECO_NYISO1-2_000005
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-48
Page 6 of 15
DECO_NYISO1-2_000006
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-48
Page 7 of 15
DECO_NYISO1-2_000007
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-48
Page 8 of 15
DECO_NYISO1-2_000008
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-48
Page 9 of 15
DECO_NYISO1-2_000009
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-48
Page 10 of 15
DECO_NYISO1-2_000010
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-48
Page 11 of 15
DECO_NYISO1-2_000011
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-48
Page 12 of 15
DECO_NYISO1-2_000012
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-48
Page 13 of 15
DECO_NYISO1-2_000013
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-48
Page 14 of 15
DECO_NYISO1-2_000014
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-48
Page 15 of 15
DECO_NYISO1-2_000015
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-49
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 1 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 2 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 3 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 4 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 5 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 6 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 7 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 8 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 9 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 10 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 11 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 12 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 13 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 14 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 15 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 16 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 17 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 18 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 19 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 20 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 21 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 22 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 23 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 24 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 25 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 26 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 27 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 28 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 29 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 30 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 31 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 32 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 33 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 34 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 35 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 36 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 37 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 38 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 39 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 40 of 41
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-49
Page 41 of 41
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-50
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 1 of 19
december 2006
MTEP06
Midwest ISO
Transmission Expansion Plan
(Revised February 2007)
The Midwest Independent Transmission System Operator, Inc.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 2 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 3 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Table of Contents iii
Table of Contents
Section 1.0 Executive Summary
1
1.1 Introduction
1
1.2 Plan Highlights
2
1.3 The Midwest ISO Planning Objectives and Process
3
1.4 Planned and Proposed Expansion Through 2011
6
1.5 System Performance with Planned and Proposed Projects
9
1.6 Developing Expansion Projects
12
1.7 Implementation and Follow-Up
18
Section 2: Evolution of the Regional Planning Process
19
2.1 Evolution of the Planning Process
19
2.2 Scope of Midwest ISO System
36
Section 3.0 Trends in Resource Adequacy, New Technologies and Operational Performance
39
3.1 Load and Generation Trends
39
3.2 Midwest ISO Primary Energy Resource Opportunities
51
3.3 Retirement Possibilities of Older Generation
54
3.4 Transmission Technology
55
3.5 Historical Operating Data
65
Section 4.0 MTEP 05 Plan Status and MTEP 06 Appendices A and B
77
4.1 Status Update on Approved Plans from MTEP 05
77
4.2 MTEP 06 Appendices A and B
81
Section 5.0 MTEP 06 Study Methodology
85
5.1 Stakeholder Process
85
5.2 Baseline Reliability Analysis Methodology
87
5.3 Energy Market Planning Methodology
108
Section 6.0 Baseline Reliability Analysis
115
6.1 Central Planning Region Reliability Analysis
131
6.2 East Planning Region Reliability Analysis
153
6.3 West Planning Region Reliability Analysis
187
6.4 Small-Signal Stability Analysis
227
6.5 Optimization of Baseline Reliability Plan
243
Section 7.0 Energy Market Planning Analysis
253
7.1 Identify Opportunities for More Efficient Dispatch
254
7.2 East Planning Region Exploratory Study
261
7.3 West Planning Region Exploratory Study
267
7.4 Vision Exploratory Study
273
Section 8.0 MTEP 06 Transmission Investment Summary
305
8.1 Investment Summaries
306
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 4 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Table of Contents iv
Figures
Section
1
Figure
1.3-1 Advisory Input
5
Figure
1.5-6 Top 15 2006 Real Time Binding Constraints Expected in 2011
11
Figure
1.6-7 CapX Group 1 Facilities
13
Figure
1.6-8 Salem-Hazelton 345 kV Project
14
Figure
1.6-9 Vectren System in Southern Indiana
15
Figure
1.6-10 Cumulative Projected Spending All Projects
17
Section
2
Figure
2.1.1 Threshold Value for B/C Inclusion Criteria
23
Figure
2.1-2
26
Figure
2.1-3
28
Figure
2.1-4
31
Future
2.1-5
31
Figure
2.2-1 Midwest ISO Reliability Area
36
Section
3
Figure
3.1-1 Load and Generation Trends
40
Figure
3.1-2 Five Year Reserve Margin Forecast
40
Figure
3.1-3
2006 Capacity by Unit Type
41
Figure
3.1-4
2011 Projected Capacity by Unit Type
41
Figure
3.1-5 MRO-Canada
42
Figure
3.1-6 MRO U.S.
43
Figure
3.1-7 RFC Capacity
44
Figure
3.1-8 SERC Capacity
45
Figure
3.1-9
2006 Queue
46
Figure
3.1-10
2005 Number of Queue Entries by Fuel Type
47
Figure
3.1-11
2005 Generation Capacity in Queue by Fuel Type
47
Figure
3.1-12
2006 Generation Capacity of Queue Entries by Fuel
48
Figure
3.1-13
2006 Queue by State
49
Figure
3.2-1 Location of Coal Sources
51
Figure
3.2-2 Natural Gas Basins
52
Figure
3.2-3 U. S. Annual Average Wind Power
53
Figure
3.3-1 Capacity of U. S. Generation Units by Age
54
Figure
3.4-1 Location of Measuring Units
56
Figure
3.4-2 Event of W. H. Zimmer
56
Figure
3.4-3 PMUs offer Wide-Area Visibility
58
Figure
3.4-4 Transmission Line Capabilities - Assumed Constant Wind
60
Figure
3.4-5 Examples of Real Time Ratings
61
Figure
3.4-6 Wind and Load Normalized
62
Figure
3.4-7 Wind Output vs. MISO Market Load
63
Table 3.5-1
Transmission Service Flowgates
67
Table 3.5-2
Transmission Service Flowgates
67
Figure 3.5-3 Minimum Monthly AFC Flowgate Distribution
67
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 5 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Table of Contents v
Figures
Figure 3.5-4 Number of FG Congested in Consecutive 12 Month Periods
68
Figure 3.5-5 Cumulative Utilization of flowgates at Milestone Points
69
Figure 3.5-6 History of FG Hours by Month in Midwest ISO RA
69
Figure 3.5-7 Pre-market MISO Flowgate TLR Activityby Time of Day Relative Eastern Interconnection
71
Figure 3.5-8 Post-market MISO Flowgate TLR Activity by Time of Day Relative Eastern Interconnection
71
Figure 3.5-9 Top 56 MISO Flowgates in Congestion During First Year of MISO Market
73
Figure 3.5-10 Itemization of EAU CLAIRE-ARPIN 345 kV TLR versus Bound During First Year of MISO Market
75
Section 4
Figure 4.1-1 MTEP05 Planned Project Status
78
Figure 4.1-2 MTEP 05 Facilities In Service at Quarterly Reports
78
Figure 4.1-3 Planned Project Exception Reporting for Delayed or Withdrawn Facilities
79
Section 5
Figure 5.1-1 Midwest ISO Planning Regions
85
Chart 5.2-1 Transient VoltageSag Monitoring Criteria
94
Figure
5.2-2 Flowchart of Analysis Tools
97
Figure
5.2-3 Composite Capacity Curve
98
Figure
5.2-4 MARELI Limitation
99
Figure
5.2-5 Study Zone Configuration
101
Figure
5.2-7 Multi-Zone ConfigurationsSensitivities
105
Figure
5.3-1 Fuel Forecast for 2006
109
Figure
5.3-3 Illustration of PROMOD case topology
113
Section
6
Figure
6.1-11 Central Region Transmission
146
Figure
6.1-11 Central Region Transmission
147
Figure
6.2-15 East Region Transmission
175
Figure
6.3-12 West Region Transmission
213
Figure
6.3-14 Red River Valley Area
219
Figure
6.4-4 Participating Factors of 0.81 Hz Mode in Base Case
232
Figure
6.4-5 Mapped Mode Shapes of 0.81 Hz Mode in Base Case
233
Figure
6.4-6 Participating Factors of 0.55 Hz Mode in Base Case
234
Figure
6.4-7 Mapped Mode Shapes of 0.55 Hz Mode in Base Case
235
Figure
6.4-10 Comparison of Damping Ratio of MAPP 1⁄4 Hz mode
238
Figure
6.4-11 Low damping oscillation by AEP Rockport-Jefferson 765 kV disturbance
239
Figure
6.4-12 Participated Factors of 0.55 Hz¶Mode with AEP Rockport-Jefferson 765 kV out
240
Figure
6.4-13 Mapped 0.55 Hz Mode Shapes with AEP Rockport-Jefferson 765 kV out
241
Figure
6.5-5 Campbell 3 and Karn 4 Availability
249
Section 7
Figure
7.1-3 Top 30 Historical Bound FGs (2005/2006)
257
Figure
7.1-5 Top 10 Highest Shadow Price constraints from 2011 Simulation
Figure
7.1-5 Top 10 Highest Shadow Price constraints from 2011 Simulation
259
Figure
7.2-1 Analytical Results for the Transmission Options Evaluated to Date
262
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 6 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Table of Contents vi
Figures
Figure
7.2-2 CEP Forecast
264
Figure
7.2-3 Transmission with CEP Forecast
265
Figure
7.2-4 Heading Descriptions
266
Figure
7.3-1 Proposed Transmission Upgrades for Combined West Exploratory
268
Figure
7.4-1 Generation Weighted LMP Contour Map
275
Figure
7.4-2
2011 Unconstrained Interface Flow
276
Figure
7.4-3 MISO Congestion Corridors
277
Figure
7.4-4 MTEP 06 Vision Proposed 765 kV Overlay
278
Figure
7.4-5 Proposed Lines
279
Figure
7.4-6 Proposed Lines
279
Figure
7.4-10 Overlay % Impact-MISO RSG Interfaces
282
Figure
7.4-11 Overlay+WIND % Impact-MISO RSG Interfaces
283
Figure
7.4-16 Production Cost Savings
288
Figure
7.4-17 Generation Revenue Change
289
Figure
7.4-18 Area Generation Displaced Due to Wind
290
Figure
7.4-19 Generation Displaced Due to WIND, sorted on ST COAL
291
Figure
7.4-20
% Generation Displaced Due to WIND by Fuel Type
292
Figure
7.4-21 Load LMP Savings Due To WIND
293
Figure
7.4-22 Average Hourly LMP
294
Figure
7.4-23 LMP Spread vs. Energy (MWhs) - WAPA to XEL Interface
295
Figure
7.4-24 LMP Spread vs. Energy (MWhs) - PJMW to NYISO Interface
295
Figure
7.4-25 BASE CASE LOAD WEIGHTED LMP
296
Figure
7.4-26 WIND CASE LOAD WEIGHTED LMP
297
Figure
7.4-27
% CHANGE LMP - WIND CASE vs. Base
297
Figure
7.4-28
% CHANGE LMP - 765 kV OVERLAY CASE vs. Base
298
Figure
7.4-29 WIND Generation Revenue
299
Figure
7.4-30 WIND Revenue Duration
300
Figure
7.4-31 WIND Generation Revenue by Area
300
Figure
7.4-32 WIND Energy & Production Cost by Area
301
Figure
7.4-33 Wind Generation Production Cost
301
Figure
7.4-34 MISO-wide Reference Generation Portfolio
302
Section 8
Figure
8.0-1 MTEP West, Central and East Planning Regions
305
Figure 8.1-1 Cumulative Projected by Year through 12/31/2011
306
Figure 8.1-4 New or Upgraded Line Miles by Voltage Class
308
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 7 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Table of Contents vii
Tables
Section 1
Table 1.4-3
Baseline Reliability Projects Eligible for Cost Sharing as of 02/02/07
8
Table 1.4-4
Generator Interconnection Projects Eligible for Cost Sharing as of 02/02/07
8
Table 1.5-5
22 of Top 30 2005/06 Real-Time Binding Historical Constraints
10
Section 2
No Tables
Section 3
No Tables
Section 4
Table 4.1-4
Planned Projects Delayed which May Impact Reliability or Service
80
Section 5
Chart 5.2-6
Internal Zone Reserve Margins (1)
102
Table 5.3-2
Summary of Operating Characteristics
110
Section 6
Table 6.0-1
Generation Projects Subject To Cost Sharing
129
Table 6.1-1
Central Control Area Summary for 2011 Summer Peak BRP Models
131
Table 6.1-2
Central Planning Region Reevaluation of MTEP 05 Projects for Cost Sharing
133
Table 6.1-2
Central Planning Region Reevaluation of MTEP 05 Projects for Cost Sharing (continued)
134
Table 6.1-2
Central Planning Region Reevaluation of MTEP 05 Projects for Cost Sharing (continued)
135
Table 6.1-3
2011 BRP Phase 2 Contractual Dispatch NERC Category B Contingency Results
137
Table 6.1-4
2006 Load Deliverability Results
139
Table 6.1-5
2011 Load Deliverability Results
139
Table 6.1-6
2011 Stand-Alone Sensitivities
139
Table 6.1-7
Dynamic Stability Analysis Results for 2011 MISO-Wide Dispatch Ph2
141
Table 6.1-8
Central Region - Additional Transmission Projects in Phase 3 Model
143
Table 6.1-9
Central Region 2011 Summer Peak Contractual Dispatch Phase 3 Results
144
Table 6.1-10 New Planned Project Over 1 Million Dollars
145
Table 6.1-12 Proposed Projects as preliminary solutions to planning criteria violations
150
Table 6.1-13 Issues with No Planned or Proposed Projects
151
Table 6.2-1
East Control Area Summary for 2011 Summer Peak BRP Models
153
Table 6.2-2
Phase 1 Project Need Documentation
155
Table 6.2-3
2011 BRP Phase 2 NERC Category A Results
157
Table 6.2-4
2011 BRP Phase 2 NERC Category B Contingency Results
158
Table 6.2-5
2006 Load Deliverability Results
162
Table 6.2-6
2011 Load Deliverability Results
162
Table 6.2-7
2011 Stand Alone Sensitivities
162
Table 6.2-8
2011 BRP Ph2
164
Table 6.2-9
East Region - Additional Transmission Projects in Phase 3 Model
166
Table 6.2-10 East Region 2011 Summer Peak Contractual Dispatch Phase 3 Results
167
Table 6.2-11 Phase 3 Constraints Identified Without Proxy Generators
169
Table 6.2-12 Proxy Generator Impact on Constraints
170
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 8 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Table of Contents viii
Tables
Table
6.2-13 Proxy Generator Impact on Constraint in CD case
170
Table
6.2-14 New East Planning Region Planned Projects over $1 million
172
Table
6.2-16 Midwest ISO Proposed Projects
184
Table
6.2-17 MTEP 06 Constraints without Proposed Projects
186
Table
6.3-1
West Control Area Summary for 2011 Summer Peak BRP Models . . .
187
Table
6.3-2
West Planning Region Reevaluation of MTEP 05 Projects for Cost Sharing
188
Table
6.3-3
2011 BRP Phase 2 CD NERC Category A Results
195
Table
6.3-4
2011 BRP Phase 2 CD NERC Category B Contingency Results
197
Table
6.3-5
2006-Load Deliverability Results Table
206
Table
6.3-6
2011-Load Deliverability Results Table
206
Table
6.3-7
2011-Stand-Alone Sensitivities
206
Table
6.3-8
2011 MRO-MISO zone FCTTC after Upgrades
207
Table
6.3-9
Dynamic Stability Analysis
208
Table
6.3-10 West Region-Additional Transmission Projects in Phase 3 Model . . .
209
Table
6.3-10 West Region-Additional Transmission Projects in Phase 3 Model . . .
210
Table
6.3-11 New Planned Project Over 1 Million Dollars
211
Table
6.3-13 New Planned Project Over 1 Million Dollars
214
Table
6.3-15 Proposed Projects as Preliminary Solutions to Planning Criteria Violations
220
Table
6.3-16 Issues with No Planned or Proposed Projects
226
Table
6.4-1
Dynamic Load Convert
230
Table
6.4-2
Power Flows on MAPP Stability Flowgates
230
Table
6.4-3
Inter-area Modes Dominated by MISO Dynamic Devices
231
Table
6.4-8
Selected Prior-outage Conditions
236
Table
6.4-9
Selected Inter-area modes of MTEP 06 2011 summer on-peak case . .
236
Chart 6.5-1
Projects Tested for Redispatch
246
Chart 6.5-2
247
Chart 6.5-3
247
Chart 6.5-4
248
Chart 6.5-6
PROMOD Results
250
Section 7
Table 7.1-1
Comparison of Top 30 Historical Bound FG in 2005/2006
and Bound Constraints in 2011 PROMOD Simulations
255
Table 7.1-2
Top 30 Binding Constraints
256
Table 7.1-4
Top 50 Binding Constraints for 2011 Based on PROMOD Simulations
258
Table 7.3 -2 West Exploratory Transmission with Study Reference
270
Table 7.3-3
Queue Generators in Study
271
Table 7.4-12
765 kV Line Additions
285
Table 7.4-13
765 kV Overlay Line Flows
286
Table 7.4-14
765 kV Bus Wind Injection Points
286
Table 7.4-15 WIND Case-765 kV Overlay Line Flows % Impact on Base (Table 2)
287
Section 8
Table 8.1-2
Projected Transmission Investment by Planning Region
307
Table 8.1-3
Investment by Allocation Category by Planning Region
307
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 9 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Table of Contents ix
Appendices
Appendix A: Projects Recommended for Board Approval
309
Project Facilities Recommended for Board Approval
320
Appendix A-1: Cost Allocation by Pricing Zone
333
Appendix B: Projects Requiring Additional Planning or Review
336
Project Facilities Requiring Additional Planning or Review
344
Appendix E: Constraint History (posted on the Expansion Planning Site)
web
Critical Energy Infrastructure (CEII) Appendices
Access to the following appendices requiries executing a Non-Disclosure Agreement for System Planning Information with Midwest ISO:
Appendix C1: Contingency Analysis Results by Planning Region
Appendix C2: Dynamic stability analysis
Appendix C3: Load Deliverability Analysis
Appendix C4: Small-Signal Stability Analysis
Appendix D1: Opportunities for More Efficient Dispatch resultsables and Figures
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 10 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Section Six: Baseline Reliablity Analysis
6.2: East Planning Region Reliability Analysis
172
6.2.7 Planned Projects for the East Region
There are a total of 91 Planned Projects in the East Region in MTEP 06 in Appendix A. Of the 91 Planned Projects
listed in Appendix A for the East Region, 83 of these were identified for the first time in this MTEP 06. 30 of these
new Planned Projects have estimated costs of $1 million or more. Table 6.2-14 below lists the newly identified Planned
Projects with estimated costs of $1 million or more for the East Region, and Figure 6.2-15 below shows the location
of these new Planned Projects on the East Region system map.
Table 6.2-14 New East Planning Region Planned Projects over $1 million
Project
Expected
Estimated
TO
Project Description
Need Summary
ID
ISD
Cost
North Medina Sub: Add a new 345/138 kV transformer
Star 345 / 138 kV transformer-#3
at North Medina substation at the junction of the Star-
overloads to 112% for the loss of Star 345
Carlisle 345 kV and Star-West Akron #2 138 kV lines
/ 138 kV transformer-#2. Star 345 / 138 kV
890
FE
6/1/2008
$8,540,000
transformer overload to 118% for category
C contingency. Problem was seen in
MTEP05 but no solution was developed.
Addition of a 300 MVAr capacitor bank at the Harding
Loss of two generating units plus the
345 kV bus in 2008 and Addition of a 300 MVAr
outage of a 345 kV line result in very low
1326
FE
6/1/2009
$5,454,346
capacitor bank at the Juniper 345 kV bus in 2009
voltage in the First Energy transmission
system
Brookside caps: Add 2 - 50 MVAR Cap Bank with 1
Low voltages below 95% appear at the
- 138 kV Switcher
Brookside Substation 138 kV bus. These
1333
FE
6/1/2010
$1,000,200
caps also help mitigate voltages in
surrounding areas.
Gallion Transformers #3 and #4 345 kV Circuit
Loss of both 345/138 kV transformers
Breaker Addition: Add 345 kV breaker to complete
at Galion results in voltage of 87% at
1336
FE
345 kV ring-bus as well as extend 138 kV bus to
the Gallion and other 138 kV buses. The
12/1/2007
$1,815,566
include another breaker string to the existing breaker-
breaker prevents loss of both transformers
and-a-half scheme.
at the same time.
Stephens - Erin 120 kV line #3: Constructs new
Relieves severe overloads of circuits in the
120 kV Cable from Stephens to Erin. Erin-Stephens
Erin loop for the common tower failure of
586
ITC
is underground as ITC is utilizing existing ROW.
Erin-Stephens 1 and 2. 154% overload on
12/31/2007
$34,000,000
Obtaining a new ROW to build an overhead line
Beck to Medina 120 kV line for category C
through a heavily populated area would be infeasible.
contingency.
Install a new 345/120 kV transformer and 120 kV bus
0.8 p.u voltage at Madrid 120 kV bus for
at Majestic, and associated 120 kV breakers. Install a
the loss of Madrid 345/120 kV transformer
686
ITC
new 120 kV Majestic-Madrid circuit (by un-six-wiring
12/31/2007
$13,000,000
the existing Majestic-Madrid 345 kV circuit) and
associated terminal breakers
Creates a Bismarck-Troy 345 kV underground line & a
Relieves 111% loading on Lincoln-Lincoln
Troy 345/120 kV transformer.
NE/NW 120 kV line for loss of Lincoln to
Northeast 120 kV, and lesser overloads for
692
ITC
other category B contingencies. Relieves
12/2009
$150,000,000
104% overload on Northeast-Pluto 120 kV
line for category B contingency of Redrun
Transformer
Decommission Marysville Station, expand Bunce
Allows for the removal of Marysville Station
Creek Station creating new Bunce Creek - Cypress,
and its associated equipment from the
Bunce Creek - Menlo, Bunce Creek - Wabash 2
ITC system as the station and power plant
905
ITC
120 kV lines.
are planned to be shutdown. Also allows
12/31/2006
$3,500,000
for the interconnection of 2 distribution
transformers at Bunce Creek to replace
capacity
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 11 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Section Six: Baseline Reliablity Analysis
6.2: East Planning Region Reliability Analysis
173
Table 6.2-14 (cont.) New East Planning Region Planned Projects over $1 million
Project
Expected
Estimated
TO
Project Description
Need Summary
ID
ISD
Cost
Build Goodinson Station, with a Belle River-
The project relieves 102% and 111%
Goodinson 345 kV, Pontiac-Goodinson 345 kV, new
overload on Bloomfield - Hamlin 120 kV
345/120 kV transformer, new Pontiac-Goodinson
under Category C and C3 conditions
907
ITC
120 kV line, Goodinson-Tienken 120 kV, Sunbird-
respectively. Project also provides 120 kV
12/2009
$50,000,000
Goodinson 120 kV, and Tienken-Spokane 120 kV
source for a new distribution substation
interconnection request by DTE
Coventry Station Upgrade: Install a new 345/230 kV
ITC’s Emergency Import requirement for
transformer at Coventry, two 230 kV lines from
2011 year is 2917. This project increases
910
ITC
Coventry to Wixom and Cody, and a 230/120 kV
the import capability to above the projected
12/31/2007
$25,600,000
transformer at Cody to increase import capability
emergency assistance need of 2917 to
3221 MW
Install a second 345/120 kV transformer at the Placid
Project solves the voltage problems in the
station, and complete ring to accommodate.
Placid area for category B contingency.
911
ITC
5/30/2007
$5,550,000
Placid, Proud, Prizm 120 buses voltage
below 85%.
Durant to Genoa 120 kV: Builds a new 120 kV Durant
This line is being built to address customer
sub-station with a new circuit from Genoa to Durant,
(DTE) requests to improve reliability to the
1011
ITC
12/31/2007
$19,000,000
and also breaks up 3-ended Prizm-Proud-Placid
Prizm sub-station and provide for future
120 kV line
load growth in the area
Hines and Walton Station Equipment Replacement
Upgrades are resulted from a bus/
breaker study done which identified
station equipment that can be normally
1302
ITC
overloaded. The Hines 230 / 120 kV
5/31/2007
$1,500,000
transformer is overloaded to 106% under
normal conditions, currently limited by
substation equipment
Replaces the Gas insulated Switchgear and all
Recurring system problems has been
breakers at Caniff, and also creates a ring bus
recorded at breakers among other
1305
ITC
configuration.
equipment at Caniff. GIS was nearing end
5/31/2007
$14,400,000
of life and would require high maintenance
costs
Replaces the Gas insulated Switchgear and all
Recurring system problems has been
breakers on the 120 kV at Midtown, and also creates
recorded at breakers among other
1306
ITC
a ring bus configuration.
equipment at Midtown. GIS was nearing
12/31/2007
$6,000,000
end of life and would require high
maintenance costs
Replace the 120 kV Breaker, buses, and station
Replace the 120 kV Breaker, buses, and
1307
ITC
equipment at Catalina Sub
station equipment at Catalina Sub as part
5/1/2007
$1,000,000
of a customer interconnection request
B3N Interconnection: Returns the Bunce Creek to
The area in the eastern part of the ITC
Scott 220 kV circuit to service, and replaces the failed
system, and the Bloomfield area were
1308
ITC
12/31/2007
$25,500,000
Phase Angle Regulator with 2 new PAR’s in series
impacted most by the unavailability of the
B3N circuit.
Targets the replacement of breakers nearing their end
Various Breakers at Monroe are nearing
1309
ITC
of life where maintenance costs will be just as high as
their end of life
12/31/2007
$3,000,000
new breakers
Targets the replacement of breakers nearing their end
Various Breakers at Waterman, Warren,
1310
ITC
of life where maintenance costs will be just as high as
Trenton, St. Clair, Wabash, Polaris, Atlanta
12/31/2007
$2,000,000
new breakers
and Brock are nearing their end of life
Tallmadge 345/138 kV TB3 transformer #3 addition
Emergency overload over 106% of either
481
METC
Tallmadge transformer for the outage of the
12/1/2008
$9,913,090
other Tallmadge transformer.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 12 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Section Six: Baseline Reliablity Analysis
6.2: East Planning Region Reliability Analysis
174
Table 6.2-14 (cont.) New East Planning Region Planned Projects over $1 million
Project
Expected
Estimated
TO
Project Description
Need Summary
ID
ISD
Cost
American Bumper - David 138 ckt # 1: Rebuild line to
117% overload on American Bumper to
645
METC
6/1/2007
$2,500,000
795 ACSS
David for category C contingency.
Rebuild 23.2 miles to 795 ACSS, Keystone to
105% Overload of 266 ACSR for category
660
METC
Clearwater
B contingency. Considered load shed or
5/1/2009
$10,200,000
redispatch in MTEP 05.
Build 30 miles new 138 kV line, 795 ACSS from
138 kV Battle Creek-Verona Ckt #2 loads
Simpson to Batavia
to 104% of Emergency for outage of
988
METC
12/1/2009
$13,000,000
Project 1 gen + 138 kV Battle Creek-
Verona Ckt #1.
Rebuild Goss 345 kV bus from GIS to air insulated
Existing gas-insulated bus has recurring
1390
METC
and replace 345 kV breakers
leakage problem. Not economical to
6/1/2008
$5,800,000
continue patchwork repairs.
Ludington 345 kV Reactor: Repair or replace faulty
Ludington voltage difficult to control
(gassing) 100MVAR reactor and replace the existing
with faulty reactor. Impacts generation.
circuit switcher with a breaker
Preventive approach is justified
1407
METC
12/1/2007
$1,500,000
considering the consequences of not
replacing the existing reactor with high
probability of failing after gassing.
System Spare Transformer: Install a spare 345/
This would be METC’s only spare
138 kV transformer at Tittabawassee
transformer in their inventory ready to be
1409
METC
6/1/2007
$2,600,000
connected anywhere in the system in the
event of a failure
Install a new 14.7 mile Tittabawassee -HSC 138 kV
117 % on the Lawndale-HSC 138 kV line
line, and associated breakers at terminals
for loss of existing Tittabawassee-HSC
Swap existing line positions on structures to provide
138 kV line. Same contingency also
1416
METC
circuit diversity on structures for new and existing
overloads Lawndale to Bay Road line to
10/1/2007
$7,227,000
lines from Tittabawassee
110%. HSC substation experiences 0.82
puvoltage at peak load for Tittabawassee-
HSC 138 kV line outage.
New 140 MW wind generation (G418) interconnecting
Required for G418 Generation
1465
METC
10/1/2007
$2,090,288
at Donaldson Creek Substation
Interconnection Request
Bass Lake - Lake County Line Rebuild to 795ACSR
The Bass Lake to Lake 138 kV line is
1206
WPSC
for future 138 kV operation
overloaded at above 118% of its normal
8/1/2006
$1,800,000
rating in the base case.
Kalkaska Gen - Kalkaska JCT - Westwood Line
The project is needed to address the
Rebuild. Summer Rating 102.4 MVA
impending and potential overloads
expected in 2006 shoulder peak time
periods. Kalkaska Gen to Kalkaska Jct
1226
WPSC
2/1/2008
$2,905,000
is loaded to 115.6% and Kalkaska Jct
to Westwood is loaded to 105.4%. Out
of cycle documentation was deemed
adequate
Gaylord Gen - Bagley Junction Rebuild. Summer
The project is needed to address the
Rating 102.4 MVA
impending and potential overloads
expected in 2006 shoulder peak time
1227
WPSC
2/1/2008
$1,000,000
periods. Gaylord Gen to Bagley Jct is
loaded to 103.6% under the Atlanta 138 to
Gaylord 138 line outage contingency.
ANR Elpaso New Load: Add 14MW load off of
A natural gas compressor station is
Wolverine’s Westwood Junction
installing electric motors to replace
1228
WPSC
8/1/2008
$1,800,000
their existing gas motors to drive their
compressors.
Add 75MVA Transformer at Redwood Substation
The existing 138/69 kV transformer at
1272
WPSC
a separate line from Redwood Junction will be ran to
Redwood overloads over 161% of rating
8/1/2010
$1,900,000
energize the transformer.
for category B contingencies.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 13 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Section Six: Baseline Reliablity Analysis
6.2: East Planning Region Reliability Analysis
176
First Energy
Following Phase 2 analysis, FE had 441 outstanding
Brookside - add 2 x 50 MVAR capacitor banks
violations. Planned projects in FE address many of the
(Project ID: 1333) In Service June 2010
issues on FirstEnergy system. The following projects
This capacitor is among the reactive power projects
costs exceed $1 million:
on the 138 kV system. Low voltages below 95% appear
at the Brookside Substation 138 kV bus. These caps also
North Medina Substation
help mitigate voltages in surrounding areas.
(Project ID: 890, 6/2008, $8.54 million)
This project adds a new 345 / 138 kV transformer
Gallion Transformer breaker addition
at North Medina substation at the junction of Star to
(Project ID: 1336) In Service December 2007
Carlisle 345 kV and Star to West Akron #2 138 kV lines
This project adds
345 kV breaker to complete
with a 167 MVA 345 / 138 transformer.
345 kV ring-bus as well as extend 138 kV bus to include
This helps relieve 112% overload on Star 345 138 kV
another breaker string to the existing breaker-and-a-half
transformer #3 for the loss of Star 345 138 transformer
scheme. This prevents loss of both 345/138 kV Galion
#2 [Category B contingency]. This also helps mitigate
transformers which thereby prevents occurrence of low
overload on one Star
345 /
138 kV transformer of
voltages due to NERC category B contingencies.
118% for category C contingency involving loss of the
These system drivers were identified in MTEP06
other two Star transformers and one Star 345 / 138 kV
Phase
2. Subsequent analysis in MTEP06 Phase
3
transformer overload of 104% for category C contingency
including all planned and proposed projects demonstrated
involving loss of the other Star transformer and Star to
their effectiveness in addressing the system needs.
Carlisle 345 kV line. For the loss of either end of the Star-
All lines overloaded for category C contingencies
W Akron #2 138 kV line, voltage at that end of the line
beyond 125% of their emergency rating were tested for
drops below 90% voltage criteria. This project also helps
cascading potential. In most cases, these lines caused
improve the voltage profile. In addition, the project helps
subsequent line trips in the local region and system
relieve 105% overload on Medina to Star 69 kV for the
stabilized. Load shedding or generation redispatch
loss of Medina to West Akron 69 kV line.
schemes were effective in mitigating all category C
contingencies.
Harding and Juniper 345 kV capacitors
There are a no open reliability issues on the FE
(Project ID: 1326, 6/2009, $5.45 million)
system based on the AC contingency analysis.
The project involves addition of two 300 MVAr (6 X
50 banks) capacitors, one at Harding 345 kV and the other
at Juniper 345 kV bus.
Loss of two generating units plus the outage of a
345 kV line result in very low voltage in the First Energy
NiSource
transmission system. Loss of a generating unit plus outage
Following Phase
2 analysis, NIPSCO had
9
of two 345 kV lines result in very low voltage in the First
outstanding violations. Reconductoring projects
Energy transmission system. There are unacceptable load
addressed 2 constraints.
consequences for these conditions. Furthermore, with
Redispatch and Load Shed schemes were employed
incremental load increase of less than 1% of 2011 load
to mitigate the remaining category C violations.
forecast, very low voltages are observed over a vast area
There are no open reliability issues on the NIPSCO
for loss of 2 units (Category C). This project significantly
system.
improves the voltage profile in these areas.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 14 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Section Six: Baseline Reliablity Analysis
6.2: East Planning Region Reliability Analysis
177
Michigan Electric Transmission Company
Keystone to Clearwater 138 kV line rebuild
(Project ID: 660, 5/2009, $10.2 million)
Following Phase 2 analysis, METC had 24 outstanding
violations, 3 of which were category-A voltage violations
This project rebuilds the 23 mile line from 266 ACSR
based on METC criteria.
to 795 ACSS with a new emergency rating of 330 MVA
It helps mitigate constraints on the line due to a
number of NERC category C contingencies involving
Tallmadge 345/138 kV TB3 transformer #3
outage of Keystone to Livingston 345 kV line. It also
(Project ID: 481, 12/2008, $10 million)
helps mitigate 105% overload of 266 ACSR for Keystone
This was a proposed project in MTEP05 and was
to Livingston 345 kV line out (Category B contingency).
changed to planned status in MTEP06. The project adds
This was also analyzed with five peaking units (Gaylord
a third transformer at Tallmadge thereby mitigating the
and Livingston) turned off and re-dispatching Plymouth
overload on the existing transformers. The project also
among other units. Historically, METC has used these
involves removal of existing reactors on TB1 and TB2,
peaking plants to alleviate overload on the underlying
addition of six new 345 kV Breakers and two 138 kV
Keystone to Clearwater
138 kV line for the loss of
Breakers and all associated structures, switches, relaying at
Keystone to Livingston 345 kV line.
Tallmadge. The reactors on the two existing transformers
would no longer be required after installation of the new
Simpson to Batavia 138 kV line
transformer. Of the 6 345 kV breakers, four breakers
(Project ID: 988, 6/2011, $13 million)
installed in the breaker and a half substation prevent loss
of any two transformers at one time (Currently, the two
This project builds a new 30 mile 138 kV 795 ACSS
transformers are on adjacent bus sections)
line from Simpson to Batavia.
It helps mitigate 104% overload on Battle Creek to
Tallmadge transformer overloads over 106% of its
Verona circuit 2 138 kV line for outage of Project 1 unit
emergency rating for the outage of the other transformer
in 2011. In addition, Category C contingency involving
and Battle Creek to Verona circuit 1. In addition, 138 kV
Campbell
2 generator and Tallmadge
345/138 kV
Battle Creek-Verona Ckt 1 loads to 96% of Emergency
transformer causes a 13% overload of the other Tallmadge
for outage of Project 1 generator and loss of 138 kV
Battle Creek-Verona Ckt 2. 138 kV Battle Creek-Morrow
345/138 kV Transformer.
overloads to 96% of Emergency for outage of 345 kV
Argenta-Battle Creek and Argenta-Tompkins tower.
American Bumper - David 138 kV line ckt # 1
138 kV Verona-Barnum Creek Junction overloads to 93%
(Project ID: 645, 6/2007)
Normal for outage of Project 1 generator.
This was a proposed project in MTEP05 and was
changed to planned status in MTEP06. The project
Rebuild Goss 345 kV bus
involves rebuilding the line to 795 ACSS. American
(Project ID: 1390, 6/2008, $5.8 million)
Bumper to David overloads over 117% of its emergency
rating for loss of Goss 345 / 138 kV transformer along
The project involves rebuilding the Goss 345 kV bus
with Goss to Nelson and Goss to Thetford 345 kV lines
from GIS to air insulated and replacing circuit switcher
(Category C contingency).
with a breaker.
Bus
“R” was retired due to oil contamination
and flashovers. Bus “F” has about 14 leaks releasing
100 pounds of greenhouse (SF6) gas per month. The
flashover issue in conjunction with the retired “R” bus
causes simultaneous outages for three circuit elements:
Transformer 1 that provides
138 kV source to Goss,
Thetford to Goss 345 kV line and Nelson Road to Goss
345 kV line.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 15 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Section Six: Baseline Reliablity Analysis
6.2: East Planning Region Reliability Analysis
178
Ludington 345 kV Reactor
METC Distribution Projects
(Project ID: 1407, 12/2007)
(Project ID: 1417, 1433, 1441, 1441, 1445 and 1447)
This project is tied to Project 481 - Tallmadge 345/
These METC projects address either Consumer
138 kV transformer #3. The existing reactors on Banks
Energy’s interconnection needs or are an outcome of
#1 and #2 will be removed as a result of adding the 3rd
METC’s 5 year out study that results in these projects
bank.
being included in METC’s capital plan. A brief
description of the projects is noted below:
System Spare Transformer
•
Race Street (1417): Install a 138 kV tie-breaker to loop
the Spaulding-Four Mile 138 kV Line into Race Street
(Project ID: 1409, 6/2007)
•
Buskirk (1433): Install bulk substation served from the
This would be METC’s only spare 345 / 138 kV
Beals-Hazelwood 138 kV line
transformer in their inventory ready to be connected
anywhere in the system in the event of a failure.
•
Ellis (Hile Road - 1441): Install bulk substation served
from a new Ellis spur from Sternberg
•
Emmet (1445): Install a second distribution transformer
at Emmet
Tittabawassee-Hemlock Semiconductor line
(Project ID: 1416, 10/2007, $7.2 million)
•
Horseshoe Creek (Deja-1447): Install bulk substation
served from the Eureka-Deja-Vestaburg 138 kV Line
The project involves installing three 138 kV breakers
at Tittabawassee and constructs a second
138 kV
The rest of the violations were category C type. These
Tittabawassee-HSC line (14.7 miles) along with required
violations can be mitigated by published generation
138 kV breakers at each end (5 total breakers). The
runback schemes, generation re-dispatch or load
project also involves installing a 2 mile 138 kV double
shedding schemes. METC has indicated that they will
circuit to swap the existing Tittabawassee and Lawndale
review the sag limits on lines overloaded due to category
line connections into HSC to prevent both circuits from
C contingencies in the MTEP06 analysis. METC criteria
Tittabawassee to HSC being on the same tower (Thus
allows for load shedding for category C violations up to
preventing loss of both circuits for a single fault).
5% of peak load. Redispatch and Load Shed schemes
117 % on the Lawndale-HSC 138 kV line for loss
were employed to mitigate the remaining category C
of existing Tittabawassee-HSC
138 kV line. Same
violations.
contingency also overloads Lawndale to Bay Road line
A few contingencies may result in severe overloads
to 110%. HSC substation experiences 0.82 p.u voltage at
on two lines. The two lines are 138 kV lines from Beals
peak load for Tittabawassee-HSC 138 kV line outage.
Road to Wealthy Street and 138 kV line from Clair to
Warren. Although, load Shed has been demonstrated to
be effective to relieve constraints on the above lines, the
overloads are severe and require load shed in excess of
200 MW.
There are no other open reliability issues on the
METC system based on the AC contingency analysis.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 16 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Section Six: Baseline Reliablity Analysis
6.2: East Planning Region Reliability Analysis
179
Wolverine Power Cooperative
Wolverine Power Cooperative has recently joined the
Bismarck-Troy 345
(Project ID: 692, 12/2009, $150 million)
Midwest ISO and started participating in the MTEP06
study mid-process. Hence, several model updates were
This was a proposed project in MTEP05. The project
submitted after Phase 2 analysis. AC contingency analysis
involves building a new
13.94 mile
345 kV line (2.3
was re-done using Wolverine and METC contingencies
overhead and 11.64 underground) from Troy from to
to monitor the 69 kV and above Wolverine system. The
Bismarck connected to the Troy 120 kV by a 300/400/500
AC contingency analysis resulted in a total of 286 thermal
MVA 345 / 120 kV transformer.
and voltage violations, of which 55 were NERC category
The project relieves 111% loading on Lincoln-Lincoln
A and B violations.
NE/NW 120 kV line for loss of Lincoln to Northeast
A second 75 MVA Redwood transformer (Project ID:
120 kV, and lesser overloads for other category B
1272, 8/2010) helped mitigate majority of the violations
contingencies. It also relieves104% overload on Northeast-
including NERC category A and B constraints. The
Pluto 120 kV line for category B contingency of Redrun
existing 138/69 kV transformer at Redwood overloads
Transformer. The project also helps relieve 128% overload
over 161% of rating for the loss of the Redwood or Lake
on Lincoln -Lincoln NE/NW 120 kV line for category
County transformer (Category B contingencies).
C3 contingency of Bloomfield to Troy and Bloomfield to
Redispatch and Load Shed schemes were employed
Wheeler and 107% overload on Lincoln -Troy 120 kV line
to mitigate the remaining category C violations.
for category C3 contingency of Bloomfield to Troy 120 kV
There are no open reliability issues on the Wolverine
and Bloomfield to Wheeler 120 kV. Project verification
system.
was conducted using the revised reduced Michigan load
forecast. Other violations are also projected, including
ITC Transmission
loading above emergency ratings during planned outages
Stephens - Erin 120 kV line #3
at load levels below 85% of peak.
(Project ID: 586, 12/2007, $34 million)
Detroit metro area is ringed by 345 kV and is supplied
This was a proposed project in MTEP05. The project
by several 345 kV substations surrounding the area. Supply
constructs a new 120 kV underground cable from Stephens
points are at Brownstown, Wayne, Wixom/Quaker, Pontiac,
to Erin (circuit 3).
Jewell, Bismarck, and Stephens/Caniff substations. This
It relieves severe overloads of circuits in the Erin loop
project provides an additional
345 kV source into the
for the common tower failure of Erin-Stephens 1 and 2. It
Northern Detroit Metro area by extending a 345 kV circuit
thereby reduces the risk of dumping 300+ MW of load for
from Bismarck to Troy 120 kV substation to off-load
a single outage. It helps relieve154% overload on Beck to
existing supplies and 120 kV circuits in the Troy area. The
Medina and 148% overload on Beck to Stephens 120 kV
project Supports 335 MW of load at Troy substation and
lines for category C contingencies.
relieves supplies to adjacent areas. At 335 MW, Troy is the
Majestic 345/120 kV switching station (Project ID: 686,
most heavily loaded substation on the ITC system. The new
12/2007, $13 million)
line will carry approximately 360 MW of new capacity into
This was a proposed project in MTEP05. The project
Troy area initially, unloading multiple existing supply lines
involves installing a new
345/120 kV transformer and
to Troy. It also substantially unloads several 50 year old
120 kV bus at Majestic, and associated 120 kV breakers. It
vintage 120 kV circuit that include cable sections 40-55 yrs
also installs a new 120 kV Majestic-Madrid circuit (by un-
old. It also relieves first contingency overloads of OH and
six-wiring the existing Majestic-Madrid 345 kV circuit) and
UG circuits at off-peak periods permitting maintenance
associated terminal breakers
of existing
(UG) circuits, in accordance with NERC
Low voltage of 0.8 p.u voltage is observed at Madrid
Standards.
120 kV bus for the loss of Madrid 345/120 kV transformer
Overhead routes for new 345 kV supply are not feasible
(Category B).Madrid 345-120 #1 transformer overloads
in large, congested urban environments. Alternatives of
to 98% of its emergency rating for loss of Cody to Nolan
upgrading 230 kV and 120 kV circuits in the area have been
120 kV line (Category B contingency). The project also
reviewed and are not feasible due to inability to upgrade
helps relieve 13% overload on existing 34/120 Madrid
facilities without lengthy outages disrupting critical
Transformer for the loss of Cody to Nolan 120 kV and Placid
industrial loads, and permitting restrictions and space
to Durant 120 kV lines (Category C contingency).
restrictions at some sites that would house 230 kV.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 17 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Section Six: Baseline Reliablity Analysis
6.2: East Planning Region Reliability Analysis
180
Marysville Decommissioning
Goodison Station
(Project ID: 905, 12/2006)
(Project ID: 907, 12/2009, $50 million)
The project decommissions Marysville Station,
This was a proposed project in MTEP05. The
expands Bunce Creek Station creating new Bunce Creek
project involves building Goodison 345 kV Station by
- Cypress, Bunce Creek - Menlo, Bunce Creek - Wabash
splitting the existing 345 kV line from Belle River to
2 120 kV lines. It allows for the removal of Marysville
Goodison to create Belle River-Goodison 345 kV and
Station and its associated equipment from the ITC system
Pontiac-Goodison 345 kV, a new 345/120 kV Goodison
as the station and power plant are planned to be shutdown.
transformer and a new Pontiac-Goodison 120 kV line.
It also allows for the interconnection of 2 distribution
The project also creates new Goodison-Tienken-Spokane
transformers at Bunce Creek to replace capacity
and Goodison-Sunbird lines using existing circuit taps
to shift support to these areas from Pontiac to New
Coventry Station Upgrade
Goodison Substation. It installs a new sectionalizing
(Project ID: 910, 12/2007)
breaker at Tienken to provide through circuit to Spokane,
new 120 kV line position at Spokane to remove adjacent
The project involves building two new 230 kV lines
Tienken tap providing dedicated Tienken-Spokane circuit
from Coventry to Cody and Wixom, new 345/230 kV
and 5% reactor at Spokane to control flow into Spokane
transformer at Coventry along with a
230/120 kV
from new Goodison source through Tienken.
transformer at Cody and expansion of the Coventry
The project relives the following overloads:
345 kV station. ITC’s Emergency Import capability
102% loading on Bloomfield-Hamlin 120 kV for Cat
requirement for 2011 year to meet LOLE of 0.1 is 2917
C3 (Line + Gen) outage of Jewel-Spokane 230 kV and St.
MW. ITC’s import capability without this project is 2381,
Clair Unit 4, 135% loading on Bloomfield-Hamlin and
deficient in 2011 by 536 MW. With the addition of the
119% loading on Auburn Heights-Hamlin for loss of Jewell-
Coventry project, ITC’s import capability goes up to
Spokane 230 kV and Apache-Troy120 kV (Category C),
3221 MW, meeting its emergency import requirement for
119% loading on Apache-Troy for loss of Jewell-Spokane
2011. Project verification was conducted using the revised
230 kV and Bloomfield-Hamlin120 kV(Category C), 111%
reduced Michigan load forecast.
loading on Bloomfield-Hamlin 120 kV for DCT outage
of Jewel-Spokane 230 kV and Jewel-St. Clair -Spokane
120 kV (Category C) and Unloads Pontiac 345/120 kV
transformers that are at 94% of emergency rating for loss
of the other to 79% post project.
In absence of Goodison
120 kV station, DTE’s
needs in the area could be met only by building 120 kV
lines from long distances as ITC has only 345 kV in the
area that DTE needs an interconnection point). Project
verification was conducted using the revised reduced
Michigan load forecast.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 18 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Section Six: Baseline Reliablity Analysis
6.2: East Planning Region Reliability Analysis
181
Placid 345 /120 kV transformer
Caniff Station Upgrade
(Project ID: 911, 5/2007, $5.55 million)
(Project ID: 1305, 5/2007, $14.4 million)
Install a second 345/120 kV transformer at the Placid
The project involves replacing gas insulated
station, and complete ring to accommodate.
switchgear and all breakers at Caniff and also creates a
Project eliminates voltage criteria violations where
ring bus configuration.
Placid, Proud, and Prizm 120 buses voltage fall below 85%
The current gas insulated switchgear installed at
for the following category B contingencies: Loss of Placid
Caniff was nearing end of life and is leaking causing
345/120 transformer 1 and Loss of Placid-Pontiac 345.
recurring alarms/failures (34 alarms since 1/2004). The
leaking gas is an environmental issue as well. GIS is 35
years old and is nearing end of life. Going forward with
Durant to Genoa 120 kV
(Project ID: 1011, 12/2007, $19 million)
the existing equipment would require high maintenance
costs. Caniff feeds downtown Detroit, and under current
The project involves construction of a new 120 kV
configuration, 1 section breaker failure can result in the
Durant sub-station with a new circuit from Genoa to
loss of the entire station. This would cause the cables
Durant, and also breaks up 3-ended Prizm-Proud-Placid
feeding the city from the south to overload at peak.
120 kV line.
Therefore a ring bus configuration is optimal.
This project is driven by DTE’s Interconnection
request with ITC for GM Milford Darlington Hills
Midtown Station Upgrade
facility and Hurst Substation. The existing 40 kV serves
(Project ID: 1306, 12/2007, $6 million)
as a hot standby to the 120 kV Placid to Proud line outage.
Existing capacity on the 40 kV is 43 MVA and increased
The project involves replacing gas insulated
loading in the area is creating N-1 overloads on the 40 kV
switchgear and all breakers at Midtown and also creates
system. Low voltages at site are also observed under these
a ring bus configuration.
conditions and problems would be worse with anticipated
The current gas insulated switchgear installed at
load growth at Milford site. Continuing load growth in
Midtown was nearing end of life and is leaking causing
area requires another transmission to sub transmission
recurring alarms/failures (13 alarms since 1/2004). The
interconnection at Hurst to resolve. Breaking the three
leaking gas is an environmental issue as well. GIS is 35
ended Prizm-Proud-Placid 120 kV line to two lines:
years old and is nearing end of life. Going forward with
Placid to Durant and Placid to Proud also helps create
the existing equipment would require high maintenance
two independent feeds into Durant substation thereby
costs. With the current configuration at Midtown, one
increasing reliability
section breaker failure can result in the loss of the entire
station, as well as bus 103 at Frisbee station. Therefore a
ring bus configuration is optimal at Midtown, and does
not add any additional cost to the project.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-50
Page 19 of 19
MISO MTEP 06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan 2006
Section Six: Baseline Reliablity Analysis
6.2: East Planning Region Reliability Analysis
182
B3N Interconnection
(Project ID: 1308, 12/2007, $25.5 million)
The project returns the Bunce Creek to Scott 220 kV
circuit to service, and replaces the failed Phase Angle
Regulator with
2 new PAR’s in series. This failed
transformer is part of the northern most interconnection
with Canada.
The new phase shifting transformers will increase
both MVA capability and phase angle control. Midwest
ISO reviewed the impact on system performance of
system operation with and without the B3N tie between
ITC and IMO in service. The review was based both
on review of the recent 2010 study reported to ECAR by
ITC, and on independent review of contingent conditions.
There a substantial number of contingencies involving
multiple elements that can result in significant system
overloads without the B3N circuit, which would not occur
with the B3N circuit available. Contingencies that have
the most significant impact are shown in the table below:
•
116% for St Clair - Cypress 120 kV & St Clair - Bunce
Creek 120 kV DCT
•
112% for Jewell-Spokane 345-230-120 kV & Apache-
Troy 120 kV
•
102% for Jewell-Spokane 345-230-120 kV & Dean (all)
•
101% for Caniff-Northeast 120 kV & Conners Creek (all)
•
130% for Greenwood 120-345 kV & Atlanta-Tuscola
120 kV
•
104% for Pontiac 345-120 kV #303 & Pontiac-Sunbird
120 kV
•
115% for Both St.Clair-Lambton lines
Following Phase
2 analysis, there were
129
outstanding violations,
7 of which were category B
violations. Proposed projects were modeled to relieve the
thermal overloads on ITC system. Subsequent analysis
in MTEP06 demonstrated the project’s effectiveness in
addressing the system needs. Midwest ISO recommends
the proposed projects become planned projects. Details
on the proposed projects are discussed in the following
section.
ITC will coordinate with DTE on category B voltage
violations. Remaining category C violations were
mitigated by means of load shedding. The exact amount
and load locations may differ.
There are no open reliability issues on the ITC
system.
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-51
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 1 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Projects Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
Allocation Category
Project Information from Facility table
App
Reporting
Allocation
Exclude
Estimated Project
Expected
Max
Min
Facility
AB
PrjID
Region
Source
Project Name
Project Description
State
FF
Share Status
FF1
Cost
ISD
kV
kV
Count
A
90
West
ALTW
Emery-Lime Crk 161kV, Ckt 2
Emery - Lime Creek 161 ckt 2, Sum rate 326
IA
Other
Excluded
Y
$8,000,000.00
6/1/2007
161
1
A
1204
West
ALTW
Adams-Rochester 161 kV line termination
Replace disconnect jumpers at Adams on Adams-Rochester 161 kV line
MN
Other
Not Shared
$5,000.00
10/1/2006
161
1
upgrade
A
1287
West
ALTW
Replace Salem 345/161 kV transformer with
Replace Salem 345/161 kV transformer with 448 MVA unit
IA
BaseRel
Shared
$5,000,000.00
6/1/2008
345
161
1
448 MVA unit
A
1288
West
ALTW
Replace Hazleton 345/161 kV transformer
Replace Hazleton 345/161 kV transformer #1 with 335 MVA unit
IA
BaseRel
Shared
$5,000,000.00
6/1/2009
345
161
1
#1 with 335 MVA unit
A
1289
West
ALTW
Marshalltown - Toledo - Belle Plaine -
Marshalltown - Toledo - Belle Plaine - Stoney Point 115 kV line will be
IA
Other
Not Shared
$19,000,000.00
6/1/2010
115
3
Stoney Point 115 kV line rebuild
rebuilt/upgraded between 2008 and 2011
A
1342
West
ALTW
Lewis Fields 161 kV substation which taps
Build a new 161 kV substation Lewis Fields to be tapped to the 115 kV line
IA
Other
Not Shared
$4,550,000.00
6/1/2009
161
115
2
the SwampFX - Coggon 115 kV line
Swamp Fox - Coggon at 5% distance via a new 161/115 kV transformer.
Also build a new 161 kV line from Hiawatha to Lewis Fields
A
1344
West
ALTW
Build a new 345 kV Beverly substation
Build a new 345 kV Beverly Tap substation and tapped to 345 kV line
IA
Other
Not Shared
$4,300,000.00
6/1/2008
345
161
2
which taps the Arnold -Tiffin 345 kV line
Arnold -Tiffin at 40% distance away from Arnold. Add a new 335 MVA
345/161 kV transformer and build a new 161 kV line connecting the new
substation to Beverly 161 kV bus
A
1471
West
ALTW
G518
G518
MN
GIP
Shared
$125,000.00
5/1/2007
69
1
A
1472
West
ALTW
G536
G536
MN
GIP
Shared
$125,000.00
5/1/2007
69
1
A
1473
West
ALTW
Mason City Armor - Emery North 69 kV line
Mason City Armor - Emery North 69 kV line
IA
TDSP
Direct Assigned
69
1
A
1348
West
ALTW/CIPCO Upgrade terminal equipment for Prairie
Upgrade terminal equipment for 115 kV line Prairie Creek - Marion so that
IA
Other
Not Shared
$200,000.00
6/1/2011
115
3
Creek - Marion 115 kV line. Rebuild 115 kV
new ratings become 198/198 MVA limited by conductor rating. Rebuild 115
line Marion - Swampfx - Coggon
kV line Marion - Swampfx7 - Coggon to the new rating as 198/198 MVA
A
1349
West
ALTW/CIPCO Replace Dundee 161/115 kV transformer
Replace Dundee 161/115 kV transformer with new ratings as 112/112 MVA
IA
Other
Not Shared
$100,000.00
6/1/2011
161
115
1
with new ratings as 112/112 MVA
A
144
Central
Ameren
Crab Orchard - Marion South 138 kV
Crab Orchard - Marion South 138 kV - Reconductor line
IL
Other
Excluded
Y
$2,712,300.00
6/1/2008
138
1
A
149
Central
Ameren
Mason-Sioux-7 345 kV
Mason-Sioux-7 345 kV - Breaker addition at Mason
MO
Other
Excluded
Y
$605,900.00
6/1/2007
345
1
A
153
Central
Ameren
Central-Watson-1 138 kV
CEE Tap - Watson section of Central-Watson-1 138 kV - Reconductor line
MO
Other
Not Shared
$311,400.00
6/1/2008
138
1
A
155
Central
Ameren
Joachim 345/138 kV
Joachim 345/138 kV - New Substation
MO
Other
Excluded
Y
$12,963,300.00
6/1/2008
345
138
1
A
708
Central
Ameren
Casey-Breed 345 kV
Casey-Breed 345 kV Line - Reconductor river crossing
IL
Other
Excluded
Y
$303,900.00
6/1/2007
345
1
A
711
Central
Ameren
Wood River-Gillespie 138 kV
Wood River-Gillespie 138 kV - Reconductor
IL
Other
Excluded
Y
$939,500.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
712
Central
Ameren
Mason 345/138 kV Substation
Labadie-Mason-3 345 kV Terminal equipment replacement
MO
Other
Excluded
Y
$184,100.00
12/1/2007
345
1
A
719
Central
Ameren
Labadie Plant
Labadie Plant - Replace 2-345 kV Breakers
MO
Other
Not Shared
$1,897,100.00
6/1/2009
345
1
A
856
Central
Ameren
Osage 138 kV Substation
Osage 138 kV Substation - Replace bus conductor in bus #1 and line to
MO
Other
Not Shared
$65,000.00
12/1/2006
138
1
Eldon
A
857
Central
Ameren
Rush Island-Joachim 345 kV Line
Rush Island-Joachim 345 kV - Replace terminal equipment at Rush Island
MO
Other
Not Shared
$283,200.00
6/1/2007
345
1
A
858
Central
Ameren
Sioux-Huster-1 138 kV
Sioux-Huster-1 138 kV - Increase ground clearance on 6 miles of 795 kcmil
MO
Other
Not Shared
$1,024,500.00
6/1/2007
138
1
ACSR
A
859
Central
Ameren
Central-Watson-1 138 kV
Central-Watson-1 138 kV - Reconductor 5.1 miles 954 kcmil ACSR
MO
Other
Not Shared
$1,500,300.00
6/1/2008
138
1
between Central and Twr. 55
A
1241
Central
Ameren
Mattoon, West Wind Farm Connection
Install 138 kV Breaker at Mattoon, West Substation to connect Wind Farm
IL
Other
Not Shared
$555,400.00
3/1/2007
138
1
A
875
Central
AmerenCILCOKickapoo 138/69 kV Substation
Kickapoo 138/69 kV Substation - Replace terminal equipment
IL
Other
Not Shared
$156,700.00
11/15/2006
138
1
A
876
Central
AmerenCILCOTazewell 345/138 kV Substation
Tazewell 345/138 kV Substation - Replace 2000 A terminal equipment with
IL
Other
Not Shared
$1,042,900.00
6/1/2007
345
1
3000 A on line to Powerton
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Projects
1 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 2 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Projects Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
Allocation Category
Project Information from Facility table
App
Reporting
Allocation
Exclude
Estimated Project
Expected
Max
Min
Facility
AB
PrjID
Region
Source
Project Name
Project Description
State
FF
Share Status
FF1
Cost
ISD
kV
kV
Count
A
150
Central
AmerenIP
Prairie State Power Plant transmission
Establish a new Prairie State 345 kV switchyard including a 6-position
IL
Other
Not Shared
$63,039,600.00
6/1/2008
345
5
outlet
breaker and ½ bus arrangement to accommodate 2 generating units and 4-
(Pre-RECB 1)
345 kV outlet lines with 9-345 kV circuit breakers. Tap the existing Baldwin-
Stallings 345 kV line 4531 "in and out" and build 7.5 miles of double-circuit
3000 A summer emergency capability line to the switchyard. Tap the
existing Baldwin-Mt. Vernon 345 kV line 4541 "in and out" and build 1.5
miles of double-circuit 3000 A summer emergency capability line to the
switchyard.
At the Baldwin 345 kV switchyard, replace 9-345 kV circuit breakers that
would be overstressed as a result of the Prairie State development. Also
install 3-345 kV circuit breakers for a new Baldwin-Rush Island 345 kV line
and a new connection for the Baldwin 345/138 kV transformer. Build a new
26 mile 345 kV 3000 A summer emergency capability line from Baldwin to
Rush Island.
A
725
Central
AmerenIP
LaSalle Area Development
N. LaSalle-Wedron Fox River 138 kV - 20 miles new line, 2-138 kV
IL
Other
Excluded
Y
$20,489,370.00
12/1/2008
138
1
breakers at N. LaSalle, 1 138 kV Breaker at Wedron Fox River
A
726
Central
AmerenIP
LaSalle Area Development
Ottawa-Wedron Fox River 138 kV - Construct 14 miles new 138 kV line, 1
IL
Other
Excluded
Y
$8,045,400.00
12/1/2008
138
1
new 138 kV breaker at Ottawa
A
728
Central
AmerenIP
Wood River-Roxford 1502 138 kV line
Wood River-Roxford 1502 138 kV line - Reconductor
IL
BaseRel
Shared
$5,264,900.00
6/1/2008
138
1
A
732
Central
AmerenIP
S. Bloomington-State Farm 138 kV
S. Bloomington-State Farm 138 kV - Reconductor
IL
Other
Not Shared
$1,172,900.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
736
Central
AmerenIP
W. Tilton 138 kV Substation
W. Tilton 138 kV Substation - Install 138 kV breaker
IL
Other
Not Shared
$1,709,400.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
738
Central
AmerenIP
Latham-Lanesville 138 kV Line
138 kV Line 1342C tap - Line 1342A - Reconductor structure 423 to 467A
IL
Other
Excluded
Y
$1,994,400.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
739
Central
AmerenIP
Franklin County Power Plant Connection
Franklin County Power Plant Connection - Tap 345 kV Line 4561 Tap, and
IL
Other
Not Shared
$7,108,700.00
1/1/2009
345
1
Install new 345 kV ring bus
(Pre-RECB 1)
A
865
Central
AmerenIP
Havana-Monmouth 138 kV River Crossing
Havana-Monmouth 138 kV Line 1362 - Rebuild river crossing
IL
Other
Not Shared
$223,700.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
869
Central
AmerenIP
Sidney-Mira Tap 138 kV
Sidney-Mira Tap 138 kV - Reconductor 2 miles 795 kcmil ACSR
IL
Other
Not Shared
$693,800.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
873
Central
AmerenIP
Baldwin Plant 345 kV Switchyard
Replace 6-345 kV breakers with breakers having 3000 A continuous
IL
Other
Not Shared
$12,726,300.00
1/31/2009
345
3
capability
(Pre-RECB 1)
A
1470
West
ATC
G483
50 MW wind farm
WI
GIP
Shared
$7,538,732.00
11/5/2006
69
5
A
1
West
ATC LLC
Arrowhead-Gardner Park 345 kV
Arrowhead - Gardner Park 345 kV line
WI
Other
Excluded
Y
$391,667,218.88
6/30/2008
345
230
7
A
2
West
ATC LLC
Weston - Northpoint 115 kV reconductor
Reconductor Weston-Dewey Tap-Northpoint 115 kV line with 795 ACSR
WI
Other
Excluded
Y
$11,071,370.00
4/1/2007
115
2
conductor.
A
21
West
ATC LLC
Metonga T-D interconnection
Venus-Metonga (was Crandon) 138 kV line
WI
Other
Not Shared
$8,745,840.00
6/1/2007
115
1
A
62
West
ATC LLC
Wien-McMillan 115 kV
Wien - Stratford - McMillan 115 ckt , Sum rate 202
WI
Other
Excluded
Y
$1,750,000.00
3/1/2007
115
1
A
64
West
ATC LLC
Kegonsa-McFarland-Femrite conversion to
Kegonsa - McFarland -Femrite conversion to 138 kV
WI
Other
Excluded
Y
$3,410,000.00
6/1/2007
138
2
138 kV
A
101
West
ATC LLC
Kelly-Whitcomb 115 kV uprate
Kelly - Whitcomb 115 ckt , Sum rate 241
WI
Other
Excluded
Y
$1,900,000.00
6/1/2008
115
1
A
177
West
ATC LLC
Gardner Park-Central Wisconsin 345 kV
Construct Gardner Park-Central Wisconsin 345 kV line and Construct new
WI
Other
Not Shared (pre
$128,900,000.00
12/1/2009
345
6
line projects
Central Wisconsin 345 kV substation
RECB 1)
A
339
West
ATC LLC
Lake Mills Transmission-Distribution
Construct a Jefferson-Lake Mills-Stony Brook 138 kV line
WI
Other
Excluded
Y
$20,450,000.00
6/1/2008
138
6
interconnection
Uprate Rockdale to Jefferson 138 kV line
Uprate Rockdale to Boxelder 138 kV line
Uprate Boxelder to Stonybrook 138 kV line
A
345
West
ATC LLC
Morgan - Werner West 345 kV line
Morgan - Werner West 345 kV line, Clintonville - Werner West 138 kV line
WI
BaseRel
Shared
$141,290,700.00
12/1/2009
345
4
(includes Clintonville-Werner West 138)
primarily on 345 kV line structures, and terminate the existing Werner -
White Lake 138 kV line at the Werner West switching station
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Projects
2 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 3 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Projects Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
Allocation Category
Project Information from Facility table
App
Reporting
Allocation
Exclude
Estimated Project
Expected
Max
Min
Facility
AB
PrjID
Region
Source
Project Name
Project Description
State
FF
Share Status
FF1
Cost
ISD
kV
kV
Count
A
350
West
ATC LLC
Weston-Sherman-Hilltop 115 kV
Weston - Sherman Street - Hilltop 115 kV line rebuild as double circuit
WI
Other
Excluded
Y
$7,750,000.00
6/1/2007
115
3
A
352
West
ATC LLC
Cranberry-Conover 115 kV and Conover-
Construct Cranberry-Conover 115 kV line, R ebuild/convert Conover-
WI
BaseRel
Shared
$117,085,000.00
12/31/2009
138
115
7
Plains conversion to 138 kV
Plains 69 kV line to 138 kV, C onstruct 138 kV bus and install 138/115 kV
150 MVA and 138/69 kV 60 MVA transformers at Conover, C onstruct 138
kV bus and install 60 MVA transformer at Bobcta, R elocate Iron River
substation (Iron Grove), C onstruct 138 kV bus and install a 138/69 kV, 60
MVA transformer at Iron Grove
A
433
West
ATC LLC
Wautoma 32.6 MVAR capacitor bank
Install 2-24.5 MVAR capacitor banks at Wautoma 138 kV and one-16.33
WI
Other
Excluded
Y
$1,200,000.00
6/1/2007
138
1
MVAR capacitor bank at 69 Kv
A
446
West
ATC LLC
Hartford 36 MVAR capacitor bank
Hartford 138 kV, 36 MVAR Capacitor bank
WI
Other
Excluded
Y
$750,000.00
4/30/2007
138
1
A
566
West
ATC LLC
Plymouth T-D interconnection
Forest Junction / Charter Steel to Plymouth 138 kV line and T-D substation.
WI
Other
Excluded
Y
$2,500,000.00
5/1/2007
138
1
Construct 1.3 mile double circuit from Plymouth municipal utility to existing
line.
A
570
West
ATC LLC
Rock River-Bristol-Elkhorn conversion to
Rock River - Bristol - Elkhorn conversion to 138 kV
WI
Other
Excluded
Y
$15,063,960.00
6/1/2009
138
6
138 kV
A
571
West
ATC LLC
North Madison-Waunakee 138 kV line
New North Madison - Huiskamp 138 kV line and a new 138/69 kV
WI
Other
Excluded
Y
$8,700,000.00
6/1/2008
138
1
substation near Huiskamp including a 100 MVA 138/69-kV transformer
A
572
West
ATC LLC
Menominee 138/69 kV transformer
Loop West Marinette - Bay de Noc 138 kV line into Menominee. Total
WI
Other
Excluded
Y
$2,000,000.00
6/1/2008
138
2
project cost $2,000,000.
A
877
West
ATC LLC
Elm Road (Oak Creek) Generation Related
Reconductor Oak Creek-Ramsey 138 kV line (2009), Reconductor Oak
WI
Other
Not Shared
$44,706,194.00
6/1/2010
345
138
12
Additions
Creek-Allerton 138 kV line (2009), Replace relaying on 230 kV circuits at
(Pre-RECB 1)
Oak Creek (2009), Replace two 345 kV circuit breakers at Pleasant Prairie
on the Racine and Zion lines with IPO breakers and upgrade relaying
(2009), Expand Oak Creek 345 kV switchyard to interconnect one new
generator (2009), Loop Ramsey5-Harbor 138 kV line into Norwich and
Kansas to form a new line from Ramsey-Norwich and Harbor-Kansas 138
kV lines (2009), Uprate Kansas-Ramsey6 138 kV line (2009), Install
second 500 MVA 345/138 kV transformer at Oak Creek (2010), Expand
345 kV switchyard at Oak Creek to interconnect one new generator (2010),
Uprate Oak Creek-Root River 138 kV line (2010), Uprate Oak Creek-
Nicholson 138 kV line (2010).
A
1451
West
ATC LLC
Femrite-Sprecher new 138 kV; Sprecher-
Femrite - Sprecher 138 (new), Sprecher - Reiner 138 (conversion), Reiner -
WI
Other
Excluded
Y
$10,600,000.00
6/1/2007
138
3
Reiner-Sycamore conversion to 138 kV
Sycamore 138 (conversion),
A
1453
West
ATC LLC
St Lawrence - Pleasant Valley - Saukville
St Lawrence - Pleasant Valley - Saukville 138 kV line reconductor
WI
BaseRel
Shared
$9,600,000.00
6/1/2008
138
2
138 kV line reconductor
A
1461
West
ATC LLC
G376, 37395-03, Green Lake Energy
Net: loop into existing substation, install 138 kV equipment at Green Lake
WI
TAP
Not Shared
$2,314,698.00
10/20/2006
138
34.5
3
Sub, replace 69 kV circuit breaker at Wautoma sub.
(Pre-RECB 1)
A
1463
West
ATC LLC
G384
Net: new two breaker 138 kV substation, loop line Y-51 into the substation,
WI
Other
Not Shared
$3,268,000.00
10/20/2006
138
5
perform a relay replacement for Kewaunee sub 138 kV line Y-51 to Shoto
(Pre-RECB 1)
sub.
A
1475
West
ATC LLC
Atlantic 138-69 kV Transformer 60 MVA
Atlantic 138-69 kV Transformer 60 MVA
WI
TDSP
Direct Assigned
138
69
1
A
1476
West
ATC LLC
Mullet River 138-69 kV - Transformer
Mullet River 138-69 kV - Transformer
WI
TDSP
Direct Assigned
138
69
1
A
1477
West
ATC LLC
N. Madison - ABS -Yahara 138 kV line
N. Madison - ABS -Yahara 138 kV line
WI
TDSP
Direct Assigned
6/1/2008
138
1
A
1478
West
ATC LLC
Waunakee - Westport - Pheasant Branch
Waunakee - Westport - Pheasant Branch 69 kV line 95 MVA
WI
TDSP
Direct Assigned
1/1/2008
69
1
69 kV line 95 MVA
A
42
Central
DEM
Bedford to Seymour 13829 Reconductor
Reconductor 13829 line from Bedford - Shawswick - Pleasant Grove -
IN
Other
Excluded
Y
$10,970,605.00
6/1/2009
138
4
Airport Road Jct - Seymour.
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Projects
3 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 4 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Projects Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
Allocation Category
Project Information from Facility table
App
Reporting
Allocation
Exclude
Estimated Project
Expected
Max
Min
Facility
AB
PrjID
Region
Source
Project Name
Project Description
State
FF
Share Status
FF1
Cost
ISD
kV
kV
Count
A
91
Central
DEM
Hillcrest 345/138 substation
Construct new 345/138 kV Hillcrest substation. Tap Suart to Foster 345kV
OH
BaseRel
Shared
$17,687,496.00
6/1/2008
345
138
8
line. Construct new 138kV line from Eastwood to Hillcrest. Replace 345kV
relays at Stuart and Foster. Replace 138kV relays at Brown and Ford
Batavia.
A
115
Central
DEM
New London to Webster 230 Reconductor
Reconductor New London to Webster St 230
IN
Other
Excluded
Y
$9,455,194.00
6/1/2007
230
1
A
116
Central
DEM
Westwood Bk2 345/138
Add 2nd 345kV line from AEP Dequine to Westwood and 2nd Westwood
IN
Other
Excluded
Y
$6,836,707.00
6/1/2007
345
138
3
345/138 kV transformer.
A
199
Central
DEM
Kokomo HP 230/138
Add 4th 230/138 kV transformer at Kokomo Highland Park.
IN
Other
Excluded
Y
$3,278,756.00
6/1/2007
230
138
1
A
200
Central
DEM
W Laf Purdue 138 Switches
Upgrade 138kV switches at West Lafayette Purdue.
IN
Other
Excluded
Y
$9,877.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
201
Central
DEM
W Laf 138 Switches
Changing out switches to achieve conductor rating. NW Tap - West
IN
Other
Excluded
Y
$100,000.00
6/1/2008
138
1
Lafayette 138
A
619
Central
DEM
IPL Petersburg 345 Breaker
Complete breaker and half scheme at Petersburg Plant. IPL total estimate
IN
Other
Excluded
Y
$200,000.00
6/1/2008
345
1
1,100,000. 200,000 is Cinergy share of project.
A
624
Central
DEM
Cloverdale to Plainfield 138 Lightning
Upgrade static and grounding on the Cloverdale to Plainfield South 138kV
IN
Other
Excluded
Y
$2,387,209.00
12/31/2007
138
1
Protection
circuit.
A
627
Central
DEM
Kenton to West End New 138 Circuit
Construct new 138kV line from Kenton to West End.
KY
Other
Excluded
Y
$1,980,041.00
6/1/2009
138
3
A
628
Central
DEM
Kok HP to Kok Delco 138 100C Uprate
Uprate 138kV line from Kokomo Highland Park to Kokomo Delco to 100C
IN
Other
Excluded
Y
$100,000.00
6/1/2007
138
1
operating temperature.
A
629
Central
DEM
Kok HP to Kok Chrysler 138 100C Uprate
Uprate 138kV line from Kokomo Highland Park to Kokomo Chrysler to
IN
Other
Not Shared
$100,000.00
6/1/2007
138
1
100C operating temperature.
A
632
Central
DEM
Gallagher to HE Georgetown 138kV
Reconductor section of the 13885 circuit from Gallagher to HE
IN
Other
Excluded
Y
$1,065,110.00
6/1/2009
138
1
Reconductor
Georgetown.
A
766
Central
DEM
Clarksville 138kV Cap
Add 57.6 MVAR 138kV capacitor at Clarksville.
IN
Other
Excluded
Y
$738,662.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
767
Central
DEM
Hastings Park 138kV Cap
Add 57.6 MVAR 138kV capacitor at Greenfield Hastings Park.
IN
Other
Excluded
Y
$598,722.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
807
Central
DEM
Dresser Bk 1&2 Limiting Equipment
Replace 138kV breakers and switches to achieve full transformer rating.
IN
Other
Not Shared
$858,000.00
6/1/2009
345
138
2
A
838
Central
DEM
Speed 69kV Cap
Add 57.6 MVAR 69kV capacitor at Speed.
IN
Other
Not Shared
$500,000.00
12/31/2006
138
1
A
839
Central
DEM
Crawfordsville 69kV Cap
Add 28.8 MVAR 69kV capacitor at Crawfordsville.
IN
Other
Not Shared
$500,000.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
842
Central
DEM
Blackwell 138/69
Construct new Blackwell 138/69kV substation. Tap LGEE 138kV line into
KY
Other
Not Shared
$589,000.00
4/30/2007
138
1
substation.
A
849
Central
DEM
Peabody Jct 600A Switches
Replace Peabody Jct 600A switches with 1200A switches.
IN
Other
Not Shared
$318,341.00
6/1/2007
138
2
A
851
Central
DEM
Laf Cumberland to Laf AE Staley 138
Reconductor section of 13806 circuit with 954ACSR 100C.
IN
Other
Not Shared
$325,000.00
6/1/2011
138
1
Reconductor
A
1193
Central
DEM
Nickel
Extend 5680 through new Nickel 138/12 sub to be built on development
OH
Other
Not Shared
$150,376.81
6/1/2010
138
1
property.
A
1195
Central
DEM
Cloverdale Ethanol 138
Construct new 138kV line from Cloverdale to new Putnam Energy ethanol
IN
Other
Not Shared
$229,811.00
5/1/2007
138
1
plant.
A
1196
Central
DEM
New London to Kok Highland Park 23009
Replace 23009 800A wave traps at New London and Kokomo Highland
IN
Other
Not Shared
$29,671.83
12/31/2006
230
2
Wave Traps
Park with 1200A wave traps.
A
1198
Central
DEM
Bedford Switch Automation
Add motors and automation to the 34506 and 34521 line switches.
IN
Other
Not Shared
$152,390.14
6/1/2007
345
1
A
1199
Central
DEM
Dresser to Water St 100C Urate
Uprate 13868 conductor to 100C operating temperature from Dresser to S
IN
Other
Not Shared
$20,000.00
6/1/2010
138
2
1st St to Water St. New limit 1200A terminal equipment.
A
1200
Central
DEM
Speed Bk3 Limiting Equipment
Upgrade 2000A 138kV breaker & switch and any other Bk3 limiting
IN
Other
Not Shared
$173,193.11
6/1/2010
345
138
1
equipment. Replace any equipment that would limit the 345/138 xfr to less
than the hot spot rating of 520 MVA.
A
1201
Central
DEM
Oakland City to Princeton 100C Uprate
Uprate 13863 to 100C operating temperature from Oackland City to
IN
Other
Not Shared
$111,331.00
12/31/2006
138
1
Princeton by adding 3 structures. New limit 1200A terminal equipment.
A
1244
Central
DEM
Cayuga to Frankfort 23013 Wave Trap
Upgrade wave traps at Cayuga and Frankfort to increase line rating to 797
IN
Other
Not Shared
$167,560.00
6/1/2011
230
2
Upgrade
MVA.
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Projects
4 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 5 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Projects Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
Allocation Category
Project Information from Facility table
App
Reporting
Allocation
Exclude
Estimated Project
Expected
Max
Min
Facility
AB
PrjID
Region
Source
Project Name
Project Description
State
FF
Share Status
FF1
Cost
ISD
kV
kV
Count
A
1246
Central
DEM
Five Points 23030 Wave Trap
Replace 800A wave trap with a 2000A wave trap. Increase line rating for
IN
Other
Not Shared
$24,038.00
6/1/2011
230
1
Five Points to Geist 230kV line.
A
1247
Central
DEM
Greentown to Peru SE 23021 uprate to
Upgrade Greentown to Peru SE 230kV line to 100C operating temperature.
IN
Other
Not Shared
$28,403.00
6/1/2011
230
1
100C
A
1251
Central
DEM
Kokomo Highland Park to Noblesville 23008
Replace 800A wave traps with 2000A wave traps at Kok HP and
IN
Other
Not Shared
$54,038.00
6/1/2011
230
2
Wave Trap Upgrade
Noblesville. Increase 230kV line rating from Kok HP to Carmel 146th St Jct
to Noblesville.
A
1252
Central
DEM
Kokomo Highland Park 23028 Wave Trap
Replace 800A wave trap with a 2000A wave trap. Increase 230kV line
IN
Other
Not Shared
$30,000.00
12/31/2006
230
1
rating to Thorntown.
A
1253
Central
DEM
Noblesville 23007 Wave Trap
Replace 800A wave trap with a 2000A wave trap. Increase line rating for
IN
Other
Not Shared
$24,038.00
6/1/2011
230
1
Noblesville to Geist 230kV line.
A
1254
Central
DEM
Charletown to CMC new 138kV line
Construct 8.5 mi. of 138kV line from Charlestown to CMC.
IN
Other
Not Shared
12/31/2009
138
1
A
1262
Central
DEM
HE Durgee Rd
HE 138/12 kV substation.
IN
Other
Not Shared
$227,341.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
584
West
DPC/XEL
Genoa-Coulee 161 kV line upgrade
Genoa-Coulee 161 kV line upgrade
WI
Other
Not Shared
$4,057,132.00
6/1/2007
161
1
A
615
East
FE
Galion 345/138 kV transformer prep
Galion 345/138 kV transformer prep
OH
Other
Excluded
Y
$1,815,566.00
12/1/2007
345
138
1
A
616
East
FE
Crissinger - Tangy 138 kV line
Crissinger - Tangy 138 kV line
OH
Other
Excluded
Y
$2,713,000.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
890
East
FE
North Medina 345/138 kV Substation
Add a new 345/138kV substation at the junction of the Star-Carlisle 345kV
OH
BaseRel
Shared
$8,540,000.00
6/1/2008
345
138
2
and Star-West Akron #2 138kV lines
A
1316
East
FE
Dale Sub - Install Reactor
Reactor to be Installed on the Dale-West Canton 138 kV line at the Dale
OH
Other
Not Shared
$401,800.00
6/1/2007
138
1
Susbstation
A
1326
East
FE
Add Capacitor Banks at Harding and
Addtion of a 300 Mvar capacitor bank at the Harding 345 kV bus in 2008
OH
BaseRel
Shared
$5,454,346.00
6/1/2009
345
2
Juniper 345 kV substations
and Addtion of a 300 Mvar capacitor bank at the Juniper 345 kV bus
A
1327
East
FE
Babb - Install 138 kV Cap Bank
Add 1 - 50 MVAR Cap Bank with 1 - 138 kV Breaker
OH
Other
Not Shared
$488,600.00
6/1/2009
138
1
A
1328
East
FE
Barberton - Install 138 kV Cap Bank
Add 1 - 50 MVAR Cap Bank with 1 - 138 kV Breaker
OH
Other
Not Shared
$677,600.00
6/1/2010
138
1
A
1329
East
FE
West Akron - Install 138 kV Cap Bank
Add 1 - 50 MVAR Cap Bank with 1 - 138 kV Breaker
OH
Other
Not Shared
$257,000.00
6/1/2009
138
1
A
1330
East
FE
South Akron - Install 138 kV Cap Bank
Add 1 - 50 MVAR Cap Bank with 1 - 138 kV Breaker
OH
Other
Not Shared
$426,000.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
1331
East
FE
East Akron - Install 138 kV Cap Bank
Add 1 - 50 MVAR Cap Bank with 1 - 138 kV Breaker
OH
Other
Not Shared
$305,000.00
6/1/2011
138
1
A
1332
East
FE
Cloverdale - Install 138 kV Cap Bank
Add 1 - 50 MVAR Cap Bank with 1 - 138 kV Breaker
OH
Other
Not Shared
$378,000.00
6/1/2009
138
1
A
1333
East
FE
Brookside -Add 138kV Cap Banks
Add 2 - 50 MVAR Cap Bank with 1 - 138 kV Switcher
OH
Other
Not Shared
$1,000,200.00
6/1/2010
138
1
A
1334
East
FE
Longiew -Add 138kV Cap Banks
Add 2 - 50 MVAR Cap Bank with 1 - 138 kV Switcher
OH
Other
Not Shared
$523,800.00
6/1/2010
138
1
A
1335
East
FE
Roberts -Add 138kV Cap Bank
Add 1 - 50 MVAR Cap Bank with 1 - 138 kV Breaker
OH
Other
Not Shared
$379,285.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
1336
East
FE
Gallion Transformers #3 and #4 345 kV
Add 345kV breaker to complete 345kV ring-bus as well as extend 138kV
OH
Other
Not Shared
$1,815,566.00
12/1/2007
138
1
Circuit Breaker Addtion
bus to include another breaker string to the existing breaker-and-a-half
scheme.
A
1350
East
FE
Cloverdale Sub - Split 138 kV Bus
Rearrange the 138 kV bus at Cloverdale to electrically separate the North
OH
Other
Not Shared
$630,900.00
6/1/2007
138
1
and the South bus and provide a separate 138 kV breaker for xfmr #4
A
596
West
GRE
Vermillion River - Empire 115 kV line
Vermillion River - Empire 115 kV line
MN
Other
Excluded
Y
$2,750,000.00
5/1/2007
115
1
A
601
West
GRE
Mud Lake - Wilson Lake 115 kV line
Mud Lake - Wilson Lake 115 kV line
MN
Other
Excluded
Y
$6,000,000.00
6/1/2008
115
1
A
1026
West
GRE
Linwood 230-69 kV transformer
Required for TSR A125 and A130
MN
TDSP
Direct Assigned
$5,000,000.00
12/1/2007
230
69
1
A
1290
West
GRE
Willmar - Granite Fall 230 kV line limit will
Willmar - Granite Fall 230 kV line limit will be 382 MVA by 2007 (CT and
MN
Other
Not Shared
$250,000.00
2/28/2007
230
1
be 382 MVA by 2007 (CT and wavetrap
wavetrap replacement to higher amperage this fall)
replacement to higher amperage this fall)
A
1459
West
GRE
G351, 37804-01, G352, 37804-02
Net: new Dakota County substation will be located between NSP Blue Lake
MN
GIP
Shared
$8,935,288.00
1/1/2009
345
16
4
and Prairie Island Substations on the 345 kV line 0976
A
1318
Central
HE
Decatur County Switch Station (DCSS)
161/138kV Switching Station w/138kV Ring Bus
IN
Other
Not Shared
$7,000,000.00
9/1/2007
161
138
3
A
1319
Central
HE
Decatur County Switch Station Tap
138kV Taplines from Cinergy 138kV Transmission
IN
Other
Not Shared
$500,000.00
9/1/2007
138
1
A
1320
Central
HE
Greensburg Honda Subs & Tap Lines
Two 138/12.47kV substations and tap lines from DCSS
IN
Other
Not Shared
$3,750,000.00
9/1/2007
138
2
A
1321
Central
HE
Napoleon to DCSS Transmission Project
161kV Transmission from Napoloen to DCSS, 30 MVAR Cap
IN
Other
Not Shared
$8,000,000.00
9/1/2008
161
2
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Projects
5 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 6 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Projects Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
Allocation Category
Project Information from Facility table
App
Reporting
Allocation
Exclude
Estimated Project
Expected
Max
Min
Facility
AB
PrjID
Region
Source
Project Name
Project Description
State
FF
Share Status
FF1
Cost
ISD
kV
kV
Count
A
1322
Central
HE
Owensville Primary Substaton
138/69kV Primary Station at Owensville
IN
Other
Not Shared
$2,500,000.00
4/1/2008
138
1
A
40
Central
IPL
Cumberland-Julietta-Indian Crk 138kV Line
Add new 138kV Line from Cumberland to Julietta to Indian Creek
IN
Other
Excluded
Y
$1,818,011.02
6/1/2008
138
2
A
893
Central
IPL
North 138 kV 150 MVAR Capacitor
Capacitor Bank SizeUpgrade: North 138 kV 100 MVAR To 150 MVAR
IN
Other
Not Shared
$300,000.00
6/1/2008
138
1
A
895
Central
IPL
Georgetown To Northeast 138kV Loop-In
Loop Georgetown to Northeast 138kV Line Into North Substation
IN
Other
Not Shared
$3,000,000.00
7/1/2007
138
2
A
503
East
ITC
Wixom-Quaker 230
Project to add 345/230 kV transformer at Wixom, un-six-wire Wixom to
MI
Other
Excluded
Y
$10,000,000.00
5/30/2007
345
120
4
Hancock 120 kV ckt, decommission Hancock to Quaker 120 kV ckt, add
230/120 kV transformer at Quaker (on new bus), create new 230 kV ckt
from Wixom to Quaker, and reconductor 4 miles of the existing Hancock to
Southfield 120 kV circuit.
A
509
East
ITC
Lenox Station
Belle River-Lenox and Lenox-Jewel 345 kV lines, Lenox 345/120 kV
MI
Other
Excluded
Y
$15,000,000.00
12/31/2006
345
120
8
transformer, and 120 kV station that ties together several 120 kV lines in
the area. (St Clair, Victor, Augusta tap, Grayling 1 & 2). Was New Haven,
named changed to Lenox.
A
518
East
ITC
Bismark-Golf
Bismark-Golf 120 kV line: create a 120 kV station at Golf and build a new
MI
Other
Excluded
Y
$4,000,000.00
5/30/2007
120
3
120 kV line from Bismarck to Golf.
A
578
East
ITC
DVARs at Wyatt and Lee
Installs DVARs at Wyatt Station and Lee Station
MI
Other
Excluded
Y
$3,500,000.00
12/31/2006
120
1
A
586
East
ITC
Stephens - Erin 120 kV line #3
Constructs new 120 kV Cable from Stephens to Erin
MI
BaseRel
Shared
$34,000,000.00
12/31/2007
120
1
A
686
East
ITC
Majestic 345/120 kV switching station
Create a Majestic-Madrid 120 kV circuit by un-six wiring the existing
MI
BaseRel
Shared
$15,000,000.00
12/31/2007
345
120
5
Majestic-Madrid 345 kV circuit and connecting the available conductor to a
new 120 kV bus and position off the Madrid 120 kV bus and the new 120
kV substation via a 345/120 kV transformer at the Majestic station.
Poroject also requiresbus expansions at both Madrid 120 kV and 345 kV
stations
A
692
East
ITC
Bismark-Troy 345 kV line
Creates a Bismarck-Troy 345 kV line with a Troy 345/120 kV transformer.
MI
BaseRel
Shared
$150,000,000.00
5/31/2008
345
120
2
A
905
East
ITC
Marysville Decommissioning
Decommission Marysville Station, expand Bunce Creek Station creating
MI
Other
Not Shared
$3,500,000.00
12/31/2006
120
3
new Bunce Creek - Cypress, Bunce Creek - Menlo, Bunce Creek - Wabash
2 120 kV lines.
A
907
East
ITC
Goodison Station
Build Goodison Station, with a Belle River-Goodison 345 kV, Pontiac-
MI
BaseRel
Shared
$50,000,000.00
5/31/2008
345
120
7
Goodison 345 kV, new 345/120 kV Xfmr, new Pontiac-Goodison 120 kV
line, Goodison-Tienken 120 kV, Sunbird-Goodison 120 kV, and Tienken-
Spokane 120 kV.
A
910
East
ITC
Coventry Station upgrade
Constructs new Coventry-Cody 230 kV line using the same right-of-way
MI
BaseRel
Shared
$25,600,000.00
12/31/2007
345
120
5
currently occupied by the Coventry-Cody 120 kV circuit. Project involves
constructing a new 345/230 kV tranformer at Coventry along with a
230/120 kV transformer at Cody. Project also invloves expansion of the
Coventry 345 kV station.
A
911
East
ITC
Placid 345/120 transformer #2
Construct second 345/120 kV transformer at the Placid station. Project
MI
BaseRel
Shared
$5,550,000.00
5/30/2007
345
120
2
involves expansions at both Placid 120 kV and 345 kV stations
A
1011
East
ITC
Durant-Genoa 120 kV
Builds a new 120 kV Durant sub-station with a new circuit from Genoa to
MI
Other
Not Shared
$15,000,000.00
12/31/2006
120
1
Durant
A
1300
East
ITC
Pontiac-Joslyn and Joslyn-Walton
Replace line terminal equipment in order to raise the thermal rating of the
MI
Other
Not Shared
$500,000.00
5/30/2007
120
2
Equipment upgrade
Pontiac-Joslyn and Joslyn-Walton 120 kV circuits.
A
1301
East
ITC
Yost Line Breaker
Adds a line breaker on the Yost end of the Yost-Polaris 120 kV Circuit to
MI
Other
Not Shared
$300,000.00
12/31/2007
120
1
reduce the trasnmission system exposure to faults on distribution circuits
A
1302
East
ITC
Hines and Walton Station Equipment
Replaces equipment and buses at Hines and Walton Stations to increase
MI
Other
Not Shared
$1,500,000.00
5/31/2007
120
2
Replacement
thermal ratings to relieve overloads
A
1304
East
ITC
Monroe Breaker
Adds a new breaker on the 120 kV side of Monroe Xfmr 303
MI
Other
Not Shared
$300,000.00
12/31/2007
345
120
1
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Projects
6 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 7 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Projects Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
Allocation Category
Project Information from Facility table
App
Reporting
Allocation
Exclude
Estimated Project
Expected
Max
Min
Facility
AB
PrjID
Region
Source
Project Name
Project Description
State
FF
Share Status
FF1
Cost
ISD
kV
kV
Count
A
1305
East
ITC
Caniff Station Upgrade
Replaces the Gas Insulated Switchgear and all breakers at Caniff, and also
MI
Other
Not Shared
$14,400,000.00
5/31/2007
345
120
1
creates a ring bus configuration. GIS was nearing end of life and would
require high maintenance costs
A
1306
East
ITC
Midtown Station Upgrade
Replaces the Gas insulated Switchgear and all breakers on the 120 kV at
MI
Other
Not Shared
$6,000,000.00
12/31/2007
120
1
Midtown, and also creates a ring bus configuration. GIS was nearing end of
life and would require high maintenance costs
A
1307
East
ITC
Catilina Substation
Replace the 120 kV Breaker, buses, and station equipment at Catalina Sub
MI
Other
Not Shared
$1,000,000.00
5/1/2007
120
1
as part of a customer intterconnection request
A
1308
East
ITC
B3N Interconnection
Returns the Bunce Creek to Scott 220 kV circuit to service, and replaces
MI
Other
Not Shared
$25,500,000.00
12/31/2007
220
2
the Phase Angle Regulator with 2 new phase angle regulating transformers
in series
A
1309
East
ITC
Breaker Replacement Program
Targets the replacement of breakers nearing their end of life where
MI
Other
Not Shared
$3,000,000.00
12/31/2007
345
12
maintenance costs will be just as high as new breakers
A
1310
East
ITC
Breaker Replacement Program
Targets the replacement of breakers nearing their end of life where
MI
Other
Not Shared
$2,000,000.00
12/31/2007
230
12
maintenance costs will be just as high as new breakers
A
1488
East
ITC
Break up 3-ended Prizm-Proud-Placid 120
Results in Placid to Durant and Placid to Proud (Durant substation replaces
MI
Other
Not Shared
$4,000,000.00
12/31/2006
120
2
kV line
Prizm sub).
A
246
West
LES
North Tier 115 kV, Phase II
NW68th & Holdrege - NW 12th & Arbor 115 ckt 1, Sum rate 373
NE
Other
Excluded
Y
$1,712,000.00
12/31/2008
115
1
A
804
West
LES
Rebuild North Tier 115 kV
Rebuild part of 19th & Alvo - 70th & Bluff 115 ckt 1, Sum rate 363
NE
Other
Not Shared
$300,000.00
12/31/2008
115
1
A
548
West
MDU
Bismarck Downtown-East Bismarck 115 kV
Bismarck Downtown-East Bismarck 115 kV upgrade to at least 160 MVA
ND
Other
Not Shared
$363,000.00
11/1/2007
115
1
upgrade to at least 160 MVA
A
1008
West
MDU
Bismarck/Mandan 115 kV Circuits
Bismarck/Mandan 115 kV Circuits transferred from old to new Memorial
ND
Other
Not Shared
$6,560,000.00
11/1/2009
115
2
transferred from old to new Memorial Bridge
Bridge
A
481
East
METC
Tallmadge 345/138 kV TB3 transformer #3
Tallmadge 345/138 kV TB3 transformer #3 addition
MI
BaseRel
Shared
$9,913,090.00
12/1/2008
345
138
3
A
497
East
METC
Tallmadge - Wealthy Street 138 kV line #2
Tallmadge - Wealthy Street 138 kV line #2
MI
Other
Excluded
Y
$40,000.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
644
East
METC
Rogue River 138 ckt # 1
Rogue River 138 ckt # 1
MI
Other
Excluded
Y
$160,000.00
6/15/2007
138
1
A
645
East
METC
American Bumper - David 138 ckt # 1
Rebuild line to 795 ACSS
MI
Other
Not Shared
$2,500,000.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
658
East
METC
Gaylord
- Livingston 138 ckt # 1
Reconductor 1.5 miles to 795 ACSS
MI
TDSP
Not Shared
$500,000.00
5/1/2008
138
1
A
660
East
METC
Keystone - Clearwater - Stover 138 kV line
Keystone to Clearwater 138 kV line - rebuild 23.2 miles to 795 ACSS
MI
BaseRel
Shared
$10,200,000.00
5/1/2009
138
1
Phase 1
A
740
East
METC
345 kV line relaying and communications
Phase 1 Upgrade 345 kV line relaying and communications on Gallagher -
MI
Other
Excluded
Y
$2,794,000.00
3/1/2007
345
3
upgrade project - Phase 1
Tittabawassee, Keystone - Livingston, and Livingston - Gallagher lines.
A
775
East
METC
Iosco 138 kV 18 MVAR Capacitors
Iosco 138 kV 18 MVAR Capacitors
MI
Other
Excluded
Y
$800,000.00
3/31/2007
138
1
A
976
East
METC
Alpine - Add one line switch
Install a tap pole and one switch on Four Mile-N Belding 138kV line
MI
Other
Not Shared
$80,000.00
5/15/2008
138
1
A
977
East
METC
Marquette 138 kV station
Replace breaker failure scheme
MI
Other
Not Shared
$200,000.00
5/1/2006
138
1
A
981
East
METC
Wabasis
Install a tap pole and two switches on N. Belding - Vergennes 138kV Line
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
6/1/2009
138
1
A
982
East
METC
Crahen
Install a tap pole and one switch on Spaulding-Race St.-Four Mile 138kV
MI
Other
Not Shared
$80,000.00
7/1/2008
138
1
line
A
988
East
METC
Simpson - Batavia 138 kV line
Simpson - Batavia 138 kV line - Build 30 miles new 138 kV line, 795 ACSS
MI
BaseRel
Shared
$13,000,000.00
12/31/2009
138
1
A
1015
East
METC
Oden
Oden - New Capacitor
MI
Other
Not Shared
$510,000.00
6/1/2008
138
1
A
1016
East
METC
Bard Road
Bard Road - New Capacitor
MI
Other
Not Shared
$596,000.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
1017
East
METC
Croton
Croton - New Capacitor
MI
Other
Not Shared
$596,000.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
1390
East
METC
Goss Station 345kV Bus
Rebuild Goss 345kV bus from GIS to air insulated and replace 345kV
MI
Other
Not Shared
$5,800,000.00
12/1/2007
345
1
breakers
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Projects
7 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 8 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Projects Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
Allocation Category
Project Information from Facility table
App
Reporting
Allocation
Exclude
Estimated Project
Expected
Max
Min
Facility
AB
PrjID
Region
Source
Project Name
Project Description
State
FF
Share Status
FF1
Cost
ISD
kV
kV
Count
A
1391
East
METC
Overdutied Breaker Replacement Plan
Replace 138kV breaker 148 at Campbell
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
1392
East
METC
Overdutied Breaker Replacement Plan
Replace 138kV breaker 188 at Campbell
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
1393
East
METC
Overdutied Breaker Replacement Plan
Replace 138kV breaker 288 at Campbell
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
1394
East
METC
Overdutied Breaker Replacement Plan
Replace 138kV breaker 388 at Campbell
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
1395
East
METC
Overdutied Breaker Replacement Plan
Replace 138kV breaker 500 at Campbell
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
1396
East
METC
Overdutied Breaker Replacement Plan
Replace 138kV breaker 588 at Campbell
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
1397
East
METC
Overdutied Breaker Replacement Plan
Replace 138kV breaker 36M9 at Spaulding
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
1398
East
METC
Overdutied Breaker Replacement Plan
Replace 138kV breaker 36B7 at Spaulding
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
1399
East
METC
Overdutied Breaker Replacement Plan
Replace 138kV breaker 377 at Morrow
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
1400
East
METC
Overdutied Breaker Replacement Plan
Replace 138kV breaker 288 at Claremont
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
1401
East
METC
Overdutied Breaker Replacement Plan
Replace 138kV breaker 388 at Claremont
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
1402
East
METC
Overdutied Breaker Replacement Plan
Replace 138kV breaker 13B7 at Goss
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
1403
East
METC
Overdutied Breaker Replacement Plan
Replace 138kV breaker 13M9 at Goss
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
1404
East
METC
Overdutied Breaker Replacement Plan
Replace 138kV breaker 6W8 at Argenta
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
1405
East
METC
Overdutied Breaker Replacement Plan
Replace 138kV breaker 499 at Hemphill
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2007
138
1
A
1406
East
METC
Breaker Repair or Replace Program
Replace 138kV Alpena 188 breaker
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
12/31/2008
138
1
A
1407
East
METC
Ludington 345kV Reactor
Repair or replace faulty (gasing) 100MVAR reactor and replace the existing
MI
Other
Not Shared
$1,500,000.00
12/1/2007
345
1
circuit switcher with a breaker
A
1408
East
METC
RTU / SCADA upgrade
Install and/or upgrade RTU's and SCADA points throughout system
MI
Other
Not Shared
$801,000.00
5/1/2007
345
138
1
A
1410
East
METC
Mobile 138kV Bulk Capacitor
Purchase a mobile 14.4 - 36MVAR capacitor for flexible use where needed
Other
Not Shared
$700,000.00
12/1/2008
138
1
throughout the system
A
1411
East
METC
Campbell Unit 3 Automatic Relay Runback
Install auto relay runback scheme on Campbell Unit 3 per MISO G479
MI
Other
Not Shared
$75,000.00
3/1/2007
345
1
SPS
project
A
1412
East
METC
Covert - Negative Sequence Mitigation
Re-arrange phases on 345kV Palisades-Argenta Ckt #1 or #2 and on
MI
Other
Not Shared
$905,000.00
6/1/2007
345
2
345kV Palisades-Cook Ckt #2
A
1413
East
METC
Bagley-Gaylord 138kV line
Rebuild line to 795 ACSS
MI
Other
Not Shared
$350,000.00
5/1/2009
138
1
A
1414
East
METC
Thetford 345kV Line Relaying
Upgrade line relaying on 345kV lines
MI
Other
Not Shared
$300,000.00
12/31/2007
345
1
A
1415
East
METC
Solar
Install a tap pole and one switch on each of the Tittabawassee-HSC and
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
10/1/2007
138
1
Lawndale-HSC 138kV lines.
A
1416
East
METC
Tittabawassee-Hemlock Semiconductor 138
Install a second 138kV Tittabawasee-HSC line (14.7 miles) along with
MI
BaseRel
Shared
$7,227,000.00
10/1/2007
138
2
kV line
required 138kV breakers at each end (5 total breakers) and install a 2 mile
138kV double circuit to swap the existing Tittabawasee and Lawndale line
connections into HSC.
A
1417
East
METC
Race Street
Install a 138kV tie-breaker to loop the Spaulding-Four Mile 138kV Line into
MI
Other
Not Shared
$2,200,000.00
6/1/2007
138
1
Race Street
A
1418
East
METC
Kinderhook
Install a tap pole and two switches on Batavia-Barton Lake 138kV Line
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
5/1/2007
138
1
A
1419
East
METC
Laundra
Install a tap pole and one switch on Bullock-Saginaw River 138kV Line
MI
Other
Not Shared
$80,000.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
1420
East
METC
Sanderson
Install a tap pole and one switch on North Belding-Sanderson 138kV Line
MI
Other
Not Shared
$80,000.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
1421
East
METC
Baraga (formerly Sinclair or Spectrum)
Install a 138kV tie-breaker to loop the Spaulding-Four Mile 138 kV Line into
MI
Other
Not Shared
$240,000.00
12/15/2007
138
1
Baraga.
A
1422
East
METC
Marshall
Install a tap pole and one switch on the Verona-Marshall 138kV line.
MI
Other
Not Shared
$80,000.00
6/1/2007
138
1
A
1423
East
METC
Eppler
Install a tap pole and two switches on the Emmet-McNally 138kV line.
MI
Other
Not Shared
$500,000.00
6/1/2007
138
1
Purchase the high side of Emmet Substation and a section of the 138kV
line from the substation to the Eppler tap point.
A
1424
East
METC
Trillium
Install a tap pole and two switches on Delhi-Tompkins #2 138kV Line
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
5/1/2007
138
1
A
1425
East
METC
Gray Road
Install a tap pole and two switches on Keystone-Elmwood 138kV Line plus
MI
Other
Not Shared
$300,000.00
6/1/2008
138
1
some relay upgrades
A
1433
East
METC
Buskirk
Install bulk substation served from the Beals-Hazelwood 138kV Line
MI
Other
Not Shared
$2,200,000.00
6/1/2008
138
1
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Projects
8 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 9 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Projects Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
Allocation Category
Project Information from Facility table
App
Reporting
Allocation
Exclude
Estimated Project
Expected
Max
Min
Facility
AB
PrjID
Region
Source
Project Name
Project Description
State
FF
Share Status
FF1
Cost
ISD
kV
kV
Count
A
1434
East
METC
Five Mile
Install bulk substation served from the Spaulding 138kV ring bus
MI
Other
Not Shared
$750,000.00
6/1/2008
138
1
A
1437
East
METC
N Ave
Install a tap pole and two switches on Argenta-Milham 138kV Line
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
6/1/2008
138
1
A
1438
East
METC
Potvin
Install a tap pole and one switch on Wexford-Tippy 138kV Line
MI
Other
Not Shared
$80,000.00
6/1/2008
138
1
A
1439
East
METC
Busch
Install a tap pole and two switches on Hemphill-Weadock 138kV Line
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
10/1/2007
138
1
A
1440
East
METC
Huckleberry
Install a tap pole and two switches on Beals Rd-Wayland-Hazelwood
MI
Other
Not Shared
$80,000.00
6/1/2008
138
1
138kV Line
A
1441
East
METC
Ellis (Hile Road)
Install bulk substation served from a new Ellis spur from Sternberg
MI
Other
Not Shared
$3,250,000.00
6/1/2009
138
1
A
1442
East
METC
Eastmanville (Pingree)
Install bulk substation served from the Fillmore-Four Mile 138kV Line
MI
Other
Not Shared
$200,000.00
10/1/2007
138
1
A
1444
East
METC
Dublin
Install a tap pole and two switches on Bullock-Edenville 138kV Line
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
6/1/2011
138
1
A
1445
East
METC
Emmet
Install a second distribution transformer at Emmet
MI
Other
Not Shared
$2,750,000.00
6/1/2010
138
1
A
1446
East
METC
Gaines
Install bulk substation at Gaines
MI
Other
Not Shared
$50,000.00
6/1/2010
138
1
A
1447
East
METC
Horseshoe Creek (Deja)
Install bulk substation served from the Eureka-Deja-Vestaburg 138kV Line
MI
Other
Not Shared
$2,200,000.00
6/1/2010
138
1
A
1449
East
METC
Juniper
Install bulk substation served from the Cobb-Tallmadge #2 138kV Line
MI
Other
Not Shared
$160,000.00
6/1/2010
138
1
A
1465
East
METC
G418, 38068-02
Construction Suspended on 5/15/2006, can be suspended for 3 years. Net:
MI
GIP
Shared
$5,192,616.00
10/1/2007
138
1
6
A
1358
West
MP
Grand Rapids - Capacitor 115 add new
Grand Rapids - Capacitor 115 add new
MN
Other
Not Shared
$320,000.00
12/30/2006
115
1
A
279
West
MPC/XEL/OTPBoswell - Wilton 230 kV Line
Boswell - Wilton 230 ckt 1, Sum rate 390
MN
BaseRel
Shared
$35,963,000.00
7/1/2010
230
1
A
757
East
NIPS
Dune Acres - Add 138 kV Capacitors - 100
Add one step of capacitors, for a total 100 MVAR, on the Dune Acres 138
IN
Other
Excluded
Y
$1,083,600.00
2/1/2007
138
1
MVAR
kV bus.
A
925
East
NIPS
ISG2 to Marktown - Upgrade Capacity
Upgrade circuit capacity on existing .6 miles of 300 KCM Cu line by
IN
Other
Not Shared
$240,500.00
12/1/2006
138
1
bundling both sets of 300 KCM CU line on shared tower line between
Marktown and ISG #2 to increase capacity to 316 MVA.
A
1298
East
NIPS
Inland #5 to Marktown - Upgrade Capacity
Upgrade Cir. 13830 capacity on existing 2.2 miles of 400 KCM Cu line by
IN
Other
Not Shared
$750,000.00
5/1/2008
138
1
upgrading conductor to 954 KCM ACSR between Marktown and Inland #5
Substation.
A
1454
West
NSP
G176, 37319-01
Net: Yankee Substation 115/34.5 kV transformer Int: two 34.5 feeder bays
MN
TAP
Not Shared
$2,306,000.00
10/1/2007
115
34.5
1
at Yankee Sub terminating at the dead-end switch structures outside
(Pre-RECB 1)
Yankee Sub.
A
1455
West
NSP
G238, 37642-02, Increase of generating
Net: 3 new 115 kV, 63 kA interrupting rating circuit breakers, disconnect
MN
Other
Not Shared
$2,770,000.00
5/1/2009
115
2
capacity at Riverside Generating Plant
switches, and relocate the existing Apache 115 kV line to a new
(Pre-RECB 1)
termination in the same substation
A
274
West
OTP
Appleton - Dawson 115 kV Line
Appleton - Dawson 115 ckt 1, Sum rate 96
MN
Other
Not Shared
$474,000.00
8/1/2008
115
1
A
275
West
OTP
Canby - Dawson 115 kV Line
Dawson - Canby 115 ckt 1, Sum rate 96
MN
Other
Not Shared
$538,000.00
8/1/2008
115
1
A
1362
West
OTP
Louisurg - Dawson 115 Convert an existing
Louisurg - Dawson 1 115 Convert an existing 41.6 kV line to 115 kV
MN
Other
Not Shared
$988,000.00
8/1/2008
115
1
41.6 kV line to 115 kV
A
1462
West
OTP / GRE
G380, 37946-02
Net: Transmission Owner will upgrade the Rugby Substation to accomdate
ND
GIP
Shared
$898,740.00
9/1/2007
230
3
the interconnection of the IC's 230 kV radial transmission line into Rugby,
will need to add additional 230 kV bus, new 230 kV breaker and associated
equipment.
A
755
West
OTP/MRES/G Alexandria Capacitor Addition
Alexandria Switching Station 115 kV 25 MVAR Capacitors
MN
Other
Not Shared
$530,000.00
6/1/2007
115
1
A
81
Central
SIPC
Marion Power Plant - Carrier Mills 161 kV
Construct a 161 kV line connecting the Marion 161 kV Plant to a new
IL
Other
Excluded
Y
$7,083,000.00
6/1/2007
161
1
line
Carrier Mills 161/69 kV Substation. The project includes the construction of
nearly 27 miles of 161 kV transmission line and converting a 69 kV
switching station into a 161/69 kV substation.
A
1205
East
WPSC
Cheboygan II Breaker Station
Add a 69KV breaker in the line from Tower to Pelston
MI
Other
Not Shared
$550,000.00
8/1/2006
69
1
A
1206
East
WPSC
Bass Lake - Lake County Line Rebuild
Line Rebuild to 795ACSR for future 138KV operation
MI
Other
Not Shared
$1,800,000.00
8/1/2006
69
1
A
1207
East
WPSC
Hersey - Osceola Line Re-rate
Rerate line to 75C
MI
Other
Not Shared
$200,000.00
8/1/2006
69
1
A
1208
East
WPSC
Oden 12MVAR Capacitor Bank
Add 12MVAR Capacitor Bank at Oden Substation
MI
Other
Not Shared
$300,000.00
8/1/2006
69
1
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Projects
9 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 10 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Projects Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
Allocation Category
Project Information from Facility table
App
Reporting
Allocation
Exclude
Estimated Project
Expected
Max
Min
Facility
AB
PrjID
Region
Source
Project Name
Project Description
State
FF
Share Status
FF1
Cost
ISD
kV
kV
Count
A
1226
East
WPSC
Kalkaska Gen - Westwood Line Rebuild
Kalkaska Gen - Kalkaska JCT - Westwood Line Rebuild. Summer Rating
MI
Other
Not Shared
$2,905,000.00
2/1/2008
69
1
102.4 MVA
A
1227
East
WPSC
Gaylord Gen - Bagley Junction
Gaylord Gen - Bagley Junction Rebuild. Summer Rating 102.4 MVA
MI
Other
Not Shared
$1,000,000.00
2/1/2008
69
1
A
1228
East
WPSC
ANR Elpaso New Load
Add 14MW load off of Wolverine's Westwood Junction
MI
Other
Not Shared
$1,800,000.00
8/1/2008
69
1
A
1229
East
WPSC
Plains Junction Breaker Station
Replace Relaying and Breakers at Plains Junction Substation
MI
Other
Not Shared
$625,000.00
11/1/2006
69
1
A
1230
East
WPSC
White Cloud Breaker Station
Replace Relaying and Breakers at White Cloud Substation
MI
Other
Not Shared
$625,000.00
9/1/2006
69
1
A
1231
East
WPSC
Superior Corn Substation
Add new load point neer Wolverine's Odessa Substation
MI
Other
Not Shared
$550,000.00
6/1/2006
69
1
A
1272
East
WPSC
Redwood 75MVA Transformer
Add 75MVA Transformer at Redwood Substation
MI
Other
Not Shared
$1,900,000.00
8/1/2010
138
69
1
a separate line from Redwood Junction will be ran to energize the
transformer.
A
56
West
XEL
Chisago - Apple River
Chisago - Lindstrom - Shafer- Lawrence Creek 69 kV rebuild to 115 kV,
MN
Other
Excluded
Y
$34,480,000.00
12/31/2010
161
115
5
Lawrence Creek - St Croix Falls - Apple River 69 kV rebuild to 161 kV. New
Lawrence Creek 161/115/69 kV substation
A
267
West
XEL
Lawrence - Minnehaha 115
Lawrence - Minnehaha 115 ckt 1, Sum rate 310
SD
Other
Excluded
Y
$829,667.00
5/1/2007
115
1
A
268
West
XEL
Minnehaha - Lincoln County 115
Minnehaha - Lincoln County 115 ckt 1, Sum rate 310
SD
Other
Excluded
Y
$925,398.00
5/1/2007
115
1
A
269
West
XEL
Prairie Island
- Red Rock 345
Prairie Island
- Red Rock 345 ckt 2, Sum rate 1198
MN
Other
Excluded
Y
$807,000.00
6/1/2007
345
1
A
270
West
XEL
Champlin - Champlin Tap 115
Champlin - Champlin Tap 115 ckt 1, Sum rate 310
MN
Other
Excluded
Y
$382,923.00
6/1/2007
115
1
A
272
West
XEL
Air Lake - Vermillion River 115
Air Lake - Vermillion River 115 ckt 1, Sum rate 200
MN
Other
Not Shared
$3,359,095.21
6/1/2007
115
1
A
366
West
XEL
Sherburne Co Area 115 kV project
Upgrade Sherco - Monticello 115 and Sherco - St Cloud 115 kV lines, new
MN
Other
Excluded
Y
$7,763,734.00
6/1/2007
345
115
5
Sherco 345/115 transformer
A
377
West
XEL
Xcel Energy Wind 425 MW project
Buffalo Ridge (SW MN) 425 MW of Generation Outlet:R emaining
MN
TDSP
Not Shared
$9,380,127.53
1/1/2007
115
1
projectcomponent.
A
385
West
XEL
Xcel Energy Wind 425-825 MW project
Buffalo Ridge (SW MN) 825 MW of Generation Outlet:
MN
TDSP
Not Shared
$124,947,480.66
6/1/2010
345
115
13
Split Rock to Lakefield Junction new 345 kVline and other upgrades
A
417
West
XEL
Westgate 115, 80 MVAR Capacitor
Westgate 115, 80 MVAR Capacitor
MN
Other
Excluded
Y
$1,500,000.00
6/1/2007
115
1
A
609
West
XEL
Long Lake - Oakdale 115 kV line
Long Lake - Oakdale 115 kV line
MN
Other
Excluded
Y
$760,000.00
6/1/2007
115
1
A
671
West
XEL
Oakdale - Tanners Lake 115
Oakdale - Tanners Lake 115 ckt # 1
MN
Other
Excluded
Y
$800,000.00
6/1/2007
115
1
A
673
West
XEL
Champlin Tap - Crooked Lake 115
Champlin Tap - Crooked Lake 115 ckt # 1
MN
Other
Not Shared
$310,000.00
6/1/2008
115
1
A
674
West
XEL
High Bridge - Rogers Lake 115
High Bridge - Rogers Lake 115 ckt # 1
MN
TDSP
Not Shared
$2,400,000.00
5/1/2008
115
1
A
780
West
XEL
Lakefield Gen - Wilmarth Series
Fieldon Township 345 kV Series Capacitor 20 ohms
MN
TDSP
Not Shared
$10,100,000.00
11/1/2007
345
1
Compensation
A
1031
West
XEL
Garwind McNeilus generator TSR upgrades
TSR conditional upgrades for delivery of G171, G239, G242
MN
TDSP
Not Shared
$780,000.00
3/1/2005
69
1
A
1034
West
XEL
Loon Lake 115/69 kV transformer upgrade
Replace Loon Lake 115/69 kV transformer with 112 MVA
MN
Other
Not Shared
$1,774,000.00
6/1/2006
115
69
1
A
1364
West
XEL
Lakefield Jct - Lakefield Generation 345 kV
Lakefield Jct - Lakefield Generation 345 kV line - Raise the structures to
MN
TDSP
Not Shared
5/1/2007
345
1
line - Raise the structures to increase the
increase the thermal rating
thermal rating
A
1365
West
XEL
Edina - Eden Prairie 115 Reconductor
Edina - Eden Prairie 1 115 Reconductor
MN
Other
Not Shared
$3,730,000.00
6/1/2007
115
1
A
1366
West
XEL
G405: Colvill Generating station -
Colvill Generating station - Transformer relocated from Cannon Falls
MN
GIP
Shared
$13,943,380.00
5/1/2008
161
115
5
Interconnection upgrades
substation, Build in and out to Cannon Falls - Empire 115 kV line, Build in
and out to Cannon Falls - Spring Creek 161 kV line
A
1456
West
XEL
G255, 37517-01
Net: a new 120 MVA, 118-36.2 kV transformer, 2 115 kV breakers, 115 kV
MN
GIP
Shared
$3,357,600.00
11/1/2007
118
36.2
2
switches and 34.5 kV breakers and switches. Int: install two new 50 MW
feeders and all associated equipment.
A
1457
West
XEL
G287, 37642-03. Upgrades for G287
G287 Upgrades: Nobles County sub upgrades, Hazel Run substation,
MN
GIP
Shared
$38,735,000.00
12/31/2010
345
6
Nobles County - Fenton 115 kV line
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Projects
10 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 11 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Projects Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
Allocation Category
Project Information from Facility table
App
Reporting
Allocation
Exclude
Estimated Project
Expected
Max
Min
Facility
AB
PrjID
Region
Source
Project Name
Project Description
State
FF
Share Status
FF1
Cost
ISD
kV
kV
Count
A
1458
West
XEL
G349, 37774-01. Upgrades for G349
G349 Upgrades: Yankee substation, Brookings Co 345/115 substation,
MN
GIP
Shared
$31,982,000.00
11/30/2011
345
115
6
Hazel Run 53 Mvar capacitor, Brookings-Yankee 115 kV line
A
1464
West
XEL
G408, 38048-01, Velva Windfarm
Net: tap McHenry - Souris 115 kV line, install switches, metering
MN
Other
Not Shared
$336,650.00
11/15/2005
115
3
equipment, and other appropriate equipment
(Pre-RECB 1)
A
1489
West
XEL
Woodbury - Tanners Lake upgrade
Reconductor the line from Woodbury - Tanners Lake to 310 MVA
MN
Other
Not Shared
$525,000.00
6/1/2011
115
1
A
853
Central
DEM
West Lafayette to Cumberland 138
Reconductor section of 13806 circuit with 954ACSR 100C.
IN
Other
Not Shared
$646,000.00
6/1/2015
138
1
Reconductor
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Projects
11 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 12 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Project Facilities Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
App
Facil
Reporting
Expected
Voltage
LS
Rating (Normal /
Map
Miles
Miles
Estimated Facility
Cost
Post
AB
ID
Source
PrjID
ISD
From Sub or Location
To Sub or Device Description
Ckt
(kV)
kV
Emergency)
Upgrade Description
Grid
State
Upg
New
Cost
Shared
Stamp
A
189
ALTW
90
6/1/2007
Emery
Lime Creek
2
161
326
New Facility
H7
IA
25
$8,000,000.00
A
2104
ALTW
1204
10/1/2006
Adams
Rochester
1
161
201/221 MVA
replace termination jumpers at Adams
I7
MN
$5,000.00
A
2116
ALTW
1287
6/1/2008
Salem 345/161 kV
transformer
1
345
161
448/448
Larger Xfmr
J8
IA
0
0
$5,000,000.00
Y
A
2117
ALTW
1288
6/1/2009
Hazleton 345/161
transformer
1
345
161
335/335
Larger Xfmr
J7
IA
0
0
$5,000,000.00
Y
A
2118
ALTW
1289
6/1/2008
Marshalltown
Toledo
1
115
233/233
Rebuild
I8
IA
16
0
$4,712,000.00
A
2119
ALTW
1289
6/1/2009
Belle Plaine
Toledo
1
115
233/233
Rebuild
I8
IA
18
0
$6,080,000.00
A
2120
ALTW
1289
6/1/2010
Belle Plaine
Stoney Point
1
115
233/233
Rebuild
I8
IA
27
0
$8,208,000.00
A
2209
ALTW
1342
6/1/2009
Lewis Fields
transformer
1
161
115
new transformer
J8
IA
$2,000,000.00
A
2208
ALTW
1342
6/1/2009
Lewis Fields
Hiawatha
1
161
250
new line
J8
IA
8.5
$2,550,000.00
A
2212
ALTW
1344
6/1/2008
Beverly
transformer
1
345
161
335
new substation
J8
IA
$4,000,000.00
A
2211
ALTW
1344
6/1/2008
Beverly Tap
Beverly
1
161
335
new line
J8
IA
7.9
$300,000.00
A
2216
ALTW
1348
6/1/2011
Marion
Prairie Creek
1
115
198
upgrade limiting equipment
J8
IA
$200,000.00
A
2544
ALTW
1348
6/1/2011
Marion
Swamp Fox
1
115
208
J8
IA
4
A
2545
ALTW
1348
6/1/2011
Swamp Fox
Lewis Field
1
115
208
upgrade limiting equipment
J8
IA
1
A
2218
ALTW
1349
6/1/2011
Dundee
transformer
1
161
115
112
replace transformer
J7
IA
$100,000.00
A
2473
ALTW
1471
5/1/2007
Generating Facility Sub
1
69
transmission structure with a 3-way, load break, manual, 1200
MN
$125,000.00
Y
amp or higher, 69 kV switch
A
2475
ALTW
1472
5/1/2007
Generating Facility Sub
1
69
transmission structure with a 3-way, load break, manual, 1200
MN
$125,000.00
Y
amp or higher, 69 kV switch
A
1856
ALTW
1473
Mason City Armor
Emery North
69
Rebuild existing line
IA
A
392
Ameren
144
6/1/2008
Crab Orchard
Marion South
1
138
269
reconductor
K11
IL
9.1
$2,712,300.00
A
397
Ameren
149
6/1/2007
Mason
Sioux
1
345
breaker addition at Mason
J11
MO
$605,900.00
A
398
Ameren
150
6/1/2008
Rush Island
Baldwin
1
345
1793
terminal at Rush Island & river crossing only
J11-K1 IL
2
$1,615,100.00
A
400
Ameren
153
6/1/2008
CEE Tap
Watson
1
138
370
reconductor
J11
MO
0.8
$311,400.00
A
401
Ameren
155
6/1/2008
Joachim 345/138 kV
transformer
1
345
138
560
new 345/138 kV transformer
J11
MO
$12,963,300.00
A
1399
Ameren
708
6/1/2007
Casey
Breed
1
345
1332
reconductor river crossing
L10
IL
0.23
$303,900.00
A
1403
Ameren
712
12/1/2007
Mason
Labadie-Mason-4 Term.
1
345
terminal equipment upgrade at Mason
J11
MO
$184,100.00
A
1410
Ameren
719
6/1/2009
Labadie Plant
Replace 4-345 kV Breakers
345
replace existing 345 kV breakers
J11
MO
$1,897,100.00
A
831
Ameren
856
12/1/2006
Osage 138 kV Substation
Eldon
1
138
200
Replace bus conductor at Osage Substation
I11
MO
$65,000.00
A
832
Ameren
857
6/1/2007
Rush Island
Joachim
1
345
1200
Replace terminal equipment at Rush Island
J11
MO
$283,200.00
A
833
Ameren
858
6/1/2007
Sioux
Huster
1
138
214
Increase ground clearance
J10
MO
6
$1,024,500.00
A
834
Ameren
859
6/1/2008
Central
Watson (Tower 55)
1
138
370
Reconductor 5.1 miles 954 kcmil ACSR from Central to Twr.
J11
MO
5.1
$1,500,300.00
55
A
1942
Ameren
1241
3/1/2007
Mattoon, West
Install 138 kV Breaker at
1
138
Install 138 kV Breaker to connect Wind Farm
K10
IL
$555,400.00
Mattoon, West
A
853
AmerenCILCO
875
11/15/2006
Kickapoo
Mason City-Decatur
138
155
Replace 600 A terminal equipment with 1200 A at Kickapoo
K9
IL
$156,700.00
A
854
AmerenCILCO
876
6/1/2007
Tazewell
Powerton
1
345
1339
Replace 2000 A terminal equipment at Tazewell with 3000 A
K9
IL
$1,042,900.00
A
1423
AmerenIP
150
6/1/2008
Line 4531 tap
Prairie State Power Plant
2
345
1470
345 kV connection to new generation
K11
IL
7.5
$2,283,900.00
A
1422
AmerenIP
150
6/1/2008
Baldwin
Rush Island
1
345
1793
26 miles of new 345 kV line
J11-K1 IL
26
$46,149,200.00
A
1424
AmerenIP
150
6/1/2008
Line 4541 tap
Prairie State Power Plant
2
345
1470
345 kV connection to new generation
K11
IL
1.5
$12,991,400.00
A
1667
AmerenIP
150
6/1/2008
Prairie State
substation
1
345
1793
new switchyard (6 position, 4 lines, 2 units)
J11-K1 IL
A
1402
AmerenIP
711
6/1/2007
Wood River
Gillespie
1
138
240
reconductor
K10
IL
7.5
$939,500.00
A
1418
AmerenIP
725
12/1/2008
N. LaSalle
Wedron Fox River
1
138
266
2 CB at N LaSalle, 1 CB at Wedron Fox River Substation
K8
IL
25
$20,489,370.00
A
1419
AmerenIP
726
12/1/2008
Ottawa
Wedron Fox River
1
138
266
1 CB at Ottawa, new 138 kV line to Wedron Fox River
K8
IL
8
$8,045,400.00
Substation
A
1421
AmerenIP
728
6/1/2008
Wood River
Roxford L1502
1
138
382
reconductor
K10
IL
4.36
$5,264,900.00
Y
A
1425
AmerenIP
732
6/1/2007
S. Bloomington
State Farm
1
138
337
Reconductor 1.3 miles 1272 kcmil ACSR
K9
IL
1.3
$1,172,900.00
A
1429
AmerenIP
736
6/1/2007
W. Tilton
Tilton Energy Center
138
new 138 kV breaker addition at W. Tilton
L9
IL
$1,709,400.00
A
1431
AmerenIP
738
6/1/2007
Line 1342C tap
Line 1342A
1
138
280
Line 1342A (structure 423 to 467A reconductor)
K9
IL
5.23
$1,994,400.00
A
1432
AmerenIP
739
1/1/2009
Line 4561 Tap
Franklin County Power Plant
1
345
345 kV connection (new ring bus) to new generation
K11
IL
$7,108,700.00
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Facilities
12 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 13 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Project Facilities Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
App
Facil
Reporting
Expected
Voltage
LS
Rating (Normal /
Map
Miles
Miles
Estimated Facility
Cost
Post
AB
ID
Source
PrjID
ISD
From Sub or Location
To Sub or Device Description
Ckt
(kV)
kV
Emergency)
Upgrade Description
Grid
State
Upg
New
Cost
Shared
Stamp
A
841
AmerenIP
865
6/1/2007
Havana
Monmouth
1
138
280
Build new river crossing
J9
IL
0.44
$223,700.00
A
845
AmerenIP
869
6/1/2007
Sidney
Mira Tap
1
138
280
Reconductor 2 miles of 795 kcmil ACSR
L9
IL
2
$693,800.00
A
851
AmerenIP
873
1/31/2009
Baldwin
Turkey Hill
1
345
1195
Replace 345 kV breakers at Baldwin terminal
K11
IL
$4,242,100.00
A
849
AmerenIP
873
1/31/2009
Baldwin
W. Mt. Vernon
1
345
1195
Replace 345 kV breakers at Baldwin terminal
K11
IL
$4,242,100.00
A
850
AmerenIP
873
1/31/2009
Baldwin
Stallings
1
345
1195
Replace 345 kV breakers at Baldwin terminal
K11
IL
$4,242,100.00
A
855
ATC LLC
1
6/1/2008
Stone Lake
Inductor
345
75 Mvar
J6
WI
$0.00
A
2064
ATC LLC
1
6/1/2008
Arpin
Capacitor bank
138
50 Mvar
J6
WI
$1,021,496.00
A
3099
ATC LLC
1
6/1/2008
Stone Lake
Capacitor
345
75 Mvar
J6
WI
$0.00
A
135
ATC LLC
1
6/30/2008
Arrowhead
Stone Lake
1
345
1092/1092 MVA
new line
I4
WI
78.85
$130,497,676.83
A
2555
ATC LLC
1
12/4/2006
Stone Lake
Gardner Park
1
345
1200/1200 MVA
new line
I4
WI
141.5
$234,148,046.05
A
121
ATC LLC
2
4/1/2007
Dewey Tap
Weston
115
244/277 MVA
Phase I increase clearance/ Phase II reconductor 12/31/07
K6
WI
15.4
$5,535,685.00
A
127
ATC LLC
2
4/1/2007
Northpoint
Dewey Tap
115
244/277 MVA
Phase I increase clearance/ Phase II reconductor 12/31/07
K6
WI
8.2
$5,535,685.00
A
119
ATC LLC
21
6/1/2007
Venus
Metonga (was Crandon)
115
175
new radial line
K5
WI
14
$8,745,840.00
A
108
ATC LLC
62
3/1/2007
Stratford
McMillan
115
135
J6
WI
10
$1,750,000.00
A
87
ATC LLC
64
6/1/2007
McFarland
Femrite (conversion to 138 kV)
138
438
conversion to 138
K7
WI
2.1
$1,000,000.00
A
86
ATC LLC
64
6/1/2007
Kegonsa
McFarland (conversion to 138
138
348
conversion to 138
K7
WI
3.7
$2,410,000.00
kV)
A
125
ATC LLC
101
6/1/2008
Kelly
Whitcomb
115
121/165 MVA
uprate clearances to 300F
K6
WI
24.3
$1,900,000.00
A
862
ATC LLC
177
6/1/2009
Highway 22 (formerly Central
new substation
345
new substation
K6
WI
$12,200,000.00
Wisconsin)
A
2457
ATC LLC
177
12/1/2009
Belle Plaine
Badger
1
115
175/240 MVA
WI
$0.00
A
2454
ATC LLC
177
12/1/2009
Kelly
Whitcomb
1
115
174/174 MVA
WI
$0.00
A
2455
ATC LLC
177
12/1/2009
Whitcomb
Caroline
1
115
138/138 MVA
WI
$0.00
A
607
ATC LLC
177
12/1/2009
Gardner Park (new Weston)
HWY 22 (formerly Central
1
345
1776 MVA SE
K6
WI
47
$116,700,000.00
Wisconsin)
A
2456
ATC LLC
177
12/1/2009
Caroline
Belle Plaine
1
115
290/401 MVA
WI
$0.00
A
892
ATC LLC
339
6/1/2008
Boxelder
Stonybrook
138
287
uprate
K7
WI
$200,000.00
A
434
ATC LLC
339
6/1/2008
Rockdale
Boxelder
1
138
383
uprate
K7
WI
$200,000.00
A
433
ATC LLC
339
6/1/2008
Rockdale
Lakehead Cambridge
138
287
uprate
K7
WI
$200,000.00
A
450
ATC LLC
339
6/1/2008
Lake Mills (provisional)
Stonybrook
138
290
construct new
K7
WI
6
$9,850,000.00
A
429
ATC LLC
339
6/1/2008
Lakehead Cambridge
Jefferson
138
348
uprate
K7
WI
$150,000.00
A
449
ATC LLC
339
6/1/2008
Jefferson
Lake Mills (provisional)
138
290
construct new
K7
WI
6
$9,850,000.00
A
608
ATC LLC
345
11/30/2008
Clintonville
Werner West
138
381/529 MVA
K6
WI
14
2
$6,091,242.00
Y
Y
A
2458
ATC LLC
345
12/1/2009
Badger
Clintonville
1
138
211/238 MVA
WI
$3,533,329.00
Y
Y
A
2459
ATC LLC
345
12/1/2009
Morgan
White Clay
1
138
293/332 MVA
WI
$3,533,329.00
Y
Y
A
480
ATC LLC
345
12/1/2009
Morgan
Werner West
345
1882 MVA SE
new line
K6
WI
47
$128,132,800.00
Y
Y
A
459
ATC LLC
350
6/1/2007
Sherman St
Hilltop
115
239
rebuild
J6
WI
6.9
$3,750,000.00
A
458
ATC LLC
350
6/1/2007
Weston
Sherman St
115
239
rebuild
J6
WI
0.2
$250,000.00
A
1247
ATC LLC
350
6/1/2007
Gardner Park (was Weston)
Hilltop
115
285
new line
K6
WI
2.4
$3,750,000.00
A
1963
ATC LLC
352
6/1/2006
Eagle River Muni
115
Construct new SS adjacent to the Cranberry 115-kV SS
WI
$2,600,000.00
Y
A
446
ATC LLC
352
1/1/2008
Eagle River
Lakota Rd (formerly Conover)
1
115
244
new line
K5
WI
14
$10,000,000.00
Y
A
447
ATC LLC
352
1/1/2008
Lakota Rd (formerly Conover)
transformer
1
138
115
150
138/115 transformer
K5
WI
$17,785,000.00
Y
138-115 kV
A
445
ATC LLC
352
7/31/2008
Lakota Rd (formerly Conover)
Iron Grove
1
138
290
convert 69 to 138 kV
K5
MI/WI
73
$69,100,000.00
Y
A
2460
ATC LLC
352
12/31/2009
Iron Grove
Aspen
1
138
400 MVA SE
K5
WI
$5,850,000.00
Y
A
896
ATC LLC
352
12/31/2009
Iron Grove
Substation relocation
138
Iron River rename/relocation
K5
MI
$5,900,000.00
Y
A
1371
ATC LLC
352
12/31/2009
Aspen
Plains
1
138
400 MVA SE
K5
WI
$5,850,000.00
Y
A
2062
ATC LLC
433
6/1/2007
Wautoma
Capacitor bank
138
2x24.5 Mvar
K6
WI
$1,200,000.00
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Facilities
13 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 14 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Project Facilities Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
App
Facil
Reporting
Expected
Voltage
LS
Rating (Normal /
Map
Miles
Miles
Estimated Facility
Cost
Post
AB
ID
Source
PrjID
ISD
From Sub or Location
To Sub or Device Description
Ckt
(kV)
kV
Emergency)
Upgrade Description
Grid
State
Upg
New
Cost
Shared
Stamp
A
2082
ATC LLC
446
4/30/2007
Rubicon
Capacitor bank
138
32 Mvar
was Hartford
K7
WI
$750,000.00
A
1244
ATC LLC
566
5/1/2007
Plymouth
Forest Junction/Charter Steel
1
138
277
K6
WI
1.3
$2,500,000.00
A
1255
ATC LLC
570
6/1/2009
La Prairie RCEC
Bradford RCEC
1
138
381
K7
WI
$1,610,612.00
A
1256
ATC LLC
570
6/1/2009
Bradford RCEC
West Darien
1
138
381
K7
WI
$3,410,708.00
A
1260
ATC LLC
570
6/1/2009
Bristol
Elkhorn
1
138
292
K7
WI
$3,410,708.00
A
1259
ATC LLC
570
6/1/2009
North Shore
Bristol
1
138
381
K7
WI
$1,610,612.00
A
1257
ATC LLC
570
6/1/2009
West Darien
Southwest Delavan
1
138
381
K7
WI
$1,610,612.00
A
1258
ATC LLC
570
6/1/2009
Southwest Delavan
North Shore
1
138
381
K7
WI
$3,410,708.00
A
1992
ATC LLC
571
6/1/2008
North Madison
Huiskamp
1
138
481 MVA SE
WI
$8,700,000.00
A
1262
ATC LLC
572
6/1/2008
Ingalls/Bay de Doc
Menominee
1
138
345
K5
WI
0.45
$1,000,000.00
A
1263
ATC LLC
572
6/1/2008
West Marinette
Menominee
1
138
345
K5
WI
0.45
$1,000,000.00
A
868
ATC LLC
877
6/1/2009
Ramsey
Norwich
138
288
loop Ramsey5-Harbor into Norwich and Kansas to form
L7
WI
3
$200,000.00
Ramsey-Norwich and Harbor-Kansas
A
869
ATC LLC
877
6/1/2009
Harbor
Kansas
138
157
loop Ramsey5-Harbor into Norwich and Kansas to form
L7
WI
2.72
$200,000.00
Ramsey-Norwich and Harbor-Kansas
A
867
ATC LLC
877
6/1/2009
Oak Creek
Expand 345 kV switchyard
345
expand switchyard to interconnect new generator
L7
WI
$19,277,005.00
A
866
ATC LLC
877
6/1/2009
Pleasant Prairie
replace two circuit breakers
345
replace circuit breakers
L7
WI
$2,357,175.00
A
865
ATC LLC
877
6/1/2009
Oak Creek
Relaying replacements
230
replace relaying
L7
WI
$2,500,000.00
A
864
ATC LLC
877
6/1/2009
Oak Creek
Allerton
138
242
reconductor
L7
WI
5.4
$2,000,000.00
A
863
ATC LLC
877
6/1/2009
Oak Creek
Ramsey
138
293
reconductor (need 382 MVA for A035)
L7
WI
8.5
$200,000.00
A
482
ATC LLC
877
6/1/2009
Oak Creek 345/138 #2
transformer
2
345
138
500
L7
WI
$6,600,000.00
A
873
ATC LLC
877
6/1/2010
Oak Creek
Nicholson
138
332
uprate
L7
WI
6.8
$136,007.00
A
872
ATC LLC
877
6/1/2010
Oak Creek
Root River
138
293
uprate
L7
WI
$136,007.00
A
871
ATC LLC
877
6/1/2010
Kansas
Ramsey6
138
290
uprate
L7
WI
5.7
$500,000.00
A
870
ATC LLC
877
6/1/2010
Oak Creek
Expand 345 kV switchyard
345
expand switchyard to interconnect second new generator
L7
WI
$10,600,000.00
A
132
ATC LLC
1451
6/1/2007
Sprecher
Reiner (conversion to 138 kV)
138
366
conversion to 138
K7
WI
10
$1,250,000.00
A
131
ATC LLC
1451
6/1/2007
Reiner
Sycamore (conversion to 138
138
366
conversion to 138
K7
WI
7
$1,250,000.00
kV)
A
123
ATC LLC
1451
6/1/2007
Femrite
Sprecher (new 138 kV)
1
138
348
new 138 kV line
K7
WI
5
$8,100,000.00
A
467
ATC LLC
1453
6/1/2008
Pleasant Valley
Saukville
138
290
reconductor
K7
WI
12
$4,800,000.00
Y
A
468
ATC LLC
1453
6/1/2008
Pleasant Valley
St. Lawrence
138
290
reconductor
K7
WI
7
$4,800,000.00
Y
A
2509
ATC LLC
1461
10/20/2006
Green Lake Sub
Interconnection Facilities will include a collection bus at a
WI
$170,146.00
voltage level of 34.5kV, 34.5kV facilities, 138/34.5 kV
transformer and 138 kV circuit breaker.
A
2511
ATC LLC
1461
10/20/2006
Green Lake Sub
transformer
138
34.5
178 MVA
a new two-breaker, 138 kV substation in a configuration
WI
$2,049,696.00
allowing future expansion to a six position ring bus. Two line
positions will allow for looping line X-4 into the substation.
A
2512
ATC LLC
1461
10/20/2006
Green Lake Sub
138
a loop into New Substation, including two (2) steel pole dead-
WI
$94,856.00
ends to facilitate entry of Line X-4 into the substation.
Transmission Owner will perform 138kV Line X-4 relay
settings updates at the Green Lake, North Fo
A
2517
ATC LLC
1463
10/20/2006
Mishicot
new substation
138
New Substation between Kewaunee Sub and Shoto Sub, New
WI
$2,612,000.00
two-breaker 138 kV substation in a configuration allowing
future expansion to a seven position ring bus. Two line
positions will allow for looping line Y-51 into the substation.
A
2521
ATC LLC
1463
10/20/2006
Shoto
Relaying replacements
138
Shoto Substation 138 kV Line Y-51, to Kewaunee, Relay
WI
$123,000.00
Replacement. This relay upgrade will include replacing the
existing line protection relays and panels with a new panel
containing relays for a directional comparison unblocking
(DCUB) system.
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Facilities
14 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 15 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Project Facilities Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
App
Facil
Reporting
Expected
Voltage
LS
Rating (Normal /
Map
Miles
Miles
Estimated Facility
Cost
Post
AB
ID
Source
PrjID
ISD
From Sub or Location
To Sub or Device Description
Ckt
(kV)
kV
Emergency)
Upgrade Description
Grid
State
Upg
New
Cost
Shared
Stamp
A
2520
ATC LLC
1463
10/20/2006
Kewaunee
Relaying replacements
138
Kewaunee Substation 138 kV Line Y-51, to Shoto, Relay
WI
$123,000.00
Replacement, This relay upgrade will include replacing the
existing line protection relays and panels with a new panel
containing relays for a directional comparison unblocking
(DCUB) system.
A
2518
ATC LLC
1463
10/20/2006
Mishicot
138
This interconnection will include extension of the 138 kV bus
WI
$179,000.00
to a disconnect switch, the addition of an H-frame dead-end
structure, and connection to the generation substation with
2156 MCM ACSR.
A
2519
ATC LLC
1463
10/20/2006
Mishicot
138
Line Y-51 Loop into New Substation. This interconnection will
WI
$231,000.00
include the installation of two new 45' steel poles (labeled as
163A and 163B ) to facilitate entry of Line Y-51 into the
substation at right angles.
A
2479
ATC LLC
1470
11/1/2006
Generating Facility Sub
69
New two-breaker 69 kV substation in a configuration allowing
WI
$1,765,957.00
Y
future expansion to a six-position ring bus
A
2480
ATC LLC
1470
11/2/2006
Y-33 line
69
63
existing line Y-33 will be re-built completely to increase the
WI
$5,268,974.00
Y
line capacity to a minimum of 63 MVA. The new line will have
T2-4/0 ACSR conductors and OPGW for fiber communication
A
2481
ATC LLC
1470
11/3/2006
Y-33 line
S. Monroe
69
replacing the existing line protection relays and panels with a
WI
$193,240.00
Y
new panel containing relays for a permissive under-reaching
transfer trip (POTT) system
A
2482
ATC LLC
1470
11/4/2006
Y-33 line
Brodhead
69
replacing the existing line protection relays and panels with a
WI
$184,941.00
Y
new panel containing relays for a permissive under-reaching
transfer trip (POTT) system
A
2483
ATC LLC
1470
11/5/2006
Generating Facility Sub
69
extension of the 69 kV bus to a disconnect switch, the addition
WI
$125,620.00
of an H-frame dead-end structure, and connection to the
generation substation with 2156 MCM ACSR
A
1861
ATC LLC
1475
Atlantic 138-69 kV
Transformer
138
69
60
New Transformer
WI
A
1862
ATC LLC
1476
Mullet River 138-69 kV
Transformer
138
69
Replacement of Tranformer
WI
A
1865
ATC LLC
1477
6/1/2008
N. Madison
ABS -Yahara
138
Uprate of N.Madison-ABS 138kV and ABS-Yahara 138kV
WI
lines
A
1868
ATC LLC
1478
1/1/2008
Waunakee
Westport - Pheasant Branch
69
95 MVA SE
Uprate of Waunakee-Westport-Pheasant Branch 69 kV line
WI
A
182
DEM
42
6/1/2007
Bedford
Shawswick
1
138
306
Reconductor Bedford to Shawswick section of 13829 line.
M10
IN
7.1
$2,110,106.00
A
184
DEM
42
6/1/2009
Shawswick
Pleasant Grove
1
138
306
Reconductor
M10
IN
18.3
$4,719,516.00
A
183
DEM
42
6/1/2009
Pleasant Grove
Airport Road Jct
1
138
306
Reconductor
M10
IN
9.3
$3,388,077.00
A
181
DEM
42
6/1/2009
Airport Road Jct
Seymour
1
138
306 MVA
Reconductor
M10
IN
2.2
0
$752,906.00
A
2536
DEM
91
6/1/2008
Eastwood
Breaker
138
Install 2 new circuit breakers, bus and associated equipment
N10
OH
$1,602,070.00
Y
for the new 138kV circuit from Hillcrest.
A
2539
DEM
91
6/1/2008
Stuart
Relays
345
Replace relays at Stuart on the 345kV line to the new Hillcrest
N10
OH
$93,403.00
Y
Y
substation.
A
2540
DEM
91
6/1/2008
Foster
Relays
345
Replace relays at Foster on the 345kV line to the new Hillcrest
N10
OH
$213,385.00
Y
Y
substation.
A
358
DEM
91
6/1/2008
Hillcrest 345/138
transformer
1
345
138
450
Add new 345/138 transformer
N10
OH
$4,120,000.00
Y
A
2537
DEM
91
6/1/2008
Brown
Relays
138
Replace relays at Brown on the 138kV lie to Eastwood
N10
OH
$210,608.00
Y
associated with the new Hillcrest to Eastwood 138kV line.
A
2538
DEM
91
6/1/2008
Ford Batavia
Relays
138
Replace relays at Ford Batavia on the 138kV lie to Eastwood
N10
OH
$270,412.00
Y
associated with the new Hillcrest to Eastwood 138kV line.
A
362
DEM
91
6/1/2008
Hillcrest
Eastwood
1
138
304
Add new line
N10
OH
8
$4,704,406.00
Y
A
2556
DEM
91
6/1/2008
Hillcrest 345 kV
substation upgrades
345
345 kV upgrades for 345/138 transformer
N10
OH
$6,473,212.00
Y
Y
A
366
DEM
115
6/1/2007
New London
Webster
1
230
800
reconductor
M9
IN
12
$9,455,194.00
A
1307
DEM
116
6/1/2007
West Lafayette
Cumberland
1
138
179
replace 600A switches
M9
IN
0
0
$154,757.00
A
367
DEM
116
6/1/2007
Westwood
Dequine
1
345
1200
Add 2nd 345kV line
L9
IN
2
$588,366.00
A
357
DEM
116
6/1/2007
Westwood 345/138
transformer
2
345
138
336
Add 2nd 345/138 transformer
L9
IN
$6,093,584.00
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Facilities
15 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 16 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Project Facilities Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
App
Facil
Reporting
Expected
Voltage
LS
Rating (Normal /
Map
Miles
Miles
Estimated Facility
Cost
Post
AB
ID
Source
PrjID
ISD
From Sub or Location
To Sub or Device Description
Ckt
(kV)
kV
Emergency)
Upgrade Description
Grid
State
Upg
New
Cost
Shared
Stamp
A
356
DEM
199
6/1/2007
Kokomo 230/138
transformer
2
230
138
200
Add fourth 230/138kV transformer.
M9
IN
$3,278,756.00
A
618
DEM
200
6/1/2007
West Lafayette Purdue
Purdue NW Tap
1
138
179
Upgrade switches at West Lafayette Purdue.
L9
IN
7.2
$9,877.00
A
536
DEM
201
6/1/2008
NW Tap
West Lafayette
1
138
240
Changing out switches to achieve conductor rating.
L9
IN
0
$100,000.00
A
1292
DEM
619
6/1/2008
IPL Petersburg
345kV breaker
345
Complete breaker and half scheme at Petersburg Plant. IPL
M10
IN
0
0
$200,000.00
total estimate 1,100,000. 200k is Cinergy share of project.
A
1300
DEM
624
12/31/2007
Cloverdale
Plainfield South
1
138
No change
Upgrade static and grounding
L10
IN
24.3
0
$2,387,209.00
A
1953
DEM
627
6/1/2007
Crescent
West End
138
239
3 wires of existing 6 wire circuit will be used for the new
Kenton to West End circuit, lowering the rating of Crescent to
West End.
A
1853
DEM
627
6/1/2009
Buffington Reactor
Florence
138
Remove reactor when Kenton to West End project is
KY
completed.
A
1304
DEM
627
6/1/2009
Kenton
West End
1
138
239
Add new line
N10
KY-OH
4.5
4.3
$1,980,041.00
A
1305
DEM
628
6/1/2007
Kokomo Highland Park
Kokomo Chrysler
1
138
179
Kok 13879 Uprate conductor to 100C operating temp
M9
IN
3
0
$100,000.00
A
1306
DEM
629
6/1/2007
Kokomo Highland Park
Kokomo Delco
1
138
179
Kok 13887 Uprate conductor to 100C operating temp
M9
IN
3.78
0
$100,000.00
A
1309
DEM
632
6/1/2009
Gallagher
HE Georgetown
1
138
202
reconducgtor 250CU, 477ACSR already 100C (no cost)
M10
IN
2.8
0
$1,065,110.00
A
3060
DEM
766
6/1/2007
Clarksville
Capacitor
138
57.6 Mvar
Add capacitor
M10
IN
$738,662.00
A
3062
DEM
767
6/1/2007
Greenfield Hastings Park
Capacitor
138
57.6 Mvar
Add capacitor
M9
IN
$598,722.00
A
812
DEM
807
6/1/2009
Dresser 345/138 Bk1
transformer
1
345
138
523
Upgrade limiting equipment to achieve full transformer rating
L10
IN
$429,000.00
A
813
DEM
807
6/1/2009
Dresser 345/138 Bk2
transformer
2
345
138
543
Upgrade limiting equipment to achieve full transformer rating
L10
IN
$429,000.00
A
817
DEM
838
12/31/2006
Speed
Capacitor
138
57.6 MVAR
Add capacitor
M10
IN
$500,000.00
A
818
DEM
839
6/1/2007
Crawfordsville
Capacitor
138
28.8 MVAR
Add capacitor
L9
IN
$500,000.00
A
822
DEM
842
4/30/2007
Blackwell
LGEE Tap
138
138 line for Blackwell 138/69, LGEE circuit
N10
KY
$589,000.00
A
824
DEM
849
6/1/2007
Peabody Jct
Farmersburg Jct
1
138
246
Replace Peabody Jct 600A switches with 1200A towards
L10
IN
$159,170.50
Farmersburg Jct in the 13821 line, 804F6402
A
823
DEM
849
6/1/2007
Peabody Jct
Jasonville
1
138
246
Replace Peabody Jct 600A switches with 1200A towards
L10
IN
$159,170.50
Jasonville in the 13821 line, 804F6402
A
826
DEM
851
6/1/2011
Lafayette Cumberland Ave
Laf AE Staley
1
138
306
13806 reconductor with 954ACSR 100C 604F6347
L9
IN
1.3
$325,000.00
A
1843
DEM
1193
6/1/2010
Nickel
138
Extend 5680 through new Nickel 138/12 sub to be built on
OH
$150,376.81
development property
A
1845
DEM
1195
5/1/2007
Cloverdale
Cloverdale Ethanol
1
138
Construct new 138kV line from Cloverdale to new Putnam
IN
$229,811.00
Energy ethanol plant.
A
1846
DEM
1196
12/31/2006
New London
Kokomo Highland Park
1
230
405
Replace New London 23009 800A wave trap with a 1200A
IN
$29,671.83
wave trap.
A
1847
DEM
1196
12/31/2006
Kokomo Highland Park
New London
1
230
405
Replace Kokomo Highland Park 23009 800A wave trap with a
IN
1200A wave trap.
A
1849
DEM
1198
6/1/2007
Bedford
345
Add motors and automation to the 34506 and 34521 line
IN
$152,390.14
switches.
A
1850
DEM
1199
6/1/2010
Dresser
Terre Haute South 1st St
1
138
287
Uprate 13868 conductor to 100C operating temperature from
IN
$10,000.00
Dresser to South 1st St. New limit 1200A terminal equipment.
A
1851
DEM
1199
6/1/2010
Terre Haute South 1st St
Terre Haute Water St
1
138
287
Uprate 13868 conductor to 100C operating temperature from
IN
$10,000.00
South 1st St to Water St. New limit 1200A terminal
A
1852
DEM
1200
6/1/2010
Speed
3
345
138
520
Upgrade 2000A 138kV breaker & switch and any other Bk3
IN
$173,193.11
limiting equipment. Replace any equipment that would limit
the 345/138 xfr to less than the hot spot rating of 520 MVA.
A
1854
DEM
1201
12/31/2006
Oakland City
Princeton
1
138
287
Uprate line to 100C operating temperature by adding 3
IN
$111,331.00
structures.
A
1945
DEM
1244
6/1/2011
Cayuga 23013 Wave Trap
Frankfort
230
797
Replace 1600A wave trap with a 2000A wave trap. Increase
IN
$68,733.00
line rating of the Cayuga to Frankfort 23013 line.
A
1946
DEM
1244
6/1/2011
Frankfort 23013 Wave Trap
Cayuga
230
797
Replace 1600A wave trap with a 2000A wave trap. Increase
IN
$98,827.00
line rating of the Cayuga to Frankfort 23013 line.
A
1947
DEM
1246
6/1/2011
Five Points 23030 Wave Trap
Geist
230
405
Replace 800A wave trap with a 2000A wave trap. Increase
IN
$24,038.00
line rating to Geist.
A
1948
DEM
1247
6/1/2011
Greentown
Peru SE
230
478
Uprate 23021 circuit to 100C operating temp
IN
$28,403.00
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Facilities
16 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 17 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Project Facilities Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
App
Facil
Reporting
Expected
Voltage
LS
Rating (Normal /
Map
Miles
Miles
Estimated Facility
Cost
Post
AB
ID
Source
PrjID
ISD
From Sub or Location
To Sub or Device Description
Ckt
(kV)
kV
Emergency)
Upgrade Description
Grid
State
Upg
New
Cost
Shared
Stamp
A
1949
DEM
1251
12/31/2006
Kokomo Highland Park 23008
Carmel 146th St Jct
230
405
Replace 800A wave trap with a 2000A wave trap. Increase
IN
$30,000.00
Wave Trap
230kV line rating to Carmel 146th St Jct.
A
1950
DEM
1251
6/1/2011
Noblesville 23008 Wave Trap
Carmel 146th St Jct
230
405
Replace 800A wave trap with a 2000A wave trap. Increase
IN
$24,038.00
230kV line rating to Carmel 146th St Jct.
A
1951
DEM
1252
12/31/2006
Kokomo Highland Park 23028
Thorntown
230
405
Replace 800A wave trap with a 2000A wave trap. Increase
IN
$30,000.00
Wave Trap
230kV line rating to Thorntown.
A
1952
DEM
1253
6/1/2011
Noblesville 23007 Wave Trap
Geist
230
405
Replace 800A wave trap with a 2000A wave trap. Increase
IN
$24,038.00
line rating to Geist.
A
1955
DEM
1254
12/31/2009
Charlestown
CMC
138
306
Construct 8.5 mi. of 138kV line from Charlestown to CMC.
IN
A
1978
DEM
1262
12/31/2007
HE Durgee Rd
138
HE 138/12 kV substation.
IN
$227,341.00
A
807
DPC/XEL
584
6/1/2007
Genoa
Coulee
1
161
375
E13
WI
18.7
$4,057,132.00
A
1283
FE
615
12/1/2007
Galion 345-138 kV
transformer prep.
345
138
Protection upgrades to separate existing transformers, so they
O8
OH
$1,815,566.00
don't trip together
A
1284
FE
616
6/1/2007
Crissinger
Tangy
1
138
275 MVA
O8
OH
23
$2,713,000.00
A
2559
FE
890
6/1/2008
North Medina 345 kV
substation upgrades
345
North Medina 345 kV substation
O8
OH
$3,540,000.00
Y
Y
A
899
FE
890
6/1/2008
North Medina new 345-138 kV
substation
4
345
138
Add a new 345/138kV substation at the junction of the Star-
O8
OH
$5,000,000.00
Y
Carlisle 345kV and Star-West Akron #2 138kV lines
A
2186
FE
1316
6/1/2007
Dale
West Canton
1
138
208/281 MVA
Add reactor at Dale end of the Dale to West Canton 138 kV
OH
$401,800.00
line.
A
2191
FE
1326
6/1/2008
Harding
capacitor bank
345
Capacitor Bank Addition
OH
$2,727,173.00
Y
Y
A
2192
FE
1326
6/1/2009
Juniper
capacitor bank
345
Capacitor Bank Addition
OH
$2,727,173.00
Y
Y
A
2193
FE
1327
6/1/2009
Babb
capacitor bank
138
Capacitor Bank Addition
OH
$488,600.00
A
2194
FE
1328
6/1/2010
Barberton
capacitor bank
138
Capacitor Bank Addition
OH
$677,600.00
A
2195
FE
1329
6/1/2009
West Akron
capacitor bank
138
Capacitor Bank Addition
OH
$257,000.00
A
2196
FE
1330
6/1/2007
South Akron
capacitor bank
138
Capacitor Bank Addition
OH
$426,000.00
A
2197
FE
1331
6/1/2011
East Akron
capacitor bank
138
Capacitor Bank Addition
OH
$305,000.00
A
2198
FE
1332
6/1/2009
Cloverdale
capacitor bank
138
Capacitor Bank Addition
OH
$378,000.00
A
2199
FE
1333
6/1/2010
Brookside
capacitor bank
138
Capacitor Bank Addition
OH
$1,000,200.00
A
2200
FE
1334
6/1/2010
Longview
capacitor bank
138
Capacitor Bank Addition
OH
$523,800.00
A
2201
FE
1335
6/1/2007
Roberts
capacitor bank
138
Capacitor Bank Addition
OH
$379,285.00
A
2202
FE
1336
12/1/2007
Gallion
capacitor bank
138
Breaker Addition
OH
$1,815,566.00
A
2189
FE
1350
6/1/2007
Cloverdale
breaker
138
Breaker Addition
OH
$630,900.00
A
1076
GRE
596
5/1/2007
Vermillion River
Empire
1
115
200
TC detaMN
6
$2,750,000.00
A
641
GRE
601
6/1/2008
Mud Lake
Wilson Lake
1
115
142
H5
MN
12
$6,000,000.00
A
752
GRE
1026
12/1/2007
Linwood 230-69 kV
transformer
1
230
69
112
TC detaMN
$5,000,000.00
A
2121
GRE
1290
2/28/2007
WILLMAR4 (63050)
GRANITF4 (66550)
1
230
382/382
Replace CTs and Wavetrap
G5
MN
0
0
$250,000.00
A
2499
GRE
1459
1/1/2009
Dakota County Sub
transformer
1
345
16
224 MVA
one 224 MVA, 345/16 kV generator step-up transformer, a
MN
$275,000.00
16/4.1 kV station aux transformer, and two 16 kV circuit
breakers and a 345 kV motor operated switch
A
2500
GRE
1459
1/1/2009
Dakota County Sub
transformer
2
345
16
224 MVA
one 224 MVA, 345/16 kV generator step-up transformer, a
MN
$275,000.00
16/4.1 kV station aux transformer, and two 16 kV circuit
breakers and a 345 kV motor operated switch
A
2501
GRE
1459
1/1/2009
Dakota County Sub
new substation
345
new substation, along with NSP Blue Lake and Prairie Island
MN
$5,959,788.00
Y
Y
transmission line construction
A
2525
GRE
1464
11/15/2005
McHenry Tap
115
ND
$233,800.00
A
2524
GRE
1464
11/15/2005
McHenry Tap
115
The Transmission Owner Interconnection Facilities
ND
$102,850.00
A
2173
HE
1318
9/1/2007
Decatur County Switch Station
138kV 6-Breaker Ringbus
1
138
2000Amp
New Construction
IN
$3,000,000.00
(DCSS)
A
2172
HE
1318
9/1/2007
Decatur County Switch Station
161/138kV Transformer
1
161
138
250MVA
New Construction
IN
$1,000,000.00
(DCSS)
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Facilities
17 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 18 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Project Facilities Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
App
Facil
Reporting
Expected
Voltage
LS
Rating (Normal /
Map
Miles
Miles
Estimated Facility
Cost
Post
AB
ID
Source
PrjID
ISD
From Sub or Location
To Sub or Device Description
Ckt
(kV)
kV
Emergency)
Upgrade Description
Grid
State
Upg
New
Cost
Shared
Stamp
A
2171
HE
1318
9/1/2007
Decatur County Switch Station
138kV Switching Station
1
138
30MVAR
New Construction
IN
$3,000,000.00
(DCSS)
w/Capacitor
A
2174
HE
1319
9/1/2007
Decatur County Switch Station
Cinergy 138 (Greensburg to
1
138
327MVA
New Construction
IN
0.5
$500,000.00
(DCSS)
Shelbyville)
A
2177
HE
1320
9/1/2007
Greensburg Honda
DCSS
1
138
215MVA
New Construction East Loop
IN
5.5
$1,875,000.00
A
2178
HE
1320
9/1/2007
Greensburg Honda
DCSS
1
138
215MVA
New Construction West Loop
IN
5.5
$1,875,000.00
A
2180
HE
1321
9/1/2008
Napoleon Primary
DCSS
1
161
338MVA
New Construction
IN
25
$7,200,000.00
A
2179
HE
1321
9/1/2008
Napoleon
Capacitor & CB Addition, and
1
161
30MVAR
New Construction
IN
$800,000.00
bus upgrades
A
2182
HE
1322
4/1/2008
Owensville Primary Tapline
Cinergy 138 (Gibson to
1
138
215MVA
New Construction
IN
0.5
$2,500,000.00
Princeton)
A
177
IPL
40
6/1/2008
Indian Creek
Julietta
1
138
286 MVA
New 138kV Line
M9
IN
5
$951,838.23
A
178
IPL
40
6/1/2008
Cumberland
Julietta
1
138
286 MVA
New 138kV Line
M9
IN
4.55
$866,172.79
A
902
IPL
893
6/1/2008
North
Capacitor
138
150 MVAR
Increase Capacitor Size To 150 MVAR
M9
IN
$300,000.00
A
905
IPL
895
7/1/2007
North
Breaker
138
245 MVA
New 2000 Amp Breaker
M9
IN
$1,500,000.00
A
904
IPL
895
7/1/2007
North
Breaker
138
245 MVA
New 2000 Amp Breaker
M9
IN
$1,500,000.00
A
759
ITC
503
12/31/2006
Quaker 230-120 kV
transformer
1
230
120
634
M9
MI
0
0
$1,500,000.00
A
757
ITC
503
12/31/2006
Wixom 230
Quaker 230
1
230
657
M9
MI
5
4.3
$2,300,000.00
A
758
ITC
503
12/31/2006
Wixom 345/230
transformer
1
345
230
782
M9
MI
0
0
$5,000,000.00
A
760
ITC
503
5/30/2007
Hancock 120
Southfield 120
1
120
244
N7
MI
3.7
$1,200,000.00
A
768
ITC
509
12/31/2006
Lenox 120
Grayling 1 120
1
120
313
O7
MI
10.8
$1,300,000.00
A
766
ITC
509
12/31/2006
Lenox 120
Augusta Tap 120
1
120
343
O7
MI
4.98
$1,300,000.00
A
765
ITC
509
12/31/2006
Lenox 120
Victor 120
1
120
313
O7
MI
1.08
$1,300,000.00
A
764
ITC
509
12/31/2006
Lenox 120
St Clair 120
1
120
312.8
O7
MI
19.5
$1,300,000.00
A
763
ITC
509
12/31/2006
Lenox 345-120 kV
transformer
1
345
120
500
O7
MI
0
$5,000,000.00
A
762
ITC
509
12/31/2006
Lenox 345
Belle River 345
1
345
2002
O7
MI
19.1
$1,750,000.00
A
761
ITC
509
12/31/2006
Lenox 345
Jewel 345
1
345
2007
O7
MI
8.7
$1,750,000.00
A
767
ITC
509
12/31/2006
Lenox 120
Grayling 2 120
1
120
313
O7
MI
10.8
$1,300,000.00
A
773
ITC
518
5/30/2007
Golf 120
Macomb 120 #2
2
120
291
O7
MI
3.2
$1,600,000.00
A
770
ITC
518
5/30/2007
Golf 120
Boyne 120
1
120
290
O7
MI
4.2
0.64
$1,200,000.00
A
771
ITC
518
5/30/2007
Golf 120
Houston 2 120
1
120
313
O7
MI
17.3
$1,200,000.00
A
2100
ITC
578
12/31/2006
Wyatt
DVAR
120
30 Mvar
N9
MI
$3,500,000.00
A
774
ITC
586
12/31/2007
Stephens 120
Erin 120
3
120
290
O7
MI
4.7
$34,000,000.00
Y
A
1377
ITC
686
12/31/2006
Majestic 120 kV
Madrid 120 kV
2
120
445
N7
MI
15.9
$2,000,000.00
Y
A
2558
ITC
686
12/31/2006
Majestic 345 kV
substation upgrades
1
345
120
681
345 kV substation upgrades
N7
MI
$600,000.00
Y
Y
A
1378
ITC
686
12/31/2006
Majestic 345/120 kV
transformer
1
345
120
681
N7
MI
$6,200,000.00
Y
A
1382
ITC
686
12/31/2007
Majestic 120 kV
Phoenix 120 kV
1
120
313
N7
MI
7.4
9.2
$3,500,000.00
A
1381
ITC
686
12/31/2007
Majestic 120 kV
Lark 120 kV
1
120
313
N7
MI
2.6
9.2
$2,700,000.00
A
1384
ITC
692
5/31/2008
Troy 345/120 kV
transformer
1
345
120
700
N7
MI
$5,000,000.00
Y
A
1383
ITC
692
5/31/2008
Bismarck 345 kV
Troy 345 kV
1
345
700
N7
MI
15.4
$145,000,000.00
Y
Y
A
931
ITC
905
12/31/2006
Bunce Creek 120 kV
Cypress 120 kV
1
120
313
N9
MI
0.1
0
$1,166,668.00
A
930
ITC
905
12/31/2006
Bunce Creek 120 kV
Menlo 120 kV
1
120
152
N9
MI
0.1
0
$1,166,666.00
A
929
ITC
905
12/31/2006
Bunce Creek 120 kV
Wabash 120 kV 2
2
120
299
N9
MI
0.1
0
$1,166,666.00
A
910
ITC
907
5/31/2008
Goodison 345 kV
Belle River 345
1
345
2151
Goodison 345 kV substation
N7
MI
35.2
$6,000,000.00
Y
Y
A
911
ITC
907
5/31/2008
Goodison 345 kV
Pontiac 345
1
345
2002
Goodison 345 kV substation
N7
MI
6.3
$6,000,000.00
Y
Y
A
912
ITC
907
5/31/2008
Goodison 345/120 kV
transformer
1
345
120
700
N7
MI
$5,000,000.00
Y
A
913
ITC
907
5/31/2008
Goodison 120 kV
Pontiac 120 kV
1
120
343
N7
MI
6.3
$11,000,000.00
Y
A
914
ITC
907
5/31/2008
Goodison 120 kV
Sunbird 120 kV
1
120
229
N7
MI
3.55
2.87
$11,000,000.00
Y
A
915
ITC
907
5/31/2008
Goodison 120 kV
Tienken 120 kV
1
120
343
N7
MI
2.78
2.34
$9,000,000.00
Y
A
916
ITC
907
5/31/2008
Spokane 120 kV
Tienken 120 kV
1
120
343
N7
MI
0.1
$2,000,000.00
Y
A
950
ITC
910
12/31/2007
Coventry 345/230
transformer
1
345
230
782
N7
MI
$8,200,000.00
Y
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Facilities
18 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 19 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Project Facilities Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
App
Facil
Reporting
Expected
Voltage
LS
Rating (Normal /
Map
Miles
Miles
Estimated Facility
Cost
Post
AB
ID
Source
PrjID
ISD
From Sub or Location
To Sub or Device Description
Ckt
(kV)
kV
Emergency)
Upgrade Description
Grid
State
Upg
New
Cost
Shared
Stamp
A
952
ITC
910
12/31/2007
Coventry 230 kV
Cody 230kV
1
230
657
N7
MI
6.6
$3,000,000.00
Y
A
951
ITC
910
12/31/2007
Cody 230/120 kV
transformer
1
230
120
693
N7
MI
$4,500,000.00
Y
A
2560
ITC
910
12/31/2007
Coventry 345 kV
substation
1
345
345 kV substation upgrades
N7
MI
$2,900,000.00
Y
Y
A
1581
ITC
910
12/31/2007
Coventry 230 kV
Wixom 230 kV
1
230
345 kV operated at 230 kV
N7
MI
$7,000,000.00
Y
A
953
ITC
911
5/30/2007
Placid 345 kV
transformer
2
345
120
700
120 kV bus work
M9
MI
$350,000.00
Y
A
2561
ITC
911
5/30/2007
Placid 345 kV
substation
345
345 kV substation upgradeds
M9
MI
$5,200,000.00
Y
Y
A
1583
ITC
1011
12/31/2006
Genoa 120 kV
Durant 120 kV
1
120
343
N7
MI
8.5
$15,000,000.00
A
2130
ITC
1300
5/30/2007
Pontiac 120 kV
Joslyn 120 kV
1
120
445
line termination
N6
MI
2.28
$250,000.00
A
2131
ITC
1300
5/30/2007
Walton 120 kV
Joslyn 120 kV
1
120
445
line termination
N6
MI
1.75
$250,000.00
A
2132
ITC
1301
12/31/2007
Yost 120 kV
Polaris 120 kV
1
120
349
line breaker
N7
MI
0.9
$300,000.00
A
2133
ITC
1302
5/31/2007
Hines 120 kV
substation equipment
120
642
station equipment replacement
N7
MI
$750,000.00
A
2134
ITC
1302
5/31/2007
Walton 120 kV
substation equipment
120
635
station equipment replacement
N6
MI
$750,000.00
A
2136
ITC
1304
12/31/2007
Monroe 345 kV
Monroe 120 kV
1
345
120
321
Adds a new breaker on the 120 kV side of Monroe Xfmr 303
N7
MI
$300,000.00
A
2137
ITC
1305
5/31/2007
Caniff 120 and 345 kV
substation equipment
345
120
replace breakers and switchgear
N7
MI
$14,400,000.00
A
2138
ITC
1306
12/31/2007
Midtown 120 kV
120
N7
MI
$6,000,000.00
A
2139
ITC
1307
5/1/2007
Catalina 120 kV
120
N7
MI
$1,000,000.00
A
2140
ITC
1308
12/31/2006
Bunce Creek 220 kV
Scott 220 kV
1
220
N7
MI
4.5
$500,000.00
A
2141
ITC
1308
12/31/2007
Bunce Creek PAR
1
220
N7
MI
$25,000,000.00
A
2149
ITC
1309
12/31/2007
Monroe 345 kV pos. FM
circuit breaker
345
CB replacement
N7
MI
$250,000.00
A
2153
ITC
1309
12/31/2007
Monroe 345 kV pos. BT
circuit breaker
345
CB replacement
N7
MI
$250,000.00
A
2152
ITC
1309
12/31/2007
Monroe 345 kV pos. BM
circuit breaker
345
CB replacement
N7
MI
$250,000.00
A
2151
ITC
1309
12/31/2007
Monroe 345 kV pos. BF
circuit breaker
345
CB replacement
N7
MI
$250,000.00
A
2150
ITC
1309
12/31/2007
Monroe 345 kV pos. FT
circuit breaker
345
CB replacement
N7
MI
$250,000.00
A
2143
ITC
1309
12/31/2007
Monroe 345 kV pos. CM
circuit breaker
345
CB replacement
N7
MI
$250,000.00
A
2146
ITC
1309
12/31/2007
Monroe 345 kV pos. LM
circuit breaker
345
CB replacement
N7
MI
$250,000.00
A
2148
ITC
1309
12/31/2007
Monroe 345 kV pos. FF
circuit breaker
345
CB replacement
N7
MI
$250,000.00
A
2147
ITC
1309
12/31/2007
Monroe 345 kV pos. LT
circuit breaker
345
CB replacement
N7
MI
$250,000.00
A
2144
ITC
1309
12/31/2007
Monroe 345 kV pos. CT
circuit breaker
345
CB replacement
N7
MI
$250,000.00
A
2142
ITC
1309
12/31/2007
Monroe 345 kV pos. CF
circuit breaker
345
CB replacement
N7
MI
$250,000.00
A
2145
ITC
1309
12/31/2007
Monroe 345 kV pos. LF
circuit breaker
345
CB replacement
N7
MI
$250,000.00
A
2165
ITC
1310
12/31/2007
Brock 120 kV pos. HP
circuit breaker
120
CB replacement
N7
MI
$150,000.00
A
2164
ITC
1310
12/31/2007
Atlanta 120 kV pos. HD
circuit breaker
120
CB replacement
N7
MI
$150,000.00
A
2156
ITC
1310
12/31/2007
Warren 230 kV pos. CF
circuit breaker
230
CB replacement
N7
MI
$200,000.00
A
2163
ITC
1310
12/31/2007
Polaris 120 kV pos. HG
circuit breaker
120
CB replacement
N7
MI
$150,000.00
A
2162
ITC
1310
12/31/2007
Wabash 120 kV pos. HL
circuit breaker
120
CB replacement
N6
MI
$150,000.00
A
2161
ITC
1310
12/31/2007
Trenton Ch. 120 kV Pos. KP
circuit breaker
120
CB replacement
O7
MI
$150,000.00
A
2160
ITC
1310
12/31/2007
Trenton Ch. 120 kV Pos. KG
circuit breaker
120
CB replacement
O7
MI
$150,000.00
A
2157
ITC
1310
12/31/2007
St. Clair 120 kV pos. JD
circuit breaker
120
CB replacement
O7
MI
$200,000.00
A
2155
ITC
1310
12/31/2007
Waterman 230 kV pos. CF
circuit breaker
230
CB replacement
O7
MI
$200,000.00
A
2154
ITC
1310
12/31/2007
Waterman 230 kV pos. BF
circuit breaker
230
CB replacement
O7
MI
$200,000.00
A
2159
ITC
1310
12/31/2007
St. Clair 120 kV pos. HS
circuit breaker
120
CB replacement
O7
MI
$150,000.00
A
2158
ITC
1310
12/31/2007
St. Clair 120 kV pos. KB
circuit breaker
120
CB replacement
O7
MI
$150,000.00
A
1585
ITC
1488
10/31/2006
Placid 120 kV
Proud 120 kV
1
120
343
N7
MI
14.3
A
1584
ITC
1488
12/31/2006
Placid 120 kV
Durant 120 kV
1
120
343
N7
MI
16.7
$4,000,000.00
A
193
LES
246
12/31/2008
NW68th & Holdrege
NW 12th & Arbor
1
115
373
New Line
F9
NE
10
$1,712,000.00
A
806
LES
804
12/31/2008
19th & Alvo
70th & Bluff
1
115
363
Rebuilt Line
F9
NE
1.5
$300,000.00
A
1576
MDU
548
11/1/2007
Bismarck Downtown
East Bismarck
115
160
Rebuild
D4
ND
$363,000.00
A
1578
MDU
1008
11/1/2009
S Mandan
Bismarck Downtown
115
180
Memorial Bridge circuit replacement
D4
ND
$2,868,000.00
A
1577
MDU
1008
11/1/2009
Heskett
NW Bismarck
115
180
Memorial Bridge circuit replacement
D4
ND
$3,692,000.00
A
1332
METC
481
12/1/2008
Tallmadge 3rd 345/138 kV
transformer
3
345
138
M7
MI
$3,649,203.00
Y
A
1534
METC
481
12/1/2008
Tallmadge Remove Reactors
Tallmadge Remove Reactors
1&2
345
remove 138 kV reactors
MI
$0.00
Y
A
2557
METC
481
12/1/2008
Tallmadge 345 kV
substation upgrades
345
sub upgrades for 3rd transformer
M7
MI
$6,263,887.00
Y
Y
A
1322
METC
497
6/1/2007
Tallmadge
Wealthy
2
138
M7
MI
0
$40,000.00
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Facilities
19 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 20 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Project Facilities Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
App
Facil
Reporting
Expected
Voltage
LS
Rating (Normal /
Map
Miles
Miles
Estimated Facility
Cost
Post
AB
ID
Source
PrjID
ISD
From Sub or Location
To Sub or Device Description
Ckt
(kV)
kV
Emergency)
Upgrade Description
Grid
State
Upg
New
Cost
Shared
Stamp
A
1327
METC
644
6/15/2007
Rogue River J. - METC
Rogue River
1
138
M7
MI
0.1
$160,000.00
A
1328
METC
645
6/1/2007
American Bumper
David
1
138
M7
MI
8
$2,500,000.00
A
1345
METC
658
5/1/2008
Gaylord
Livingston
1
138
M5
MI
1.5
$500,000.00
A
1347
METC
660
5/1/2009
Keystone
Clearwater
1
138
M5
MI
23.2
$10,200,000.00
Y
A
1434
METC
740
3/1/2007
Gallagher
Tittabawassee
1
345
relaying & communications
M5
MI
0
$1,000,000.00
A
1435
METC
740
3/1/2007
Keystone
Livingston
1
345
relaying & communications
M5
MI
0
$1,000,000.00
A
1436
METC
740
3/1/2007
Livingston
Gallagher
1
345
relaying & communications
M5
MI
0
$794,000.00
A
3083
METC
775
3/31/2007
Iosco
Capacitors
1
138
18 Mvar
N6
MI
0
$800,000.00
A
1539
METC
976
5/15/2008
Alpine
Add one line switch
138
Add One switch
MI
$80,000.00
A
1540
METC
977
5/1/2006
Marquette Station
Replace breaker failure
138
Replace breaker failure scheme
MI
$200,000.00
scheme
A
1544
METC
981
6/1/2009
Wabasis J. - N. Belding -
Wabasis
1
138
Install aTap Pole and Switches
MI
$160,000.00
Vergennes
A
1545
METC
982
7/1/2008
Crahen J. -Spaudling - Race
Crahen
1
138
Install a Tap Pole and one switch
MI
$80,000.00
Street
A
1551
METC
988
12/31/2009
Simpson
Batavia
1
138
MI
30
$13,000,000.00
Y
A
1587
METC
1015
6/1/2008
Oden
Oden - New Capacitor
1
138
21.6 Mvar
Oden - New 21.6 Mvar Capacitor
MI
$510,000.00
A
1588
METC
1016
6/1/2007
Bard Road
Bard Road - New Capacitor
1
138
36 Mvar
Bard Road - New 36 Mvar Capacitor
MI
$596,000.00
A
1589
METC
1017
6/1/2007
Croton
Croton - New Capacitor
1
138
36 Mvar
Croton - New 36 Mvar Capacitor
MI
$596,000.00
A
2393
METC
1390
12/1/2007
Goss 345kV
345kV GIS bus and breakers
345
Replace old, leaking 345kV GIS bus & breakers with open-air
MI
$5,800,000.00
type. Patchwork repairs haven't been successful.
A
2394
METC
1391
12/31/2007
Campbell 138kV
Breaker 148
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2395
METC
1392
12/31/2007
Campbell 138kV
Breaker 188
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2396
METC
1393
12/31/2007
Campbell 138kV
Breaker 288
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2397
METC
1394
12/31/2007
Campbell 138kV
Breaker 388
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2398
METC
1395
12/31/2007
Campbell 138kV
Breaker 500
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2399
METC
1396
12/31/2007
Campbell 138kV
Breaker 588
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2400
METC
1397
12/31/2007
Spaulding 138kV
Breaker 36M9
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2401
METC
1398
12/31/2007
Spaulding 138kV
Breaker 36B7
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2402
METC
1399
12/31/2007
Morrow 138kV
Breaker 377
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2403
METC
1400
12/31/2007
Claremont 138kV
Breaker 288
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2404
METC
1401
12/31/2007
Claremont 138kV
Breaker 388
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2405
METC
1402
12/31/2007
Goss 138kV
Breaker 13B7
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2406
METC
1403
12/31/2007
Goss 138kV
Breaker 13M9
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2407
METC
1404
12/31/2007
Argenta 138kV
Breaker 6W8
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2408
METC
1405
12/31/2007
Hemphill 138kV
Breaker 499
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2409
METC
1406
12/31/2008
Alpena 138kV
Breaker 188
138
Replace overdutied breaker with higher capacity breaker.
MI
$160,000.00
A
2410
METC
1407
12/1/2007
Ludington 345kV
Reactor
345
Repair or replace existing 100MVAR reactor and replace
MI
$1,500,000.00
circuit switcher with a breaker
A
2411
METC
1408
5/1/2007
RTU/SCADA upgrades
Throughtout System
345
138
Install and/or upgrade numerous RTU/SCADA points
MI
$801,000.00
A
2413
METC
1410
12/1/2008
Mobile 138kV Capacitor
138
14.4 - 36MVAR
Purchase a mobile 138kV capacitor for use where needed
MI
$700,000.00
during outages, heavy transfers, etc.
A
2414
METC
1411
3/1/2007
Campbell 345kV
Relay Runback SPS on Unit 3
345
Install auto relay runback SPS for Campell Unit 3 per MISO
MI
$75,000.00
G479 Study
A
2415
METC
1412
6/1/2007
Palisades 345kV
Argenta 345kV
1or2
345
Modify phase connections at the Palisades and Argenta ends
MI
$170,000.00
of the 345kV line for Covert project
A
2416
METC
1412
6/1/2007
Palisades 345kV
Cook 345kV
2
345
Modify phase connections at the Palisades and Cook ends of
MI
$735,000.00
the 345kV line for Covert project
A
2417
METC
1413
5/1/2009
Bagley 138kV
Gaylord 138kV
1
138
Rebuild line to 795 ACSS
MI
$350,000.00
A
2418
METC
1414
12/31/2007
Thetford 345kV
Line Relaying
345
Upgrade 345kV line relaying.
MI
$300,000.00
A
2419
METC
1415
10/1/2007
HSC 138kV
Tittabawasee 138kV &
1
138
Install a tap pole and one switch on each of the Tittabawassee-
MI
$160,000.00
Lawndale 138kV
HSC and Lawndale-HSC 138kV lines. (Solar Project)
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Facilities
20 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 21 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Project Facilities Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
App
Facil
Reporting
Expected
Voltage
LS
Rating (Normal /
Map
Miles
Miles
Estimated Facility
Cost
Post
AB
ID
Source
PrjID
ISD
From Sub or Location
To Sub or Device Description
Ckt
(kV)
kV
Emergency)
Upgrade Description
Grid
State
Upg
New
Cost
Shared
Stamp
A
2421
METC
1416
10/1/2007
HSC 138kV
Tittabawasee 138kV
2
138
Install new,second 138kV Tittabawasee-HSC line and 5 total
MI
$4,527,000.00
Y
138kV breakers for connecting the line at each end. (HSC
Project)
A
2420
METC
1416
10/1/2007
HSC 138kV
Tittabawasee 138kV &
1
138
Install a new 2-mile 138kV double circuit to swap the existing
MI
$2,700,000.00
Y
Lawndale 138kV
138kV Tittabawasee and Lawndale line connections into HSC.
(HSC Project)
A
2422
METC
1417
6/1/2007
Race Street 138kV
138kV Tie Breaker
138
Install a 138kV tie-breaker to loop the Spaulding-Four Mile
MI
$2,200,000.00
138kV Line (Race St)
A
2423
METC
1418
5/1/2007
Batavia 138kV
Barton Lake 138kV
1
138
Install a Tap Pole and Two Switches (Kinderhook)
MI
$160,000.00
A
2424
METC
1419
6/1/2007
Hackett Junction 138kV
Saginaw River 138kV
1
138
Install a Tap Pole and one Switch (Laundra)
MI
$80,000.00
A
2425
METC
1420
6/1/2007
North Belding 138kV
Sanderson Junction 138kV
1
138
Install a Tap Pole and one Switch (Sanderson)
MI
$80,000.00
A
2426
METC
1421
12/15/2007
Michigan Junction 138kV
Race Street Junction 138kV
1
138
Install a 138kV tie-breaker and loop the Spaulding-Four Mile
MI
$240,000.00
138 kV Line into new Baraga substation (Baraga)
A
2427
METC
1422
6/1/2007
Marshall 138kV
Hughes Junction 138kV
1
138
Install a Tap Pole and one Switch (Marshall)
MI
$80,000.00
A
2428
METC
1423
6/1/2007
Emmet 138kV
McNally 138kV
1
138
Install a tap pole and two switches on the Emmet-McNally
MI
$500,000.00
138kV line. Purchase the high side of Emmet Substation and
a section of the 138kV line from the substation to the Eppler
tap point. (Eppler)
A
2429
METC
1424
5/1/2007
Delhi 138kV
Churchill Junction 138kV
2
138
Install aTap Pole and Switches (Trillium)
MI
$160,000.00
A
2430
METC
1425
6/1/2008
Keystone 138kV
Elmwood 138kV
1
138
Install a Tap Pole and Switches. Relay upgrades. (Gray Rd)
MI
$300,000.00
A
2437
METC
1433
6/1/2008
Beals 138kV
Hazelwood 138kV
1
138
Install bulk substation served from the Beals-Hazelwood
MI
$2,200,000.00
138kV Line (Buskirk)
A
2438
METC
1434
6/1/2008
Spaulding 138kV
138
Install bulk substation served from the Spaulding 138kV ring
MI
$750,000.00
bus (Five Mile)
A
2441
METC
1437
6/1/2008
Argenta 138kV
Milham 138kV
1
138
Install a tap pole and two switches on Argenta-Milham 138kV
MI
$160,000.00
Line (N Ave)
A
2442
METC
1438
6/1/2008
Wexford 138kV
Tippy 138kV
1
138
Install a tap pole and one switch on Wexford-Tippy 138kV
MI
$80,000.00
Line (Potvin)
A
2443
METC
1439
10/1/2007
Hemphill 138kV
Weadock 138kV
1
138
Install a tap pole and two switches on Hemphill-Weadock
MI
$160,000.00
138kV Line (Busch)
A
2444
METC
1440
6/1/2008
Beals 138kV
Wayland 138kV
1
138
Install a tap pole and two switches on Beals Rd-Wayland-
MI
$80,000.00
Hazelwood 138kV Line (Huckleberry)
A
2445
METC
1441
6/1/2009
Sternberg 138kV
138
Install bulk substation served from a new Ellis spur from
MI
$3,250,000.00
Sternberg (Ellis/Hile Rd)
A
2446
METC
1442
10/1/2007
Fillmore 138kV
Four Mile 138kV
1
138
Install bulk substation served from the Fillmore-Four Mile
MI
$200,000.00
138kV Line (Eastmanville/Pingree)
A
2448
METC
1444
6/1/2011
Bullock 138kV
Edenville Junction 138kV
1
138
Install a tap pole and two switches on Bullock-Edenville 138kV
MI
$160,000.00
Line (Dublin)
A
2449
METC
1445
6/1/2010
Emmet 138kV
distribution
138
Install a second distribution transformer at Emmet (Emmet)
MI
$2,750,000.00
A
2450
METC
1446
6/1/2010
Gaines 138kV
138
Install bulk substation at Gaines (Gaines)
MI
$50,000.00
A
2451
METC
1447
6/1/2010
Eureka 138kV
Vestaburg 138kV
1
138
Install bulk substation served from the Eureka-Deja-Vestaburg
MI
$2,200,000.00
138kV Line (Horseshoe Creek/Deja)
A
2453
METC
1449
6/1/2010
Cobb 138kV
Tallmadge 138kV
2
138
Install bulk substation served from the Cobb-Tallmadge #2
MI
$160,000.00
138kV Line (Juniper)
A
2039
MP
1
6/30/2008
Arrowhead
Capacitor
230
2 x 75 Mvar
I4
MN
$1,858,227.20
A
318
MP
1
6/30/2008
Arrowhead 230-230 kV
Phase-Shifter
1
230
230
800
I4
MN
$13,741,772.80
A
319
MP
1
6/30/2008
Arrowhead 345/230 kV
transformer
1
345
230
800
I4
MN
$10,400,000.00
A
2258
MP
1358
12/30/2006
Grand Rapids
Capacitor
115
1x27 Mvar
add new
b11
MN
$320,000.00
A
1098
MPC/XEL/OTP
279
7/1/2010
Boswell
Wilton
1
230
390
Add a new 230 kV line between Boswell and Wilton
H4
MN
85
$35,963,000.00
Y
A
3032
MRES
755
6/1/2007
Alexandria Switching Station
Capacitors
115
25 Mvar
Add a 1 x 25 MVAr capacitor bank at the Alexandria Switching
G5
MN
$530,000.00
Station
A
3034
NIPS
757
2/1/2007
Dune Acres
Capacitor
138
Add Capacitor - (1) 100 MVAR step
L8
IN
$1,083,600.00
A
970
NIPS
925
12/1/2006
ISG2
Marktown
1
138
316
Upgrade Connections and Circuit
IN
0.6
$240,500.00
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Facilities
21 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 22 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Project Facilities Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
App
Facil
Reporting
Expected
Voltage
LS
Rating (Normal /
Map
Miles
Miles
Estimated Facility
Cost
Post
AB
ID
Source
PrjID
ISD
From Sub or Location
To Sub or Device Description
Ckt
(kV)
kV
Emergency)
Upgrade Description
Grid
State
Upg
New
Cost
Shared
Stamp
A
2128
NIPS
1298
5/1/2008
Inland #5
Marktown
1
138
316/380
Upgrade Connections and Circuit
2.2
$750,000.00
A
377
OTP
274
8/1/2008
Appleton
Louisburg
1
115
96
Convert an existing 41.6 kV line to 115 kV
G5
MN
6.9
$474,000.00
A
378
OTP
275
8/1/2008
Dawson
Canby
1
115
96
Convert an existing 41.6 kV line to 115 kV
G8
MN
21.1
$538,000.00
A
2266
OTP
1362
8/1/2008
Louisurg
Dawson
1
115
96
Convert an existing 41.6 kV line to 115 kV
G6
MN
14.4
$988,000.00
A
2516
OTP
1462
9/1/2007
Rugby
substation
230
upgrade the Rugby Substation to accommodate the
ND
$705,931.00
Y
interconnection of the Interconnection Customer’s 230 kV
radial transmission line into the Rugby Substation.
A
2515
OTP
1462
9/1/2007
Rugby
bus
230
radial bus within the Rugby Substation needed to
ND
$104,809.00
accommodate the interconnection of the Interconnection
Customer’s 230 kV radial transmission line into the substation
230 kV bus.
A
2514
OTP
1462
9/1/2007
Rugby
radial line
230
The new 230 KV overhead radial transmission line
ND
9
$88,000.00
Interconnection Facilities from the Interconnection Customer’s
collector substation to the Transmission Owner’s Rugby
Substation.
A
60
SIPC
81
6/1/2007
Marion
CarrierMills
1
161
286
K11
IL
27
$7,083,000.00
A
1900
WPSC
1205
8/1/2006
Cheboygan II
Breaker
69
Add Breaker at Cheboygan II
MI
$550,000.00
A
1901
WPSC
1206
8/1/2006
Lake County
Bass Lake
69
102.4 MVA
Rebuild Overloaded Line
MI
8.35
$1,800,000.00
A
1902
WPSC
1207
8/1/2006
Hersey
Osceola
69
35.9 MVA
Rerate Overloaded Line
MI
4.02
$200,000.00
A
1903
WPSC
1208
8/1/2006
Oden
12MVAR cap. Bank
69
Add 12MVAR at Oden Sub.
MI
$300,000.00
A
1926
WPSC
1226
2/1/2008
Kalkaska Generation
Westwood
1
69
102.4
Rebuild 69 kV Line
MI
11.62
0
$2,905,000.00
A
1927
WPSC
1227
2/1/2008
Gaylord Generation
Bagley Junction
1
69
102.4
Rebuild 69 kV Line
MI
4
0
$1,000,000.00
A
1928
WPSC
1228
8/1/2008
Westwood
New Load
69
Add 14MW Load to Westwood
MI
$1,800,000.00
A
1929
WPSC
1229
11/1/2006
Plains X
Bus Upgrade
69
Upgrade exsisting 69KV bus
MI
$625,000.00
A
1930
WPSC
1230
9/1/2006
White Cloud
Bus Upgrade
69
Upgrade exsisting 69KV bus
MI
$625,000.00
A
1931
WPSC
1231
6/1/2006
Superior
New Load
69
Add new load tap off 69KV line
MI
$550,000.00
A
1994
WPSC
1272
8/1/2010
Redwood 138
Redwood 69
138
69
75MVA
Add 75MV transformer
MI
0
$1,900,000.00
A
2563
WPSC
1465
10/1/2007
G418, 69 kV line upgrades
69
69 kV line upgrades
MI
$1,080,000.00
Y
A
2562
WPSC
1465
10/1/2007
Redwood 138/69
transformer
138
69
MI
$2,022,328.00
Y
A
2526
WPSC
1465
10/1/2007
Donaldson Creek Sub
generator
138
1
138.9 MW
new wind generation interconnecting at Donaldson Creek
MI
Substation
A
2528
WPSC
1465
10/1/2007
Donaldson Creek Sub
radial line
138
Construction of a new 138 kV transmission line from the
MI
6
$1,080,000.00
Generating Facility Collector Substation to the Transmission
Owner’s Donaldson Creek 138 kV Substation will be required.
A
2529
WPSC
1465
10/1/2007
Donaldson Creek Sub
network upgrades
138
138 kV circuit breakers at POI
MI
$845,291.00
Y
A
2527
WPSC
1465
10/1/2007
Donaldson Creek Sub
interconnection upgrades
138
The 138 kV double circuit line with one side operated at 69 kV
MI
$164,997.00
and the other at 138 kV, connecting the Transmission Owner’s
Donaldson Creek Substation and the Generating Facilities’
138 kV Collector Station
A
306
XEL
56
12/31/2010
Lindstrom
Shafer
1
115
310
New line
Q4
MN
2.8
$5,800,000.00
A
303
XEL
56
12/31/2010
Lawrence Creek
St Croix Falls
1
161
371
New 161 kV line
Q4
MN
2.05
$9,080,000.00
A
301
XEL
56
12/31/2010
Chisago
Lindstrom
1
115
310
New 115 kV line
Q4
MN
7
$10,100,000.00
A
310
XEL
56
12/31/2010
Shafer
Lawrence Creek
1
115
310
New line
Q4
MN
6.2
$3,500,000.00
A
304
XEL
56
12/31/2010
Lawrence Creek 161-115 kV
transformer
1
161
115
336
New substation with 161-115 kV transformer
Q4
MN
$6,000,000.00
A
563
XEL
267
5/1/2007
Lawrence
Minnehaha
1
115
310
Upgrade existing line
G7
SD
5.2
$829,667.00
A
564
XEL
268
5/1/2007
Minnehaha
Lincoln County
1
115
310
Upgrade existing line
G7
SD
5.8
$925,398.00
A
1137
XEL
269
6/1/2007
Prairie Island
Red Rock
2
345
1198
Upgrade existing line
Q6
MN
32
$807,000.00
A
1138
XEL
270
6/1/2007
Champlin
Champlin Tap
1
115
310
Upgrade existing line
O4
MN
2.4
$382,923.00
A
277
XEL
272
6/1/2007
Air Lake
Vermillion River
1
115
200
New line
TC detaMN
4.2
$3,359,095.21
A
572
XEL
366
6/1/2007
Sherco
Monticello
1
115
310
Upgrade existing line
H5
MN
2.2
1
$714,344.00
A
573
XEL
366
6/1/2007
Sherco 345-115 kV
transformer
1
345
115
448
New transformer
H5
MN
$3,001,443.00
A
574
XEL
366
6/1/2007
St Cloud
I94 Industrial Park tap
1
115
310
Upgrade existing line
H5
MN
5
$850,409.00
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Facilities
22 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 23 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Project Facilities Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
App
Facil
Reporting
Expected
Voltage
LS
Rating (Normal /
Map
Miles
Miles
Estimated Facility
Cost
Post
AB
ID
Source
PrjID
ISD
From Sub or Location
To Sub or Device Description
Ckt
(kV)
kV
Emergency)
Upgrade Description
Grid
State
Upg
New
Cost
Shared
Stamp
A
569
XEL
366
6/1/2007
I94 Industrial Park tap
Salida Crossing
1
115
310
Upgrade existing line
H5
MN
14.3
$2,432,170.00
A
571
XEL
366
6/1/2007
Salida Crossing
Sherco
1
115
310
Upgrade existing line
H5
MN
2.5
1
$765,368.00
A
268
XEL
377
1/1/2007
Minn Valley
Redwood Falls Tap
1
115
310
Upgrade existing 115 kV line
G6
MN
27.2
$9,380,127.53
A
307
XEL
385
10/1/2007
Nobles Co
Lakefield Jct
1
345
2085
New line
G7
MN
42
$37,070,397.41
A
308
XEL
385
10/1/2007
Nobles Co
Fenton
1
115
600
New line
G7
MN
12
$7,913,905.06
A
309
XEL
385
10/1/2007
Nobles Co 345-115 kV
transformer
1
345
115
600
New transformer
G7
MN
$5,792,804.96
A
272
XEL
385
10/1/2007
Redwood Falls Tap
Franklin
1
115
310
Upgrade existing 115 kV line
H6
MN
13
$3,185,000.00
A
537
XEL
385
11/1/2007
Buffalo Ridge
Yankee
1
115
620
New 115 kV line
MN
A
311
XEL
385
11/1/2007
Split Rock
Nobles Co
1
345
2085
New line
G7
MN
52
$44,966,947.42
A
2315
XEL
385
11/1/2007
Yankee
Brookings County
1
115
620
New 115 kV line
MN
A
302
XEL
385
11/1/2007
Fenton
Chanarambie
1
115
600
New 115 kV line
G6
MN
14
$7,412,392.63
A
2041
XEL
385
11/1/2007
Nobles Co
Capacitor
115
40 Mvar
New capacitor
G7
MN
$634,038.22
A
2283
XEL
385
11/1/2008
Brookings Co
White
2
345
2085
New 345 kV line
G7
SD/MN
A
975
XEL
385
6/1/2010
Nobles Co 345-115 kV
transformer
2
345
115
672
New transformer
G7
MN
$5,792,804.96
A
2038
XEL
417
6/1/2007
Westgate
Capacitor
115
80 Mvar
New capacitor
H6
MN
$1,500,000.00
A
800
XEL
609
6/1/2007
Long Lake
Oakdale (from Woodbury)
1
115
310
Upgrade existing line
P5
MN
3.7
$760,000.00
A
1359
XEL
671
6/1/2007
Oakdale
Tanners Lake
1
115
223
Upgrade existing line
P5
MN
5.2
$800,000.00
A
1361
XEL
673
6/1/2008
Champlin Tap
Crooked Lake
1
115
223
Upgrade existing line
TC detaMN
3.1
$310,000.00
A
1362
XEL
674
5/1/2008
High Bridge
Rogers Lake
1
115
585
Upgrade existing line
TC detaMN
4.2
$2,400,000.00
A
3088
XEL
780
11/1/2007
Fieldon Township
Series Capacitor
345
20 ohms
New series capacitor on LGS-Wilmarth 345
H6
MN
$10,100,000.00
A
803
XEL
1031
3/1/2005
Kasson
Dodge Center
1
69
84
upgrade line
I6
MN
7.8
$780,000.00
A
1079
XEL
1034
6/1/2006
Loon Lake 115-69 kV
transformer
1
115
69
112
H6
MN
$1,774,000.00
A
2274
XEL
1364
5/1/2007
Lakefield Jct
Lakefield Generation
1
345
1165
Raise the structures to increase the thermal rating
G6
MN
A
2275
XEL
1365
6/1/2007
Edina
Eden Prairie
1
115
310
Reconductor
TC detaMN
4.7
$3,730,000.00
A
2277
XEL
1366
5/1/2008
Colvill Generating station
Transformer
1
161
115
187
New sub with transformer relocated from Cannon Falls
I5
MN
$10,428,380.00
Y
substation
A
2281
XEL
1366
5/1/2008
Colvill Generating station
Spring Creek
1
161
234
Build in and out of the Covill generating station from Cannon
I5
MN
$365,000.00
Y
Falls - Spring Creek line
A
2280
XEL
1366
5/1/2008
Colvill Generating station
Empire
1
115
200
Build in and out of the Colvill generating station from Cannon
I5
MN
$3,150,000.00
Y
Falls - Empire 115 kV line
A
2278
XEL
1366
5/1/2008
Colvill Generating station
Cannon Falls
1
115
140
Build in and out of the Colvill generating station from Cannon
I5
MN
$0.00
Y
Falls - Empire 115 kV line
A
2279
XEL
1366
5/1/2008
Colvill Generating station
Cannon Falls
2
115
167
Build in and out of the Covill generating station from Cannon
I5
MN
$0.00
Y
Falls - Spring Creek line
A
2491
XEL
1456
11/1/2007
Yankee
transformer
118
36.2
120 MVA
a new 120 MVA, 118-36.2 kV transformer, a 115 kV breaker,
MN
$2,826,000.00
Y
switches, and 34.5 kV breakers and switches and all other
associated equipment.
A
2490
XEL
1456
11/1/2007
Yankee
feeders
34.5
Two 50 MW 34.5 kV feeders and all associated equipment
MN
$531,600.00
A
2303
XEL
1457
6/1/2010
Nobles County
Fenton
2
115
620
New 115 kV line plus permitting and ROW
MN
$13,560,000.00
Y
A
2565
XEL
1457
12/31/2010
Nobles County
substation
345
345 kV substation upgrades
MN
$344,270.00
Y
Y
A
2494
XEL
1457
12/31/2010
Nobles
feeders
34.5
four new 50 MW 34.5 kV feeders and all associated
MN
$1,100,000.00
equipment at Nobles County Sub.
A
2550
XEL
1457
12/31/2010
Nobles County
substation
115
Substation upgrades
MN
$11,992,730.00
Y
A
2552
XEL
1457
12/31/2010
Fenton County
substation
115
Substation upgrades
MN
$776,000.00
Y
A
2551
XEL
1457
12/31/2010
Hazel Creek (Hazel Run)
substation
115
New Substation and in-and-out taps to transmission
MN
$10,962,000.00
Y
A
2549
XEL
1458
6/1/2010
Hazel Creek
Capacitor
115
53 MVAR
Capacitor Bank, 115 kV CB, 0.33 Mvar SVC
MN
$5,290,000.00
Y
A
2299
XEL
1458
6/1/2010
Yankee
Brookings County
2
115
310
New 115 kV line plus permitting and ROW
G7
MN
$9,955,000.00
Y
A
2554
XEL
1458
12/31/2010
Brookings Co
substation
345
115
448 MVA
Substation upgrades (new 345/115 transformer, 3-115 kV CB,
MN
$6,101,122.00
Y
associated equip)
A
2553
XEL
1458
12/31/2010
Yankee
substation
115
120 MVA
Substation upgrades (new 115/34.5 transformer, 8-115 kV CB,
MN
$7,120,000.00
Y
4 -34.5 kV CB)
A
2566
XEL
1458
12/31/2010
Brookings Co
substation
345
Substation upgrades 4-345 kV CB
MN
$1,313,878.00
Y
Y
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Facilities
23 of 24
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-51
Page 24 of 24
MTEP06 Appendix A - Project Facilities Recommended for Board Approval - 1/30/2007
App
Facil
Reporting
Expected
Voltage
LS
Rating (Normal /
Map
Miles
Miles
Estimated Facility
Cost
Post
AB
ID
Source
PrjID
ISD
From Sub or Location
To Sub or Device Description
Ckt
(kV)
kV
Emergency)
Upgrade Description
Grid
State
Upg
New
Cost
Shared
Stamp
A
2496
XEL
1458
11/30/2011
Yankee
feeders
34.5
four new 50 MW underground feeder lines and all associated
MN
$2,202,000.00
equipment
A
2564
XEL
1459
1/1/2009
Dakota County Sub
in-and-out tap
345
tap Blue Lake-Prairie Island 345 kVl ine
MN
$2,425,500.00
Y
Y
A
2523
XEL
1464
11/15/2005
McHenry
Souris
115
12 MW
new generation interconnection on the McHenry - Souris 115
ND
kV line
A
2548
XEL
1489
6/1/2011
Woodbury
Tanners Lake
1
115
Upgrade to 310 MVA
MN
3.49
$525,000.00
A
2484
XEL (NSP)
1454
10/1/2007
Yankee
Transformer
115
34.5
120 MVA
New Transformer, plus 1 115 kv breaker and two 34.5 kV
MN
$2,306,000.00
breakers
A
2488
XEL (NSP)
1455
5/1/2009
Riverside Generating Plant
breakers
115
IC to install 115 kV breakers on IC side of interconnection
MN
$165,000.00
facilities as well as two sets of metering equipment
A
2489
XEL (NSP)
1455
5/1/2009
Riverside Generating Plant
Apache Substation
115
63 kA CB
IC to install three new 115 kV, 63 kA interrupting rating circuit
MN
$2,605,000.00
breakers, six 115 kV switches, two 115 kV current coupling
voltage transformers, as well as relocate the existing Apache
115 kV line to a new termination in the substation.
A
645
XEL/WAPA
385
11/1/2007
Brookings Co
White
1
345
600
G6
SD
2
A
646
XEL/WAPA
385
11/1/2007
Brookings Co
345/115 transformer
1
345
115
672
G6
SD
$12,179,190.00
A
828
DEM
853
6/1/2015
West Lafayette
Cumberland Ave
1
138
306
13806 reconductor with 954ACSR 100C 604F6325
L9
IN
2
$646,000.00
MTEP06_Appendix_A_2007-01-30.xls, Facilities
24 of 24
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-52
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-52
Page 1 of 1
NYISO/MISO 3-8. Were the Replacement PARs designed and constructed to perform the same
function as the Original PAR was designed and constructed to perform?
a. If your answer to NYISO/MISO 3-8 is “no,” please explain the differing
purposes that the Original PAR and Replacement PARs were each constructed
to perform, and provide copies of all Documents that support your response.
b. If your answer to NYISO/MISO 3-8 is “no,” please provide the design
specifications for both the Original PAR and Replacement PARs.
Response: In general, yes. The Original PAR performed a function of controlling loop flow but
had lesser capability than the New PARs. MISO understands that the New PARs have greater
capabilities help to control Lake Erie loop flow than the Original PAR. MISO does not have in
its possession or control the design specifications of the Original PAR or the New PARs which it
understands are different. MISO maintains its prior objection to the extent such information is
not within MISO’s possession or controland refers NYISO to ITC for information responsive to
this request. MISO also states that it has identified approximately 18,000 potentially relevant
documents responsive to NYISO data requests and is engaged in relevance and privilege review.
MISO intends to attempt in good faith to provide a more complete response, subject to the
Protective Order issued on January 23, 2012 on a rolling basis as Documents are identified.
Sponsored by:
Kevin Frankeny
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-53
REDACTED
PROTECTED MATERIAL
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-54
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-54
Page 1 of 1
NYISO/ITC 1-14. Please explain why the costs of the Replacement PARs were not allocated
within MISO to other than ITC customers, and provide copies of all Documents that ITC relies
on to support its explanation.
Response to NYIS/ITC 1-14: The project was approved as a like for like replacement and thus
was not eligible for cost sharing within MISO under MISO tariff Attachment FF. Please refer to
the Midwest ISO MTEP06 Midwest ISO Transmission Expansion Plan, December 2006
(Revised February 2007) pages 173, 182, Appendix A page 7, Appendix A page 19 which is
Response prepared by Carlo Capra
17
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-55
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 1 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 2 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 3 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 4 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 5 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 6 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 7 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 8 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 9 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 10 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 11 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 12 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 13 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 14 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 15 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 16 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 17 of 18
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-55
Page 18 of 18
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-56
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-56
Page 1 of 4
DECO_NYISO1-11_000006
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-56
Page 2 of 4
DECO_NYISO1-11_000007
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-56
Page 3 of 4
DECO_NYISO1-11_000008
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-56
Page 4 of 4
DECO_NYISO1-11_000009
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-57
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-57
Page 1 of 10
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-57
Page 2 of 10
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-57
Page 3 of 10
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-57
Page 4 of 10
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-57
Page 5 of 10
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-57
Page 6 of 10
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-57
Page 7 of 10
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-57
Page 8 of 10
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-57
Page 9 of 10
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-57
Page 10 of 10
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-58
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 1 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 2 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 3 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 4 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 5 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 6 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 7 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 8 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 9 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 10 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 11 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 12 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 13 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 14 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 15 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 16 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 17 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 18 of 19
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-58
Page 19 of 19
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-59
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 1 of 44
Direction of Transaction
# of Transactions
MW
MISO->ONT
749
59644
ONT->MISO
1464
186731
Total
2213
246375
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 2 of 44
TagName
Source
Sink
Flowgate TLRConfirmationTime
TLREffectiveTime TLRLevel
IssuingRC
ScheduleMW
TDF
CutMW
ImpactStatus
TLRHour
OutsideRestriction
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/12/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.003038
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/13/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.458598
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/13/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
33
5.458598
33
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/13/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.292301
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/13/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.292301
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/13/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.308484
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/13/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.308484
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/13/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.297507
83
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/13/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.297507
41
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/13/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.280073
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/13/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.280073
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.298422
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.298422
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.303334
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.303334
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
473
5.365261
116
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.365261
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.365261
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.46183
57
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.46183
28
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/14/2009 18:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
5.033962
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/14/2009 18:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
51
5.033962
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.498296
66
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.498296
66
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.498296
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
200
5.498296
132
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
200
5.486883
183
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.486883
92
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/14/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.486883
92
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/15/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
200
5.487386
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/15/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.487386
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/15/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.487386
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/15/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.487386
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/15/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.498573
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/15/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.498573
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/15/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
75
5.498573
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/15/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.489339
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/15/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.489339
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/15/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.704223
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/15/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
6.704223
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/15/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.486101
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/15/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.486101
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/15/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.701478
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/15/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
6.701478
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/15/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.487226
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/15/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.487226
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/15/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.622639
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/15/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
6.622639
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/15/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.486796
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/15/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.486796
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/15/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.622572
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 3 of 44
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/15/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
6.622572
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/16/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.704632
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/16/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
6.704632
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/16/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.704721
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/16/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
6.704721
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/16/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.703481
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/16/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
6.703481
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/16/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.7312
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/16/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
6.7312
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/16/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
473
5.042651
79
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
1/17/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
19
6.198553
19
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
1/17/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
6.210641
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
1/17/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
6.210641
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
1/17/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
6.20025
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
1/17/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
6.20025
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/17/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
5.115336
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/17/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
51
5.115336
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/17/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.493875
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/17/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.493875
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
1/17/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
6.188203
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
1/17/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
6.188203
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/17/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
5.109645
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/17/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
51
5.109645
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/17/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.472578
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/17/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.472578
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
1/17/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
6.145813
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
1/17/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
6.145813
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/17/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.494071
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/17/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.494071
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/17/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.41103
1
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/17/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.41103
1
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/17/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.282729
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/17/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.282729
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/17/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.278502
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/17/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.278502
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.304669
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.304669
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.304669
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.304669
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.355016
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.355016
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.484429
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.484429
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.480491
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.480491
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.488565
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.488565
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.487625
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.487625
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 6:05 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.48806
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 6:05 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.48806
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.483918
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 4 of 44
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.483918
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.484688
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.484688
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.482242
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.481369
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.486742
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 13:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.487567
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/18/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
5.137791
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/18/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
51
5.137791
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.467511
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.467511
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/18/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
5.093436
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/18/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
5.093436
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/18/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
51
5.093436
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/18/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
51
5.093436
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.469183
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.469183
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.48156
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.48156
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/18/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.492145
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/19/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.504223
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/19/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.51684
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/19/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.454307
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/19/2009 14:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.295959
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/19/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.365262
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/19/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.365262
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/19/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.494373
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/19/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
6.494373
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.290157
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.290157
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.283775
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.283775
32
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.283775
16
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.290513
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.290513
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.292144
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.292144
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 14:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
473
5.654837
473
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
473
5.531533
473
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
473
5.717987
473
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
473
5.385102
473
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 18:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
473
5.379789
4
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/21/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
473
5.236366
210
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/21/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
100
5.257408
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/21/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
100
5.257408
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/21/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
100
5.188547
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/21/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
140
5.270004
140
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/21/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
140
5.423277
140
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 1613
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/22/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.591295
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/22/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
22
5.593173
22
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/22/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.956156
97
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/22/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.956156
48
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 5 of 44
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/22/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.038513
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/23/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.664123
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/23/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.025906
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/23/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.025906
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/23/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
75
6.025906
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/23/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.657582
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/23/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
200
5.657582
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/23/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.657582
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/23/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.006823
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/23/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
200
6.006823
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/23/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
150
5.638658
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/23/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.612541
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/23/2009 18:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.95603
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/23/2009 18:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.95603
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/28/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.193492
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/28/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
75
6.193492
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/28/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
75
6.193492
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/28/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
75
6.193492
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/28/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.193492
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/28/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.193492
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.911368
8
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.911368
4
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
200
5.911368
16
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
150
5.911368
12
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.22336
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
6.22336
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
65
6.22336
65
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
150
6.22336
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.22336
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
6.22336
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.951052
15
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
200
5.951052
58
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.951052
29
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.951052
29
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
31
5.944531
31
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
75
5.912762
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.912762
34
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.912762
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/29/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.912762
16
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
1/29/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.58532
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
1/29/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.58532
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
1/29/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.58532
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
1/29/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.58532
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
1/29/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.49204
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
1/29/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.49204
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
1/29/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.49204
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
1/29/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
126
11.48515
90
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
1/29/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.48515
72
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
1/29/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.48515
72
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
1/29/2009 18:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.48967
59
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
1/29/2009 19:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
50
11.46838
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
1/29/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
50
11.47227
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 6 of 44
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
1/29/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
125
11.46885
125
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
1/29/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.46885
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/1/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.749268
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/1/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.749268
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
2/1/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.935147
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 3250
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
2/1/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
6.935147
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 3250
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/1/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.922261
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/1/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.922261
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
2/1/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.952529
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 3250
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
2/1/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
6.952529
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 3250
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/1/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.706533
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/1/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.706533
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
2/1/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
7.002065
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 3250
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
2/1/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
7.002065
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 3250
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
2/1/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
7.002065
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 3250
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/1/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.055058
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/1/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.055058
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/1/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
6.055058
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/1/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.796321
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/1/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.796321
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/1/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
37
6.277942
37
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/1/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
6.022461
37
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/1/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
6.022461
18
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/2/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.780548
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/2/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
67
5.785975
67
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/2/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.04363
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/2/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.796478
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/2/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
6.003189
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/2/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
6.003189
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/2/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.359798
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/2/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.359798
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/2/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.759143
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/2/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.759143
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/2/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.254847
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/2/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.254847
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/5/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.098382
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/5/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
6.098382
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 6:15 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
9.84097
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 6:15 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
9.84097
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
9.841034
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
9.841034
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/5/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.939185
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/5/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.939185
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
9.865128
28
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
9.865128
14
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
10.10066
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
9.719097
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
9.719097
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
9.719097
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/6/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
175
6.069949
175
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/6/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
6.069949
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/6/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
6.069949
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 7 of 44
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/7/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.608572
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/7/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.608572
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/7/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.256075
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/7/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
6.256075
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/7/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.84082
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/7/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.84082
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/7/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.40338
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/7/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
6.40338
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/7/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.616024
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/7/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.616024
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/7/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.251502
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/7/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
6.251502
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
150
5.556698
24
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.556698
16
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.556698
16
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.556698
16
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
200
5.556698
31
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.804664
46
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.804664
46
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.804664
46
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.804664
46
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
200
5.804664
92
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.804664
23
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.604988
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.604988
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.604988
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.997497
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.749325
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.011037
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 18:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.754384
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 19:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.743808
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 19:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.743808
11
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 19:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.743808
5
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.000683
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.000683
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.000683
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.000683
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.75699
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.762035
19
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/9/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.762035
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/10/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
6.001904
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/10/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.727713
44
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 3405
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/10/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.727713
44
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 3405
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/10/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
50
10.11047
44
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/10/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
50
10.11047
44
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/10/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
50
5.728416
18
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/10/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.728416
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/10/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
75
5.984159
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/10/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.984159
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/10/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
75
10.11231
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 3250
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/10/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
10.11231
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 3250
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/12/2009 14:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
8
6.214501
8
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 8 of 44
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/18/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
9.86251
48
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/18/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
9.86251
23
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/18/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
9.86251
46
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/18/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
9.826501
95
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/18/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
9.826501
47
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/18/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
9.826501
92
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/6/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.705836
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/6/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.705836
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/6/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.713559
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/6/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.713559
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/6/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.671563
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/6/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.671563
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/6/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.663571
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/6/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.663571
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/7/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.738635
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/7/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.738635
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/7/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.694221
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/7/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.694221
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/7/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.695571
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/7/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.695571
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/7/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.755503
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/7/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.755503
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/7/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.578207
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/7/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.578207
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/7/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.291818
99
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/7/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.291818
49
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/8/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.300058
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/8/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.300058
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/8/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.369887
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/8/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.369887
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/8/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.318762
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/8/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.318762
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/8/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.384923
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/8/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.384923
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.326536
82
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.326536
40
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.283791
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.283791
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.353569
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.353569
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.286243
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.286243
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.286243
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.286243
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.286758
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.286758
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.050095
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.050095
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 18:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.042955
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 18:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.042955
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
10/9/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.042758
7
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
10/9/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.042758
3
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 9 of 44
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.042758
7
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/9/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.042758
3
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
10/10/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
9
5.104872
9
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/10/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
9
5.104872
9
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 522
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/11/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.016364
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/11/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.016364
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
7.848221
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
7.848221
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
7.848221
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
7.850106
84
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
7.850106
41
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
7.846865
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
7.846865
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
7.843679
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
7.843679
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
7.825107
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
7.825107
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
7.811956
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
7.811956
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 14:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
50
7.337492
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 14:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
7.337492
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
7.364186
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
7.364186
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
7.369688
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
7.369688
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 18:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
7.387744
71
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/18/2009 18:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
7.387744
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/19/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
7.683793
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
15997
10/19/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
7.683793
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/21/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.236794
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/21/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.236794
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/25/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.141496
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/25/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.141496
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/25/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.320292
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/25/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.320292
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/25/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.121435
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/25/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.121435
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/25/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
126
5.116946
126
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
10/29/2009 1:15 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.430083
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
10/29/2009 1:15 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.430083
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
10/29/2009 1:15 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.430083
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
10/29/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.428509
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 2975
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
10/29/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
100
5.428509
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 2975
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/29/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
5.428509
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 522
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/29/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
5.428509
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 522
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/29/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.429317
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/29/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.429317
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/29/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.496806
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/29/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.496806
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/30/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.681452
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/30/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.681452
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
11/2/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.941367
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 10 of 44
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
11/2/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.941367
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
11/2/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.875524
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
11/2/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.875524
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
11/2/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
5.970862
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
11/2/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
5.970862
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
11/2/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
104
6.032644
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
11/2/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
PJM
51
6.032644
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
5.442776
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
7
5.442776
7
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.442776
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.442776
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
5.430645
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.430645
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.430645
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.434007
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.434007
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
5.434444
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.434444
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.434444
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.434352
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.434352
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
5.440781
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.440781
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.440781
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
5.342527
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.342527
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.342527
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/23/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
5.029518
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/23/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
5.164342
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/23/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
5.164342
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/24/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.01028
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/24/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.01028
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/24/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.014966
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/24/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.014966
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/24/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.0694
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/24/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.0694
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/24/2009 13:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.06905
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/24/2009 13:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.06905
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/24/2009 14:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.051536
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/24/2009 14:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
51
5.051536
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.8168
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
12.8168
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.49209
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.49209
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.65927
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.65927
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.57397
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.57397
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.53809
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.53809
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.71659
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.71659
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 11 of 44
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.54802
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.54802
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
4/5/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
11.76183
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
4/5/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
24
11.7347
24
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
4/5/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
11.74617
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
4/5/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.68499
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
4/5/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.73752
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
4/5/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.74632
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
7104
4/5/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
38.22868
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
4/5/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.79515
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
7104
4/6/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
38.10456
70
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
4/6/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.75104
70
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
7104
4/6/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
38.16793
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
7104
4/6/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
104
38.16793
14
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
4/6/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.84377
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
4/6/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
11.84377
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - MISO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
4/6/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.57543
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
4/6/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
11.57543
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - MISO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
4/6/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.59153
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
4/6/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
11.59153
66
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/6/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
12.92583
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - MISO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/6/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.81396
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/6/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
12.81396
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - MISO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/6/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.81802
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/6/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
12.81802
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/7/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
50
13.29785
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/7/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.22707
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/8/2011 5:15 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.52642
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/8/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.40279
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/8/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.3226
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/8/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.3226
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/8/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.64072
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/8/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.64072
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2337
4/12/2011 2:15 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
14.933
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2337
4/12/2011 2:15 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
14.933
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/13/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.67305
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/13/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
12.67305
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/13/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.41555
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/13/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.41555
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/13/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.41881
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/13/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.41881
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/13/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.40901
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/13/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.40901
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/13/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.42536
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/13/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.42536
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/13/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
15.05692
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/13/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
15.05692
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/13/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.41743
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/13/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.41743
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/13/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.45195
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/13/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.45195
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2337
4/13/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
14.45252
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 12 of 44
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2337
4/13/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
14.45252
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.56492
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.56492
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.65645
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.65645
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.67847
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.62701
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.65003
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.57728
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.58043
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.86322
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.57205
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.57205
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.55305
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.5757
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.47801
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.59122
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
12.59122
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.5205
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
12.5205
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.25889
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.41319
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2337
4/14/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
15.02967
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.41992
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2337
4/15/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
15.02713
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2337
4/15/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
15.08424
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2337
4/15/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
15.03823
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2337
4/15/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
15.05568
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/15/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
15.75907
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/15/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
15.65866
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/16/2011 13:15 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.86269
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/16/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.84618
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/16/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.80499
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/16/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.80499
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/16/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.85301
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/16/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.83249
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/16/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.80089
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/16/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
12.80089
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/16/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.80517
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/16/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.98252
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/16/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.03003
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/16/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.93194
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/16/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
12.93194
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/17/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.97194
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/17/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.92879
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/17/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
12.96084
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/17/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
13.26601
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3459
4/18/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.21218
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3459
4/18/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.21218
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3459
4/18/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.1505
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3459
4/18/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
11.1505
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3459
4/19/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.25048
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 13 of 44
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3459
4/19/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
11.2783
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/25/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
9.4179
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/25/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
9.297578
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/25/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
9.402982
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/25/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
9.393271
79
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/25/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
9.366772
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/25/2011 8:10 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
10.39901
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/25/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
9.818097
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/25/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
9.705314
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/25/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
9.714314
94
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
5/3/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
12.89636
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
17017
5/3/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
13.07582
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/9/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
ICTE
104
5.694506
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/9/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
ICTE
104
5.754837
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/9/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
ICTE
104
5.709442
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3167
5/18/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.146237
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3167
5/18/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.175633
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3167
5/18/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.342193
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3167
5/18/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.412531
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3167
5/19/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
71
6.771636
71
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3167
5/19/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.603784
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3167
5/19/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.588911
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3167
5/19/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.32631
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3167
5/19/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.416803
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3167
5/19/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.94754
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3167
5/25/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
6.648245
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3167
5/25/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
7.376907
5
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3167
5/25/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
7.352919
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3167
5/25/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
7.368984
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3167
5/26/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
7.384053
8
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 16807
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16893
5/27/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
6.960112
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16893
5/27/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
6.959237
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16893
5/27/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
6.99501
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16893
5/27/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
7.060184
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16893
5/27/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
6.977157
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16893
5/27/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
7.004453
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16893
5/27/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
7.053423
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16893
5/27/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
6.995097
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16893
5/27/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
7.005715
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16893
5/27/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
TVA
104
6.9341
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
12/22/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.48108
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
12/23/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
104
5.489765
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
12/23/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
50
5.596741
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
12/23/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
50
5.596741
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
12/24/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
50
5.606456
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
12/24/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
50
5.606456
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
12/24/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
50
5.468693
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/13/2009 5:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
104
5.302974
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/13/2009 5:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
104
5.303278
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/13/2009 5:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
51
5.302974
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/13/2009 5:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
51
5.303278
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/14/2009 12:15 TLR Level
3B
TVA
104
5.055907
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 14 of 44
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/14/2009 12:15 TLR Level
3B
TVA
51
5.055907
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/14/2009 16:35 TLR Level
3B
TVA
104
5.01636
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/14/2009 16:35 TLR Level
3B
TVA
51
5.01636
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/16/2009 3:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
104
6.704632
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3571
1/16/2009 3:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
51
6.704632
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/16/2009 21:25 TLR Level
3B
TVA
473
5.043374
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
1/17/2009 1:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
104
6.191407
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
1/17/2009 1:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
51
6.191407
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
1/17/2009 1:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
75
6.191407
75
Curtailed
Current Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
1/17/2009 2:15 TLR Level
3B
PJM
19
6.201244
19
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/17/2009 5:30 TLR Level
3B
TVA
104
5.098878
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
1613
1/17/2009 5:30 TLR Level
3B
TVA
51
5.098878
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/17/2009 5:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
104
5.478674
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/17/2009 5:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
51
5.478674
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/19/2009 1:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
100
5.5163
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/19/2009 1:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
100
5.516816
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/19/2009 14:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
50
5.516944
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/19/2009 14:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
23
5.516944
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 12:45 TLR Level
3B
PJM
473
5.671229
473
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 12:45 TLR Level
3B
PJM
473
5.671229
473
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 12:45 TLR Level
3B
PJM
104
5.679338
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 12:45 TLR Level
3B
PJM
104
5.679338
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 12:45 TLR Level
3B
PJM
51
5.679338
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/20/2009 12:45 TLR Level
3B
PJM
51
5.679338
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/22/2009 14:45 TLR Level
3B
PJM
288
5.567812
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/22/2009 14:45 TLR Level
3B
PJM
100
5.567812
100
Curtailed
Current Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/22/2009 14:45 TLR Level
3B
PJM
100
5.591295
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/22/2009 22:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
100
6.037373
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/26/2009 0:45 TLR Level
3B
PJM
100
5.117734
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
1/26/2009 0:45 TLR Level
3B
PJM
100
5.65693
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/2/2009 16:15 TLR Level
3B
PJM
104
5.764921
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/2/2009 16:15 TLR Level
3B
PJM
51
5.764921
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/2/2009 16:15 TLR Level
3B
PJM
100
5.764921
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/2/2009 16:15 TLR Level
3B
PJM
100
5.780094
100
Curtailed
Current Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3250
2/2/2009 16:15 TLR Level
3B
PJM
70
5.780094
70
Curtailed
Current Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 15:15 TLR Level
3B
MISO
75
10.15486
75
Curtailed
Current Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 15:15 TLR Level
3B
MISO
75
10.15465
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 15:15 TLR Level
3B
MISO
75
10.15486
75
Curtailed
Current Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 15:15 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
10.15465
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 15:15 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
10.15486
100
Curtailed
Current Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 15:15 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
10.15465
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 15:15 TLR Level
3B
MISO
200
10.15486
159
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 15:15 TLR Level
3B
MISO
200
10.15465
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
2/5/2009 15:15 TLR Level
3B
MISO
50
10.15465
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/6/2009 23:15 TLR Level
3B
MISO
75
6.290784
75
Curtailed
Current Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/20/2009 5:45 TLR Level
3B
MISO
104
6.059753
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/20/2009 5:45 TLR Level
3B
MISO
51
6.059753
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3570
2/20/2009 5:45 TLR Level
3B
MISO
67
6.059753
67
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/25/2009 4:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
104
5.140244
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/25/2009 4:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
51
5.140244
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/29/2009 1:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
5.430296
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
TLR on Flowgate 522
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/29/2009 1:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
5.430296
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
TLR on Flowgate 522
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 15 of 44
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/29/2009 1:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
5.432306
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/29/2009 1:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
5.430296
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
TLR on Flowgate 522
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
10/29/2009 1:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
5.432306
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
11/1/2009 22:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
100
5.829233
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
522
11/1/2009 22:30 TLR Level
3B
PJM
50
5.829233
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 0:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
15
5.432313
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 0:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
15
5.432313
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 0:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
5.432313
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 0:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
5.442789
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 0:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
104
5.432313
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 0:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
104
5.442789
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 0:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
51
5.432313
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2975
11/17/2009 0:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
51
5.442789
51
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 9:45 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
12.96513
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 9:45 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
13.39997
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 9:45 TLR Level
3B
MISO
104
12.96513
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 9:45 TLR Level
3B
MISO
104
13.39997
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 11:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
12.75658
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 11:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
13.20514
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 11:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
104
12.75658
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/4/2011 11:30 TLR Level
3B
MISO
104
13.20514
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2337
4/13/2011 22:45 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
14.45796
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2337
4/13/2011 22:45 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
14.42693
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2337
4/13/2011 22:45 TLR Level
3B
MISO
104
14.45796
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
2337
4/13/2011 22:45 TLR Level
3B
MISO
104
14.42693
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 4:20 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
13.54471
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 4:20 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
13.55934
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 4:20 TLR Level
3B
MISO
104
13.54471
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3314
4/14/2011 4:20 TLR Level
3B
MISO
104
13.55934
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/15/2011 4:20 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
15.43077
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3405
4/15/2011 4:20 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
15.62037
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3459
4/19/2011 3:45 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
11.2337
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
3459
4/19/2011 3:45 TLR Level
3B
MISO
100
11.29174
0
Curtailed
Current Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/24/2011 11:30 TLR Level
3B
ICTE
104
6.002176
45
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/24/2011 13:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
5.954544
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/24/2011 14:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
5.893287
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/24/2011 15:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
5.858137
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/24/2011 16:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.984654
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/24/2011 17:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.60527
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/24/2011 18:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.645777
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/24/2011 19:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.630488
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/24/2011 20:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.677029
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/24/2011 21:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.688105
4
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/24/2011 22:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
64
6.761175
3
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/25/2011 10:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.911915
103
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/25/2011 11:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.863448
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/25/2011 12:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
7.101058
3
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/25/2011 13:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.834455
2
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/25/2011 14:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.919235
2
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/25/2011 15:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.792198
3
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/25/2011 16:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.801748
6
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/25/2011 17:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.729698
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 16 of 44
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/25/2011 18:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.276639
12
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/25/2011 19:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.249273
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/25/2011 20:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.335413
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/25/2011 23:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.964756
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 0:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
7.004527
8
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 1:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
7.152369
8
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 2:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
7.177126
7
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 3:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
7.158473
5
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 9:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
7.770365
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 10:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
7.080322
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 11:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
7.076143
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 12:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
7.088253
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 13:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
7.164203
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 14:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
7.112864
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 17:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
7.072799
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 18:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
7.009771
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 19:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.93448
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 20:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.875563
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 21:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.941972
6
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 23:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.945638
3
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/26/2011 23:10 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.9175
104
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
MISO-EXP (ONT)
ONT
16807
5/27/2011 0:00 TLR Level
5A
ICTE
104
6.846044
2
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
1/2/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
27.37697
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
1/2/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
27.37697
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
1/2/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
27.37697
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
1/2/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
27.32659
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
1/2/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
27.32659
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
1/2/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
27.32659
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7010
1/3/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
12.96398
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7010
1/3/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
12.96398
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7010
1/3/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
12.94409
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7010
1/3/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
12.94409
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7010
1/3/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
12.90521
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7010
1/3/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
12.90521
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.00547
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.00547
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.21588
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.21588
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.34092
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.34092
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.40323
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.40323
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.34268
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.34268
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.4001
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.4001
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.34072
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.34072
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.41624
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.41624
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.27312
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.27312
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 17 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.44369
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.44369
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.27098
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.27098
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.44188
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.44188
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.96899
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.96899
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.39079
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/3/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.39079
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.02522
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.02522
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.96639
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.96639
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.05269
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.05269
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.76754
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.76754
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.79248
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.79248
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.73566
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.73566
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.61679
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.61679
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.57159
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.57159
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
8:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
41.66772
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
8:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.66772
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
8:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.66772
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
41.56791
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.56791
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/4/2009
9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.56791
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/5/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.31607
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/5/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.31607
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/5/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.31607
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/5/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.28236
34
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/5/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.28236
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/5/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.28236
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/5/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.54029
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/5/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.48773
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/5/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.48773
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/5/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.48773
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/5/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.56247
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/5/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.56247
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/5/2009
6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.38282
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/5/2009
6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.38282
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/9/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.43449
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/9/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.47106
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/9/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.39476
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/9/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.54598
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/9/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.54598
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/12/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.37977
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 18 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/12/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.37977
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/12/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.42547
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/12/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.42547
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/12/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.56384
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/12/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.56384
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/12/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.49019
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/12/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.49019
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/12/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.4428
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/12/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.4428
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/18/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.89825
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/18/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.89825
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/18/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.99068
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/18/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.99068
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/18/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.9003
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/18/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.9003
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/18/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.96511
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/18/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.96511
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/25/2009
0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.21341
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/25/2009
0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.21341
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/25/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.18138
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/25/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.18138
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/25/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.34401
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/25/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.34401
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/25/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.18503
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/25/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.18503
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/25/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.18406
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/25/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.18406
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/25/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.2025
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/25/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.2025
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/25/2009
6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
42.23691
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/25/2009
6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.23691
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/26/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
43.23119
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/26/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.23119
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/27/2009
0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
43.98567
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/27/2009
0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.98567
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/27/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
44.0767
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/27/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
44.0767
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/27/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
44.06885
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/27/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
44.06885
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/27/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
43.94231
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/27/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.94231
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/27/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
43.91465
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/27/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.91465
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/27/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
43.82406
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/27/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.82406
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/30/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.26313
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/30/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.26313
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/30/2009
6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
41.3409
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
1/30/2009
6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.3409
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
2/7/2009
0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.95514
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/7/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.76964
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/7/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.81234
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 19 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/7/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.7797
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/7/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.90113
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/7/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.3573
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/7/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
31.52181
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/7/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.79741
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/7/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.95098
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/8/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.91769
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/8/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.94695
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/8/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.88141
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/8/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.17188
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/8/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.12341
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/8/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.16431
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/8/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.60753
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
2/11/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.42076
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
2/11/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.43719
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
2/11/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.41885
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
2/11/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.42917
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
2/11/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
41.47359
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/17/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.23352
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/17/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.18116
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
2/17/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.1985
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/2/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.82767
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/2/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.77467
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/2/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.7959
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/2/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.87106
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/2/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.87407
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/2/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.21535
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/3/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.10789
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/3/2009 1:05 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.12955
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/3/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.10771
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/3/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.21342
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/3/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.53886
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/3/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.48004
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/3/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.61202
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/3/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.61283
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/3/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.5483
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/4/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.33916
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/4/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.53006
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/4/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.90445
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/4/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.96458
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/4/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.59558
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
6124
10/11/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
5.245516
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
35
11.62718
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.77957
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.62718
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
6124
10/11/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
MISO
100
5.242888
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
35
11.54034
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.69344
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.54034
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
11.54034
49
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.54034
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
35
11.62111
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 20 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.77726
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.62111
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.62111
151
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
35
11.55135
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.55135
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.55135
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.55135
151
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
35
11.62721
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.78383
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.62721
15
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.62721
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.62721
151
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
35
11.55287
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.7119
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.55287
12
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.55287
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.55287
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.79779
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.6365
7
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.6365
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.6365
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.80562
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.64445
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.64445
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.61692
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.61692
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
11.61692
53
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.61692
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.6946
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/11/2009
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.6946
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/14/2009
23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.68172
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/14/2009
23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.68172
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/15/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.60444
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/15/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.60444
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/15/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.79861
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/15/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.79861
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/15/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.84143
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/15/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.84143
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/15/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.75063
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/15/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.75063
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/15/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.84139
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/15/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.84139
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/16/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
43.82012
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/16/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.82012
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/16/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.82012
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/16/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
500
43.82012
400
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/16/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.75503
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/16/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
500
43.75503
400
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/16/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.06097
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/16/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.06097
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.11135
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.11135
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 21 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.02612
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.02612
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.10145
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.10145
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.02577
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.02577
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.17712
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.17712
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.17712
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.17712
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.17852
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.17852
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.17732
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/17/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.17732
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.28644
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.28644
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.24629
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.24629
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.24629
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.24629
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.28644
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.28644
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.24921
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.24921
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.37857
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.37857
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.43248
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.43248
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.0462
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.0462
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.12883
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/18/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.12883
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/19/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.50467
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/19/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.50467
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/19/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.48275
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/19/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.48275
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/19/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.4921
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/19/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.4921
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/19/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.34373
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/19/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.34373
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/19/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.32151
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/19/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.32151
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/19/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.30016
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/19/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.30016
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/19/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.39583
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/19/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.39583
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/20/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.63924
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/20/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.63924
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/20/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.42002
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/20/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.42002
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/20/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.67537
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/20/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.67537
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 22 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/20/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.7071
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/20/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.7071
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/20/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
43.58126
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/20/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
43.58126
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/20/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.24589
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/20/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.24589
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/20/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.20913
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/20/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.20913
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/21/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.31657
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/21/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.31657
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/21/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.2046
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/21/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.2046
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/21/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.30204
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/21/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.30204
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/21/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.26279
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/21/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.26279
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/21/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
42.26828
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
10/21/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
42.26828
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/21/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.5665
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/21/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.5665
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/21/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.60379
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/21/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.60379
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/22/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.45569
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/22/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.45569
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/22/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.77417
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/22/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.77417
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/22/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.81849
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/22/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.81849
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/22/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.63942
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/22/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.63942
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/22/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.95289
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/22/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.95289
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/22/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.05036
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/22/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.05036
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/22/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.01755
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/22/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.01755
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/23/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.95645
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/23/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.95645
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.12215
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.12215
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.20547
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.20547
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.11923
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.11923
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.11923
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.11923
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.20937
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.20937
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.11871
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.11871
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.36783
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.36783
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 23 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.27239
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.27239
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.34944
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.34944
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.38436
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.38436
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.39113
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.39113
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.38465
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.38465
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.39124
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.39124
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.36074
65
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.36074
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/24/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
30.46054
65
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/24/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
30.46054
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.2078
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/24/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.2078
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/24/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
30.29784
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/24/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
30.29784
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.16847
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.16847
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/25/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
30.61042
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/25/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
30.61042
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.21426
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.21426
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/25/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
30.50949
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/25/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
30.50949
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
11.03169
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.03169
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.03169
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/25/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
30.6903
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/25/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
30.6903
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/25/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
30.6903
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.21416
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.21416
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/25/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
30.50857
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/25/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
30.50857
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.2
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.2
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/25/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
30.55738
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/25/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
30.55738
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.2044
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.2044
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/25/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
30.57911
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/25/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
30.57911
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.21872
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.21872
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.24094
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.24094
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
35
11.20749
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.20749
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 24 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.20749
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
35
11.18743
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.18743
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.18743
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
35
11.20373
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.20373
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.20373
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
35
11.21059
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.21059
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.21059
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
35
11.22221
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.22221
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.22221
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
35
11.2188
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.2188
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.2188
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
35
11.23294
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.23294
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.23294
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.22169
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.22169
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
75
11.43868
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.2517
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.2517
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
11.2517
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
20
11.33105
20
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
75
11.51247
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.33105
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.33105
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
11.33105
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
20
11.34023
20
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
75
11.52171
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.34023
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
75
11.34023
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.34023
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
20
11.32836
20
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
75
11.51218
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.32836
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.32836
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
20
11.32192
20
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.32192
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.32192
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
21:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
20
11.34132
20
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
21:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.34132
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/25/2009
21:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.34132
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/25/2009
23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.34023
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/25/2009
23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.34023
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/26/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.63234
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/26/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.63234
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/26/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.3432
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/26/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.3432
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/26/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.92993
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 25 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/26/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.92993
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/26/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
30.21098
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
10/26/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
30.21098
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/31/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.82114
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/31/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.82114
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/31/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.78851
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/31/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.78851
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/31/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.79616
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/31/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
10.79616
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
10/31/2009 22:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.79616
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
11/1/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.9015
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
11/1/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.9015
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
11/1/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.7651
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
11/1/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.7651
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
11/1/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.76968
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
11/1/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.76968
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
11/1/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.76968
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
11/1/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.76968
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
11/1/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.76984
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
11/1/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.76984
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
15.00158
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
15.00158
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
14.94856
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
14.94856
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
14.95406
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
14.95406
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
14.63685
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
14.63685
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7001
11/14/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.77881
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7001
11/14/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.77881
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
14.65197
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
14.65197
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
14.67958
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
14.67958
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
15.36097
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
15.36097
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
15.36017
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
15.36017
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
15.36175
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
15.36175
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
15.35423
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
15.35423
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
15.35157
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
15.35157
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
15.35401
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
15.35401
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/14/2009 21:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
15.35495
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/15/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
36.25986
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/15/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
36.25986
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/15/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
36.44474
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/15/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
36.44474
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/15/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
36.65179
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 26 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/15/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
36.65179
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/15/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
36.68503
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/15/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
36.68503
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/15/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
36.6674
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/15/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
36.6674
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/15/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
36.68136
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/15/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
36.68136
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/15/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
36.41496
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/15/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
36.46741
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/15/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
36.46741
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/15/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
15.39104
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/15/2009 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
15.39104
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/15/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
15.39381
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/15/2009 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
15.39381
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/15/2009 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
15.3604
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/15/2009 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
15.3604
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/15/2009 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
15.42912
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
11/15/2009 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
15.42912
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/16/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
40
37.75227
40
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/16/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
37.75227
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/16/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
37.75227
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/16/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
37.66871
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/16/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
37.66871
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/16/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
37.14978
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/16/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
37.14978
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/16/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
37.19025
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/16/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
37.19025
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/16/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
37.1978
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/16/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
37.1978
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/16/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
38.0317
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/16/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
38.0317
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/16/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
37.8377
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
11/16/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
37.8377
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/17/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.2412
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/17/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.2412
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/17/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.25558
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/17/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.25558
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/17/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.24096
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/17/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.24096
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/17/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.23728
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/17/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.23728
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/17/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.2132
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/17/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.2132
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/17/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.23395
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/17/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.23395
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/17/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.49124
65
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/17/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.49124
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/18/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.51776
65
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/18/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.51776
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/18/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.49797
45
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/18/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.49797
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/18/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.53596
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 27 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/18/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.49515
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/18/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.55236
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/18/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.55236
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/18/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.543
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/18/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.543
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.08687
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.08687
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.16472
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.16472
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.15274
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.15274
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.13118
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.13118
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.09777
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.09777
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.12133
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.12133
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.12502
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.12502
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.77683
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.77683
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.43961
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.43961
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/19/2009 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
24.56309
1
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/20/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.43877
65
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/20/2009 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.43877
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/20/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.55332
65
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/20/2009 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.55332
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/20/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.42019
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/20/2009 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.42019
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/20/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.52903
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/20/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.52903
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/20/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.39257
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/20/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
24.48322
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/20/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.43655
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/20/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
24.52866
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/20/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.4998
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
150
24.60733
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
150
24.60733
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.60733
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.60733
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.60733
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.60733
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
150
24.69509
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.69509
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.69509
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
150
24.61214
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.61215
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.61215
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
150
24.70024
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.70024
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.70024
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 28 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009
7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
150
24.57776
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009
7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.57777
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/22/2009
7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.57777
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/23/2009
0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.43234
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/23/2009
0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.43234
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/23/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.56411
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/23/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.56411
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/23/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.40478
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/23/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.40478
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/23/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.55393
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/23/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.55393
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/23/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.51611
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/23/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.51611
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/23/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.25655
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/23/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.25655
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/26/2009
0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.97797
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/26/2009
0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.97797
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/26/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.09366
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/26/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.09366
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - MISO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/26/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.04731
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/26/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.04731
153
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/26/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.00406
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/26/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.00406
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/26/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.96256
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/26/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.96256
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/26/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.01057
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/27/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.3444
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/27/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.3444
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/27/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.46782
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/27/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.46782
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/27/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.39016
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/27/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.39016
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/27/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.46979
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/27/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.37391
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/27/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.37391
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.46829
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.46829
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.36871
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.36871
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.498
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.498
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.49407
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
25.49407
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
25.49407
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.47943
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.47943
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.47943
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.45143
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.45143
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.45143
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.41776
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009
6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.41776
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 29 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.41776
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.46667
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
24.46667
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
11/29/2009 7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
24.46667
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
2/9/2011
19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.95889
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
2/9/2011
20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.9604
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
2/9/2011
21:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.96858
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
2/9/2011
22:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.967
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/2/2011
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.78241
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/2/2011
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.78241
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/2/2011
19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.79096
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/2/2011
19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.79096
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
7.021624
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
7.021624
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
7.021624
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
7.024315
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
7.024315
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
7.024315
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
7.047053
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
7.047053
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
7.047053
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
7.037478
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
7.037478
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
7.037478
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
6.933547
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
6.933547
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
6.933547
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
6.931332
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
6.931332
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
6.931332
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
6.934907
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
6.934907
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
6.934907
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
6.919722
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
6.919722
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17024
4/3/2011
19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
6.919722
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.07449
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.07449
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.07449
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.07449
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.07449
2
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.07449
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.07449
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.12581
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.12581
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.12581
102
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.06112
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.06112
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.06112
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.06813
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.06813
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.06813
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 30 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.85282
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.85282
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.06532
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.06532
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.06532
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.85761
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.85761
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
12.85761
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.05513
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.05513
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/10/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.05513
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/11/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.38172
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/11/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.38172
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/11/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.36254
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/11/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.36254
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/11/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.3592
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/11/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.3592
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/11/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.37195
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.6383
70
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
170
29.6383
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
250
29.52879
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
29.52879
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
29.52879
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.52879
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
170
29.52879
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
29.55354
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.55354
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
170
29.55354
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
29.52543
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.52543
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
29.52543
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
170
29.52543
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.53917
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
29.53917
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
170
29.53917
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.97603
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.97603
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
10.97603
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
170
10.97603
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
10.95854
8
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
10.95854
36
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.95854
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
170
10.95854
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
10.96676
21
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
10.96676
101
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.96676
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
170
10.96676
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.9241
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
170
10.9241
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.044
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
170
11.044
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.03554
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 31 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
170
11.03554
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.23039
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
170
11.23039
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.26828
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
170
11.26828
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.28283
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
170
11.28283
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.24735
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
170
11.24735
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
21
11.37068
21
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
11.37068
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.37068
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
170
11.37068
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.28504
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/12/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
170
11.28504
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.80161
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
170
28.80161
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.82444
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
170
28.82444
170
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/12/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.82615
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/13/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.82788
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/13/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.82788
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/13/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.84229
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/13/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.84229
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/13/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.68327
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/13/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.68327
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/13/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.82044
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/13/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.82044
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
42
11.45475
12
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
11.45475
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
11.45475
46
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.45475
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.45475
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
11.48116
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.48116
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.48116
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
11.5044
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
11.5044
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.5044
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.5044
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
11.44139
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.44139
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.44139
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
11.39759
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.39759
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.39759
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
11.40241
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.40241
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.40241
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.40831
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.40831
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.40831
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 32 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.40831
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
11.39189
113
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.39189
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.39189
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.46431
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.46431
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.42882
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/13/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.42882
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/13/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.97132
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/13/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.97132
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.95517
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.95517
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.05469
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.05469
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.06412
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.06412
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.0876
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.0876
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/14/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
11.19362
1
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/14/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
11.19362
4
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/14/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
11.19362
6
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/14/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.19362
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/14/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.19362
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/14/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.18846
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/14/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.18846
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/14/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.21427
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/14/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.21427
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.4988
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.4988
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/14/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
11.29124
174
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/14/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.29124
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/14/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.29124
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
250
28.80372
174
Curtailed
Next Hour
TLR on Flowgate 7004
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.80372
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.80372
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/14/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.49616
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/14/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.49616
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.83196
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.83196
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.02827
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/14/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.02827
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.00727
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.00727
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.09228
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.09228
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.04409
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.04409
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.02197
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.02197
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.9358
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.9358
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.9358
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 33 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.9358
70
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.9358
70
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.9358
70
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.9358
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.9358
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.9358
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.05438
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.05438
70
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.05438
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.87636
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.87636
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.87636
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.68687
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.68687
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.68687
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.68687
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.7445
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.7445
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.7445
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.7445
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/15/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.99313
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.0735
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.0735
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.99976
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.99976
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.03391
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.03391
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.97892
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.97892
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.72896
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.72896
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.23455
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.23455
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.32564
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.32564
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.25159
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.25159
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.25159
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.34292
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.34292
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.34292
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.28473
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.28473
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.29262
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.29262
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.21125
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.21125
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.13505
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.13505
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.13112
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.13112
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.10725
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 34 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.10725
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.10056
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.10056
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.14966
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.14966
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.20724
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.20724
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.19275
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.19275
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.09351
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/16/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.09351
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.05198
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.05198
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.10563
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/16/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.10563
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.99095
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.99095
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.98862
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.98862
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.93328
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.93328
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.07599
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.07599
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.01701
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.01701
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.08695
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.08695
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.75396
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
12.75396
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.83401
12
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.83401
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
12.83401
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.75916
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.75916
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
12.75916
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.83367
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.83367
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
12.83367
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.75789
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.75789
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
12.75789
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.94267
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.94267
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.84319
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.84319
80
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
30
12.84319
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
12.84319
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.0513
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
30
29.0513
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.0513
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.77519
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.77519
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 35 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
30
12.77519
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
12.77519
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.98868
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.98868
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.82531
14
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.82531
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
30
12.82531
9
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
12.82531
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
15:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.01572
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
15:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.01572
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.76782
6
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.76782
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
30
12.76782
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
12.76782
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
16:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.99997
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
16:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
30
28.99997
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
16:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.99997
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.8303
3
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.8303
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
30
12.8303
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
12.8303
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
17:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.05506
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
17:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
30
29.05506
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
17:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.05506
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.70019
28
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.70019
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
30
12.70019
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
12.70019
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
18:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.98792
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
18:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
30
28.98792
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
18:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.98792
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.76149
11
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.76149
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
30
12.76149
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
12.76149
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
19:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.04623
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
19:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
30
29.04623
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
19:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.04623
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.7022
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
30
12.7022
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
12.7022
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
20:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.98655
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
20:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
30
28.98655
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
20:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.98655
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
21:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
12.76173
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/17/2011
21:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
12.76173
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.06959
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.06959
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.88111
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.88111
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/17/2011
23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.97404
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/18/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.88057
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 36 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/18/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.96378
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/18/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.46201
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/18/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.00001
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/18/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.00162
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/18/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.00162
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/18/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.38534
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/18/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.38534
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/18/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.3434
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/18/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.3434
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/18/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.27726
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/18/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.27726
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/19/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.34435
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/19/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.34435
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/19/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.29924
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/19/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.29924
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/19/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.34353
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/19/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.34353
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/19/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.29153
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/19/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.29153
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/19/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.36603
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/19/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.36603
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/21/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.56487
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/21/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.56487
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.73803
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.73803
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.69544
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.69544
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.76865
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.76865
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.68782
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.68782
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.79232
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.79232
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.9342
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.9342
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.47012
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.47012
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.38765
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.38765
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.44878
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.44878
156
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.38896
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.38896
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/22/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
11.75918
3
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/22/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.75918
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/22/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
11.75918
3
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/22/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.75918
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.45157
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.45157
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/22/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
11.69469
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/22/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
11.69469
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.38738
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 37 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.38738
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/22/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.3374
90
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.38524
90
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/22/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.27409
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/22/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.27409
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
50
29.32806
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.44051
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.44051
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.35992
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/22/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.35992
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.43826
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.43826
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.34958
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.34958
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.43827
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.43827
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.34927
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.34927
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.43694
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.43694
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.25174
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.25174
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.14453
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.14453
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.14453
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.22453
23
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.22453
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.22453
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.2295
7
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.2295
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.2295
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.18746
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.18746
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.19187
23
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.19187
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.19187
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.19601
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.19601
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.19086
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.19086
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.20233
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.20233
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
13.19799
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
4/23/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
13.19799
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.1974
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.1974
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.09279
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.09279
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.2022
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.2022
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.0961
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.0961
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 38 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.30094
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.30094
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.19456
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.19456
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.30705
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.22994
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
190
29.22994
190
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.34992
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/23/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
190
29.34992
190
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/24/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.28201
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/24/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
190
29.28201
190
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/24/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.38354
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/24/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
190
29.38354
190
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/24/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.27737
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/24/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
190
29.27737
190
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/24/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.39585
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/24/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
190
29.39585
190
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/24/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.288
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/24/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
190
29.288
190
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/24/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.2581
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/24/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.26948
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/24/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.26948
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/24/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.34807
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/24/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.34807
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.36884
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.36884
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.10901
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.10901
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
29.12027
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
29.12027
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.23675
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.23675
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.07869
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.07869
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.03264
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.03264
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
27.99665
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
27.99665
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
27.9522
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
27.9522
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.10103
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.10103
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.07259
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.07259
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.25013
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.25013
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.23639
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.23639
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.2507
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.2507
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.06823
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.06823
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 39 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.12918
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.12918
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.27285
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.27285
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
28.29361
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
28.29361
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
27.62228
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/25/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
27.62228
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/26/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
27.44851
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/26/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
27.44851
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/26/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
27.23866
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/26/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
27.23866
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/26/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
27.25364
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/26/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
27.25364
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/26/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
26.70397
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/26/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
26.70397
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/26/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
26.6625
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7009
4/26/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
26.6625
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.03541
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
40.03541
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
39.78842
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
39.78842
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
39.8393
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
39.8393
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
39.72687
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
39.72687
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.28527
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
40.28527
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.27889
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
40.27889
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.29427
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
40.29427
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.40425
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
40.40425
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.43704
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
40.43704
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.35057
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
40.35057
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.29441
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
40.29441
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.39521
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
40.39521
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.27461
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/26/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
40.27461
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/27/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.21284
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/27/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
40.21284
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/27/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.21662
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/27/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
40.21662
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/27/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.14581
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/27/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
40.14581
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/27/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
39.73035
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/27/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
200
39.73035
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 40 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7018
4/27/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
4
5.553406
4
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7018
4/27/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
5.553406
2
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7018
4/27/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
5.553406
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7018
4/27/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
5.607026
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7018
4/27/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
5.633646
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7018
4/27/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
5.697379
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7018
4/27/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
5.679923
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/27/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
41.14488
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7018
4/27/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
5.679698
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/27/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.94092
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7018
4/27/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
5.631083
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/27/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.89135
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/27/2011 21:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.9037
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/27/2011 22:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
41.06571
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/27/2011 23:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
41.03763
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 0:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
41.03218
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 1:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
41.37399
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
41.1045
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 3:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
41.12179
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 4:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
41.09892
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 5:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
41.12384
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.65854
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.87824
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
41.53912
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.9934
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.71194
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 11:05 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.61175
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.6517
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
15
40.73118
15
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
40.73118
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
15
41.01572
15
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
41.01572
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
15
41.02967
15
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
4/28/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
41.02967
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.51423
2
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
41
13.51423
41
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
13.51423
6
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
20
13.51423
20
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.53854
1
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.53854
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
13.53854
3
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.59204
14
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.59204
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
13.59204
66
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.52541
5
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.52541
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
13.52541
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.52541
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.50978
11
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.50978
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
13.50978
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.50978
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 41 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.52047
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
13.52047
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.35236
1
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.35236
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
13.35236
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.52296
1
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
14
13.52296
14
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
13.52296
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.64648
4
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.64648
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
13.64648
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.65215
4
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
13.65215
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.65428
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.63356
19
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
13.63356
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
13.63356
92
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/2/2011 20:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
25
13.65303
25
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.34013
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
300
12.34013
274
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.34013
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
12.34013
31
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 6:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
12.34013
19
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
17
12.36771
17
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
105
12.36771
85
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
12.36771
80
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 7:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
12.36771
48
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.33473
42
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.33473
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
58
12.33473
58
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
12.33473
39
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
12.33473
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.37182
40
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.37182
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
12.37182
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
12.37182
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.32559
44
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.32559
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
12.32559
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
12.32559
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.40396
31
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
10
12.40396
7
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
12.40396
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
12.40396
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
12.3533
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
300
12.3533
300
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
12.3533
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
12.3533
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
90
12.37896
90
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
12.37896
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
12.37896
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
11.13573
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 42 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
11.13573
195
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
11.13573
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
35
11.20057
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
11.20057
153
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
11.20057
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
11.17209
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
11.17209
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
250
11.19502
250
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
11.19502
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
11.19502
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
11.2038
34
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
1
11.2038
1
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/3/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
11.2038
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/5/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
14.07006
15
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/5/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
14.07006
8
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7101
5/11/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
300
30.69514
300
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7101
5/11/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
300
30.66527
270
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7101
5/11/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
300
30.60943
172
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7101
5/11/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
24
28.78351
24
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7101
5/11/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
300
28.80502
300
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/16/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
10.35534
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/16/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
10.40899
25
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/16/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.40899
82
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/16/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
10.37216
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/16/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.37216
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/16/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
10.39566
25
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/16/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.39566
69
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/16/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.36742
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/16/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.36839
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/16/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.34311
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/16/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.34459
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/16/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.30063
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/16/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.28774
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/16/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.2691
39
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/17/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
9.948272
33
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/17/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
69
10.26324
69
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/17/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
10.26324
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/17/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.11876
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/19/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
10.0141
59
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/19/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
10.05347
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/19/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.05347
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/19/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
10.05809
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/19/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
10.05809
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/19/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
9.927649
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/19/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
9.927649
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/19/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
10.03987
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9160
5/20/2011 2:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
25
33.74813
25
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/20/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.52821
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/20/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
10.52821
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/20/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.43845
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/20/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
10.43845
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/20/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
10.43845
119
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 43 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/20/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.47574
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/20/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
10.47574
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/20/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.38275
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/20/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
35
10.38275
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/20/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
10.38275
96
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/20/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
10.38275
2
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/20/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.34571
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/20/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
10.34571
150
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/20/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
200
10.66826
194
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/20/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
150
10.66826
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17180
5/21/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
6.039969
10
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17180
5/21/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
6.039969
5
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17180
5/21/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
30
6.047068
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17180
5/21/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
6.047068
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17180
5/21/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
30
6.025865
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17180
5/21/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
6.025865
98
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17180
5/21/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
30
6.060905
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17180
5/21/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
30
6.114578
11
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17180
5/21/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
6.114578
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17180
5/21/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
6.114578
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17180
5/21/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
30
6.131311
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17180
5/21/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
40
6.131311
40
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17180
5/21/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
6.131311
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17180
5/21/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
30
6.135155
30
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
17180
5/21/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
100
6.135155
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
8.990036
35
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 9:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
9.008683
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
75
8.998552
67
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
9.044615
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
75
9.044615
75
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
9.024133
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 12:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
75
9.024133
25
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
9.04579
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
75
9.04579
25
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
9.003196
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
75
9.003196
25
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 15:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
75
9.033491
25
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
8.993167
23
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
75
8.993167
25
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
9.028572
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 17:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
75
9.028572
25
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 18:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
9.006484
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
9.030334
1
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
9.030334
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/23/2011 19:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
116
9.030334
116
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9159
5/24/2011 8:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
55.02074
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9159
5/24/2011 10:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
54.88008
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9159
5/24/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
55.00424
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
9159
5/24/2011 16:00 TLR Level
3A
ONT
100
54.31631
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/26/2011 11:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
10.74268
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/26/2011 13:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
10.84989
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/26/2011 14:00 TLR Level
3A
NYIS
50
10.63579
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-59
Page 44 of 44
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/27/2011 9:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
10.73835
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/27/2011 10:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
10.67939
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/29/2011 13:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.42962
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/29/2011 14:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.41392
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/29/2011 15:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.41925
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/29/2011 16:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.41438
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
5/29/2011 17:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.4421
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
12/26/2011 17:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
200
10.52064
27
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7004
12/26/2011 18:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
200
10.34156
28
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/27/2011 15:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.76025
44
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/27/2011 16:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
50
11.66513
47
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/27/2011 16:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
200
11.66513
177
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/27/2011 17:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
50
11.89786
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/27/2011 17:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.89786
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/27/2011 17:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
200
11.89786
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/27/2011 17:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.89786
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/27/2011 18:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
50
11.6642
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/27/2011 18:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.6642
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/27/2011 19:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
50
11.76513
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/27/2011 19:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.76513
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/29/2011 13:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.40677
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/29/2011 14:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.29827
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/29/2011 15:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.36879
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/29/2011 16:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
200
11.3096
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/29/2011 17:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
200
11.38586
200
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/29/2011 17:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.38586
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/29/2011 18:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.35259
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/29/2011 18:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.35259
2
Curtailed
Next Hour
NO
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/29/2011 19:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.43627
50
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
ONT
MISO-IMP (ONT)
7000
12/29/2011 20:00 TLR Level 3A
NYIS
100
11.34828
100
Curtailed
Next Hour
CA - ONT
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-60
REDACTED
PROTECTED MATERIAL
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-61
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-61
Page 1 of 4
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-61
Page 2 of 4
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-61
Page 3 of 4
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-61
Page 4 of 4
DOCKET NO. ER11-1844
EXHIBIT NO. NYI-62
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-62
Page 1 of 2
NYISO/MISO 7-1. On March 26, 2012, the MISO distributed a notice to stakeholders
via email (attached as a PDF to the e-mail serving this data request) with the
subject line, “[MISO] Michigan-Ontario Interface Phase Angle Regulators,”
(“Notice”). The Notice stated the following: “MISO, IESO, ITC and Hydro One
have formally set 1000 hours EDT Thursday, April 5, 2012 as the target for
starting coordinated operation of PARs on the Michigan-Ontario interface. The
Hydro One L4D PAR at Lambton is not expected to be available by April 5th,
2012. As a result, MISO does not intend to change the methodology for pricing
transactions scheduled across the Michigan-Ontario interface as originally
planned. The existing pricing methodology will remain in place until further
notice.” Please explain, in detail, and Provide copies of all Documents, and any
additional information, Related To:
a. The methodology for pricing transactions scheduled across the Michigan-
Ontario interface that MISO intended to utilize as described in the Notice.
b. The purpose of the intended change in methodology for pricing
transactions scheduled across the Michigan-Ontario interface.
c. The difference between the current methodology and the intended new
methodology for pricing transactions scheduled across the Michigan-
Ontario interface that MISO is not utilizing due to the unavailability of the
Hydro One L4D PAR at Lambton.
d. The reason MISO has decided not to change the methodology for pricing
transactions scheduled across the Michigan-Ontario interface.
Response:
a. The methodology for pricing transactions scheduled across the Michigan- Ontario
interface that MISO intended to utilize as described in the Notice.
As described in MISO August 30, 2011 update to the Market Subcommittee, MISO
intended to price transactions scheduled across the Michigan-Ontario interface at a
nodal price that represents the Michigan-Ontario interface. This, in effect, prices such
transaction at the interface, rather than the ultimate sink as is the current practice.
b. The purpose of the intended change in methodology for pricing transactions scheduled
across the Michigan-Ontario interface.
The intended change in the methodology for pricing transactions scheduled across the
Michigan-Ontario interface was to align the pricing of such transactions with the actual
power flows to the extent practical.
Docket No. ER11-1844
Exhibit No. NYI-62
Page 2 of 2
c.
The difference between the current methodology and the intended new methodology for
pricing transactions scheduled across the Michigan- Ontario interface that MISO is not
utilizing due to the unavailability of the Hydro One L4D PAR at Lambton.
The notice referenced above indicates only that MISO is not changing the current pricing
methodology at this time. Inferring there is a “new” pricing methodology is incorrect. As
of April 5th, MISO had not decided if any changes to the original intended methodology
are appropriate or warranted.
d.
The reason MISO has decided not to change the methodology for pricing transactions
scheduled across the Michigan-Ontario interface.
As explained in b., the intent is to align the pricing of transactions scheduled across the
interface with actual power flows created by those transactions, to the extent practical.
As of April 5th, actual power flow associated with transactions scheduled across the
Michigan-Ontario interface was not expected to flow across the interface to a sufficient
degree to warrant the pricing of such transactions at the interface price.
Sponsored by:
Kevin Frankeny