March 30, 2012

 

By Electronic Filing

The Honorable Kimberly D. Bose Secretary

Federal Energy Regulatory Commission 888 First Street, N.E.

Washington, D.C. 20426

Re:    Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation d/b/a/ National Grid - Proposed

Amendments to the Wholesale Transmission Service Charge Under the NYISO Open Access Transmission Tariff - Docket No. ER12-

Dear Secretary Bose:

 

Pursuant to Section 205 of the Federal Power Act ("FPA"), 16 U.S.C. § 824d, and Part

35.13 of the Commission's Regulations, 18 C.F.R. Part 35.13, Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation
d/b/a National Grid ("National Grid" or "Company") submits for filing revisions to the FERC Open
Access Transmission Tariff ("OATT") administered by the New York Independent System
Operator, Inc. ("NYISO").1 The proposed changes are being made to certain National Grid-specific
components of the Wholesale Transmission Service Charge ("Wholesale TSC") formula under the
NYISO OATT, to become effective for transmission bills rendered for service on and after July 1,
2012. The primary purpose of this filing, in addition to certain ministerial changes, is to update the
depreciation rates set forth in National Grid’s Revenue Requirement (“RR”) under the Wholesale
TSC.  National Grid respectfully submits that its proposal is just and reasonable and should be
accepted without suspension or hearing.

 

I. Statement of Nature, Reasons and Basis for Filing

The primary objective of this filing is to modify depreciation rates set forth in the RR component
of the Company’s Wholesale TSC formula rate set forth in Attachment H to the NYISO OATT.
The NYISO OATT specifically provides that the RR, the Scheduling, System Control and Dispatch
Costs ("CCC") component, and Annual Billing Units ("BU") components of a Transmission
Owner's Wholesale TSC rate may be updated "based on Transmission Owner filings to FERC."2
Under the terms of Attachment H to the NYISO OATT, Transmission Owners, including the
Company, have rights to amend the components of their respective Wholesale TSC rates on their

 

 

 

1 Capitalized terms used, but not defined in this filing are intended to have the meanings given to such terms in

Attachment H of the NYISO OATT including the April 2009 Settlement filed with the Commission on April 6, 2009.

 

2 See NYISO OATT, Attachment H, Section 14.1.2.1.2.


 

 

The Honorable Kimberly D. Bose, Secretary
Page 2

 

own initiative by making the requisite filing for Commission approval under Section 205 of the
FPA.3

In addition to making certain ministerial changes described below, National Grid is seeking to revise the Wholesale TSC in order to ensure that the depreciation rates in the RR are identical to those recently approved by the New York Public Service Commission (“NYPSC”) in the state jurisdictional Case 10-E-0050.   This will permit the Company to have a consistent set of
depreciation rates on its books and ensure that both electric retail customers and Wholesale TSC customers are consistently charged the same depreciation rates.

 

Since it is the NYISO that administers the NYISO OATT, and specifically Attachment H which
contains National Grid’s Wholesale TSC, National Grid has consulted with the NYISO to
determine a mutually acceptable means for National Grid to exercise its FPA Section 205 rights
with respect to this amendment of the RR component of the Wholesale TSC. While not sponsoring
National Grid’s filing in this proceeding, the NYISO is submitting this filing on National Grid’s
behalf under the Commission’s e-tariff regulations.  Thus, the NYISO is facilitating the exercise of
National Grid’s FPA Section 205 rights with respect to this portion of the NYISO OATT.

II. Background

 

A. National Grid

National Grid, a New York corporation, is a combination gas and electric utility. National Grid is primarily engaged in the business of transmission and distribution of electricity, and the
distribution and transportation of natural gas in New York State. National Grid serves over 1.6
million retail electric and 568,000 retail gas customers in Buffalo, Syracuse, Albany, and other
portions of upstate New York. National Grid owns approximately 6,000 miles of electric
transmission lines and 8,500 miles of main and distribution gas pipelines. All of National
Grid's bulk transmission facilities are subject to the operational control of the NYISO.
Transmission service and generator interconnections associated with National Grid's facilities are provided to customers on a non-discriminatory basis pursuant to the NYISO OATT.
Approximately 30 municipal electric utilities in upstate New York currently take service under
National Grid's Wholesale TSC. In addition, approximately 80 customers external to the NYISO take service under the Company's Wholesale TSC.

 

B. The Wholesale TSC

On January 27, 1999, the Commission conditionally accepted the proposal made by National Grid
and the other New York Transmission Owners ("NYTOs") to establish the NYISO in Docket
ER97-1523-000. In conjunction with that filing, on November 17, 1999, the NYTOs filed a joint
settlement agreement among all parties except Sithe/Independence Power Partners, L.P. ("Sithe")
resolving all issues set for hearing in Docket No. ER97-1523-000 ("the NYISO Settlement"). The
NYISO Settlement established as part of Attachment H to the NYISO OATT a "settlement"
Revenue Requirement and Transmission Service Charge for wholesale transmission services

 

 

 

3 Id.  With respect to National Grid specifically, see also Section 14.1.9.4.3.6.


 

 

The Honorable Kimberly D. Bose, Secretary
Page 3

 

provided using National Grid's facilities that was made applicable to parties except those who were excepted.4

On February 11, 2008, as supplemented on May 30, 2008, National Grid submitted a filing under
Section 205 of the Federal Power Act to replace its stated rates for its Transmission Service Charge
in Attachment H to the NYISO OATT with formula rates to become effective May 1, 2008.  On
July 29, 2008, the Commission accepted and suspended the proposed formula rates, to become
effective October 1, 2008, subject to refund, and establish hearing and settlement judge
procedures.5  On April 6, 2009, National Grid on behalf of the Settling Parties6 filed a Settlement
(“April 2009 Settlement”) intended to resolve all issues set for hearing in that proceeding.  Among
other things, the Settlement set forth the terms of a formula rate for the calculation of National
Grid’s transmission service charge under the NYISO OATT (the “Settlement TSC Formula Rate”),
as well as procedures for the annual adjustment of certain inputs to the formula rate.
Contemporaneously with the filing of the Settlement, National Grid also filed an Unopposed
Motion for Implementation of Settlement Rates on an Interim Basis, seeking authorization to
implement the Settlement TSC Formula Rate on an interim basis. National Grid expressed that
granting this motion would not prejudice any party to this proceeding, would allow customers to
benefit from the lower rates and would reduce the amount of refunds that National Grid will be
obligated to pay upon Commission approval of the Settlement.  For good cause shown, the
Commission’s Chief Administrative Law Judge granted National Grid’s motion for interim rate
relief on April 8, 2009 and allowed the Settlement TSC to be implemented on an interim basis
effective as of January 1, 2009 (“Settlement Effective Date”) pending approval by the
Commission.  In a letter order issued June 22, 2009, the Commission approved the Settlement.7

On November 30, 2009, National Grid filed to modify the manner of calculating the long-term debt
cost of capital rate. The filing sought to adjust the determination of the amount of long-term debt
used in the calculation which was based on the average beginning of the year and year end long-
term debt balances. On January 13, 2010 the filing was accepted by the Commission effective
February 1, 2010.8

 

4 Non-settling parties were made subject to a separate "filed" Revenue Requirement and

Transmission Service Charge ("Filed TSC"). The NYISO Settlement also required National Grid to make a compliance filing revising its Filed TSC under the NYISO OATT based on the outcome of the hearing in Docket No. 0A96-194-000. The NYISO Settlement was approved by the
Commission by letter order dated July 31, 2000. National Grid subsequently filed to revised its Filed TSC rate based on the final outcome of Docket No. 0A96-194-000.

5 Niagara Mohawk Power Corp., Order Accepting and Suspending Formula Rate Subject to Refund and Establishing Hearing and Settlement Judge Procedures, 124 FERC ¶ 61,106 (2008)(“July 29 Order”). Certain Settling Parties
requested rehearing of aspects of the July 29 Order. On February 25, 2009, the Commission issued an Order that
denied rehearing in part and granted rehearing in part. 126 FERC ¶ 61,173 (2009).

6 The signatories consist of National Grid and the following entities: Allegheny Electric Cooperative, Inc., the City of Cleveland, Ohio, Multiple Interveners, Municipal Electric Utilities Association, New York Association of Public
Power, New York Municipal Power Agency, New York State Electric & Gas Corporation, and Rochester Gas &
Electric Corporation (“Settling Parties”).

7 See Niagara Mohawk Power Corp., 127 FERC ¶ 61,289 (2009).

8 See Niagara Mohawk Power Corp., unpublished Letter Order, Docket Nos. ER10-328-000, ER10-328-001 (January 13, 2010).


 

 

The Honorable Kimberly D. Bose, Secretary
Page 4

 

 

 

In accordance with the April 2009 Settlement, National Grid is directed to calculate each year new
values for the Revenue Requirements (“RR”), control center costs (“CCC”) and billing units
(“BU”) components of the Settlement TSC Formula Rate based on updated Data Inputs.  National
Grid is further directed to prepare an Annual Update that reflects the revised Data Inputs, the
resulting RR, CCC, and BU components, and certain supporting information.  According to
Section 14.1.9.4 in Attachment H to the NYISO OATT, National Grid is directed on or before June
14th of each year to (1) post the Annual Update on the NYISO’s Internet website, (2) submit the
Annual Update to the Commission as an informational filing requiring no action by the
Commission, and (3) serve the Annual Update electronically on all Interested Parties.

 

In response to challenges to its 2010 Annual Update filing, National Grid filed with the

Commission on November 18, 2010, a Stipulation and Agreement and a Supplemental

Informational Filing (“2010 Stipulation”) setting forth a modification to be made in National

Grid’s future Annual Updates of certain components of the National Grid TSC based on adjusted
inputs to the Settlement TSC Formula Rate. Specifically, as stated in the 2010 Stipulation, National
Grid agreed to include in the 2011 Annual Update a Billing Adjustment of ($2,383,112) plus
interest calculated in accordance with 18 C.F.R. §35.19(a) to reflect the removal of the Temporary
Assessment under NY PSL section 18-a(6)from the 2009 Historical Transmission Revenue
Requirement, and the Annual True-up of the 2010 forecasted revenue requirement will reflect a
true-up to the actual 2010 revenue requirement that excludes any costs associated with the section
18-a Temporary Assessment. Subject to the requirements of any modification of NY PSL section
18-a (6), or regulations or regulatory orders implementing any such modifications thereto.
National Grid also agreed to exclude the costs of the section 18-a Temporary Assessment in any
future Annual Update of the Settlement TSC Formula Rate. National Grid further agreed in the
2010 Stipulation to, inter alia, provide certain documentation to the parties and take certain actions
upon the receipt by National Grid of final reports, orders or other documents in currently pending
regulatory investigation and audit proceedings before, respectively, the New York Public Service
Commission and the FERC. National Grid and the interested parties further agreed that,
conditioned upon the Commission’s acceptance of such filing without change or condition
unacceptable to all Parties, no Party will submit any Preliminary Challenge or Formal Challenge to
the 2010 Annual Update. The Commission accepted the 2010 Stipulation in a letter order issued
January 7, 2011.9

 

III.Description of Filing

There are three types of changes being proposed in this filing.  The primary purpose of the filing is
to amend the depreciation rates set forth in the RR component of the Company’s Wholesale TSC
rate.  The testimony and exhibits of Mr. James Holodak support these changes. National Grid is
proposing to reflect updated depreciation rates in its TSC formula rates pursuant to new
depreciation studies that were submitted to the NYPSC as part of state-jurisdictional rate case
proceedings.  The depreciation rates set forth in this docket were approved by the NYPSC on
January 20, 2011 with an effective date of January 24, 2011 in NYPSC Docket Number 10-E-0050.

 

 

9 See, Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation, Docket No. ER11-2228-000 (2011).


 

 

The Honorable Kimberly D. Bose, Secretary
Page 5

 

 

National Grid proposes to amend its transmission depreciation rates under the RR component of its
Wholesale TSC rate in time for its 2012 Annual Update that will establish TSC rates effective as of
July 1, 2012.  NMPC’s revenue requirement for calendar year 2011 will be used as the basis for
determining its July 1, 2012 TSC rates.  NMPC is proposing that the revised depreciation rates
become effective as of January 24, 2011, the same date that identical depreciation rates were
approved to become effective for NMPC by the NYPSC in Docket Number 10-E-0050.

Second, Mr. Holodak supports ministerial changes to Section 14.2 of Attachment H to the NYISO
OATT, modifying Section headers so that they match the renumbering convention recently
implemented by the NYISO as part of its e-tariff compliance filing.  Specifically, the NYISO
modified paragraph numbering in Attachment H of the NYISO OATT as part of its compliance
with FERC Order 714, Electronic Tariff Filings.  The NYISO OATT was renumbered to facilitate
section-based filings in e-Tariff.  The NYISO filed its e-Tariff baseline on June 30, 2010 in Docket
No. ER10-1657-000.

 

Third, Mr. Holodak supports a modification to the revenue requirement calculation in Section 14.2
of the NYISO OATT to incorporate the terms of the 2010 Stipulation accepted by the Commission
in Docket No. ER11-2228-000 as part of NMPC’s 2010 Annual Update filing.  Under the terms of
the 2010 Stipulation, the Company agreed to exclude from any future Annual Update of the TSC
rate the costs of a Temporary Assessment under section 18-a of the NY PSC.  We have taken the
opportunity in this filing to codify that change into National Grid’s revenue requirement formula.

T

 

 

IV.Contents of Filing

 

  Attachment A, Service List

 

  Exhibits NMP-1 through NMP-7, which include:

o   Exhibit NMP-1 - Direct Testimony of James Holodak

o   Exhibit NMP-2 - Clean and Black-lined versions of revised sheets to the tariff

o   Exhibit NMP-3 - Cost of Service Statements AA through BL

o   Exhibit NMP-4 - Formula Rate Spreadsheets filed with 2011 Annual Update

o   Exhibit NMP-5 - Black-lined version of Formula Rate Spreadsheets

o   Exhibit NMP-6 - Testimony and exhibits of Ron White filed in NYPSC Case 10-E-
0050

o   Exhibit NMP-7 - Testimony and exhibits of PSC Staff in NYPSC Case 10-E-0050

National Grid notes that Attachment A is attached to this transmittal letter and Exhibits NMP -1 through NMP-7 are contained in a separate volume.

 

V.Proposed Effective Date


 

 

The Honorable Kimberly D. Bose, Secretary
Page 6

 

 

National Grid respectfully requests the formula rate and associated tariff revisions be accepted for
filing effective for transmission bills rendered for service on and after July 1, 2012.  To the extent
waiver is needed for this proposed effective date, National Grid hereby requests waiver.  The
Commission has actively encouraged transmission owners to adopt formula rates of the type
implemented by National Grid herein. Consistent with its policy of encouraging formula rates, the
Commission’s practice has been to permit such formula rate filings to become effective after a
suspension period of no more than one day.10   In this proceeding, National Grid requests the
Commission to allow the amended depreciation rates for its amended RR component to go into
effect as of January 24, 2011, the same date that the NYPSC allowed such rates to go into effect.
The Company’s calendar year 2011 cost of service calculated under the RR will be used for
establishing the TSC rate for bills rendered for service on and after July 1, 2012.

 

VI.Communications

National Grid requests that all correspondence, pleadings and other communications concerning

this filing be served upon the following persons to be designated for service:

Terry L. SchwennesenJames G. Holodak, Jr.

Attorney for National Gridc/o National Grid

c/o National Grid14th Floor

40 Sylvan RoadOne MetroTech Center

Waltham, Massachusetts 02451Brooklyn, New York 11201

(401) 480-9051(718) 403-2338

Terry.schwennesen@us.ngrid.comJames.Holodak@us.ngrid.com

VII.   Service

Pursuant to Section 32.5(d) of the Commission's Regulations, a copy of this filing is being served electronically on National Grid's customers under the rate affected by this filing, on the New York State Public Service Commission, and on the NYISO. The service list for this filing may be found in Attachment A to this filing letter.

 

VIII.   Request for Waiver

National Grid respectfully requests waiver of any requirements of the Commission's rules and
regulations, as well as any authorization as may be necessary or required, to permit the revised
rates to be accepted by the Commission and made effective in the manner proposed herein.

IX.Miscellaneous

No agreement is required by contract for the filing of this rate filing. There are no costs included in this filing that have been alleged or adjudged in an administrative or judicial proceeding to be

 

 

 

10 Allegheny Power System Operating Companies, 111 FERC ¶ 61,308 at P 51 (2005) (accepting a formula rate

proposal for filing and suspending it to become effective one day after the FERC order "where the Commission has, in
fact, urged transmission owners to move from stated rates to formula rates"), order on reh'g, 115 FERC li 61,156
(2006).


 

 

The Honorable Kimberly D. Bose, Secretary
Page 7

 

 

illegal, duplicative, or unnecessary costs, nor has any expense or cost been demonstrated to be the
product of discriminatory or employment practices, within the meaning of Section 35.13(d)(3).

 

X.Conclusion

For the foregoing reasons, National Grid respectfully requests that the Commission accept these proposed tariff changes without suspension, condition or modification.

 

 

 

Respectfully submitted,

/s/ Terry L. Schwennesen

 

Terry L. Schwennesen, Esq. National Grid

40 Sylvan Road

Waltham, MA  02451 (781) 907-1811

Fax: (781) 907-1659

Terry.Schwennesen@us.ngrid.com

Attorney for

Niagara Mohawk Power Corporation d/b/a National Grid

 

Attachments


 

 

 

 

 

Attachment A

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

E-Mail List of Interested Parties upon Which this Filing was Served


 

 

 

 

 

Attachment A

 

Village of Akroncrebmann@akronvillage.us

Village of Andoverandoverclerk@frontiernet.net

Village of Andoverandover_dpw@yahoo.com

Village of Arcadelarrykilburn@villageofarcade.org

Municipal Commission of Boonvillekstabb@prodigy.net

Village of Broctonbrocton@stny.rr.com

Village of Churchvillemeghan@churchville.net

Village of Churchvillepaul@churchville.net

Village of Frankfortrvivacquavof@yahoo.com

Village of Holleyholley.electric.water@gmail.com

Village of Ilionstacy@lilonny.com

Village of Ilionmayorstephens5@ilionny.com

Village of Little Valleydreynoldsvolv@atlanticbbn.net

Village of Mohawkmohawkmuni@hotmail.com

Village of Philadelphiavphil@centralny.twcbc.com

City of Salamancakking@salmun.com

Village of Skaneatelesbob.lotkowictz@gmail.com

Village of Springvilleklux@villageofspringvilleny.com

Village of Theresatheresa@ridgeviewtel.us

Village of Wellsvillebillwhitfield@wellsvilleny.com

Village of Wellsvillepamelareed@adelphia.net

Village of Westfieldbboneberg@villageofwestfield

Village of Fairportkwm@village.fairport.ny.us

New York Municipal Power Agencytmodafferi@nympa.org

Bergenjchimino@villageorbergen.com

Lake Placidclerk@lpvillage.org

Lake Placidelectric1@lpvillage.org

Oneida Madisonsherwood@oneida-madison.coop

Tupper Lakevilltupplake@centralny.twcbc.com

Tupper Lakejohnbouck@centralny.twcbc.com

Jamestowndleathers@jamestownbpu.com

Jamestowndgustafson@jamestownbpu.com

Green Islandjack@greenislandpowerauthority.com

Richmondvillervillerpl@nycap.rr.com


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Former External TSC Customers

CustomerEmail Address

Allegheny Energylconley@aeglobalmarkets.com

Allegheny Electric CooperativeGary_Wright@ccsenergy.com

Allegheny Electric CooperativeBruce_Erickson@ccsenergy.com

Amerada Hesshjain@hess.com

American Electric Powersepotters@aep.com

Dominion Energy MarketingRobert_J_LaRochelle@dom.com

Dominion Energy MarketingShirley_Flexon@Dom.com

Duke Energyseison@duke-energy.com

Consolidated Edison of NYselfc@coned.com

Edison Mission Marketingrstalter@edisonmission.com

El Paso Merchant EnergyDavid.Lazos@ElPaso.com

Emera Energy ServiceKaren.Hutt@Emera.com

Energy Endeavors LLCpjones@energyendeavorsllc.com

Merchant Energy Group of the Americassterling_koch@transalta.com

Model City Energypzeliff@ieslfge.com

AES New EnergyTamlynn.Apfelbaum@AES.com

NYSE&G Solutionsmbeaudoin@theenergynetwork.com

Public Service of Coloradorodney.d.sgrignoli@xcelenergy.com

Pure Energydelpowell@cox.net

PSEG Energy Resources and Tradinghoward.fromer@pseg.com


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Former External TSC Customers (Continued)

CustomerEmail Address

PSEG Energy Resources and Tradingemily.pestano@pseg.com

Seneca Energy IIpzeliff@ieslfge.com

Southern Company Energyvicki.lynch@mirant.com

TransCanada Power Marketing LTDelaine_beaudry@transcanada.com

TXU Energy Tradingdbogus1@txu.com

US Energy Partnersrkreppel@energypartnersusa.com


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Current External TSC Customers


Customer

Barclays Bank PLC
Black Oak Capital LLC
Black Oak Energy LLC
BP Energy Company
BP Energy Company

Brookfield Energy Marketing, Inc. Brookfield Energy Marketing, Inc. Bruce Power Inc.

Calpine Energy Service
Calpine Energy Service
Cargill Alliant, LLC
Centre Lane Trading

BNP Paribas Energy Trading GP formerly Fortis Energy Marketing Citigroup Energy

Citigroup Energy

City Power Market LLC
City Power Market LLC
Conectiv Energy Supply

Constellation Energy Commondities Group Constellation NewEnergy

Coral Power LLC

Shell Energy North America (formerly Coral Power LLC) Dayton Power and Light

DC Energy LLC
DTE Energy Trading
DTE Energy Trading
Dynegy Power Marketing

EDF Trading North America, LLC
Epcor

Exelon Generation LLC (formerly PECO) Capital Power Corporation

FPL Energy Marketing Gotham Energy marketing Hess Corporation

HQ Energy Services (US)

Integrys (formerly WPS) Energy Services

J. Aron and Company

KeyTex Energy LLC Lehman Brothers

Lighthouse Energy Trading Macquarie Cook Power Inc. MAG Energy Solutions

Macquarie Energy LLC Mirant Energy Trading Morgan Stanley

NextEra Energy Power Marketing LLC Northern States Power


Email Address

Nicholas.Andrews@barclayscapital.com

ckopp@blackoakcap.com spicard@blackoakenergy.com randy.prescott@bp.com
richard.waswil@bp.com

franklin.francis@brookfieldpower.com chantal.dube@brookfieldpower.com ayman.faddah@brucepower.com

garciab@calpine.com
Bryan.Stevens@calpine.com

lester_welch1@cargill.com
jbrant@mackieresearch.com
lloyd.jackson@us.fortis.com

Kolby.P.Kettler@citigroup.com laurel.r.adams@citigroup.com kstsingas@citypwr.com

jwebster@citypwr.com
paul.wassil@conectiv.com

brian.schuppert@constellation.com
brian.schuppert@constellation.com

wilma.chin@shell.com

John.B.Coleman@shell.com

brenda.haupt@dplinc.com wilde@dc-energy.com

hissongm@dteenergy.com
pfankucha@dteenergy.com
tiffany.e.mccaa@dynegy.com

amie.jackson@edftrading.com settle@capitalpower.com

dirk.vanderlaan@exeloncorp.com jjtaza@firstcommodities.com

lauren_romero@fpl.com

pjones@gothamenergymarketinglp.com powersettlements@hess.com

bedard.lise@hydro.qc.ca

dverban@wpsenergy.com
allison.weingarten@gs.com
clanager@keytexenergy.com

energyoperations@lehman.com

imqasqas@lhenergy.com
hope.hernandez@macquarie.com
mgauthier@magenergysolutions.com

hope.hernandez@macquarie.com

vicki.lynch@mirant.com

gospecops@morganstanley.com bonny_arena@fpl.com

rodney.d.sgrignoli@xcelenergy.com


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Current External TSC Customers (Continued)

CustomerEmail Address

NorthPoint Energysettlements@northpointenergy.com

NYPAwilliam.palazzo@nypa.gov

NYSEG (LSE)nyseget@nyseg.com

NYSEG (LSE)caroe@nyseg.com

Ontario Power Generatrichard.gell@opg.com

Powerex Corporationtom.bechard@powerex.com

PP&L Energy Plus Cotatlas@pplweb.com

PPM Energy Inc.debbie.skinner@iberdrolaren.com

PSEG Energy Resources & Trading, LLCemily.pestano@pseg.com

Iberdrola Renewables, Inc.k.morrison@rainbowenergy.com

RBC Energy Servicesiris.chow@rbccm.com

Rochester Gas and Electriccaroe@nyseg.com

S.A.C. Energy InvestSACLegalNotice@sac.com

Saracen Merchant Energy LPsbaucom@saracenenergy.com

Sempra Energy Trading Corp.Marvina.Robinson@rbssempra.com

SESCO Enterprises LLCmschubiger@sescollc.com

Sempra Energy Trading LLCJohn.B.Coleman@shell.com

Shell Energy North America (US) L.P.John.B.Coleman@shell.com

SIG Energy LLPJamie.Miano@sig.com

Sitheshannon.brown@dynegy.com

Split Rock Energy, LLCjsolberg@acespower.com

Strategic Energy, Ltd.kkukic@sel.com

Susquehanna EnergyJamie.Miano@sig.com

TransAlta Energy Mareric_macdonald@transalta.com

Twin Cities Power Generationscurtis@tcpowergen.com

Vitol Inc.Lmm@vitol.com

West Oaks Energy NY NE LPms@westoaksenergy.com


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

From original service list (without duplicates)

wrussell@wrassoc.com

Tom Rudebachtlr@dwgp.com

Couch White, LLPrloughney@couchwhite.com

Couch White, LLPmmager@couchwhite.com

Sonnenscheinehand@sonnenschein.com

Sonnenscheincvince@sonnenschein.com

NYMPAinfo@nympa.org

Cleveland Public Powertsmith@cpp.org

Cleveland OHhmadorsky@city.cleveland.oh.us

Central Missouri Electric Cooperative, Incgstern@cmeec.org;

Thompson Coburn LLPdstraus@thompsoncoburn.com

david_dulick@ccsenergy.com

State of Vermonthans.mertens@state.vt.us

DPS NY Statewilliam_heinrich@dps.state.ny.us

DPS NY Statedavid_drexler@dps.state.ny.us

NYISOrfernandez@nyiso.com

Hunton & Williams LLPtmurphy@hunton.com

Van Ness Feldman Law Firmjbn@vnf.com

Public Utilities Dept, RImkirkwood@pud-ri.org

Duncan & Allen, Counselors at Lawjpc@duncanallen.com

Massachusetts Municipal Wholesale Electric Companybmckinnon@mmwec.org

ppanj@tellurian.com

Con Edisonnachmiass@coned.com

Con Edisonsmithce@coned.com

NYPAgary.levenson@nypa.gov

Thompson Coburn LLPgnewell@thompsoncoburn.com

Saint Regis Mohawk Tribedale.white@srmt-nsn.gov

duthie@attglobal.net


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

From original service list (without duplicates) (Continued)


Stinson Morrison Hecker LLP Central Maine Power Co

 

Rochester Gas & Electric Central Hudson

FERC

Municipal Electric Utilities Association of New York State FERC

Couch White, LLP

Van Ness Feldman Law Firm Van Ness Feldman Law Firm Bell South

Duncan, Weinberg, Genzer & Pembroke, P.C Winston & Strawn LLP

Winston & Strawn LLP

Duncan, Weinberg, Genzer & Pembroke, P.C NYSEG

NYPA
NYISO

Black & Veatch
Sonnenschein


hreiter@stinson.com

scott.mahoney@cmpco.com catherine.mccarthy@dl.com marjorie_perlman@rge.com jwatzka@cenhud.com

Roger.St.Vincent@ferc.gov tmodafferi@meua.org

james.pepper@ferc.gov
jgoodman@couchwhite.com msc@vnf.com

dpy@vnf.com

fsaffer@bellsouth.net rw@dwgp.com

ddankner@winston.com rwuslich@winston.com jea@dwgp.com

RPKinney@nyseg.com carol.garcia@nypa.gov mlampi@nyiso.com robertsjl@bv.com

WBOOTH@SONNENSCHEIN.com glooker@wrassoc.com

dorothy.pierce@chguernsey.com

Jmontone2@aol.com
mayor@Sherillny.org

Mayville5@fairpoint.net


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

 

I hereby certify that I have served by electronic mail the foregoing document upon all

parties on the email service list of Interested Parties provided on Attachment E of this Annual
Update, pursuant to the requirements of the Settlement in the above-captioned proceedings.

Dated at Waltham, MA, this 30th day of March, 2012.

 

 

/s/ Terry Schwennesen

c/o National Grid

40 Sylvan Road

Waltham, MA  02451 (401) 480-9051